Black Vans WIP: Superhero Emergence (Patreon)
Content
Taking another crack at this one. Let me know if I'm on the right track or if there are issues I haven't addressed.
This version:
Creates Allegiances, which give characters more options to choose from than Devoted vs. Renegade, permitting new archetypes of the superhero genre, such as the vigilante folk hero.
Distinguishes Sentiment from an individual cohort's Reputation and divorces it from the number of Crises/conspiracy actions.
Allows for a chronicle where a conspiracy is still a major antagonist, while allowing Crises/MacGuffins as an alternative to conspiracy actions/Icons where appropriate.
Eliminates Opponents.
Makes a few small clarifications to Audacity.
Allows greater variety in how many Variations/Merits are available at character creation (and changes Variation purchases to a per-dot cost), which should permit gadgeteers and others who are heavily invested in Forms instead of in Variations.
Greatly decreases the number of Scars.
Permits characters in high Standing game to wield Variations whose Magnitude exceeds 5 by leaning on the End Stage guidelines in Shallow Graves.
Expands Beloved Community, Sacred Code, and Victim Profile Merits to make them natural and upgradable extensions of Allegiances.
Thanks again for all the input you've provided on this one.
Superhero Emergence
Superhero emergence (also known as superhuman awakening) is a superhero subgenre in which ordinary people suddenly develop (or are born with) extraordinary abilities, leading to superpowers becoming an increasingly common phenomenon. It explores themes of identity and the ethical implications of newfound powers, and often delves into the responses of ordinary people to those with superpowers. In some stories, some of those with remarkable powers become superheroes — costumes, secret identities, and all — while others wield their abilities to selfish or evil ends. In others, the public reaction to the superpowered is suspicion, if not outright hostility. Given the size of that subgenre tent within the almost impossibly large and varied superhero genre, we’re going to focus on four elements of this subgenre:
Powers: The superhero genre emphasizes the cool things its protagonists can do, rather than the price they paid for their superhuman abilities. That doesn’t diminish their Scars or negate their Origin, but aside from the occasional origin story or issues episode, it isn’t the focus of the greater narrative.
Identity: Superhero emergence chronicles explore and twist identity as its heroes wrestle with whether and how their powers change who they are. Some incorporate their superpowers into their mundane lives, and others use their abilities to guide them into new vocations, but the genre has a long tradition of characters who try to have it both ways by adopting a secret identity.
Obligation: When and how to use one’s powers are key questions for the newly Remade. It isn’t reasonable to expect that someone will never use their superpowers to benefit themselves or protect their interests, but most systems of morality and ethics emphasize the individual’s obligation to use their abilities to benefit others — and superheroes can’t fully escape that, either.
Public Sentiment: Those who lack superhuman gifts nevertheless hold strong opinions about how the Broken should (and shouldn’t) use them. The Remade are numerous and the Divergence phenomenon is relatively well-known to the public, but Baselines still greatly outnumber them. How a Deviant uses his power has an impact on public sentiment towards the Remade, and that in turn shapes how Baseline institutions respond to the Broken.
Setting: Our Superpowered World
This genre takes the ordinary world and adds one major wrinkle: the supernatural is real, and Deviant superheroes have entered the public awareness in a big way. Maybe the Divergence is a new class of technology — one that’s got tech bros, investment executives, Luddites, and the media talking about virtually nothing else. Or perhaps people all over the world manifest supernatural abilities after suffering horrible accidents or enduring nightmarish torments. Possibly, the government has publicized the existence of its super soldier program as part of a recruitment and propaganda campaign as it engages in (or defends itself from) an invasion — or a super cop program meant to address some internal turmoil.
Whatever the specifics, the existence of the Remade is no secret, although the cohort’s powers might be.
Allegiance
Each Deviant holds one of six Allegiances: Advocate, Champion, Enforcer, Rebel, Reformer or Rogue. Allegiance, along with Origin, determines the Broken’s starting mix of Loyalty and Conviction Touchstones. Half are considered Devoted Allegiances for the purposes of determining how furthering Touchstones replenishes Willpower and heals Instability, while the other half are Renegade Allegiances).
Advocate (Devoted): These Deviants subscribe to a system of beliefs that drives them to build, create, or preserve something of value. Most are religious, or at least abide by a principled code of ethics, and they tend towards altruism (and philanthropy, if they have the means). They begin play with 3 Loyalty Touchstones, no Conviction Touchstone, and two dots of the Sacred Code Merit (p. XX), which counts as a fourth Loyalty Touchstone.
Champion (Devoted): These Remade embody Loyalty and service to their communities. They are the most likely of the Allegiances to behave as traditional superheroes and take any injury suffered by those under their protection personally. They begin play with 2 Loyalty Touchstones, 1 Conviction Touchstone, and two dots of the Beloved Community Merit (p. XX), which counts as a third Loyalty Touchstone.
Enforcer (Devoted): These Broken serve an organization that sanctions them to perform violence in its name. They might be law enforcement, military, or the Devoted servants of conspiracies. They regain Willpower and heal Instability like Devoted. They begin play with 2 Loyalty Touchstones, 1 Conviction Touchstone, and two dots of the Victim Profile Merit (p. XX), which counts as a second Conviction Touchstone.
Rebel (Renegade): These Remade regard themselves as protectors of a group of their choosing and do their best to eliminate anyone who threatens their chosen family. The best of them are vigilantes and folk heroes beloved by those they protect. The worst are terrorists. They begin play with 1 Loyalty Touchstone, 3 Conviction Touchstones, and two dots of the Beloved Community Merit (p. XX), which counts as a second Loyalty Touchstone.
Reformer (Renegade): These Deviants adhere to a system of beliefs that drives them to tear down existing systems and those who defend them. Although not all of them resort to force, they are unquestionably more interested in removing enemies than in winning over friends. They begin play with no Loyalty Touchstones, 3 Conviction Touchstones, and two dots of the Sacred Code Merit (p. XX), which counts as a Loyalty Touchstone.
Rogue (Renegade): These Broken use their powers to carry out their fantasies, most of which involve hurting people. While some have legitimate grievances against their targets — such as to avenge themselves against those who murdered people close to them — many are bullies, if not serial killers. They begin play with no Loyalty Touchstones, 3 Conviction Touchstones, and two dots of the Victim Profile Merit (p. XX), which counts as a fourth Conviction Loyalty Touchstone.
