Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

After spending some time reviewing beta reader notes, I've started implementing changes to the text of Black Vans. Fiction, Intro, and Chapter One are done, for now, and Chapter Two is in progress. I say "for now" because although I've taken steps to address beta reader feedback, I'll ultimately complete another read-through of everything from beginning to end before sending it all out for editing.

In some ways, this is one of the hardest revision passes. Beta readers more often identify things that are missing or require more explanation than the find things that are extraneous and should be cut. But if I only add words, to the beta reader draft, what goes into editing will rapidly trend towards 200,000 words, which it can't afford to be.

So, a soft goal of this revision pass is to cut as much as I add, which is hard. This means meticulously going sentence-by-sentence, paragraph-by-paragraph to find ways to cut a few word here and there. You can imagine how much fun that is; there are reasons that writers/developers are often incredibly sick of reading our work by the time it finally goes to print.

It also involves a certain amount of "this whole section isn't pulling its weight and needs to go." This is differently hard. There is very little I enjoy reading more than most of everything I've written. I don't think this is a universal experience among writers (I've met plenty who seem to hate reading just about everything they have written), but I don't think it's rare. A writer who doesn't at least enjoy some of what they've written is as unlikely to become a writer as someone who hates the sight of blood is to become a trauma surgeon. Like, you're going to be spending a lot of time reading what you've written until your eyes cross and common words start looking like they're misspelled even when they aren't, so you'd better enjoy it at least some of the time. Cutting those words - murdering your darlings, as the horrifying expression goes - isn't easy. You sweated blood for those words, after all!

But revision relies on a willingness to let some of that stuff go. I find that maintaining prior versions of my work makes it less difficult. Even stuff that doesn't make it into the finished product still exists out there in some file folder on my laptop - like the plaster cast of the paw print of your dearly loved and sadly departed pet cat. It won't curl up in your lap and purr anymore, but you still have that memento (and let's be honest, a file folder of pictures of them doing cute and/or stupid things when they were alive). In the same way, I could go back to one of those early drafts and reread it if I wanted to; that I probably won't (at least not very often) doesn't really matter.

And if I find that my net word count change is negative, maybe I'll dig up one of the sections from the cutting room floor and restore it to the latest draft. I could, but I probably won't. Necromancy is frowned upon by most decent folk, after all.

Comments

Jonathan Lang

A practice I've seen other writers use is to make the "cutting room floor" stuff available for public consumption; this has usually been in an "author's notes" article somewhere where the author is asked to provide commentary on the writing process and/or to elucidate their vision for the product. In this case, it's in the form of "what might have been, and why I didn't go there". In this case, why not publish here some of the things that _won't_ be going into Black Vans, and why you're cutting them? "In order to make room for this, I ended up cutting that."

Eric Zawadzki

I might do something of the sort one day - likely on the Patreon, because I don't think that context is worth the trouble of layout and design. "To make room" is usually the reason I cut things, although sometimes it's more along the lines of "it was clunky and betas didn't seem excited about it, but making it good was going to require more work than just cutting it and putting in something cooler."