Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

What Should We Watch Next?

  • Frieren: Beyond Journey's End 445
  • Fruits Basket 102
  • Your Lie in April 148
  • Erased 131
  • Skip and Loafer 64
  • 2025-07-08
  • —2025-07-12
  • 890 votes
{'title': 'What Should We Watch Next?', 'choices': [{'text': "Frieren: Beyond Journey's End", 'votes': 445}, {'text': 'Fruits Basket', 'votes': 102}, {'text': 'Your Lie in April', 'votes': 148}, {'text': 'Erased', 'votes': 131}, {'text': 'Skip and Loafer', 'votes': 64}], 'closes_at': datetime.datetime(2025, 7, 12, 1, 0, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2025, 7, 8, 18, 45, 50, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 890}

Content

We are almost done watching Violet Evergarden, so we need to figure out what to replace it with! Remember we are trying to keep the genres varied across the week, so that is why these ones were put on the poll!

Please vote for any and all that would interest you! Poll closes Friday evening.

Comments

JujuChonk

Your Lie In April getting snuffed again. 🥲

Oatmeal

FRIEREN FRIEREN FRIEREN FRIEREN

Merielle

I recently binged frieren, absolute wonder💕 loved every second!

Jeff Grant

I’m voting Frieren but I think Skip and loafer would also be great

Алта

Fruits basket my shaylaaaa

ibtsaam BR

AOT another episode a week

Vivien He

Can I also recommend Black Butler!!!!

P Barb

Glad "Your Lie in April" made the list. And Frieren, of course!

Sam C.

Frieren!!!

Rosheanne (Ro)

This anime line-up is crazy good and evil LOL can't go wrong with any of these shows <3

Icaro Torres

Blue lock would be fun too! 🙈

Carlos Cantu

Never seen Frieren but I want to and this is a good time to watch it

Jimbeezee

Frieren for sure; it will be a healing experience for you after the trauma of VE and AOT.

Aaron Ly

Frieren is my all time favorite single season of anime ever!

Alex Chen

All bangers. As a pianist, I personally can’t watch it again. It hits too close to home.

Mia

Never seen frieren but would like to watch it with u guys!

Igor Pinchuk

while Frieren has my vote, all the options here are excellent. Kudos to whoever filtered these down from the suggestions! I am not sure I have seen Skip and Loafer on any reactor's lists before

Kiribukai

Frieren! It’s such a beautiful journey! I know you both will love it! 🩵

69PoopDollar

Frieren will win for sure but erased would be a good short one shot similar in vibes to death note

Shaybay44

All of these are great and different genres as well. Personally I'd love to see you react to Skip and Loafer as it's a short and very light, fluffy and cute 😍 series and it'd be a change of pace from other series you're currently reacting to.

piaa

freaking LOVE this whole list,,, but frieren wins for me

piaa

I hope they react to that one next🥹

Lixien

Frieren lets goooooooo

Judy

I know Fruits Basket isn’t winning the poll right now, but i think it deserves to win because it’s one of those shows that completely catches you off guard. On the surface it looks like this cute romance, but it goes so much deeper n darker than you'd expect. It’s about trauma, healing, generational pain, n emotional growth and the way it all unfolds is seriously powerful. Plus, it’s a complete story with an incredible payoff, unlike Frieren which is still ongoing. It’s honestly one of the most rewarding shows to react to because people love seeing others go through the emotional rollercoaster for the first time. I rewatched it recently and was a weeping mess every episode. This one's right up Sarah's alley. 🤞🏽Hope it wins.

EMMIL

I’d be so happy with any of these omg!!! Best community ever to make a list like this

Judy

That's what I'm saying 😭

a.

you guys are insane with these choices!!! alskdjf i say all of them lol seems like frieren will win, which YES super excited for that, but i have my fingers crossed for fruits basket at some point. it's my all time favorite manga/anime ever. it's absolutely incredible and a staple in it's genre

Judy

Fruits basket is getting stomped 😞

Judy

Bestie 🙌🏽

SDCWW171

Excited for you to watch Freiren, it was my favorite anime the year for 2023/2024. Also randomly on my Spotify wrapped for 2024, Evan Call(The composer of the series) was my top listened to artist because the entire soundtrack is a delight to listen to while reading.

MasterPpv

Frieren is one of the most hyped shows of all time, and deservedly so, because it's one of the best anime ever created. It's going to completely steamroll the voting because of it, but to be frank, I would personally want you guys to experience some of these other shows first. For one, since Frieren just had its first season, you'll more or less be automatically committing to all of the rest of the seasons whenever they release, which may interrupt future scheduling at some point. Also, as far as curation goes, one of the things that made Frieren so special was how much of a breath of fresh air it was for folks who had been watching anime for ages and could see how brilliantly it did things that others just don't, as well as not doing things that feel tired and same-y after seeing them done in a ton of other shows. Getting the experience of Frieren this early in your anime watching will of course be great, but there is a very real possibility that it will result in you guys having slightly lesser experiences when you get around to some older classics and masterpieces. They are things that Frieren is standing on the shoulders of, but also utterly eclipses with its own quality and merits, and I do worry that even if just subconsciously, your viewing of some other things may be affected negatively because you'll have already seen a perfected evolution. It's probably too late now though, and to be fair, as I stated in the beginning, it is one of the best anime ever created. It's practically flawless, in fact. And it's going to absolutely obliterate any poll it's in, so I feel bad for all of these wonderful suggestions that are going to get left in the dust by the hype train.