Origin
A Broken’s Origin grants a single Touchstone. Autourgics and Epimorphs receive an additional Loyalty Touchstone. Exomorph and Genotypal receive an additional Conviction Touchstone. Pathologicals receive the player’s choice of a Loyalty or Conviction Touchstone.
Changing Allegiance
A Deviant may change Allegiance once per story.
• Changing from one Devoted Allegiance to another (or from one Renegade Allegiance to another) has no special requirements.
• Changing from a Devoted Allegiance to a Renegade Allegiance requires that the character has more Conviction Touchstones (including the Victim Profile Merit granted by her Allegiance) than Loyalty Touchstones.
• Changing from a Renegade Allegiance to a Devoted Allegiance requires that the character has more Loyalty Touchstones (including the Beloved Community or Sacred Code Merit granted by her Allegiance) than Conviction Touchstones.
The benefits of the old Allegiance are immediately lost and the new ones gained.
Sentiment
Sentiment is a measure of the public’s collective opinion of Remade on a continuum from Glorified (the most enthusiastic) to At War (the most hostile). A chronicle’s Sentiment will shape the cohort’s interactions with the public and public institutions. The Storyteller should determine Sentiment in consultation with the players, as this will color all Deviants’ interactions with the public and public institutions.
High and low Sentiment grant mechanical benefits — whether only to Devoted/Renegades or to all Deviants.
Sentiment also determines what kinds of behavior affects a character’s Reputation (see below).
Glorified
Baselines expect Remade to solve all their problems and to spare them every hardship and inconvenience. This sentiment is most appropriate in a setting that explores the stultifying experience of being a public resource who faces constant public scrutiny and unrealistic expectations.
Improving Reputation: The Deviant saves or restores many lives or preserves something of similarly great significance to many people (such as a landmark or priceless work of art).
Worsening Reputation: A significant harm occurs when the Remade conceivably could have been present in the scene to prevent it.
Remade: In addition to the benefits of Positive, at the end of each chapter, the cohort generates Effort that they may invest in conspiracy Projects. The amount of Effort is equal to half current Standing (rounded up).
Devoted: In addition to the benefits of Positive (see below), once per chapter, the Devoted may negate the events of a single scene for the purpose of worsening Reputation.
Positive
Baselines expect Deviants to use their supernatural talents to further the interests of humanity (although exactly what that means varies from one Baseline to the next). Positive Sentiment is most appropriate in a setting where Remade are superheroes with the full support of a number of Baselines, whether they’re government authorities, members of a spiritual community, or a conspiracy.
Improving Reputation: The Broken saves a life, prevents destruction of property (including public property) or natural beauty, or apprehends a Renegade. Alternatively, he risks harm or sacrifices something significant in the service of the established order and public good.
Worsening Reputation: The Deviant is visibly present in the scene and doesn’t intervene to prevent a significant harm or to accomplish a good deed (even a small one). Alternatively, harm occurs while the Remade isn’t present, and he doesn’t publicly acknowledge it or help with recovery.
Remade: All Deviants benefit from the Qualified Immunity Merit (p. XX).
Devoted: In addition to the benefits of Favorable (see below), the Devoted may take a conspiracy action once per chapter, treating conspiracy Attributes as equal to Standing + 2. If unused, this action is lost.
Favorable
The public regards the Remade as interesting and exciting, like a new technology with a lot of untapped potential. Favorable Sentiment is most appropriate for a setting in which Broken often play at being superheroes but haven’t gained widespread support from Baseline institutions.
Improving Reputation: The Deviant uses their Variations in the service of others or the public good without the expectation of reward. Alternatively, they accept compensation or donations (in advance or after the fact) to save a life, to prevent destruction of property (including public property) or natural beauty, or to apprehend a Renegade.
Worsening Reputation: The Broken publicly tries but fails to prevent a harm or accomplish a good deed (whether compensated or not).
Devoted: These Deviants wield influence within Baseline society by making friends and proving that Remade can be valuable to their communities. The Devoted receives two dots of Allies, Anonymity, Contacts, Mentor, Resources, Retainer, Safe Place, Staff, or Status (all are in Deviant except for Staff, which appears in Devoted Companion — p. 18), which can be shared by other Devoted in their cohort.
Neutral
Either the Remade are such a new phenomenon that Baselines haven’t yet formed a collective opinion of them, or they’re polarizing figures with a close to even mix of strong proponents and detractors. Neutral Sentiment is most appropriate for a setting in which Divergence is a new phenomenon (or one only recently entering the public consciousness).
Neither Devoted nor Renegades enjoy any special benefits due to Sentiment.
Improving Reputation: The Deviant uses his Variations in a context that shows them to be useful and beneficial (even if they’re paid to do so).
Worsening Reputation: The Remade uses his Variations in a context that shows their limitations, the danger they represent, or the thorny moral and ethical issues they raise.
Unfriendly
The Remade have captured public imagination, and Baselines everywhere shake their heads as they recount the latest news stories about people with dangerous powers engaged in reckless or criminal behavior. Unfriendly Sentiment is most appropriate in a setting where Broken are mistrusted or face prejudice.
Improving Reputation: The Broken publicly embraces the principle of serving Baselines and/or Baseline institutions or encourages other Remade to do so.
Worsening Reputation: The Deviant uses her Variations to commit a nonviolent crime, or her Variation use causes minor property damage (such as flattening a car or destroying a city sidewalk) or serious injury to a Baseline.
Renegade: Deviants use their abilities to accumulate resources and attract those who crave proximity to power or wield supernatural influence of their own. The Renegade receives two dots of Allies, Anonymity, Contacts, Mentor, Resources, Retainer, Safe Place, Staff, or Status (all are in Deviant except for Staff, which appears in Devoted Companion), which can be shared with other Renegades in her cohort.
Hostile
The public blames the Remade for much of what goes wrong in the world, and Deviants with known identities live under the constant threat of harassment if not outright mob violence. Hostile Sentiment is most appropriate in a setting where Broken face violence if they are recognized for what they are, incentivizing secrecy and subtlety.
Improving Reputation: The Deviant doesn’t use his Variations when it’s obvious to witnesses it would have benefited him to do so.
Worsening Reputation: Members of the cohort use their Variations to commit a violent crime, to commit a serious nonviolent crime (such as a bank, casino, or jewelry heist), or to cause moderate property damage (such as burning down a house or causing several city blocks to lose power). Alternatively, their Variations kill a Baseline or hurt many Baselines.
Remade: All Deviants enjoy the benefits of the Armed and Extremely Dangerous Merit (Deviant, p. 100), which applies against all Baselines not expecting to encounter Deviants.
