Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

I'm about halfway through reviewing feedback on Shallow Graves and writing an errata document for it, so I haven't written anything new for Black Vans in the last week. However, a patron requested a taste of the "crossover chapter" I've already written the first draft of, and that's a request I can accommodate.

The usual caveat applies: this is a first drafts, and things will change (possibly a great deal) before I have the finished product. In addition, be warned that I'm not giving you the full context here (such as what the heck a "Greater Form" or "Lesser Form" is), as that's covered in the chapter introduction. Moreover, be aware that the crossover chapter does not attempt to slavishly emulate each splat using Deviant mechanics. There is a huge amount of simplification, as well as some creative liberties meant to make other critters fit into the "world" of Deviants a little more readily. Finally, accounting for the interactions between a thousand or more powers across 11 game lines struck me as a fool's errand, so this section doesn't do that.

With all that in mind, here is the first draft of the Mage crossover section.

Mage

Mages are people who experienced a startling revelation that opened their eyes to the magic that undergirds all reality. They refer to themselves as willworkers, the Awakened, or the Wise. Their defining characteristics are their curiosity (which drives them to pursue mysteries to the point of obsession) and self-assurance (which can often turn into hubris). They organize themselves into Orders – societies of mages with different philosophies. Some Orders have cordial relationships with one another, while others are sworn enemies.

Threat Level: 6

Themes

Mage: The Awakening features wizards whose investigation of the occult leads them into all kinds of trouble. The Awakened are driven by their Obsessions as surely as Remade are compelled to further their Touchstones, and the two can get along well when these drives mesh. Many mages are also self-proclaimed guardians against Baselines learning too much about the supernatural, so they can be the natural enemies of Web of Pain conspiracies. Awakened making war with rival willworkers who have enmeshed themselves in the Web of Pain can also welcome Renegade allies in their fight.

Allies

Mages make potent allies, for what they lack in raw power (and experienced mages certainly don’t lack for that), they more than compensate for in versatility. This makes them a natural complement for high Threat Level Deviants, who can’t match them for adaptability but often surpass them in potency within their narrow areas. Mages who seek the company of Remade usually do so because the Broken are interesting; Variations, Scars, and the Divergence as a whole brim with Mysteries for a willworker to explore.

Enemies

The Wise are dangerous enough enemies when provoked, but those mages who have given into their hubris completely are truly terrifying. A wizard who wants to study the Renegades’ souls and test the limits of their Variations (and the extent of their Scars) is little more than a nuisance. One who has no qualms about dominating the Broken and forcing them to serve him can be a conspiracy unto himself. The worst Awakened seek nothing less than the annihilation of reality by the alien forces outside of it.

Web of Pain

For the most part, mages don’t like exposing Baselines to the supernatural, as the presence of the uninitiated mixes badly with the magic of the Awakened. However, some factions of the Wise who seek to dominate humanity will cheerfully use the conspiracies of the Web of Pain to further their goals as they play puppet masters, and they are rarely averse to transforming Baselines into their Remade tools.

Additionally, over the centuries, the Wise have identified and cultivated the abilities of Proximi – humans with lineages that grant them innate occult abilities that allow them to safely interact with sorcery. Those who belong to these bloodlines are significantly more likely to Awaken as mages, but they are also more prone to Divergence, and their Wise minders seldom discard them when this happens; on the contrary, these rare events tend only to pique the willworkers’ curiosity.

Greater Form: Mage

The creature is one of the Awakened. She has a Supernatural Potency trait called Gnosis, Anchors called Obsessions, an Integrity trait called Wisdom, and a Fuel trait called Mana. The Wise wield Awakened magic and risk Paradox, which have special systems and apply regardless of whether they have the Greater Form or one of its Lesser Forms.

Supernatural Potency: Gnosis

Gnosis is the mage’s power and understanding, which are what drive Awakened magic. She understands the universe intuitively and can see the threads she must pull to enact meaningful change. For a mage, the question is never how to make change, but instead whether she’s able and willing to do what is necessary.

[table]

Gnosis  Number of Obsessions             Maximum Arcanum Rating

1-2        1           3

3-4        2           4

5-6        3           5

7-8        4           5

9-10      5           5

[end table]

Anchors: Obsessions

The Awakened has the usual complement of a Baseline’s Virtue, Vice, two short-term Aspirations, and one long-term Aspiration. Additionally, a willworker has one or more Obsessions.

