First Steps on the Road to Collaborative Storytelling (Patreon)
Content
Deviant unquestionably betrays my preference for a collaborative style of Storytelling. From the Mag 3 effects of some Superhuman Attributes to letting players help define the conspiracy's traits to the Setting the Scene option, I seem hellbent on bringing players behind the Storyteller's screen - if not ceding narrative control to them entirely. This is the reflection of a long journey, though, not something that just happened when I started out.
My very first TTRPG game involving other people (rather than elaborate solo plays with adventure modules) was a one-on-one D&D adventure in 5th grade. My first DM killed 14 of my characters in the first dungeon - a monstrosity of his own creation, although one could be forgiven for assuming it was Tomb of Horrors, because I'm pretty sure that's what he was riffing on. It was a pretty adversarial game, to put it mildly. He was all of ten or eleven years old, so I can forgive him for letting the power of commanding an entire world go to his head.
He always talked up Grimtooth's Traps, so when I found that in my local hobby store a couple of years later, you can bet I snapped it up. Inside, I found tons of fiendishly clever (and occasionally juvenile) ways of killing characters in a D&D game. Get greedy? Dead. Get overconfident? Dead. Forget to check every door and stone tile for traps? Dead. Check every door and stone tile for traps? Still dead.
No matter what you did, if your DM wanted to kill you, your character was doomed. As young as I was, I thought this was the coolest thing ever. Even as an adult looking back, I can appreciate the cleverness of many of the traps (even if an outsized number of them involved melted wax). Grimtooth's Traps wasn't so much a book of traps, or even a book about how to make traps, but a philosophy of adversarial GMing with 101 examples as supporting evidence - all delivered with humor and sarcasm.
On a lark - probably not on the exact same trip, but I always entangle these two trips together in my mind - I picked up some game called PARANOIA and a couple of its modules on clearance. PARANOIA seemed to have that same adversarial GMing style, delivered with manic, "I'm sorry this thing I'm doing to you happened" humor. It took pains down to its core premise to make it possible to kill a character five times in a single mission without worrying that a player would be sidelined. But it also had the most profound advice for player: "Entertain or die."
Those three words conveyed an assumption that not only could a player convince an adversarial GM to spare his character, but that the GM was encouraged to reward being clever, being funny, and playing into the tropes of the game by staying his hand.
Those two works, taken together, revealed to me two truths:
1. If the GM wants to kill your character, there's nothing you can do to stop it.
2. Killing characters isn't the point of being a GM (see #1); the point is to get players to do things in-character that are interesting to you.
That's still a far cry from a truly collaborative style of DMing/GMing/STing/HGing, but it was an important first step away from my first experiences with gaming: trying to have a cool adventure when the person running the show is primarily interested in finding hilarious ways to hurt, frustrate, or kill your character. Later experiences would refine that further.