Renegade: In addition to the benefits of Unfriendly (see above), Renegades count their Scar Power, Scar Finesse, and Scar Resistance as one higher (to a maximum of 6).
At War
Baseline society regards Remade as an existential threat to humanity and is actively attempting to eliminate them — whether by “curing” or exterminating them. They might still use Devoted to further this goal, but loyal Broken are merely lower priority targets. At War Sentiment is most appropriate in settings where Broken are openly hunted and killed as monsters by Baseline governments and vigilantes alike.
Improving Reputation: The Broken is nice to a Baseline without expectation of a reward, even if her kindness costs her nothing.
Worsening Reputation: The Deviant uses her Variations to cause major property damage (such as destroying a landmark or blowing up a skyscraper) or widespread injury and death to Baselines.
Remade: In addition to the benefits of Hostile (see above), all Deviants quickly learn to use their powers creatively in order to survive and may improvise a Technique once per scene instead of once per chapter (Shallow Graves, p. 199).
Renegade: In addition to the benefits of Hostile (see above), once per chapter, a Renegade may gain access to two dots of the Manticore Companion and/or Prototype Merits, which may be shared with other Renegades in her cohort to gain access to a more powerful Manticore/Prototype.
Reputation
Whereas Sentiment reflects the public opinion of Remade in general, Reputation concerns the perception of a specific Deviant. Reputation is a Renegade-Devoted continuum ranging from –10 (the most Renegade) to 10 (the Most Devoted).
At character creation, Reputation is 0.
Improving/Worsening Reputation
Depending on the current Sentiment, the Deviant’s actions improve or worsen her Reputation. The previous section provides examples of actions that increase (improve) or decrease (worsen) Reputation.
A Deviant may improve or worsen his Reputation once per scene each, increasing or decreasing his Reputation rating by 1 (or leaving it the same if he both improves and worsens Reputation in the same scene).
• Actions that improve Reputation at higher tiers of Sentiment also improve Reputation at lower tiers. Saving the lives of dozens of people (which improves Reputation at Glorified Sentiment) still improves Reputation if Sentiment is Neutral or At War, for example.
• Actions that worsen Reputation at lower tiers of Sentiment also worsen it at higher tiers. Destroying a cherished landmark (which worsens Reputation at At War Sentiment) still worsens Reputation if Sentiment is Neutral or Glorified, for example.
• Actions that improve Reputation at lower tiers of Sentiment don’t improve it at higher tiers. Giving sweets to children has no measurable impact on the public perception of a Deviant when society expects Broken to save lives without compensation
• Actions that worsen Reputation at higher tiers of Sentiment don’t worsen it at lower tiers. Failing to halt a runaway train on the other side of the city (which worsens Reputation at Glorified Sentiment) isn’t going to be much of a public relations hit in a world where Broken are the leading cause of train derailments (current Sentiment is At War).
Heroic Merits
Beloved Community, Sacred Code, and Victim Profile are collectively known as Heroic Merits and have a special relationship with Reputation.
• Whenever the Remade takes a public action that furthers a Heroic Merit (i.e., would heal Instability), it also improves or worsens his Reputation (player chooses which) by 1. If the action would also improve/worsen his Reputation in the same direction based on the current Sentiment, it instead improves/worsens it by 2. A Champion (Devoted) who protects children in a Favorable Sentiment chronicle could increase his Reputation by 2 if he saved the life of a child in a public way.
• Actions that further a Heroic Merit never move the Broken’s Reputation in an unwanted direction (whether improving or worsening it). An Enforcer (Devoted) engaged in a war against drug kingpins can kill these criminals and their lowlife underlings without damaging his Reputation.
The above benefits also apply if the character purchases additional Heroic Merits with starting Merit dots or Experiences.
Moving Sentiment
Through concerted effort, a Deviant can change public opinion of all Remade.
• If a player’s character’s Reputation reaches 10, Sentiment increases by one tier (from Neutral to Favorable, for example, or from At War to Hostile).
• If a player’s character’s Reputation reaches –10, Sentiment decreases by one tier (from Glorified to Positive, for example, or from Unfriendly to Hostile).
• Each time Sentiment moves in this way, all characters reset their current Sentiment to 1 (if a Devoted) or –1 (if a Renegade).
Optional Rules: Changes
For a Deviant chronicle set in the superhero emergence genre, consider the following optional rules.
Visibility
Conspiracies exist, but one isn’t necessarily the cohort’s main antagonist. In chronicles that lack a conspiracy to fight, replace the Surveillance roll with a Visibility roll, which is modified based on much attention the Deviants have attracted to themselves and their supernatural abilities. Even in a chronicle that features a conspiracy, Visibility rolls may be made in addition to Surveillance rolls, with any Crises coming from the per-chapter “pool” of conspiracy actions available to the primary antagonist.
Some of this is mundane; the Deviant’s enemies have an easier time finding them, and people in need of their help can seek out the Remade more readily. However, it also has a narrative component; a cohort with greater Visibility seems to be a magnet for opportunities to make a difference.
Visibility has three main components: Standing, Lifestyle, and Audacity.
Standing
Standing has the greatest influence on Visibility.
Lifestyle
Lifestyle is the sum of precautions the cohort takes to foil mundane methods of identifying and tracking them — on a scale from –5 to +5. If some members of the cohort are more careful than others, use the average of their Lifestyles (rounded up) for the cohort as a whole.
The Anonymity Merit (Deviant, p. 100) reduces the Lifestyle factor by half its rating, rounded up, but can’t reduce the cohort’s overall Lifestyle modifier below –5. In this genre, it is a shared Merit, much like Safe Place.
The Fame Merit (p. XX) increases the Lifestyle factor by half its rating, rounded up, although it only applies to members of the cohort who have the Merit and can’t increase the cohort’s overall Lifestyle modifier above +5.
• Myth (–5): No public record of the cohort exists, and members diligently avoid anything that could be traced to them. They live off the grid or wander from city to city, paying cash to stay in a motel or sleeping outdoors. On those occasions when they must use modern information technology, it involves burner phones or other devices that are borrowed, stolen, or bought with cash and then discarded after a couple of uses. They have no social media or web presence. They don’t have steady jobs, maintain bank accounts, or own assets that aren’t portable (any vehicle is stolen or has stolen plates and no insurance). They have no criminal records, arrest warrants, or debts in collection.
