Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Videos

  • 555959548.mp4

Downloads

Content

Files

Comments

Jordyn Mickus

From what I’m understanding of the show is that Pinocchio is saying that he ripped out the story because he didn’t want his own story to be told but with what we’ve seen Pinocchio did nothing wrong in the pages that we saw in the story that was told in this episode because all he did was actually try to help David’s father so if we think about it, there’s no reason that Pinocchio should be worried about anyone seeing that part of a story. So what I believe is that Pinocchio when he gave hook those pages that did actually show hook killing that man that is when Hook realized oh crap I killed David’s father so he knew that he had killed that man like he remembered that he just didn’t put together that that was David’s father until he saw the pages so when we jump back in time at the end there, that’s basically hook, looking through the pages and instead of having him read it to us or whatever they have it as an actual scene so hook killing David’s father is actually on the pages that he has. So I always saw the ending as Pinocchio showing Hook the real reason he ripped out the pages.

Melody L.

Hook probably didnt know it was James' father! He recognize him when he saw the picture... maybe! :) But indeed no matter he needs to tell the truth!

mia

Interesting take! I always thought the pages he gives Hook are part of a larger story (whatever Pinocchio did on that island), and he kinda just tore the whole section out. I never got the sense August knew abt the murder, and always thought the picture just sparked a memory that never made it into the storybook. Hard to tell, though! But you're right, Hook definitely didn't realize until he saw David's father on the page

Sophie Minocha

Honestly I missed so much stuff on my first watch that I caught while rewatching this show! Sometimes I'll be watching it again and STILL somehow find things I haven't noticed before. I really hope you do a rewatch with us, it'd be so fun to see you catch things you never noticed this first time (and I always love hearing your opinions on the crazy situations they get into, so it'd be great to hear them with a new perspective and more context!)!!

Omar Rodriguez

I know you are hating Rumple to the maximum expression at the moment Audrey, but I just wanted to clarify your question about him helping find David’s dad finding James when King George was looking for the kid. You got to remember that to Rumple there is always a price with magic and it always will be but when he heard David’s father's case wanting to find his son, it touch a deep chord in him as in Rumple seeing himself in the same situation wanting also to find and reunite with his son, Baelfire. But he couldn't simply say “alright, I’ll help you out cause I understand what you are going through” and basically destroy his reputation as a dark one, so he said that lie of needing a hair from him as a proper transaction or in Rumple’s fashion a deal. He simply helped him thinking that he could also could find his son in the future, while saying “someday maybe all will be reunited with our sons.”

Alecia Bateman

Yes in the original story the stuff he did that once upon a time diddnt show he did some bad things.

Alecia Bateman

Hook wouldn’t have known that was David’s father.

Alecia Bateman

Season 6 doesn’t wrap everything though there is some storyline’s that get finalised in season 7

Kam

I think that Hook didn't realize that he killed David's father until he saw the pages and recognized David's father as the man that he had killed

FlyFree

The tradition of asking the father's blessing to marry his daughter is a beautiful one, IF......IF....IF......IF.....the woman comes from a good home and has a father with integrity and character. Not everyone has that. So i can understand some people not liking that tradition. But to trash the tradition as whole for everyone worldwide just because of someone's personal experience is small minded. It's best to consider that our limited worldviews and experiences and family dynamics don't apply to everyone.