Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Here's the first draft of the "putting it all together" section I've tacked onto the end of Chapter Five. It has a quite typical case of first draft overruns (it's about 500 words longer than I want it to be), but it should give you some idea of what I'm trying to accomplish here. I opted for more short examples rather than fewer long examples.

One Piece at a Time

A Deviant: The Renegades chronicle isn’t built on an assembly line. Every troupe has different ideas for what kind of chronicle they want to play — if not which one they want to play this time. The game’s core book offered a huge variety of potential characters and stories, and four supplements of new character options, alternate setting assumptions, and system hacks have only multiplied the number of possibilities. You can’t do everything in Deviant, but you can do a lot if you put your mind to it.

DIY Ethos

Let’s talk about what goes into designing an alternate Deviant setting.

Some Assembly Required

Before you start tinkering with game systems, it’s important to know what kind of stories you want to tell in your chronicle.

Place

Consider the where of your chronicle.

Genre: The genre or sub-genre is a good starting point. Modern horror is the default, but we’ve presented six other options, any of which could be smudged, modified, or mixed — and a motivated Storyteller could even steer clear of those and build a new one from scratch.

Theme and Mood: A well-built chronicle explores central themes and conveys a certain mood. This doesn’t mean every chapter rigidly adheres to these guide stars (that would be boring), but events should return to them again and again. Traditionally, Chronicles of Darkness games have called out two of these (one theme and one mood), while Chapter Five of this book instead presents four such guiding lights, but there isn’t a magical number of these. However, it’s best to keep the list short — no more than five and probably two or three.

Backdrop: The physical setting flows from its genre, themes, and mood. Pick qualities and set pieces that reinforce the overall flavor you’re going for. Some of these may suggest mechanics, as well, but the focus here is on creating an interesting place for events to take place in — whether it’s a single neighborhood at a defined point in time or an entire network of interdimensional outposts scattered across multiple parallel timelines.

People

Think about the who of your chronicle. This includes Storyteller characters but should focus on the players’ characters.

Commonalities: What is the common ground that draws (and keeps) the members of the cohort together? This can be circumstantial, such as being made by the same conspiracy or marooned on the same planet, but it could be a shared interest, such as studying ghosts or competing in athletic events as a team.

Differences: How do the members of the cohort distinguish themselves from their fellows? This is often as simple as having different Variations or choosing different Skills, but it might not be in a chronicle where everyone was chosen for Divergence because they shared certain skills and were given largely identical Variations. Players like for their characters to have some niche, both in terms of capabilities and personality.

Main Event: What is the central gameplay loop(s) of the chronicle — that is, how are the characters expected to spend most of their time? This could easily be two to four related activities; the main events for core Deviant are “elude/fight the conspiracy and further Conviction/Loyalty Touchstones”.

Sideshows: How much flexibility do the characters have to pursue activities that are outside of the main event, and what kinds of activities are most common? A chronicle in which a conspiracy pursues the cohort constantly is different from one where a conspiracy must share the spotlight with a parade of monsters of the week.

Motivations

Focus on the whys of the chronicle — specifically, why the cohort does the things they’re meant to do. These motivations have three axes:

Narrative/Mechanical: Narrative motivations invoke the chronicle’s story and play on the players’ desire for an engaging plot and interesting characters. Mechanical motivations offer rewards for some behavior and threaten to punish others. Which axis works best at your table depends heavily on who sits at it. While some players will embrace genre conventions and swallow plot hooks without question, most benefit from occasional mechanical nudges to keep them on-task. And for some, mechanical reinforcement is a primary driver of in-character behavior.

External/Internal: Some motivations exert pressure on the characters from within, while others do so from without. The conspiracy’s actions, Projects, and most of its key agents are external motivations. Aspirations and Scars are usually internal motivations. Touchstones and Instability have qualities of both internal and external motivations. It’s usually a good idea to include a mix of internal and external motivations. External motivations are unifying, usually drawing in the whole cohort to address a threat or seize an opportunity, but they can feel a bit impersonal. Internal motivations, meanwhile, are extremely relevant to the players whose characters pursue them but are less likely to unite the cohort into a set action.

Carrots/Sticks: Most methods of motivation boil down to either rewarding players for doing things the Storyteller wants them to do or punishing them for doing things the Storyteller doesn’t want them to do. In Deviant, these carrots and sticks are written into the mechanics. Characters receive carrots for playing up their Scars and furthering their Touchstones. They’re met with sticks when they Falter, when they choose not to engage with their Touchstones, or ignore the conspiracy (which generally responds by unleashing nastier Projects). Both approaches work, but carrots are less likely to generate player resentment (and more likely to inspire cooperation) when they’re used liberally.