• Invisible (–3): Either no one alive has reason to look for the cohort, or the Remade have taken great pains to avoid the attention of those interested in their whereabouts. They have no fixed residence, couch-surfing or living out of hotels (or a car). They use simple disguises or change hairstyles to obfuscate their identity. They minimize use of computers, cellphones, and social media, and take basic steps to avoid letting these be traced back to them. One of them may hold a job or maintain a bank account using a false ID, but the cohort operates mostly in cash.
• Careful (–1): The cohort takes some precautions against being connected to their identities. This largely involves avoiding situations that require them to produce ID, but it relies heavily on security through obscurity — being one more face in the crowd or one more anonymous avatar on the internet. They may live in an apartment, own a car, or even hold down a job, but they studiously avoid standing out as anything other than an unassuming Baseline.
• Careless (+1): Cohort members have apartments or homes, cellphones, laptops, cars, and jobs with advancement prospects. They live within their apparent means, either carefully laundering any additional money they earn from their Variations (or other illicit sources) or not using them for financial gain in the first place.
• Public (+3): Information about the cohort is easy to find. Details of their personal lives are available online. They might be a public official or maintain a blog. Perhaps they published an autobiography or they once went viral on social media. Possibly, they were involved in a crime or major local event that left their faces plastered all over the news (or on law enforcement’s Most Wanted lists). If they have illicit income sources that allow them to live beyond their means, either the sums are small enough to escape notice or the Remade aren’t completely stupid about making purchases that will attract attention.
• Influencer (+5): This degree of accessibility doesn’t happen by accident. The cohort has a substantial catalog of blog entries, online videos, and social media posts aimed at increasing their profile. They might not actually be famous, but it isn’t for want of trying. They spend any income from illicit sources lavishly and without regard to whether it will attract the attention of law enforcement.
Audacity
Audacity measures how openly members of the cohort use their Variations and how difficult to hide their Scars are.
Manifesting a Controlled or Involuntary Scar means activating its attached Variation. Manifesting a Persistent Scar means taking a Beat from it. The Conspicuous Appearance Scar and Identifier Standard Deviation affect Visibility rolls exactly the way they affect surveillance rolls.
In a similar vein, using a Controlled or Involuntary Variation or Toggled Persistent Variation means activating it. In the case of Perpetual Persistent Variations, it means benefiting from them in a narratively significant way. Merely having Superhuman Strength doesn’t count as benefiting from the Variation, for example, but ripping the door off a car with her bare hands would.
When calculating the Magnitude of a Subtle Tiered Variation used in a scene, the actual effect the Deviant invokes is used, not necessarily his full Magnitude rating. For example, a Deviant with Body Snatcher 5 who only uses it to ride a victim’s senses (the Magnitude 1 effect) is considered to be using a Magnitude 1 Subtle Variation, but if he later seizes control over the victim’s actions for a turn (the Magnitude 3 effect), he is treated as having used a Magnitude 3 Subtle Variation.
Using a Variation or manifesting a Scar only impacts the Audacity factor if there is a chance that the incident could have been observed by someone outside the cohort and their close associates. This can include security cameras or unnoticed bystanders, so this protection only applies if the cohort can reasonably ensure that they are alone when they use their Variations or manifest their Overt Scars.
The Audacity factor of a Visibility roll looks at the Variation use and Scar manifestation in the previous two chapters and reflects the higher Audacity factor between the two. For example, if the cohort avoided using non-Subtle Variations and Scars but used some high-Magnitude Subtle Variations in the prior session (–3) but caused massive destruction with their powers in the chapter before that (+5), the Audacity factor would be +5. Note that this means that the cohort always enjoys the benefit of being Ascetic (–5) for the first chapter of the chronicle (but not the first chapter of each story).
Ascetic (–5): No one in the cohort used a Subtle Variation of Magnitude 3 or higher or an Overt Variation, nor did they manifest an Overt Scar.
Secretive (–3): At least one member of the cohort used a Magnitude 1 or 2 Subtle Variation in front of Baseline witnesses but without directly affecting them or causing notable damage to anything around him. None of them used an Overt Variation or manifested an Overt Scar.
Constrained (–1): At least one member of the cohort manifested an Overt Scar or used a Subtle Variation of Magnitude 1 or 2 in front of Baselines who were directly affected by it. Alternatively, at least one member of the cohort told a Baseline witness that she was a Deviant.
Reserved (+1): At least one member of the cohort used an Overt Variation (or Magnitude 3+ Subtle Variation) in front of Baseline witnesses but without directly affecting them or causing notable damage to anything around him. Alternatively, a Baseline witness who was directly affected either consented to it or was persuaded to keep secret what they witnessed.
Obvious (+3): At least one member of the cohort used an Overt Variation (or Magnitude 3+ Subtle Variation) in front of Baseline witnesses in a way that affected them directly or caused significant damage to something around them. Alternatively, the Variation didn’t affect a Baseline directly or damage anything nearby, but the display of supernatural power had many witnesses, was violent or frightening, or both.
Unmistakable (+5): At least one member of the cohort used an Overt Variation (or Magnitude 3+ Subtle Variation) in front of many Baseline witnesses in a way that affected them directly and/or caused significant damage in the area.
Visibility Roll
Dice Pool: Standing + Lifestyle + Audacity
Action: Instant
Roll Results
Success: Crises that occur during this chapter can target the cohort directly.
Exceptional Success: As a success but increase the number of Crises by one.
Failure: Crises that occur during this chapter can’t target the cohort directly.
Dramatic Failure: As a failure, but reduce the number of Crises by one.
Crises
Crises are narrative complications that threaten the cohort’s interests but are also an opportunity to advance their goals. In most ways they resemble conspiracy actions in that their frequency (the number of Crises that could appear in each chapter) and scale (how big a problem they represent) is based on Standing.
Below are some examples of Crises a cohort might face. Each one has a suggested ideology (Devoted, Renegade, or Either) and Sentiment range. These are not hard rules. A Renegade could be motivated to prevent a bus full of passengers from falling off a bridge because one of those passengers is a Loyalty Touchstone, for example, and a Deviant in an At War Sentiment chronicle might risk discovery, arrest, and death to protect a Baseline community from a terrorist attack.
On a successful Visibility roll, a Crisis may target a member of the cohort directly. Instead of the mob making an example of some other unfortunate Broken, its target might be one of the players’ characters, for example, or rather than vandalizing a random building, the graffiti calls out the cohort or appears somewhere closely associated with them.