Obsessions resemble long-term Aspirations that concern some occult mystery that currently holds the mage’s attention. They are secrets that take the mage at least multiple chapters to fully understand, and some are truly open-ended – the mage will never know everything about it. Once per story, the willworker can swap one of his Obsessions with a new one or change which of its motive slots (Virtue, Vice, long-term Aspiration, or short-term Aspiration) it replaces.

Whenever the mage indulges an Obsession in a minor but notable way, he regains a point of Willpower. If doing so creates a complication for him or his allies (one lasting no more than a few scenes), he also takes a Beat. He regains all Willpower and takes a Beat whenever he allows his Obsession to create a problem that dominates the events of an entire chapter.

Integrity Trait: Wisdom

A mage’s Wisdom reflects the degree to which she wields magic judiciously. Awakened who are selfish or reckless with their magic or who use it to cause harm risk Wisdom with each Act of Hubris.

A mage’s Wisdom ranges from 10 to 0. Characters start out with seven dots of Wisdom.

A mage’s Wisdom marks him as either Enlightened (8-10), Understanding (4-7), or Falling (1-3). A willworker who reaches Wisdom 0 becomes one of the Rapt – a mage so overpowered by his Obsessions that he no longer has control over his magic (and is only appropriate as a Storyteller character). An Enlightened mage risks Wisdom whenever he commits any Act of Hubris. An Understanding mage only risks Wisdom when he commits an Understanding or Falling Act of Hubris. A Falling mage only risks Wisdom when he commits a Falling Act of Hubris.

Whenever a mage commits an Act of Hubris that constitutes a Wisdom risk for him, he rolls a number of dice based on the graveness of the Act of Hubris. Add two dice if he did so in the furtherance of his Virtue. Subtract one die if he did so to indulge his Vice. Subtract a die if his actions were in the furtherance of an Obsession.

A mage takes a Beat whenever he commits an Act of Hubris that risks Wisdom.

Enlightened (5 dice): Using magic selfishly or to accomplish something the willworker could have easily accomplished without magic. Allowing his magic to affect an innocent bystander (but with little or no harm done).

Understanding (3 dice): Using magic in the presence of Baseline witnesses. Controlling (instead of containing) a Paradox. Forcing a sapient being to act against its will or transforming it without its consent. Deliberate and premeditated murder or violence that leaves its victim with long-term injury.

Falling (1 die): Wielding magic in the most selfish, harmful, and reckless ways, such as killing someone in a fit of rage, destroying an Awakened soul, or trafficking with alien intelligences that seek the annihilation of reality.

Roll Results

Success: The mage doesn’t lose Wisdom.

Exceptional Success: The mage retains his Wisdom and takes an additional Beat.

Failure: The mage loses a dot of Wisdom and suffers the Hubris 3 Scar (Shallow Graves, p. XX), using his Wisdom in place of his Scar Resistance roll; this temporary Scar lasts until the first time he earns a Beat from it.

Dramatic Failure: As Failure, but the temporary Scar instead lasts until the mage gains or loses a dot of Wisdom.

Fuel Trait: Mana

Mana is the palpable, measurable bleed of magic into the world. The Wise can hold Mana no greater than 9 + Gnosis and generate it in one of two ways:

•            Oblation: Once per day, the mage may perform an hour-long ritual to regain points of Mana equal to half her Gnosis (rounded up).

•            Scouring: Once per day, the mage may suffer a point of lethal damage to regain three points of Mana.

Mana can be spent to:

•            Spend 1 Mana to reset a per-scene or per-chapter Variation or other ability, including casting spells that are not Rotes or spells of the mage’s Ruling Arcana (see below).

•            When casting a spell whose Reach exceeds his Grasp, the mage may spend Mana to reduce the number Paradox dice on a one-for-one basis.

•            Spend 3 Mana as an instant action to heal a point of bashing or lethal damage or to remove a Mental Condition (without earning a Beat) or a Tilt that represents a physical injury.

Arcana

Mages divide the power over which they have mastery into 10 Arcana (sing. Arcanum). By default, a mage’s rating in an Arcanum is 0, meaning she has no power over it. Awakened who have learned an Arcanum have a rating in it ranging from 1 to 5 dots.

Whenever gains her first dot in an Arcanum, she chooses four Variations within its purview – either from the examples below or other Variations approved by the Storyteller. She may cast spells that emulate those Variations at Magnitude 1. Variations like Sacred Flesh, Hypercompetence, and Cursed Flesh that are actually a collection of related Variations must be selected as individual spells each time. Whenever she increases her Arcanum rating, she increases the Magnitude of these Variations by 1.