Taking Stock

Once you know the where, who, and why of your chronicle, make some decisions about how to render them mechanically. This can sound intimidating, but Deviant offers many systems and options that serve as examples that can be adapted to represent other things. You’ll see this all over Black Vans — taking systems from the core, The Clades Companion, The Devoted Companion, and Shallow Graves and redefining or adding to them so that they represent a non-Deviant character or convey a theme or mood appropriate to a new genre. Here are some of the tools already at your disposal:

Adaptations: Adaptations help define different “types” (Clades) of Deviant characters. Making all of them Universal removes much of that distinction, while mandating new arrays of Adaptations multiplies the number of Clades. Disallowing reset Adaptations greatly reduces the use of limited-use abilities and should be done with caution.

Forms: Core Forms represent a shift in capabilities (rather than a net increase or decrease in power), while Advanced Forms allow the investment of Merit dots (and potentially Experiences) to make them a hybrid of Variations, Scars, and Merits all in one customizable package. Despite their flavor, they can all be reskinned to reflect other situations that match their mechanics. Symbiote, for example, could represent a high fantasy priest’s powers being granted to him by a goddess who may withhold or deny them outright if his use of them isn’t in line with her goals. Situational Forms like Allayed and Visitor often reflect adverse conditions and methods of compensating for them. Greater Forms and Lesser Forms are essentially Forms nested within other Forms, and although we use them as the basis for crossover, the concept could be used to build any number of remarkable new creatures or specialized concepts.

Merits: Most Core Merits give a character options not available to others, while the rest enhance existing capabilities in some notable way. Deviant-Only Merits interact with Remade systems, often increasing the utility of Variations in ways beyond the scope of Techniques. Most narrowly defined nifty capabilities can be rendered as Merits. Variation-Specific Merits can expand the scope of a Variation beyond the normal 5-dot range and/or create new capabilities that reflect the synergy between two Variations.

Variations/Scars/Standard Deviations: In the core, these represent the powers (and their costs) of Broken. Although often designed as packages of related abilities, Variations are eminently customizable using the inspired Variation process in Shallow Graves. Natural Variations and Scars (and Forms that increase/decrease Size) shift the conversation from “what you can do” to “what you naturally are”, allowing the introduction of extraterrestrial species and extradimensional visitors alike. Storytellers shouldn’t hesitate to forbid some of these if they’re tonally wrong for the intended chronicle or to mandate others that are required to make a chronicle work.

Instability: Instability is at once a premium fuel trait and a looming existential threat. At base, it provides mechanical motivation to pursue some courses of action while avoiding others. It reinforces tropes regarding protagonists in a given genre or subgenre, which is why Chapter Five so often leans on it to do exactly that.

Conspiracies: Although cohorts face individual enemies, Deviant has extensive systems for collective antagonists — especially with the expanded conspiracy rules presented in The Devoted Companion. As we’ve already illustrated, they need not represent literal conspiracies. They can reflect a hostile environment, collective frenemies, or even the pure narrative imperative of a Storyteller to introduce new complications to a story (especially if the cohort isn’t being proactive about confronting their source).

Rewards: While healing Instability is one way to reward desired behavior, the main reward mechanisms are Willpower and Beats. Willpower is a quick hit but ultimately temporary. It’s like an annual bonus; you can stick it in savings or splurge on something nice, but it doesn’t affect next month’s paychecks. Beats, on the other hand, have minimal impact right now, but they represent the long-term growth of a character. Conspiracy Beats in The Devoted Companion and Static in Shallow Graves offer ways of rewarding behavior that aren’t directly Willpower, Instability healing, or Beats, but including too many reward mechanics can make character advancement unnecessarily complicated.

Deviant Equipment: Although implied in the core and rendered for antagonists in The Devoted Companion, The Clades Companion presents details about equipment that interacts with Variations and Scars directly (Repressors/Boosters/Neutralizers) or emulate them (Prototypes). A character heavily invested in Prototypes might be a gadgeteer, especially if they exchange most of their starting Variation Magnitude for extra Merit dots (p. XX) or have the Inventor Form (p. XX).

Ephemeral Entities: These beings are naturally out of phase with the physical world. Although The Clades Companion presents them as antagonists, they could be adapted as player characters, albeit not without some caveats. First, the active conspiracy (or other collective foe) must have some means of dealing with them — both in terms of knowing what they can do and being able to pursue and threaten them. Second, if they’re capable of traveling to an otherworld, the rest of the cohort must have the same ability to do so, whether because their ephemeral ally can grant them that access or they have it by some other means.

