Black Vans Sneak Peek - Investigations (Patreon)
Content
Options for running chronicles that involve other splats or that use the tropes of another genre are exciting for those who want to run a Deviant chronicle that eschews many of the game's default assumptions. However, no Storyteller's Guide would be complete without practical advice for Storytellers who want to run a chronicle of the sort described in the core book - one with shadowy conspiracies, tragic Scars, and the promise of violent (or even less-violent) revenge. To that end, Black Vans explains and expands upon the Storytelling System, showing how to use it to enhance the roleplaying experience and offering guidance and optional systems for further customizing it to the themes and mood of Deviant. Today's sneak peek is an exploration of the Investigation system.
Usual caveats: This is a first draft. Things will change between now and the finished product, and you're not getting the full context of everything (what the heck is the Interruptions and Milestones permutation?).
Investigation
The investigation system (Deviant, p. 210) is closely related to the extended action system, particularly its Interruptions and Milestones permutation. Whether singly or in a group, the Remade engage in a scene that gives them insight into a larger problem or puzzle. At the end of it, they come closer to a fuller understanding of what they’re investigating (receive a Clue). If things go badly during the scene, they still receive a Clue, but it’s a little less useful in furthering the investigation (or actively hampers it, on a dramatic failure). The cohort can also “rush” to the truth before they’ve accumulated enough Clues, but it results in complications.
The dice pool to uncover the Clue depends on the method the character(s) are using to investigate. The Storyteller should feel free to assign a bonus or penalty to a roll based on the events of the scene. An engaging but short scene might afford a small benefit or disadvantage on the roll, while an elaborate one with several rolls could grant a massive bonus if perfectly executed or impose a substantial penalty if it’s a complete fiasco.
Number of Clues
The decision of how many Clues are required to uncover the truth rests with the Storyteller and is almost always exactly equal to the number of scenes she expects the cohort to devote to the mystery at hand. Picking that number is a pacing decision. An investigation that requires a few Clues can often be completed in a single chapter if the cohort is single-minded in its pursuit, while one that demands ten or more Clues could stretch across an entire story (or longer if the Renegades have little opportunity to focus on unraveling it).
Most of the time, the players don’t know exactly how many Clues are needed to complete an investigation, but the Storyteller should clearly communicate when they’ve successfully uncovered the truth. It is often a good idea to convey the scale of the investigation in broad terms so that players have some sense of how bad an idea it is to rush the investigation. They might regard facing slightly stronger opposition as an acceptable risk but consider being overwhelmingly outnumbered and outgunned an outright suicidal pursuit.
Elements
A Clue’s elements can always be spent to further the investigation. This can be applied in several different ways:
Uncover Clues: At the culmination of a scene, a character makes the roll to uncover the next Clue. The elements of any Clue – even an incomplete one from a failed roll – can be expended to grant a bonus to uncover the next Clue. Finding a corner piece of the jigsaw puzzle makes it easier to fit the other pieces together.
Lead-up Scenes: The Remade may also use elements to boost a roll during one of the other scenes that further the investigation, even one that doesn’t seem directly related to the Clue, such as a bonus to an Athletics roll to climb a fence.
Culmination Scene: Investigations in roleplaying games are rarely undertaken out of pure intellectual curiosity. They nearly always precede some action, whether it’s an attack on a Node or a high stakes meeting with an elusive Renegade to secure her help. The Broken may use any elements remaining to boost their dice rolls in the scene that is the culmination of their investigation. Alternatively, they may spend elements to impose a penalty to a conspiracy action taken during the culmination scene, as they have taken measures to make sure the conspiracy is off-balance. Especially dramatic moments in a chronicle can stretch out a culmination scene to affect an entire chapter – for better or worse.
Retroactive Preparations (Optional Rule)
Knowing what lurks ahead helps the Renegades prepare for it – even if the players (or the Storyteller!) aren’t quite sure what they’ll need. Under this optional rule, players can spend an element to retroactively define some reasonable preparation they made for the current scene – whether it’s one of the Clue-gathering scenes or the event the investigation was leading up to.
