Brainstorming Fantasy (Patreon)
Content
I had a pretty fantastically productive week (10k words, which is twice my typical weekly output) and hope to have a productive weekend, too. Labor Day is one of three weekends of the year when Beth takes the kids to her parents' and leaves me to catch up on sleep, watch anime with some friends, and, most importantly, write a bunch.
I've got some quite exciting announcements coming soon, but I'm not quite ready to do more than tease about their existence, so for now I'm going to share my brainstorming notes on the fantasy section of Black Vans. This one is simultaneously easy and hard for me. I started writing fantasy novels with a friend when I was 14 and continued to do so until I started getting regular assignments to write for Onyx Path. We even self-published a couple of them back in the day, but they unfortunately never took off, and so we kind of went our separate ways, creatively. Between that and my voracious, lifelong consumption of exemplars of the genre (and the many TTRPGs it has spawned), I have very strong feelings about it. And marrying the tropes of the genre to those of Deviant is a particular creative challenge.
Have no fear that I'll remain in a state of stunned shock at the sheer number of possibilities, though. All forms of creativity are at least in some part a process of excluding what isn't needed, zooming in on what is most important, and building something beautiful (or at least fun) on that foundation. Still, if today's brainstorming post is a little chaotic and scattered, that's why.
The usual caveats here: These are a pretty random outpouring of passing thoughts as they happen. Not everything here will make it into the first draft, much less the final - and good thing, too, because some of them are mutually exclusive.
Fantasy
Heritage System: Less offensive version of race, origin, or species (with a side of small o origin).
Limited stories vs. epic ones.
The local/global/regional/otherworldly dynamic is likely the same here based on threat level.
Trap and dungeon crawl systems.
It might be time to bring in Horror mechanics.
If there’s a place for a good vs. evil Integrity system, it’s here.
Prophecies and divine omens are hard to do in a TTRPG.
Each conspiracy is a unified threat the cohort faces. Unlike in vanilla Deviant, they don’t necessarily have a human face.
How should I translate Origin and Clade, if Divergence isn’t some weird singular event? The cheating way to handle it is to change them to some form of Heritage/DefinitelyNotClass system. Call it Who and Why, for now, but that definitely can’t be what they’re called.
The Scar-free Magnitude of Variation from Origin might often wind up literally being based on the character’s origin (har har) or upbringing.
Apotheosis
Currently missing suggested Specialties for Archery, Enigmas, and Ride.
Naming power and unique Prototypes.
Resources runs contrary to treasure-hunting stories. Either I don’t care (because this genre isn’t that) or I need to address this.
Creating some kind of pseudo-conspiracy seems a likely result of all this adventuring, but the choice not to do so should also be supported.
Will probably need to formally add weapons, armor, and possibly also other fantasy equivalent.
There’s a quite interesting weapon/armor creation system in Dark Antiquities (p. 51-53). Not completely different conceptually from other games, but conveniently specific to CofD.
Prototypes that represent magic items can be bought with starting Variation Magnitude.
I’m pretty sure I’m ditching Origin in its ordinary form. Characters have an Origin (or perhaps a Clade in its original definition) that is a combination of biological and cultural heritage. They also have a Vocation that is, narratively, a combination of educational background and choice of profession similar to what other games call a class, but which is also the equivalent of a Clade. These are the Arcanist (Coactive), Champion (Invasive), Mystic (Cephalist), Praxist (Mutant), and Wildling (Chimeric) – maybe, as I’m not sure I want it to be quite so clearcut.
Alternatively, Clade summarizes whether the power comes from heritage (Chimeric), an external force/being (Coactive), gear (Invasive), hard work (Cephalist), or hard experience (Mutant). As with Clade in the core, this doesn’t close off Variation options, just narrows them very slightly. Perhaps recommend a couple of “Clade Scars” that are slightly more likely to occur.
As an alternative to the alternative, abolish Clade entirely. Set some guidance around Adaptations, maintain that Variations that grant secondary Variations can’t grant Clade Variations, and go from there.
Demons, gods, and monsters walk among us. Overt Variation use tends to attract their attention.
No matter how different everyone may seem on the surface, there’s a weird homogeneity of language and certain cultural elements. There are only a relative handful of modern languages and a similar number of dead languages. Multilingual only works for modern languages and has two versions – one that grants spoken fluency but requires a roll to read/write, and one that grants fluency in writing but allows only halting verbal communication. Philologist is specific to ancient/dead languages and allows a roll to read/write/speak/understand two languages.
If there’s a “no/few Scars” setting, this is it. They likely still apply on high-Mag Variations, and everyone probably gets at least one, but they’re not nearly as much the focus as in other settings. Alternatively, threat level determines the maximum Variation Magnitude at the start of the chronicle (half Standing, rounded up); this also makes Natural Variations of high Magnitude unobtainable except in chronicles with a high threat level.
The universality of Variations means “dirt farmer epic fantasy” isn’t going to be an option.
Consider offering some fantasy pedigrees based on ephemeral entity categories and the half-splats of the various CofD games – beast-blooded, Proximi (spun as sort of magically manufactured elves), Fractals, scarecrows (pseudo-Prometheans and fetches), dhampirs, demigods, immortals, what else? Offer birth-based and culture-based Natural Variations/Scars.
BTW, if you want me to expand on any of the ephemeral entity types in Clades Companion or add any others that didn’t rate a mention there (or wouldn’t fit a modern chronicle), let me know in the comments.
What is Instability in this genre? I feel like End Stage should transform you into a monster. Perhaps Remade are bound by Principles that prevent their powers from raging out of control, and Instability is what happens when you fail to adhere to yours. Instability’s impact/emphasis can be lessened, leaving out the automatic Instability at the beginning of each story and mandatory action each chapter. With it being less commonly inflicted, it’s okay for it to be harder to heal (but not Feral-level difficult to heal). Maybe suffering a complication due to your Scars heals it, along with adhering to or suffering for your Principles.