Lash is a special case. A Bruising Lash is only available at Arcanum 3 or higher, and a Cutting Lash is only available at Arcanum 4 or higher.

Death: This Arcanum concerns cold, darkness, decay, enervation, ghosts, and souls.

Sample Variations: Out of Phase, Shadow Selves, Specialized Sense, Storm-Caller, Creeping Dread, Otherworldly Connection, Anomalous Biology, Cryokinesis, Shadow Command, Traumavore, Soul Seer, Cursed Flesh

Fate: This Arcanum includes blessings, destiny, fortune, hexes, oaths, and probability.

Sample Variations: Specialized Sense, Predator’s Cunning, Blessing, Fate’s Agent, Sacred Flesh, Chronological Alignment, Tool Mastery, Fate-Bind, Cursed Flesh

Forces: This Arcanum commands electricity, fire, gravity, heat, light, movement, sound, and weather.

Sample Variations: Bioluminescence, Camouflage, Electrokinesis, Environmental Adaptation, Flight, Immunity, Pyrokinesis, Specialized Sense, Storm-Caller, Telekinesis, Gravity Reduction, Gravity Intensification, Magnetic Control, Vocalization

Life: This is the Arcanum of animals, disease, food, healing metamorphosis, Physical Attributes and actions, and plants.

Sample Variations: Aquatic, Boneless, Brachiation, Face Thief, Gigantic, Healer, Hyper-Competence, Immunity, Miniaturization, Specialized Sense, Superhuman Attribute, Animal Transformation, Sacred Flesh, Sticky Filaments, Stretching, Extra Appendages, Plant Control, Beast Mastery, Body Modification, Cursed Flesh

Matter: This is the magic of alchemy, crafting, gases, liquids, shaping, solids, stasis and transmutation.

Sample Variations: Carapace, Environmental Adaptation, Immunity, Storm-Caller, Integrate Technology, Aerokinesis, Hydrokinesis, Terrakinesis, Tool Mastery, Matter Control

Mind: This Arcanum concerns communication, dreams, emotion, hallucination, language, memory, Mental and Social Attributes and actions, mental projection, and thought.

Sample Variations: Hyper-Competence, Superhuman Attribute, Astral Travel, Body Snatcher, Creeping Dread, Memory Thief, Telepathy, Pheromones, Omnicompetence, Dream Invader, Delude, Emotion Amplification, Cursed Flesh

Prime: This Arcanum commands Awakened magic, illusion, Mana, truth, and Yantras.

Sample Variations: Holographic Projection, Immunity, Fate’s Agent, Hidden Compartments, Conjuration, Occult Singularity, Emulate, Cursed Flesh

Space: This is the magic of conjuration, distance, names, scrying, separation, sympathy, and warding.

Sample Variations: Gigantic, Minaturization, Specialized Sense, Translocation, Psycho-Onomastics, Conjuration, Opener of Ways, Refuge, Clairvoyance

Spirit: This Arcanum concerns animistic spirits and otherworlds.

Sample Variations: Out of Phase, Astral Travel, Blessing, Otherworldly Connection, Opener of Ways, Refuge, Cursed Flesh; Summoner Form

Time: This is the magic of prophecy, change, postcognition, prophecy, time contraction and dilation, time travel.

Sample Variations: Enhanced Speed, Shadow Selves, Shadows of the Past, Translocation, Predator’s Cunning, Precognition, Omnicompetence, Anomalous Biology

Awakened Magic

The magic of the Wise involves the mage imposing his will on reality to make his vision (what the Awakened call the imago) real. Only a rare few accomplish this in the first place, and it takes long practice to sustain the imago for more than a few seconds at a time.

By default, a spell has the following properties:

•            A mage can only cast one spell per scene, although Adaptations and certain other effects can reset this.

•            Casting a spell requires an instant action and a successful roll using the mage’s Gnosis (minimum 1) + dots in the Arcanum of the spell.

•            The spell hits one subject of Size 5 or less (i.e., valid targets), or an area equal to an arm’s-length circle around a point.

•            The mage must be touching the subject of the spell, or be casting on herself, or must make a successful Gnosis + Athletics/Firearms - Defense attack with a range of 10/20/40.

•            Directed Variations (including a ranged Lash) can’t be granted, only directed. They have an instantaneous duration and a Scar Power equal to 1 + Arcanum dots (maximum 6).