Adverse Environment (Either; Any): A fire, broken water pipe, sudden downpour, or other event imposes an appropriate Environmental Tilt on the current scene or creates a dangerous situation nearby that threatens innocent bystanders.
Alliance (Either; Any): Unless the cohort intervenes, two Opponents forge an alliance or otherwise pool resources. The alliance shares a Linchpin whose destruction will dissolve the bond between them. Starting with the next chapter and lasting until the alliance is destroyed, the cohort suffers one additional Crisis during any chapter in which the Visibility roll succeeded.
Betrayal (Either; Any): A trusted Baseline or Remade ally betrays the cohort’s trust in some way. This might be a small indiscretion or an unquestionable betrayal.
Bully (Devoted; Any): A Baseline (possibly backed up by a few friends) attempts to show his dominance over a known or suspected Deviant. At high Sentiment, the bully might attempt to exploit the Broken’s refusal to resort to violence or other unbecoming behavior. At moderate Sentiment, this may take the form of physical intimidation or pranks meant to show dominance. At low Sentiment, it’s likely to involve mob violence and vigilante justice.
Containment Team (Either; Glorified to Unfriendly): Well-trained and suitably equipped agents confront and attempt to capture a known or suspected Deviant. Their purpose could be incarceration for a crime or for the public good, or they might intend to force the Remade into service to themselves or to a buyer.
Cyber-Harassment (Devoted; Glorified to Unfriendly): A cyber-stalker targets the Remade, attempting to bait or frighten them through tactics ranging from turning them into memes or making deepfakes of them doing something nefarious to doxing and swatting. If the cohort takes no action to halt or debunk these attacks, it might cause Sentiment to fall or grant a bonus to a future Visibility roll.
Fan (Either; Any): Someone who knows a member of the cohort by reputation or prior direct contact is present in the scene and behaves accordingly. If the Visibility roll succeeded, they might approach the Broken to beg her for an autograph or a selfie, especially if this draws unwanted attention to her. If the Visibility roll failed, the fan talks up his idol or makes a clumsy attempt to emulate her that has the potential to move Sentiment.
Goody Two-Shoes (Renegade; Any): A Devoted (or a cohort of them) makes a public attempt to improve Sentiment. This could range from deploying their Variations to the benefit of random Baselines as a show of goodwill to stepping in to prevent Renegades (including the players’ cohort) from committing a crime successfully.
Hardware Failure (Either; Any): Whether by coincidence or enemy action, a device or object abruptly gives out or breaks. A rope snaps, a tire goes flat, a computer crashes, and so forth. Fixing the problem requires a successful Skill roll and several minutes (turns, in action scenes). If the Visibility roll succeeded, it specifically harms the cohort; otherwise, it adds to the general chaos in the scene or threatens or harm bystanders in the scene.
Hooligans (Devoted; Glorified to Hostile): Rowdy troublemakers arrive on the scene looking to cause some property damage. They might be vandals armed with spray paint and looking to leave their mark on buildings, sports fans celebrating a victorious football game by flipping over cars, or radical anarchists lobbing Molotov cocktails through storefront windows.
Imposter (Either; Glorified to Unfriendly): The cohort receives unwanted credit for actions taken on their behalf by someone pretending to be them. The copycat might do so out of an appreciation for the cohort or as a means of sullying their names. If the cohort takes no action, the copy moves Sentiment, and the imposter’s antics might also grant a bonus to Visibility rolls.
Introduce/Seize/Wield MacGuffin (Either; Any): One of the cohort’s Opponents introduces the existence of a new MacGuffin (up to the limit based on Standing). Alternately, they create, steal, or otherwise claim a previously defined MacGuffin. They may instead use a MacGuffin they already control to advance their goals. No Opponent may do more than one of introduce, seize, or wield a MacGuffin in the same chapter.
Kill Squad (Renegade; At War): Heavily armed and well-trained soldiers confront and attempt to kill a known or suspected Deviant.
Law Enforcement (Either; Any): Police arrive or are already present at the scene. If the Visibility roll failed, their presence is incidental but represents a potential complication if the cohort attracts attention. If it succeeded, they may be there to consult with, investigate, or arrest members of the cohort, or to politely insist that they come to the station for questioning.
Enemy (Either; Any): One of the cohort’s Opponents arrives or is already present in the scene. If the Visibility roll succeeded, her presence is likely directly related to them. If not, she has some other business there. If the number of Opponents is currently below the base for the cohort’s Standing, this may instead introduce a new Opponent.
Pickpocket (Devoted; Any): Someone in the current scene commits an act of theft, whether it’s picking a pocket, snatching a purse, shoplifting, or stealing a parked car. If the Visibility roll failed a member of the cohort witnesses the act and is in a position to respond. If it succeeded, the theft targets one of their possessions.
Propagandists (Either; Positive to Hostile): This is only usable if the Visibility roll succeeded. Someone with an interest in moving Sentiment attempts to feature the Deviants in propaganda aimed at achieving that. They might goad the cohort into behaving contrary to their ideology and capture the episode or gather footage to cherry-pick and publicize out of context to make them (or what was done to them to trigger the Divergence) look good or bad. In addition to the threat to Sentiment, the next two Visibility rolls achieve an exceptional success on three successes instead of five.
Rampaging Renegade (Devoted; Any): A Renegade (or a cohort of them) disturbs an otherwise peaceful scene. They might be calling out high profile Devoted to increase their own reputation or committing a crime for some obvious purpose (such as robbing a bank or assassinating a politician who promotes anti-Deviant policies), but they might be the victim of one of their Scars (possibly not a Renegade at all). If the cohort takes no action, the Renegade’s actions will worsen Sentiment.
Resource Denial (Either; Any): When a member of the cohort attempts to call upon a Social Merit with an external component (such as Allies, Contacts, Manticore Companion, Mentor, Retainer, Staff, or Status), he finds that resource temporarily unavailable to him. A friend isn’t picking up the phone, the bank denies his credit card purchase, etc. This only affects the current scene if the Visibility roll failed, but it lasts until the end of the chapter if it succeeded.
Rival Renegade (Renegade; Favorable to Hostile): Another Renegade (or a cohort of them) arrives on the scene. Their actions and/or motives are mutually exclusive with those of the players’ characters. They might be pursuing the same MacGuffin, for example.
Robbery (Devoted; Any): Someone attempts to use the threat of violence to force someone in the scene to hand over their money or other possessions.
Terrorists (Devoted; Any): A rogue group with an extremist agenda (whether Renegades or Baselines) attempt to further it by violence or threats of violence in the current scene. Alternatively, a spree shooter arrives in the scene and opens fire, whether he has specific intended targets or merely wishes to kill as many people as possible.