This could be a piece of personal equipment to which the character could reasonably have with him but which the player didn’t specifically mention having on his person when the scene started. It can instead be the prompt arrival of a member of his cohort who isn’t tied up elsewhere. It might even be an action taken prior to the scene that impacts it or its aftermath, but this is subject to Storyteller approval, who may require the expenditure of multiple elements or introduce additional complications related to the action. This advantage shouldn’t last beyond the current scene.
Tainted Clues
Tainted Clues are usually either self-inflicted (by choosing to take a dramatic failure to get a Beat) or rare. However, they have a strong impact when they occur, subtracting a success from rolls to advance the investigation until their element is used (imposing a -2 penalty to an affected roll). Which rolls this affects at her table is a decision for the Storyteller, but here are some broad possibilities:
Unlimited or Not: If Tainted Clues have unlimited effect, they impose their penalty to all rolls in scenes that will end in the cohort uncovering a Clue. The Storyteller may instead only apply this to a single roll during each scene or only to the roll to uncover the scene’s Clue’s. It could instead only affect the culmination scene, encumbering the Broken’s actions when they matter most. A common balancing consideration is that a player may not invoke the element of a Tainted Clue except for actions that would have their successes reduced by the Tainted Clue.
Group Clues vs. Individual Clues: The Storyteller should decide whether the effects of a Tainted Clue (including the option to invoke its element) apply only to the character who suffered the dramatic failure that created it or whether it affects the entire cohort.
The more rolls a Tainted Clue potentially impacts, the more likely the players are to invoke its element at the earliest opportunity.
Major Complications
Renegades (and some players) aren’t renowned for the patient care they put into planning their operations before executing them. Even those who would like to approach strikes against the conspiracy and its agents with caution don’t always have the opportunity. Time spent investigating the enemy instead of acting against it is time that enemy has to expand its power and influence, which makes any operation conducted against it that much more dangerous. Leaping before they look can land a cohort in a lot of hot water in the form of “one major complication per Clue they fall short,” but what does this mean?
The Opposition: A conspiracy can achieve a great deal within its sphere of influence, but it is considerably more dangerous when faced at its centers of power. If the culmination scene takes place at a conspiracy’s Node, the conspiracy may spend a major complication to take an additional conspiracy action that doesn’t count towards its limit for the chapter – and may spend multiple complications this way. However, these actions must be confined to the events of the current scene.
External Factors: Complications need not stem from the conspiracy directly. They can involve factors beyond anyone’s control, such as an Environmental Tilt or the arrival of an interested third party who adds chaos to an already volatile situation. They could also target individual characters whenever they fail on a roll, automatically converting that failure to a dramatic failure (but still awarding a Beat when they do so).
Time Sensitive Missions (Optional Rule)
Often a cohort doesn’t have the luxury of time to carefully research a target before taking action against it. A Linchpin will arrive in a week and leave a day later, and if the cohort isn’t ready to strike when she is in town, they’ll miss the opportunity and waste any time they spent probing the Node’s defenses ahead of an attack.
This optional rule combines the Investigation system with the Beat the Clock version of extended actions. The Storyteller provides the troupe with a limited ration of scenes that they can devote to some mixture of conducting their investigation and advancing any of their other goals (such as coming to the aid of a Loyalty Touchstone). For maximum pressure, this limit should be close to the number of Clues required to reveal the truth before the culmination scene. If they allow themselves to get distracted, they have the choice of either aborting the operation or proceeding with it knowing that the culmination scene will involve that many more unexpected complications.
While the Storyteller might choose not to reveal exactly how many Clues the investigation will require, she should usually be pretty clear about how much time the cohort has to complete it – and whether this is to be measured in scenes (which encourages the cohort to engage in them together) or in-world time (which encourages them to take a divide-and-conquer approach to the investigation).