Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Ok, just double checking- is Avalon the Roman version of Valhalla??

Files

Servant | Vinland Saga S1E17 Reaction

Servant- Vinland Saga season 1, episode 17 anime reaction. Source Materials: "Servant." Vinland Saga. Writ. Kenta Ihara, Dir. Daisuke Kurose, Wit Studio, 2019. ↓ WATCH NEXT ↓ ATTACK ON TITAN REACTIONS: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLYukMZg0pKdBtd3wWCdHxe120Acc9ay2p DEMON SLAYER REACTIONS: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLYukMZg0pKdA2RpA7uDzF9Q7fEAm5aCpj MOB PSYCHO 100 REACTIONS: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLYukMZg0pKdAbnIk8QJdIVzSGLi4NIxHG DEATH NOTE REACTIONS: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLYukMZg0pKdAmwH86TNrpuQ8NXP1fvubH All the videos, songs, images, and graphics used in the video belong to their respective owners and this channel does not claim any right over them. Copyright Disclaimer under section 107 of the Copyright Act of 1976, allowance is made for “fair use” for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, education and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing. #vinlandsaga #anime #animereaction #animegirl

Comments

Frolaytia

Thorkell and dimple having the same voice actor will never not fry me

Wsgyan

Here’s an example Sarah: an experienced basketball player doing crazy moves seems super good to regular people you know you just have to think of askeladd of that super experienced fighter that has almost lost nothing and he’s super wise and smart thors even called him strong and that coming from the guy that was considered the strongest is important. If we’re talking about the basketball player I’d say an nba player could easily beat 15 guys trying to defeat him coming at him in waves of like 3/4 ppl that’s the same for askeladd and his group was full of mercenaries a lot of them don’t really know how to fight they just like violence

Wsgyan

Like I’m pretty sure wemby playing a bunch of regular humans would be the same he’s winning with a success rate of 99% ahaha

Igor Pinchuk

Avalon is a mythical island in King Arthur lore where the sword Excalibur was forged and where Arthur went after getting injured. Depending on the version of the story, he either died there or is recovering to return and save England. So, it is a bit like heaven and shares a few similarities with Valhalla, but pretty different otherwise. While Vinland Saga is a historical fiction and draws heavily from historical events, it also embellishes them to convey a specific feeling. Like, Thorkell's feats of strength are clearly not humanly possible, but they are there to convey a felling that he is larger than life. Same with Thors being able to fight 50 armed men without a weapon and come out unscratched. The quality of armor and weapons would also make a huge difference in those circumstances. A skilled fighter with good equipment can achieve amazing things against average joes with no gear. The show implies that Askeladd's armor being better than average chainmail allowed him to take some punishment and keep on fighting. With that said, skilled fighters in favorable conditions are able to achieve remarkable things. A recent(ish) real world example which stuck in my memory, in early 2010s there was a story from a smaller village in China where a dozen goons showed up at someone's house to shake down a family for some money (I forgot the exact context, wish I could find the link to the story). Unknown to the goons, the dad of the family was a hardcore fitness instructor and martial artist. The video of the aftermath of this fight showed up on Vine (this was a LONG time ago lol) and you just see 11 dudes knocked unconscious spread around different rooms of the house, with their weapons (bats and crowbars) all around the place. The dad fled and was not on the scene. It was one of the most surreal sights, with all the villagers filming the aftermath and wondering what happened. Long story short, my feeling is that the reality of one skilled fighter vs many is embellished in Vinland Saga, but a smaller scale version of it could happen.

Lixien

This is definitely unrealistic. No matter how good a person is at fighting, if they get jumped by +10 guys they would be done. But, while this has a realistic setting, it's still a show, and the most important character like Thors, Thorfinn, Askeladd, Thorkell, etc are portrayed as really elite combatants to the point that they're almost superhuman. You are supposed to have a bit of suspension of disbelief when it comes to fights that involve the main characters lol.

L

I always felt that the parallels they were drawing here for Avalon was the Welsh equivalent of Vinland. I guess mythically you are right, but thematically I think it ties in better to Vinland, maybe I'm wrong.

Igor Pinchuk

Good point and I agree with your take about the Avalon/Vinland thematic parallels. I guess I was too focused on addressing their question about Valhalla that I didn't mention this lol

Sang

Sarah pls check dm

Richard Spilles

I think the exaggeration aspect plays in a lot of the role of viking myths and legends. In these stories things are discribed to be similar in absurdity and unrealism. Since it is easier to teach while also being entertaining my guess is, they wanted this exaggerated stylistic because it not only captures what anime/manga/literature is capable of, it also feels at least to me intuitive to me since it doesnt make the historical figure feel inacurrate in my eyes. All the literature about the characters from long ago can always have flaws, lies or exaggerations in them. The Romans did that plenty of times, they produced literature speaking mostly bad about the germanic tribes because it would be bad propaganda to your own civilization to empathize with the enemy right? Reading into historics also needs to corrected by question the source and intention of documenting.

na

100%. the Norse and icelandic skalds told stories soooo much more outrageous than askeladds stand. Like if this happened, they would've turned it into 20 thorkells and 200 jomsvikings lol. Legends are always greatly exaggerated...especially in these times.

na

I think my favorite thing rn is Sarah calling ppl brigands. makes me laugh every time. Avalon is a Celtic (which Askeladd is by blood) holy/mythical/otherworldly place in Arthurian legend (and a beautiful beach town in new jersey). One superior warrior could cut down untrained conscripted, unmotivated peasant/farmers...but Askeladd's crew do not fall under that category. they are too experienced, and too versed in tactics for that specific scene. Unless they were going for 1v1 battle-glory (which is cited a lot of times in Norse records as motive/cause for improbable deeds. Norse/Icelandic records, as I have mentioned before, are to be taken with a handful of salt). One way to make Askeladd's stand make more sense- he held his own vs Thors for awhile. Thors demolished that whole group of brigands PLUS Bjorn while making sure he didn't accidentally kill any of them. The narrow confines of a viking ship def give an outnumbered individual better odds though. There is a somewhat more believable story of a viking warrior taking on dozens of guys before dying. It was vs the Saxon's at Stamford Bridge in England. One lone viking stood in the middle of a narrow bridge, allowing his men to retreat (in vain, in turned out) and took out "dozens" of Saxon warriors, before they sent some guys in barrels or smth that speared him from below. This is more believable than most Norse sagas bc iirc the story actually comes from the Saxons bc almost all the Norse/vikings were killed. Usually stories of the enemy doing something like that wouldn't be passed down unless it was something of unbelievable merit. Also the fact the guy got to take on Saxons one at a time bc the bridge was too narrow makes it somewhat more believable. Again, I say somewhat. I'm sure it wasn't as dramatic as the lore says....but then again, there are feats of valor in the 20&21st century that seem absolutely unrealistic that are 100% true with video evidence and eyewitness accounts. So who knows, really.

na

im pretty sure you nailed it. That was always how I viewed it fwiw

na

he's winning 100% vs regulars lolll