Techniques: As presented in Shallow Graves, Techniques resemble Variation-Specific Merits. They differ in two ways. First, they can be used (in a limited way) without needing to spend Experiences for them. Second, they don’t have the potential to scale into a whole style the way Merits do. Although specific to Variations, the premise could be expanded to include Skills, allowing those with significant mundane training (say 3 or more dots) to pull off stunts that leave hobbyists gawking but are still roughly equivalent to a 1-dot Merit when Mastered.

Splats and Genres: It’s no mistake that the splats and alternate genres have so little mechanical overlap. We could have made Variation/Scar entanglements work the same way in both High Fantasy and Superhero Emergence, for example, but we consciously chose not to so that troupes would have access to two systems that reduce the impact of Scars but in different ways. The various pieces of these chapters are meant to work together to convey a specific setting or include the characters and themes of other games, but they can also be mixed and tweaked to create something new.

Setting Examples

Although we don’t have space for full write-ups of mix-and-match settings, here are a few short examples.

Setting Example #1: Cyber-Renegades

The troupe plays a cohort of Remade with Unsupported Upgrades seeking to tear down the powerful people and organizations responsible for the atmosphere of oppression that pervades the world. It takes the Cyberpunk setting and gives it a more traditional Renegades chronicle character, while adding in elements from Superhero Emergence to track their progress towards reforming society.

Each player takes on the role of an Upgraded with only Unsupported Upgrades, typically ones that are either Antiquated or Jailbroken. The main gameplay loop is that of a Renegade-focused core Deviant chronicle, with the cohort targeting a conspiracy that is, for one reason or another, on their collective shit list. Each player’s character has either the Rebel or Reformer Allegiance (p. XX), while their Devoted enemies are nearly always Enforcers.

Characters have a Renegade Allegiance — usually as Rebels or Reformers (p. XX).

They can seek out and accept operations from collectives to raise money to buy/replace equipment or otherwise fund their larger goals. Whenever a Remade with no Pressure or Enhancement would reduce Pressure, track “negative Pressure” called Savings that can be spent instead of gaining Pressure.

Sentiment begins at Neutral (p. XX) but is specific to the cohort’s actions and reflects the public perception of them. However, powerful people and organizations hate and fear the Renegades with a passion equal to the degree to which the public loves and respects these Upgraded. When the prevailing Sentiment improves, the cohort gains any benefits as though they were both Devoted and Renegades and treats Sentiment as though it were its mirror.

For example, if Sentiment has become Positive (two steps above Neutral), it would also count as Hostile (two steps below Neutral). Ordinary people love the Renegades, but the powers that be recognize the cohort as a serious threat to their power. Members of the cohort receive a double ration of extra Merit dots, the Qualified Immunity Merit, the option to take a conspiracy action, the Armed and Extremely Dangerous Merit, and count their Scar Power/Finesse/Resistance as one higher, although other cohort don’t automatically enjoy any of these benefits.

On the other hand, if the prevailing Sentiment becomes negative, members of the cohort only gain the benefits of negative Sentiment (including those afforded Renegades).

Setting Example #2: Time Fixers

The troupe plays a squad Devoted whose reincarnations work to protect and improve the timeline. It takes Dark Eras (p. XX) and incorporates some elements of Mummy (p. XX), while leaving open opportunities to dabble in Post-Apocalyptic, Cyberpunk, and Space Opera genres.

Each player takes on the role of a Deviant (or other supernatural creature, with Arisen being the most obvious) in a historical time and place with a life and memories appropriate to the era. However, they have a vague awareness that there’s something important they must accomplish — the mission for which they were sent to this time. They might be tasked with preventing rival time travelers from changing history, with hiding something of value for someone to find and use centuries in the future, or with changing history in a small but important way.

The characters have no memories of their past (or future) lives when each story begins (Memory 0). As they move through the world and encounter (or intentionally seek out) reminders, however, they earn Memory Beats. Whenever they earn 5 Memory Beats, they increase Memory by 1 (to a maximum of 10). Each +1 increase in Memory grants them Merit dots that can be used to purchase the benefits of the Amalgam Form (Shallow Graves, p. 55), which represent half-remembered skills learned in other lives, caches of resources hidden for just such an eventuality, and connections to the ancestors of key Storyteller characters they can invoke. These Merit dots are lost at the end of the story. At Memory 3, they also realize that they’re time travelers. At Memory 5, they know their mission in the current era. At Memory 7, they understand the mission’s purpose. At Memory 10, they have a complete recollection of who they are within the conspiracy they serve in the far future.

Setting Example #3: God War

The troupe plays as an alliance of gods engaged in an epic and apocalyptic struggle against a rival alliance of gods in a High Fantasy setting. It blends High Fantasy with the detailed conspiracy mechanics from The Devoted Companion.