Karina

🥲 I love all of these but sadly only one can win. Voted for Frieren, we are lacking female lead shows on this channel. And I adore Fruits Basket but I think you would enjoy Frieren more. (watched the first Furuba anime in 2003 ? I think and was gunning for a readaptation of the manga for yeaaars until it finally happened lol. But probably my ultimate favorite shoujo story that had a significant impact on me as a teenager.)

Karina

Also, Apothecary Diaries is a gem and should be watched once during your anime journey! Older stuff with a female protagonist that I would also recommend: 1. Seirei no Moribito (Moribito: Guardian of the Spirit) 2.Gokusen (this one is comedy lol) 3.Juuni Kokuki (The Twelve Kingdoms).

Inky

Okay I have only watched the last three, but oh man I am so torn between Your Lie in April and Skip and Loafer!!

Inky

Btw does anyone know if there's a place we can give our recommendations so Sarah and Adam can consider putting these on future polls?

bebe

Skip and loafer is also so good

Talosig23

Since we're all here. Does anyone remember if Frieren has after credit scenes? And if the opening and closing credits are spoiler-free?

peachy af

Erased against frieren omg my darling was never gonna win 😭😭 but frieren is fantastic too so im not too sad about it yet

sophia palmieri

Openings do have spoilers if you are good at context clues. The endings less so but do have nuggets you can pick out after watching some episodes. I think the only after credits is the final episode. The rest just follow through with the music, but no ending song animations. I would need to double check on that, but I think that is how it goes. After the endings it just gives the preview of the next episode name.

Who Really Cares

So excited for Frieren! Just started watching it with my mom and sister and they love it. I think Sarah in particular will fall in love with the show

yu kana

frierennnn🔥🔥

Unknown

They're all great shows but Frieren is a masterpiece

Talosig23

Ah yes. The one with overlapping dialogues

Tiffany Chang

the recommendation list is on discord

MV# Katorin

I am one of the rarest of anime watcher who don't like Friere , it's so boring, I tried to watch it a couple of times and could always not finish it.. But I KNOW YOU BOTH WOULD PROBABLY LOVE ERASED!! Please watch that instead, pretty please!

Carolina Olivares

your lie in April Is also kind of sad. In the other hand Frieren has a lot of content not just sadness also funny moments is a masterpiece.

Freedom

Your lie in april suits you the best, Sarah!!!! If i’m not mistaken, you also play the piano, so i think you can relate to it in that aspect. Personally, i just like watching you react to really tear-jerking heartfelt scenes, coz you really get it! This show also has a competitive aspect to it which you as an athlete can also relate to. Anyway, if this doesnt win maybe you can give it a try as a watch party, i’m down either way! It’s such a gem, I promise!!!!

Vu D

Frieren is in its own class.

Freedom

I have watched all of them except for erased Your lie in april - highly recommended!!! Piano, tears, competition Skip and loafer - underrated slice of life / like a modern kimi ni todoke Frieren - i’m okay with it winning since it’s for sure going to be popular on youtube Fruits basket - really good but 3 seasons Erased - didnt watch it. I would personally recommend Steins;Gate instead by a mile

Vie

AoT please 😢

lex

are jujutsu kaisen and apothecary diaries on their watchlist?

Danny

They're already watching aot lol

Vie

I mean two episodes a week

Peter

wow these are all good options!

peachy af

Theyre not going to do two episodes a week

rossana

ERASED PLEASEEE

Jeff Grant

oh wow its not even close anymore

JujuChonk

This is what I've been saying! 😭

Elle

At least we know erased and ylia will have a close race in 2026 😭😭🤣

Inky

Ah thank you Tiffany!

Kaito Fuuma

Oooh if you're craving for a slow life fantasy then frieren you could do both since erased is maybe adam cup of tea

Carina P

I know you both will absolutely love FRIEREN

Summer Nguyen

I’m sad Fruits Basket is falling behind but I hope you guys will considering keeping it on future polls. Definitely worth the watch and I would love to hear your discussions surrounding the characters, twists/reveals, and emotional story!

Sharles Davis Kendy

Is it the second or third time YLiA gets second place? Killing me here!

Gracia Toent

I love Frieren but is not finished, Fruit Basket would be my dream reaction right now

Elle

Pretty sure this is the first time YL has been in a poll

melon

Skip and loafer😭😭

Kim Kjell Khan

The stock market for tissues are going to rise.

