Shared Lore (Patreon)
Content
William just finished a week of Adventures in Cardboard, which is a day camp that lives at the intersection of Renaissance Festival, a running game of capture the flag, and a boffer LARP. Everyone makes their own cardboard swords (along with some shields and even armor) and spends their time hitting each other with them. Those who complete quests of varying kinds earn gold coins, and a certain percentage of them, my son among them, make a side hustle of running shops that sell extra weapons, mercenary/assassin services, snacks/drinks, and opportunities to engage in gambling using the coin of the realm.
William has been doing this for the last couple of years, and it's been fun watching how his focus has shifted from one year to the next. The first year, he was just so utterly floored by the whole premise that he just let himself flow with it. The second year, he discovered that he could bring bags of candy from home and make a killing as a shop owner. This year, it was all about the lore.
Lore has always been a component of the game. The camp counselors adopt personas who give quests, oversee the action, and participate in the roleplaying. But this year's meta involved a tyrannical king who increasingly banned innocuous activities that have emerged from the cardboard culture. This included gambling - a prohibition William first attempted to evade by renaming it "dice therapy", but when therapy was banned as well, he took to running a gambling speakeasy beneath the cardboard castle at the center of play. The whole week culminated in a successful regicide (and I'm thrilled that my son has had enough exposure to English literature via memes to describe this quite naturally as "Brutus-ing the king") and the coronation of a handmade stuffed mushroom with eyes.
As these events were being summarized for the crowd of parents by a friend's daughter reading from a cardboard scroll (somehow a wedding at a Noodles and Company was involved?), I couldn't help but think about how lore emerges in roleplaying games. All friendships are, in part, about shared experiences and recounting them to one another. Sometimes it's tales of shenanigans you pulled or challenges you faced together - the sorts of things that get dredged up during best man and maid of honor speeches. More often, it's about mutual or substantially similar things you experienced separately - the movies you watched, the music you love, the hobbies you enjoy, the exciting sportsball tournament arc finale that you still remember. Roleplaying is mostly built on direct shared experiences, but because these games obey their participants' sense of drama, they have many of the opportunities for analysis and discussion that a popular book or movie has.
A "you know you're a TTRPG gamer if" list I saw many years ago included "If you have more 'no shit, there I was in a game' stories than you have about your own children, you might be a TTRPG gamer." This seemed funny to pre-fatherhood me, but do you know what? It remains true. I mean, I tell stories about my children a lot (I've never met a parent who couldn't be coaxed into sharing some anecdote about their kids), but I've also played a lot of roleplaying games. My first "roleplaying with someone who wanted to roleplay, rather than with my younger siblings who had not idea what I was on about" experience was in 1987, and I can count the number of times I've gone without running or playing a game for more than the duration of a summer vacation on the fingers of one hand.
I take delight in hearing people talk about their Deviant chronicles in the same spirit that a grandparent likes to hear stories about their grandchildren. The stories are not of my making, not within my control on either side of the Storyteller's screen. But I had a hand in making them possible, and hearing about how that turned out is incredibly cool and lets me participate in their games by proxy. And as with most grandparents I know, I can't help but retell those stories to others - and so the shared lore spreads and maybe draws more people together in the experience.