Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

I'm in the process of writing a section on a staple of cyberpunk fiction - hacking. I've read lots of great sci-fi that featured cyberspaces through the lens of fantasy realms, whether it was Heroes Die, Otherland, Snow Crash, or even Reamde. It's totally cool to have a virtual reality that looks like Alice in Wonderland or something even stranger. In a roleplaying game, however, this approach runs into a few problems.

First, it really only works if all the players' characters are along for the ride. This sort of scenario really is no place for one or two dedicated haxx0rs and a bunch of meatspacers.

Second, it can run to the whimsical side, which doesn't really fit Deviant's tone - not even in a cyberpunk version of Deviant.

Third, it kind of...doesn't make sense? I can see some eccentric weirdo setting up the security on his files so that only those with a deep familiarity with the Simarillion will be able to puzzle out the algorithm that will decrypt them, but I have a hard time imagining that any self-respecting conspiracy in the Web of Pain would do something like that. But if successfully completing a King's Quest IV walk-through isn't the secret to hacking the googleplex mainframe or whatever, then cyberspace antics begin to feel rather extraneous.

So, the route I'm leaning towards right now is to make cyberspace an overlay to physical reality. To say that those who have installed Upgrades (i.e., Variations) need for those enhancements to grant them some kind of web connection (because I somehow doubt the future no longer has need for firmware upgrades and software patches). This makes Upgrades (which, conveniently, all Remade have) a liability as well as an advantage. It means that those with the right resources and skills can hack the Upgraded, so it's a good idea to have an ally or two who can counteract those virtual attacks (and launch cyber attacks of their own). Surveillance is already so ubiquitous in the setting that it doesn't really seem all that weird that virtually present characters can make a real impact on a physical location - or that some targets are going to be more hardened to physical incursions than to virtual ones (or vice versa).

A cohort might choose to conduct an entire operation remotely, with real consequences if they fail or make a lot of noise. But its members could instead rely on physical presence or make use of a hybrid approach - or choose their approach from operation to operation depending on preliminary reconnaissance. This feels both very cyberpunk and completely Deviant.

Comments

Jonathan Lang

Sorry for the delayed response; I was in a tight financial binduntil today, and my membership lapsed. My own thoughts here are that cyberspace — at least, the version I'm more interested in — is less a matter of some eccentric weirdo setting up his security system to operate his digital security, and more like what you see in the Tron franchise; which is why, when I mentioned it before, I pointed out the parallels to Astral Space. Flynn didn't sculpt an appearance for Tron when he wrote his security program; and the idea that there was a digital landscape populated by humanoid beings that were manifestations of programs in the system came as a shock to him. With that parallel in mind: "First, it really only works if all the players' characters are along for the ride. This sort of scenario really is no place for one or two dedicated haxx0rs and a bunch of meatspacers." This is exactly as true of a Deviant with Astral Travel as it is with a netrunner. And yet, nobody complains that the Astral Traveler doesn't bring the entire group along with his voyages into the psychic landscapes of other people. "Second, it can run to the whimsical side, which doesn't really fit Deviant's tone - not even in a cyberpunk version of Deviant." The trick, then, is not to be whimsical; at least, not _too_ whimsical. I remember you commenting elsewhere that Deviant's art has a touch of dark whimsy about it, but just a touch; that's how I'd see the Astral-like version of cyberspace. Don't go the fantasy route, per se; make security programs more like Manticores: dangerous little monsters that are symbolic of the Conspiracy that wrote them and the function they were written to perform, in the same way that Goetia that an Astral Traveler encounters while diving into a person's soul are presented to the player as humanoids or creatures symbolic of whatever aspect of that person's soul they represent. I'd also l look to the likes of Ghost in the Shell: Stand-Alone Complex for an example of an Otherworldly cyberspace that isn't whimsical. Granted, the digital dives there tend to be more along the lines of VR-based social platforms: we don't see the Major invading a digital fortress, but we _do_ see her diving into a digital forum for investigatory purposes. "Third, it kind of...doesn't make sense? I can see some eccentric weirdo setting up the security on his files so that only those with a deep familiarity with the Simarillion will be able to puzzle out the algorithm that will decrypt them, but I have a hard time imagining that any self-respecting conspiracy in the Web of Pain would do something like that." …which is why you don't present it as something that digital site managers set up. The digital landscape and the programs that populate it would be an emergent property of the Oneiros-equivalent Realm that the netrunner immerses himself in. "So, the route I'm leaning towards right now is to make cyberspace an overlay to physical reality." In this regard, I have two thoughts: first, more recent takes on cyberspace as an Otherworld have _also_ included Augmented Reality as well as Virtual Reality, with the former being more like Twilight (Clade Companion p.30). On the other hand, I _do_ agree that cyberspace as an Otherworld shouldn't be the _default_ approach to hacking in Deviant's cyberpunk; I could see relegating it to a box that references the Clades Companion, particularly the Outsider Form with its AI root and the Ephemeral Entities chapter with its Creating New Realms section, with a recommendation that said cyberspace be patterned after the Astral Realms with digital sites substituting for Oneiroi and programs substituting for Goetia. That's really all I'm looking for: a box that gives advice on how a Storyteller who wants to include an Otherworldly cyberspace could go about it.

Jonathan Lang

In terms of hacking Upgrades: absolutely, that should be a thing. To me, one of the big things about the cyberpunk genre is that it blurs the line between man and machine: the Replicants of Blade Runner exist specifically to question where the line should be drawn; Total Recall is a study of what happens when you have technology that can hack memories; and Ghost in the Shell: Stand-Alone Complex features peoples' perceptions being hacked, the result being similar to creating an illusion. So on the one hand, you have artificial people who originated as machines but are still _people;_ while on the other hand, you have people who have received Upgrades and are now vulnerable to being hacked, something that we currently view as something only machines are vulnerable to. As well, the Web of Pain has a tendency to view people as things; it's central why it is the Web of _Pain._ This existence of people-like machines and machine-like people, as well as people being treated like machines and machines being treated like people, is an essential part of the genre. I think here the question becomes, to what extent can someone _without_ Upgrades engage in hacking of those who do? And what does that look like in game terms?

Eric Zawadzki

No worries. I suspected you just hadn't set up auto-renew and lost track of the date you were set to lapse.

Eric Zawadzki

You should check out yesterday's patrons-only post. I think it should give you a clear idea of the direction I've gone in the first draft, and I welcome suggestions from there, although it might be a bit before I circle back to Cyberpunk now that I've wrapped up that section's initial draft.