Tip (Devoted; Glorified): As another relevant Crisis, but the cohort receives sufficient advance notice of the threat that they can intercede. However, the timing invariably forces them to choose between involving themselves with the coming Crisis or pursuing one of their other priorities (including another Crisis about which they were tipped off), and if they ignore the tip, the public is automatically aware of the cohort’s failure to prevent the resulting harm.
Touchstone Entanglement (Either; Any): One of the cohort’s Touchstones features in the current scene. It could be a Loyalty Touchstone who is in danger or otherwise needs the cohort’s help. It might instead be a shining opportunity to stick it to a Conviction Touchstone or thwart their plans.
Traffickers (Either; Favorable to Unfriendly): Opportunistic kidnappers attempt to subdue one or more vulnerable people to press into servitude. While their victim might be one of the Broken, they’re more likely to target immigrants, children, or anyone they think no one will miss. Most traffickers are Baselines, but Deviants are capable of this crime.
MacGuffins
In the context of this genre, a MacGuffin is an object, person, or event that supplies motivation to the cohort and other characters — especially in a chronicle that doesn’t feature a conspiracy as its primary antagonists. Each MacGuffin replaces an Icon.
Some present a danger to some parties that encourages them to neutralize or destroy it, while offering other parties an opportunity that encourages them to seek out and/or seize it. Others are a limited resource that gives those who control it an advantage or benefit. Less commonly, they pose a threat to multiple parties that each of them will want to minimize for themselves.
MacGuffins typically have a local effect and shape the narrative for the duration of a story, although this can vary. Oftentimes, the cohort’s successes or failures in addressing one MacGuffin suggest the introduction of the next MacGuffin. Examples of MacGuffins include:
Artifact: An object of great power is created, built, or discovered, offering a major advantage to whomever controls it. However, it comes with a drawback that also makes maintaining control over it hazardous or expensive, whether it’s a curse, a strict maintenance regimen, a hunger for human blood (or lives), or something stranger still.
Crime Wave: It might be the work of a single organized crime ring, the result of economic hardship coupled with a disinterested police force, or the impact of occult influence on the area, but certain crimes (or crimes in general) surge. The cohort or their allies might fall victim to some of the crimes, or the criminality (or underlying cause) might threaten to move Sentiment.
Disaster: A natural disaster strikes the area, whether it’s a hurricane, flood, tornado, or earthquake. It causes power outages, damages some structures, and complicates travel by making roads slick or flooded or covering them with debris, snow, or lava flows. Action scenes during or after this disaster will usually have Environmental Tilts.
Divergence Event: Whether it’s a celestial occurrence, an industrial accident, or the unearthing and activation of an occult structure or artifact, something causes an unusually large number of people to Diverge at once (with the usual casualties that inflicts on the many who don’t). Alternatively, the cohort learns of an emerging situation that could lead to a Divergence event if they don’t prevent it. If the event occurs, it could move Sentiment or introduce an Opponent.
Dreams: Vivid, portentous dreams plague the cohort. These could affect the entire cohort, a single member, one of their close associates, or a sizable population of local Baselines (or all of them). They might be identical and repetitive, share a common thread or feature an identifiable figure, or build in intensity and urgency as the event they portend comes to pass. The dreams often introduce or foreshadow a new Opponent, MacGuffin, or Crisis, and a cohort that investigates this phenomenon may gain the Informed Condition related to the subject of the dreams.
Haunting: An incorporeal being appears in (or already inhabits) a place within the area. It might be a new manifestation triggered by a grisly murder or the disturbance of its grave or a sacred place, but it could be a presence documented centuries ago. While it could be a literal ghost, the entity could be a demon, angel, spirit, yokai, or any other ephemeral entity — or even an especially elusive animal or mythological beast or monster. If it’s a new phenomenon, its appearance could be disruptive or offer an opportunity to those who befriend it or harness its power. If it’s an established inhabitant, it might guard a place where the cohort (or their enemies) wish to go or possess information or abilities that they need.
Invasion: Whether it’s an ambitious and militarily adventurous neighboring nation or an extraterrestrial, extradimensional, or extratemporal threat, a hostile force arrives in the area with the intention of conquering it and subjugating (or exterminating) its populace. The local players might attempt to ally with these invaders, use them as unwitting weapons against their local enemies, or drive them off. The interlopers might have valuable scientific secrets or advanced technology that could give the cohort (or their enemies) an advantage after the invasion ends. If the initial invasion fails but not all invaders are driven off or destroyed, the marooned survivors could emerge as a new Opponent.
Mass Production: Someone discovers a means of mass producing a Prototype (Clades Companion, p. 56) so that it can be distributed to a larger population — whether that is the agents of one of the cohort’s Opponents or Baselines as a whole. If it achieves widespread adoption by Baselines, this MacGuffin has the potential to make a significant change to the setting by granting many or most people access to a specific Variation (and imposing a Scar) — whether in the short term (such as if the story ends with the new technology ceasing to function) or long term (if it becomes a permanent feature, losing its status as a MacGuffin).
New Remade: A new cohort (or powerful individual Deviant) with unknown motives arrives in the area. They could be transplants from another region or Broken who only recently Diverged, but they are briefly outside the normal social order and present opportunities to tip the balance in favor of one existing group or another. The cohort could recruit them as allies, take them as students, or beg them for mentorship, but their enemies are likely to be equally interested in these Deviants for the same reasons. The new arrivals could be on the run from enemies who follow them, or they might see their new home as a place ripe for conquest.
Outbreak: A natural or occult disease strikes local inhabitants. It could spread like wildfire, bringing misery, disfigurement, and death in its wake, or it might be isolated to a small enough population that quarantine is still possible. A supernatural disease could move along novel vectors of infection, single out populations for infection in adherence to strange (if not outright metaphysical) criteria, and manifest symptoms that defy everything scientists know about how biology works. It might transform its victims into mindless, shambling husks with a single drive: to spread the plague further by biting new victims. Or it could drive the infected to obsessive, violent, or simply alien behavior. Depending on the population it affects, some groups may benefit from the outbreak’s propagation, while others will seek its containment or eradication. A widespread occult disease that Baselines associate with the Remade, if left unchecked, could worsen Sentiment, while Broken who find a way to cure the disease might improve Sentiment.