Mysbis

Haha, I saw these results coming. It’s hard to beat mainstream hype. These are all great shows, though, so I hope you’ll continue polling them. Honestly, I share the same concerns about the show ordering as MasterPpv, especially because we haven’t even gotten to any shows from the genre Frieren is specifically building off of, but I’m sure it’ll be a good time. I just hope when we do get to those shows, you can watch them with that awareness. I’m sure with the correct framing, this ordering could also lead to some interesting discussions in the future. I’ll wait patiently for the day Skip and Loafer gets its run 😂. There’s no real rush (other than my heart) for that one haha. I think Skip would be a great option to save for when you need a fluffy, feel-good show (which you might need after some of these other options on the poll 😂). That show is so emotionally intelligent and covers some surprisingly deep subjects without dipping into tragedy/letting the mood of the show grow too heavy, which I find kind of rare. It really is a gem in its genre. It’s also a bit similar to Frieren in the sense that it feels very much like a modern show that built and evolved off of its predecessors to really shine the way it does within its category.

Leo Li

All of these are GREAT choices! Out of all of them, I haven't seen Erased but I might as well watch it at this point, seeing how passionate people are about it. It does have a very interesting premise to say the least. I will give my thoughts to the ones that I have watched though. Frieren is a very versatile anime that touches on a lot of things, and I think the reason why it is so popular and praised by so many people is just because everyone can relate to some aspects of it (if not all). Overall, it is considered fantasy/adventure so this would be right up your alley (especially for Adam lol). I don't know what else to say besides that it is very freaking good (Sarah will probably cry a few times but we'll see). Goated OST as well (same composer as Violet Evergarden's!). The only downside is that the manga is still ongoing, so it would be a while before we get to witness the end of it. Fruits Basket. I mean, If you love character development and/or great character writing, this is the ULTIMATE anime to watch (and fortunately you do!). There are a lot of characters, but you will get very invested with them and come to appreciate every single one of them (I can already see Adam struggling with the names lol). It also deals with heavy issues that hit very hard (be prepared to cry). Story can be a bit slow at times but the payoffs are so worth it. I hope you get to react to it at some point. It is a very good anime. Your Lie in April, the first anime that I've watched besides Studio Ghibli movies as a kid, and it is the reason why I am an anime watcher and a pianist right now, which should be reasons enough to prove that this is a great one. I also love the classical music elements and some inherent issues within its system that this anime manages to talk about, and I think every musician can relate to some aspects of it, (not to say that general viewers won't, I wasn't a piano player when I first watched this). And oh yeah, please prepare tissues, like A LOT. Skip and Loafer, If you enjoy coming-of-age/slice of life/romance, this is your go-to anime. It's cute and relaxing (for the most part), and does leave you feeling good after every episode. Unfortunately for me, it is the weakest out of the 4 that I have watched (I just pissed off so many people haven’t I), but that's just because the other ones are TOO good. I guarantee that you will have a great time with it if you do eventually watch this (and please react to the opening, you guys CAN'T miss this one). The manga is also not finished for this one either, just a little heads up. Judging by the poll, Frieren is like 100% winning lol. All I can say is buckle up for the ride and enjoy your time while it lasts! Looking forward to your reactions.

Chawamushi

delicious dungeon by any chance?

riddle

I've been procrastinating on starting Frieren, so I'm glad I will get to watch it along with you guys! I attended the Frieren panel at Anime Expo last week despite not having seen the show yet, since I am a fan of Kobayashi Chiaki, who was a guest at the panel. I don't think you've heard him in any shows yet 🤔. I did inevitably get spoiled for something that I'm assuming was a major plot point LOL. But thankfully, I don't know much else about the show beyond that. I personally enjoy going into shows blind, so I've been avoiding anything about the show as much as possible.

NUTSOFODEN

Not surprised Frieren has such a commanding share here. Don't take this as a slight against the other options though, they're great as well, especially Fruits Basket, they're just not in the same class. The same Poll minus Frieren would have been a much closer result.

Marshal Childress

I really want them to watch komi can't communicate

Karina

Oh that would be cute! Shirobako could maybe work as well. And after they have watched a few shoujo titles and are familiar with the tropes, Gekkan Shoujo Nozaki-kun would be a delight I think.

maggiesaus

Frieren is more current than the other choices, and season 2 (third cour) is releasing in early 2026 so it might be worth it to go now because the 28? episodes it has will be continued with new episodes in January 2026 by the time you finish the first season. Fruits Basket is very 90s, early 2000s flavored family dynamic oriented feels good with angsty bits. Not sure which version (original or remake) you'll watch but the story is so impactful regardless. The rest that I've seen/read manga for (Your Lie in April, Erased) are all different and full of drama, thrills, angst, you name it - great shows and great recommendations. Definitely worth watching down the road for when you get the chance!

Angeli Rafer Art

Ach -- I was so busy earlier this month and I missed this poll but if Frieren is who we're going with I am really, REALLY excited for y'all to dip into it :) It's got a lot of Interesting Things to Say about Life and Memory

lomoko

after watching your analysis in sports anime like haikyuu i feel like it would be fun for you guys to react to my hero academia! it's like if you added superpowers to sports + the plot is actually really interesting. a ton of character growth for everyone too! if i had to describe it it's kind of like a mix of haikyuu and jujutsu kaisen (another amazing show i super recommend)