Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

First, a quick reminder that Shallow Graves is part of STV's Black Friday sale, but I think that ends after Monday.

When I'm writing a first draft, the only thing that really matters to me is adding words to the current work in progress (WIP). I measure the success of my writing day by the net increase in this word count. Back when there was a Twitter - back when I was on Facebook, on LiveJournal - I'd crow about how many words I had written. Nothing encapsulates this quite like NaNoWriMo (best wishes to all who celebrate on this the final day), which I did once and "won" despite a catastrophic hard drive failure during week 3.

This was something I figured out even as a young writer: You can't finish any writing project unless you actually, you know, do a bunch of writing.

First drafts are the part of the move where you bring all the stuff you own into the empty house. If you don't bring it into the house, then it won't be in the house when you start rearranging furniture.

First drafts are a little bit indiscriminate. They want the words to be good, but the main goal is to make sure there are enough of them.

Once the words are in the house, I arrange them (redlines). Then I rid myself of that couch that won't fit in the new living room, run to IKEA to buy a couple bookshelves to replace the built-ins I had at the old place, and unpack everything (second draft).

It is at this point that I leave behind the the moving day metaphor and put on the developer hat. This was the part of the process I was once really bad at. We writers love our words - every cute turn of phrase, every winking allusion, every additional example and helpful sidebar. We spend so much time unearthing those nuggets that it's painful to discard any of them.

But if the finished product is going to be any good, you have to.

You have to be able to take each sentence and ask "this is pretty good, but is it good enough - is it necessary?" And if the answer is "no", you are obligated to cut it.

Arya recently decided she wanted to clean her room - not in the "stuff everything in the closet and call it good" sense but to de-clutter it. I'm not even exaggerating when I say that she threw away one-third, gave away one-third, and kept the last third. And while that ratio is more extreme than what I'm doing, de-cluttering makes a decent metaphor for the development pass.

Just like with the first draft, I have a word count goal for each section, for each chapter, and for the overall project. But this time the number is smaller than the one I start out with.

Those cuts aren't indiscriminate. They can't be. Because the point is to say all the same things using fewer words and just throwing out an entire section would be like dividing your bedroom into quarters and just throwing away everything in quadrant B. Instead, you have to pick up each toy, examine each drawing, and decide whether to keep or discard it. It's tedious and potentially emotional.

At Thanksgiving, my mother-in-law was telling me about an episode of Hoarders she saw where the...contestant? Not sure what you call that, but anyway, this person had a story attached to every object in her overflowing house and was so reluctant to let go of any of it that the hosts eventually threw up their hands and offered to just move it all into a storage unit. They wouldn't throw away any of it, you see, just put it in storage, and wouldn't she be willing to help them decide what would stay in the house and what should go into storage? This was, at last, something she could do. The psychology changed from "keep only what you need" (but I might need all of it!) to "keep only what you need right now." (No word on whether she later went through that storage unit or whether that storage unit ends up a contestant on Storage Wars in a few years.)

I've long told people that I am a data pack rat. I keep every draft. Every adorable turn of phrase I've ever lovingly crafted is somewhere on my hard drive. In another era, I'd be one of those writer stereotypes with scraps of paper and draft manuscripts piled up around my study, but I grew up in the digital age, and a terabyte of storage (more than I'll write in a lifetime) takes up less space than a kid's first chapter book. I hoard these scraps of thoughts that didn't make it to the final draft. I used to tell myself that maybe one day someone will want to see all the stuff I cut, but I know that's just fantasy. The real reason I keep it all is the same reason moving everything to a storage unit feels better than throwing it all away.

Knowing that the second draft is still out there as its own file allows me to maintain a degree of detachment when I'm making cuts that would otherwise be painful. Those cuts make for a cleaner and less cluttered book and help keep production costs from ballooning. They're not anything a reader will ever miss. And if I'm being honest, they're not anything I'll miss, either.

Comments

No comments found for this post.