Portal: An occult (or Clarkestech) gateway is created, built, or discovered — or unexpectedly opens. It could connect two points locally or far apart, or it might lead to a pocket dimension, alternate timeline, or otherworld. It likely grants two-way access, allowing locals to enter it and bring back valuable resources (or serious trouble), but it could also permit those on the far side of it to infiltrate or invade the cohort’s home city/land/world. It could permit travel to a variety of destinations. Whichever party controls access to the portal enjoys unquestionable advantages, although they might also be exposed to unusual threats from the other side.
Predator: Something stalks the area, whether it leaves a trail of corpses, badly injured victims too traumatized to articulate what happened to them, or mindless drooling husks. The predator might be a Deviant, some other occult being, or an especially clever Baseline serial killer. It might target one of the cohort’s Loyalty Touchstones or frame them (or a member of the cohort) as the most obvious suspect. If the Remade are Devoted likely to put a stop to such things, perhaps merely hurting innocent people will be enough to prompt an investigation. Stopping the predator or leaving him to wreak havoc will move Sentiment.
Prophecy: The cohort becomes ensnared in a prediction about the future, whether it’s an ancient prophecy or a recent prognostication — one with occult origins or based on predictive scientific models. They might be its immediate and obvious subject, or they might have an interest in those it directly touches. They may seek its fulfillment or hope to prevent its coming to pass.
Regulation: A debate springs up around the regulation of the Remade and their abilities. This could affirm or strip away their rights. It could accord them additional privileges or saddle them with obligations that are not currently imposed on Baselines (such as military or public service). It could create a government office responsible for regulating (or subduing, imprisoning, or destroying) the Broken. The cohort might be opposed to the legislation on the table, or they might be the driving force behind it, but in either case they will face voices on the opposite side. Actions in support of or opposition to the proposals will move Sentiment.
Scar Site: An occult or technological marvel is built, discovered, or appears that imposes a Scar (or magnifies/reduces/suppresses existing Scars) in an area. It might instead affect the entire region but only temporarily. It could affect all Remade but may instead only affect those of a single Clade or methodology; alternatively, it could affect even Baselines. Most likely, it imposes the same Scar on everyone, although some might impose Scars based on Clade, Origin, methodology, or personality quirks. In rare cases, the same site (or event) also temporarily grants new Variations or increases the Magnitude of existing ones. A place that imposes or worsens Scars is one Broken are less likely to frequent, although they may not have much choice.
Spatial/Temporal Anomaly: A region of pinched, stretched, or looped time or space is created or discovered or manifests in the area. It could be a house that’s impossibly large on the inside, a forest clearing where a day passes outside for every hour spent within, or a room of frozen time. This could be a temporary phenomenon (possibly one that affects an entire region or allows a whole city to exist within an area only a few yards wide) or a long-lasting one (but likely more limited in scope).
The Trial: Whether it’s a Baseline (or several) on trial for a crime against a Deviant, or one of the Remade in court to fight charges that he harmed a Baseline, the case draws significant public attention to the Broken in ways that could shift Sentiment. Members of the cohort might be directly involved in the trial as victims, defendants, or witnesses. They could instead be drawn into spillover clashes between Baselines and Remade.
Wild Manticore: One or more spontaneous or escaped Manticores are on the loose in the area. It might be a serious danger to anyone it meets (such as a pack of invisible velociraptors). It could be a local nuisance (such as a species of Manticore racoons with telekinetic abilities). In any case, the Manticore presents a threat the cohort must account for or offers an opportunity to move Sentiment or gain access to the Manticore Companion Merit.
Systems
Touchstone Changes: Characters do not become Guardians or Nemeses.
Standing: Standing is a measure of the overall average potency of the cohort, not necessarily just their average total Variation Magnitude. Remade begin play with starting Merit dots based on Standing (including the normal 10). Standing otherwise has its normal effect on conspiracy traits, Crises/conspiracy actions, and Icons/MacGuffins.
[table]
Standing Starting Merit Dots Average Total Experiences/Starting Merit Dots
1 16 16-21
2 22 22-25
3 26 26-31
4 32 32-35
5 36 36-41
6 42 42-45
7 46 46-51
8 52 52-61
9 62 62-71
10 72 72+
[end table]
New/Improved Variations: New and worsening Scars don’t allow characters improve existing Variations or purchase new Variations, nor does End Stage supercharge Variations. Instead, Tiered Variations (including Discrete Variations that can benefit from Adaptations that increase the Magnitude of Tiered Variations) cost 2 Experiences (or starting Merit dots) per Magnitude to purchase or increase. Discrete Variations cost 2 Experiences (or starting Merit dots) at Magnitude 1 and 1 additional Experience (or starting Merit dot) per Magnitude above 1 (a Magnitude 3 Specialized Sense costs 4 Experiences instead of 6, for example).
Scars: Each Variation doesn’t require an entangled Scar. Instead, each Deviant has a single Scar with a Magnitude equal to her highest Magnitude Variation. If this is a Controlled or Involuntary Scar, however, it applies to all her Variations.
Super-Heroic Variations: At Standing 6 and higher, a Variation’s Magnitude is no longer limited to 5. A super-heroic Variation becomes supercharged as though the Deviant were in End Stage (Shallow Graves, p. 179), gaining a number of effects equal to its Magnitude in excess of 5. Once chosen, the effect is fixed; the Remade may not spend Willpower to swap it for a different effect.
The Variation must already be Magnitude 5 to become super-heroic. Each Magnitude of a Variation in excess of 5 costs 4 Experiences (or starting Merit dots). These Experiences do not count towards the average Experiences/Starting Merit dots of the cohort for the purposes of Standin.
Magnitude 6 requires Standing 6+ and Acclimation 1+.
Magnitude 7 requires Standing 7+ and Acclimation 2+.
Magnitude 8 requires Standing 8+ and Acclimation 3+.
Magnitude 9 requires Standing 9+ and Acclimation 4+.
Magnitude 10 requires Standing 10 and Acclimation 5.
Modified Deviant-Only Merit: Beloved Community (••, ••••, or ••••••)
At two dots, this is identical to the Merit of the same name in Shallow Graves (p. 69), except it has no Acclimation prerequisite.
At four dots, choose one:
• Greater Concerns: Downgrade by one step any Instability you suffer for Faltering against your community (major to medium or medium to minor), to a minimum of minor.
• Larger World: Your community extends to hundreds of thousands or even a few million people. It might encompass an entire city or a larger but less densely populated area, for example. Or it could include all children, citizens of a nation, or members of a major world religion.