•            Variations that lack the Directed keyword can be granted to a target (even if they have Directed effects), allowing them to enjoy the benefits as though they had the Variation during the duration (much like the Boon version of the Sacred Flesh Variation). They are non-instantaneous, meaning they last until the end of the scene (or until the mage dismisses them as a reflexive action) and count the mage’s Scar Power as 1.

•            A mage can’t have more spells active at a time than his Gnosis (minimum 1). This is his spell capacity.

•            An unwilling or unknowing sapient creature can’t be targeted if its relevant Resistance Attribute exceeds the mage’s Arcanum rating + 1.

•            If called upon to make a Scar Finesse roll to exercise exacting control over a Variation (including targeting the Directed effects of a Variation that lacks the Directed keyword), the willworker uses Gnosis (minimum 1) + Arcanum rating.

Reach and Grasp

A mage’s Grasp represents the safe limits of his magic. When casting a spell, a mage’s Grasp is equal to his Gnosis (minimum 1) + Arcanum rating. Certain effects can increase a willworker’s Grasp, some of which we’ll describe later, but one is universal to all Awakened:

•            Ritual (+1 Grasp): By undertaking a ritual lasting at least an hour, the spellcaster increases the limits of his magic.

Every spell has a Reach based on how difficult it is to cast. By default, a spell’s Reach is equal to the Arcanum rating (i.e., Variation Magnitude) at which it is being cast. A mage who wishes to overcome the usual limits of her magic can do so by increasing its Reach. Some of these we’ll describe later, but some are universal to all Awakened:

•            Range (+1 Reach): The spell can be targeted at sensory range.

•            Spell Limit (+1 Reach per excess spell): If the mage has reached his spell capacity, she may cast additional spells by accepting Reach equal to the number of active spells by which the new spell will put her capacity. A willworker with Gnosis 2 who has two spells active adds 1 Reach to cast another spell, and one with three active spells adds 2 Reach to cast another spell, and so forth.

As long as a spell’s Reach doesn’t exceed the mage’s Grasp, it remains fully within her control. If it exceeds her Grasp, she risks Paradox.

Paradox

Paradox is the fruit of hubris that punishes mages who reach beyond their grasp. If a spell’s Reach exceeds the mage’s Grasp, he must choose either to release or attempt to contain the Paradox:

•            If the spell is released, the Storyteller rolls the spell’s total Reach (not just the amount by which it exceeded his Grasp). Each success affects one person as though they were the victims of the Scapegoat Scar with a Magnitude equal to the mage’s dots in the spell’s Arcanum. This is an Understanding Act of Hubris if it affects a Baseline temporarily, but it is instead a Falling Act of Hubris if a Baseline is killed or permanently transformed while under the effects of the Paradox.

•            If the mage attempts to contain the Paradox, he makes a Wisdom roll contested by dice equal to the amount by which the Reach exceeded his Grasp. If the mage wins or ties, he takes bashing damage equal to the amount by which Reach exceeded Grasp; this damage can’t be healed by supernatural means. If the willworker loses this contest, he instead suffers the Persistent Drawback Scar for the spell’s duration and the Aftermath Scar after the spell’s duration ends. The Magnitude of these Scars is equal to the mage’s dots in the spell’s Arcanum. If the mage loses the contest and the spell’s Reach exceeded his Grasp by more than five, the Scars are Magnitude 5, but the spell fails.

•            The Secondary Scars imposed by these Scars should reflect the Arcanum of the spell and the mage’s intent or state of mind. The player may suggest appropriate Scars, but the Storyteller is final arbiter of what is appropriate.

Lesser Form: Path

The Wise categorize themselves into five “flavors” of mage, each with a special connection to two of the ten Arcana. The willworker doesn’t count spells cast from these Ruling Arcana against his once-per-scene limit and adds two dice to spellcasting rolls involving them. These magical Paths are:

Acanthus: Witches and prophets, their Ruling Arcana are Fate and Time.

Mastigos: Scryers and telepaths, their Ruling Arcana are Mind and Space.

Moros: Alchemists and necromancers, their Ruling Arcana are Death and Matter.

Obrimos: Channelers of natural and supernatural forces, their Ruling Arcana are Forces and Prime.

Thyrsus: Shamans and mystics, their Ruling Arcana are Life and Spirit.

This Form grants one dot in each of the mage’s Ruling Arcana. If he later purchases additional dots of Ruling Arcana through the Order and/or Legacy Forms (or has purchased them previous to selecting the Path Form), those dots also benefit from the effects above.