Each player takes on the role of a single god or other Meddler from the High Fantasy setting and commands a conspiracy based on Standing. Each Node represents a center of power in the mortal world (a consecrated temple, for example, or the merchants who pray to him), with a Linchpin who is a hero the player can direct (or seize direct control of for a chapter as a conspiracy action). When directly controlled this way, the hero earns Conspiracy Beats that can be used to generate additional Effort towards the deity’s Projects.

The troupe alternates between focusing on the strategy of outmaneuvering their divine rivals (or making alliances with neutral Meddlers) and playing as a cohort of heroes in the Meddlers’ service who engage in Quests.

Setting Example #4: Final Haven

The troupe plays as Exo pilots and their support staff defending one of the last bastions of humanity against invaders and other hazards in a post-apocalyptic hellscape. It uses Post-Apocalyptic (p. XX) as its base but includes the Exo Form from Space Opera (p. XX) and the high-tech Upgrades of Cyberpunk (p. XX).

Each player is a Devoted in the service of a futuristic fortress-city. It might be a far future Earth or an alien world, but in either case the inhabitants either can’t produce soul ships or can’t use them to escape. The Remade use Hope and earn/heal Despair as they work towards and complete the missions that the city authorities assign to them. The city itself has Association and other conspiracy traits, but the threats to it follow the World of Pain model (p. XX).

Setting Example #5: Episodic Space Opera

The troupe plays the crew of a roving soul ship on a mission of exploration, spending one or a few chapters on each encounter with the unknown. This uses Space Opera (p. XX) as its base but focuses on adventures on the surface of hitherto unknown alien worlds — whether it’s time-space anomalies, dangerous biomes, or extraterrestrials with strange cultures and unique problems that the crew can potentially solve — and can allow for a kitchen sink approach.

All or nearly all members of the crew should be human Remade, but it might include one or two representatives of another spacefaring species or of an entirely different splat. To represent alien species, use the Heritage system from High Fantasy (p. XX). Worlds may impose the Visitor Form (p. XX) based on their environments. Temporal anomalies could send the visiting crew to a Dark Era (p. XX). Unexpected accidents might temporarily maroon the crew, placing them in a Post-Apocalyptic (p. XX) scenario. Certain dystopian worlds may resemble Cyberpunk (p. XX), while diplomatic missions (or trips to xenophobic planets) might have the prevailing Sentiment system of Superhero Emergence (p. XX).

Setting Example #6: Portalverse

The troupe plays explorers, adventurers, entertainers, spies, and scientists who routinely travel to (or have taken refuge in) a fantasy world where they have superhuman abilities. This uses Superhero Emergence as the base, but most of the action occurs in a High Fantasy (p. XX) setting, and some Cyberpunk (p. XX) elements creep in.

Humans have discovered a means of opening portals between our world and a parallel world where magic is real and dangers are many. Baselines who enter that world gain superhuman powers (and suffer occult Scars) that make them veritable demigods in it. Gunpowder and most technology from the Renaissance and later simply don’t function in the fantasy world, and anything brought back through the portal disintegrates in transit. This has made invasion less attractive and trade impossible. However, a handful of media conglomerates have found a means of extracting, recording, and broadcasting the memories of returning explorers, which has made the fantasy world a potential source of entertainment. Some governments and scientists also use this technology to study the fantasy world, and it’s becoming an increasingly popular tourist destination.

Visitors don’t retain their powers or Scars when they return. Leaving the fantasy world can be accomplished through any number of permanent portals, all of which return the visitor the portal on Earth that they used to get there. Thus, the earthly portal can take a traveler to any fantasy portal, but all fantasy portals lead home. Entering the fantasy world inflicts minor Instabilities equal to the traveler’s highest Variation Magnitude.

Origin reflects the circumstances under which characters first came to the fantasy otherworld. Characters manifest a Clade the first time they enter the fantasy world, but no one knows the logic behind this. Sentiment reflects the parallel world’s opinion of visiting demigods. Visibility isn’t a factor; instead, employers back home and fantasy Meddlers alike assign Quests. The Secret Identity Merit isn’t available.

Comments

Jonathan Lang

"Greater Forms and Lesser Forms are essentially Forms nested within other Forms," You should probably mention Scar Forms here as well, just to be complete. Though to be fair, you only introduced two of those: one for Prometheans and another for Vampires. So there aren't as many examples of how to create or use them as there are for Greater and Lesser Forms.

Jonathan Lang

By the way, I love the suggestion of attaching Techniques to Skills. I could see using that to create my favorite kind of superhero, the modern-day version of an Exalt.