Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

There are a lot of things about Jeordie’s family in particular (but also other characters, and the social dynamic of the town of Rigsby in general) that I would like to explore, but as a white lady of limited experience I feel no matter how much research I do or how many stories I read or how many people I talk to, I will never be quite the right person to tell some of these stories. I am thinking in particular of Liz’s backstory. She was removed from her family at a very young age and placed into foster care, and like many indigenous children separated from their families, was raised with the goal of assimilation, as a person to be dealt with and “fixed,” rather than in a house of love with parents who cared for her. This left her with a deep sense of an inability to belong, both in a white community and a tribal community, as well as affecting her ability to be a parent to her own children. Despite knowing that her upbringing was outside of ideal conditions and wanting her children to be raised in a more loving environment than she was raised in, she was ill-equipped to create such an environment because she herself was not raised in one and could not follow by example. As such, there was a pretty big learning curve when Darius was born. She was never abusive or neglectful, but instead felt very lost and spent a lot of time questioning her actions and ability to control her temper, and agonizing over her parenting decisions (which is pretty normal for a new parent anyway, but this was turned up to an extreme because she had literally no compass to follow). 

Dealing with your own anger, anxiety, sadness and depression is hard enough, but realizing that you can so easily pass all of that on to your children through your own actions while not having the emotional tools to avoid doing so is a terrifying experience. It’s a story that I’d feel pretty confident in writing, but adding on a layer of cultural genocide, American exceptionalism and manifest destiny feels like something someone closer to that experience should write. The far-reaching effects of removal and assimilation of native children is not a small issue, but I feel like I almost never see historical trauma addressed in mainstream popular fiction like movies, television, novels or comic books. Or even like, a high school history class. But those stories, I think, belong to the people who experienced them and were affected by them, so writing a story that focuses specifically on that experience would feel a little weird, as a white lady. 

Anyway, that’s just an example, but there are a lot of really interesting topics that I could cover in this story that I would love to write about if only because I never see them handled correctly or even addressed in other stories. But then I also have to ask, am I the right person to write that story? While I would love to see more comics, movies and television shows written about non-white, non-hetero, non-cis topics and characters, having them written by cis straight white people is also not the best. I’m not saying that they can’t or shouldn’t write characters who aren’t cis straight white people, I just think certain stories are best told by people who experienced them. An effort should be made to encourage and consume content created by people from a multitude of backgrounds, otherwise we’ll just keep regurgitating the same basic stories about the same basic people.

If this were a situation where this comic were a movie or tv show and there were a team of writers you would obviously want to hire a multitude of voices, but this is kind of a solo project and I am just one white lady. I guess I just have to write what I feel comfortable writing and also be open to critique/criticism. Please let me know if one of my characters seems like an ignorant characterization; I am always trying to make better stuff.

Also sorry, this was more of an essay than a sketch answer, but here’s a sketch of Liz and her foster sister Shari as teenagers wandering around in the desert, wearing stupid 1960s culottes.

Files

Comments

Shinji Tanaka

Wow! I'm a Native person myself, so this was a real treat to read. I've always loved Liz as a character and what we knew of her backstory, so reading this and your extra thoughts on her hit really close to home. I can't know how many people you've talked to or where you got your inspiration from, but at least from my perspective I think her story is pretty realistic, as unfortunate as that is. I understand your hesitancy to throw all that into the comic, though, but I'm very glad I got to read about her.

Nathan Obral

The hesitancy is totally understandable. For far too long, native Americans and the First Nations have either been portrayed with such a gross inaccuracy and a borderline inflammatory tone, or in a way that turns them more into a mythical people that no longer exist. Your care and thoughtfulness show the total opposite, and it is to be respected and commended. Through my collaborations with Betsy (who you may remember from the CT days?) I’ve been so fortunate and thankful to have befriended a close mutual friend of hers, Tonya Song, a full-blooded member of the O’otham nation. Yes, Tonya’s in the fandom, but she’s also a composer of classical music, a highly talented musician, an outspoken advocate and a storyteller in her own right. A lot of these stories are not pleasant - many are violent and end in death - but they are vivid slice of life experiences that her peers no doubt went through back in the late 19th century. If it’s ever possible, I would like to introduce you to Tonya. Not saying she’d be the definitive answer on any of your concerns, that’s just not possible, but the two of you have such passion for your characters and of the craft of storytelling. Maybe she can provide guidance if you ever need it, she has with me and my characters. And... she’s a very dear friend.