Lesser Form: Order

The Awakened join mystical Orders whose magical philosophies are compatible with their own. Membership grants the following benefits:

•            The mage receives one free dot of Occult.

•            The mage receives one free dot in the Status Merit for their Order.

•            The mage increases the rating of two Arcana of their choice by 1

•            The mage learns three Rotes, which must be spells/Variations she can currently cast. Casting a Rote doesn’t count against the mage’s once-per-scene limit, adds two dice to spellcasting rolls involving them, and treats the willworker as having an Arcanum rating of 5 for the purposes of calculating duration, Scar Power, and Grasp. Additional Rotes can be purchased for 1 Experience each.

Lesser Form: Legacy

Every mage’s soul has its own destiny – the shape it will take when she achieves sufficient enlightenment. This Legacy grants the following benefits:

•            The mage increases one Resistance Attribute of her choice by 1.

•            The mage adds two dots to any one Arcanum and may purchase additional Arcana dots at a cost of 4 Experiences each.

Lesser Form: Attainments

Prerequisites: The Path, Order, or Legacy Lesser Form

Mages don’t just wield magic; they are magic, and Attainments reflect the fundamental changes wrought by constant contact with mystical forces. This Form grants the following benefits:

Mage Sight: The Awakened can perceive all things within the purview of their Arcana that aren’t hidden by occult powers (which trigger a Clash of Wills). The mage enjoys perpetual access to Specialized Sense (Technology) 1 and Specialized Sense 2 relevant to their Arcana. Once per chapter, they may gain Specialized Sense 3 relevant to one of their Arcana until the end of the scene.

Mage Armor: Once per chapter, the mage gains the benefits of the Carapace Variation with a Magnitude equal to half their highest Arcanum rating (rounded up) until the end of the scene. This is a reflexive action but may only be used against attacks the willworker is aware of.

Arcana: Each Arcanum rated at 2 or higher grants one additional benefit:

•            Death: The mage benefits from Otherworldly Connection (Ghosts) 2. Once per chapter, they may increase this to Magnitude 3 until the end of the scene.

•            Fate: Once per chapter, when casting a spell with a non-instantaneous duration, the mage may define an event that will cause the spell to end immediately, even if they aren’t present at the time.

•            Forces: The mage gains 9-again on instant Physical actions. Once per chapter, they may instead gain 8-again on such rolls.

•            Life: The mage benefits from Rapid Healing 1. Once per chapter, they may heal a point of bashing or lethal damage to themselves.

•            Matter: Once per chapter, when casting a non-instantaneous spell, the mage may extend its duration until the end of the story or until they dismiss it. The spell still counts towards the willworker’s spell capacity.

•            Mind: The mage gains 9-again on Mental and Social actions. Once per chapter they may instead gain 8-again on such rolls.

•            Prime: The mage benefits from Fate’s Agent (Awakened Magic) 1. Once per chapter, they may instead increase this to Magnitude 3 until the end of the scene.

•            Space: The mage benefits from Clairvoyance 1. Once per chapter, they may increase this to Clairvoyance (Balanced) 3 until the end of the scene.

•            Spirit: The mage benefits from Otherworldly Connection (Spirits) 2. Once per chapter, they may increase this to Magnitude 3 until the end of the scene.

•            Time: The mage gains the Tactical Delay 1 Merit on any of their spells with a non-instantaneous duration and ignoring the prerequisites. They must choose to invoke this Merit when casting the spell. Once per chapter, they may instead benefit from the Tactical Delay 2 Merit when casting a spell with a non-instantaneous duration.

Lesser Form: Improvised Magic

Prerequisites: The Path, Order, or Legacy Lesser Form

Awakened magic flows from the imagination, and anything a mage may fix in an imago is within his grasp if his will is strong enough. The mage may cast spells that emulate any Variation whose effects fall into the purview of his Arcana (subject to Storyteller approval).

Lesser Form: Thaumaturgy

Prerequisites: The Path, Order, or Legacy Lesser Form

The Awakened’s vision exceeds those of lesser sorcerers. Once per chapter, when she casts a spell, she may Reach in order to expand its influence:

•            Duration: A non-instantaneous spell lasts until the end of the story or until it is dismissed by the mage (as a reflexive action) or dispelled (+1 Reach). The spell instead lasts until it is dispelled or dismissed (+2 Reach).

•            Area: The spell may affect an area up to the size of a small house (+1 Reach), a grocery store (+2 Reach), a shopping center (+3 Reach), or a small town (+4 Reach).