At six dots, both effects above apply.
Champion or Rebel: If you have Greater Concerns, as an optional effect that costs two additional Merit dots, you can only suffer Instability once per chapter (instead of once per scene) for Faltering against your community. If you have Larger World, as an optional effect that costs two additional Merit dots, any Baseline in the scene with you counts as a member of your community.
Modified Deviant-Only Merit: Sacred Code (••, ••••, or ••••••)
At two dots, this is identical to the Merit of the same name in Shallow Graves (p. 73), except it has no Acclimation prerequisite.
At four dots, choose one:
• Daily Rituals: Regardless of whether you are a Devoted or Renegade, you regain a point of Willpower the first time you uphold a precept in a scene, even if doing so doesn’t involve risking or harming yourself. You also regain all Willpower the first time each chapter that you risk danger or suffer to uphold a precept.
• Grace: Once per chapter (which can’t be reset), you may violate one of your precepts without your sacred code becoming Wavering.
At six dots, both effects above apply.
Advocate or Reformer: If you have Daily Rituals, as an optional effect that costs two additional Merit dots, adding a new precept heals a minor Instability or downgrades a medium Instability to minor, and abandoning a precept inflicts a minor Instability (instead of a medium Instability). If you have Grace, as an optional effect that costs two additional Merit dots, you suffering a medium Instability (instead of medium Instability) for violating a precept while your sacred code is Wavering.
Modified Deviant-Only Merit: Victim Profile (••, ••••, or ••••••)
At two dots, this is identical to the Merit of the same name in Shallow Graves (p. 74) , except it has no Acclimation prerequisite.
At four dots, choose one:
• Long Con: Once per chapter (which can’t be reset), you may aid someone who meets your victim profile without Faltering.
• Pure Hate: Characters meeting any of your criteria (not just all of them) are considered to meet your victim profile.
A six dots, both effects above apply.
Enforcer or Rogue: If you have Long Con, as an optional effect that costs two additional Merit dots, you may only Falter once per chapter due to aiding someone who meets your victim profile.
If you have Pure Hate, as an optional effect that costs two additional Merit dots, any Baseline in the scene with you is considered to meet your victim profile.
New Social Merit: Fame (• to •••)
Your character is recognized within a certain sphere, for a certain skill, or because of some past action or stroke of luck. This can mean favors and attention, it can also mean negative attention and scrutiny. When choosing the Merit, define what your character is known for. As a rule of thumb, one dot means local recognition, or reputation within a confined subculture. Two dots means regional recognition by a wide swath of people. Three dots means worldwide recognition to anyone that might have been exposed to the source of the fame. Each dot adds a die to any Social rolls among those who are impressed by your character’s celebrity.
Drawback: Any rolls to find or identify the character enjoy a +1 bonus per dot of the Merit. A character with Fame cannot have the Anonymity Merit.
New Social Merit: Secret Identity (•, •••, or •••••)
Prerequisites: Subterfuge ••
The Deviant has bifurcated his public identity into a Baseline identity and a Remade identity. This allows him to operate under one in a scene without being recognized as the other except by those he has chosen to reveal his secret identity to. This doesn’t furnish documentation of either ID, but it prevents bystanders and investigators (including Opponents) from putting the pieces together.
Once per scene, as long as the Broken hasn’t yet used an Overt Variation or benefited from a Subtle Variation of Magnitude 3 or more, his player may retroactively declare whether he has assumed his Baseline or Remade identity.
In his Baseline identity, the character is not considered present for the purpose of moving Sentiment or being directly targeted by a Crisis initiated by the cohort’s Opponents. His Baseline identity can get caught up in a robbery or natural disaster, but he won’t be targeted by those looking to hurt a Deviant, nor will the crimes he commits under this identity stain Remade as a whole (although it could get him in legal hot water just like any other Baseline). He loses the benefits of this Merit until the end of the chapter if he uses an Overt Variation or benefits from a Subtle Variation of Magnitude 3 or higher — unless he first adopts his Remade alter ego (see below).
In his Remade identity, the character can use his Variations freely, but he suffers Crises and his actions move Sentiment. However, Crises initiated by Opponents will not directly threaten anyone associated with his Baseline identity, such as Loyalty Touchstones he primarily associates with while posing as, say, a mild-mannered accountant.
The Broken can exit the Remade identity in favor of his Baseline identity (or vice versa) during a scene by spending at least a minute in private to adopt his alter ego.
If the character has the Anonymity (Deviant, p. 100) or Fame Merit, you must decide whether it attaches to his Baseline or Remade identity. The benefits and drawbacks only apply when in that identity. A character cannot have both Fame and Anonymity associated with the same identity.
Team Identity (+2 dots): The Broken can convince onlookers that his associates are not who they seem. Once per chapter, the character may extend the protection granted by this Merit to anyone in the cohort who is present in the scene with him, although they must initially adopt the same identity (Baseline or Remade) that he has chosen for the scene. This can’t be reset with Adaptations.
Deep Secret (+2 dots): The Remade has developed clever ways of concealing the use of his more obvious powers. He can use Overt Variations of Magnitude 2 or less and benefit from any Subtle Variation while in his Baseline identity without losing the benefits of this Merit.
New Social Merit: Qualified Immunity (•••)
Prerequisites: Deviant
The Remade enjoys a certain degree of carte blanche. He never has to worry about being targeted by lawsuits or having a warrant issued for his arrest. Enemy Broken who have him in their power will not kill him, instead attempting to win him over or handing him over to Baselines for justice (which he will invariably escape). This doesn’t protect him from being apprehended by law enforcement while committing a crime, however, nor does it prevent Baselines from taking action to defend themselves from him. His actions still move Sentiment normally.
New Technique: Body Double
Sample Variations: Face Thief, Holographic Projection, Hyper-Competence (Crafts or Larceny), Shadow Selves
The Deviant creates a copy of herself or another character in the current scene, casting doubt as to which is the real one. The target gains the Secret Identity • Merit (p. XX) until the end of the scene and may immediately choose whether to adopt a Baseline or Remade identity — even if he has already used an Overt Variation or high-Magnitude Subtle Variation in the current scene.
Mastery: The Deviant may affect any number of members of his own cohort in the current scene. In addition, once per chapter, she may retroactively swap places with a member of her cohort as long as they haven’t yet used an Overt Variation or benefitted from a Subtle Variation of Magnitude 3 or more in the current scene, and as long as their player consents to the swap. The Remade need not be in the same scene at the time, but her presence must not be impossible.