•            Targets: The spell may affect up to five targets of Size 5 or less (+1 Reach), up to 10 targets of up to Size 10 or less (+2 Reach), or up to 20 targets of up to Size 20 or less. Each additional Reach doubles the number of targets and the maximum Size of each target.

•            Withstand: When determining whether the mage’s spell successfully targets an unwilling or unknowing, sapient subject, count her Arcanum rating as 2 higher (+1 Reach) or 4 higher (+2 Reach). Each additional Reach adds two to this effective Arcanum rating.

•            Customization: Once per chapter, the mage may make a modification to a spell as they cast it, the equivalent of a +0 Magnitude Deviation (+1 Reach).

Once per chapter, the mage may spend 1 point of Experience to remove a spell from those under the mage’s control. She can no longer dismiss the spell, but it doesn’t count towards her spell capacity. If it is dispelled or otherwise ceases to benefit her or her allies, the Sanctity of Merits applies.

Archetypes

Jealous Mystagogue: She’s warned them of ambushes and traps more times than the Renegades can count, and the rituals she conducts the night before their big operations really do seem to work. The way she studies them, like she’s meticulously vivisecting them with her eyes, is unsettling, and her reassurances that no other mage in the city will trouble them because she has claimed them as hers are anything but reassuring.

Conspiracy Vizier: He taught them how to crack a soul to unleash its power, and for the scraps of his knowledge they carry out his orders unquestioningly – supplying fresh subjects for his experiments and confounding his many enemies. To him, the Web of Pain is just another symbol of the will of the Exarchs he serves – one meant to keep humanity enchained. And if the Divergence destroys any hope that a victim will Awaken, that only means fewer people to compete with him for the Exarchs’ favor.

Incensed Reaper: She regards the Remade and those who made them as abominations for their mistreatment of the soul and has made it her mission to destroy the Web of Pain. Although she is reluctant to ally herself with the Broken, she can be persuaded to side with the Renegades in their fight. The core of her affront is by no means moralistic, however. She steals and consumes human souls regularly to fuel her power and extend her unnaturally long life – and she won’t countenance mere Baselines dabbling in arts that are the sole province of her kind.

Comments

Earth Seraph Edna

It looks to me like Black Vans mages can set themselves up to be simply superior to an equivalent-Threat Deviant. A Threat Level 3 Remade, for comparison, has a relatively humble 7 + 1 Scar-free = 8 Magnitude of Variations. A Threat Level 3 mage can have Path, Legacy, and Thaumaturgy. This is enough to support 3 dots in one Arcanum and 1 dot in another. Let us say that this mage is a Mastigos who is perfectly happy settling for four instances of Superhuman Attribute 3. Over the course of a day or two, they keep trying, and trying, and trying with Ritual and Duration to land three spells at indefinite duration, spending Mana as necessary to reduce Paradox to a chance die. (If they suffer Paradox, they contain it and resume their attempts.) Eventually, they get all three spells up. The character now has 12 Magnitude of Variations, completely Scar-free. Their Scar Power is stuck at 1, but it does not matter if they pick Superhuman Attributes that do not call for Scar Power. The mage scales better and better with Threat Level and Gnosis, buying up more and more Arcana (and, importantly, Improvised Magic) in such a way that they can simply walk around with multiple Variation 5s without Scars. Am I missing anything?

Eric Zawadzki

Spell control is a significant factor for Lesser Form mages, but the big thing is I made a huge mistake in the calculation of Grasp. It should be equal to the mage's Arcanum dots. There's a long story about why this can be explained as a simple copy/paste error, but it's not worth getting into here.

Earth Seraph Edna

Does Withstand count in Superhuman Attribute? If so, then Superhuman Attribute becomes an unusually effective method of becoming immune to undesired spells: even amongst mages themselves. Perhaps the listed Paths could merely be suggestions or samples, in case the Storyteller wants to run their own take on mages with their own Paths? I think that this could go for many other supernatural type as well. It would help the Storyteller customize their game world.

Eric Zawadzki

I can't think of a reason why it wouldn't. But as any Mage player will tell you, being immune to the direct effects of spells doesn't protect you from *indirect* effects. As far as Paths (and Arcana!) being samples, I considered that as a space-saving measure, but I wanted to maintain a bit more of Mage's structure. They're already the most versatile of all splats, after all. That said, stay tuned for High Fantasy, which *does* offer Vocations as mere examples of the myriad possibilities.