Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

I managed to finish two key pieces of media, this week - the second season of Severance and the movie Sinners.

First, Severance. This show is an example of what I started calling "one thing sci-fi" even in my 20s, as it is really just our world except with one huge technological advance. At the time, I used the term dismissively because, too often, it seemed like an excuse for lazy world-building to keep a movie budget low. I've literally forgotten all the movies I applied the term to back in the day because they were so eminently forgettable. Like "the fantasy we had", they weren't so much a defining style or movement of art as a complaint about the technological or cultural limitations that inhibited it. In the absence of the combustion engine, DaVinci's sketch of a helicopter was never going to get off the ground.

I've since moderated my position on this because it can be a way to deeply explore the implications of a single piece of new technology - the ethical questions it raises and the ways it reshapes the world. Severance gives me ample justification for this more generous take. It takes a kind of weird premise ("What if a company found a way to make it so people didn't remember what they did at work when they were at home and didn't remember who they were or what they did at home when they were at work?") and really explores the world that comes out of it.

Retirement parties become funerals. A saccharine self-help book found in a meeting room can be read as scripture. The company can be the weirdest cult imaginable when you're at work, because you know nothing else. And being forced to work on your day off is a life-altering violation of the implied bargain you agreed to.

Each character has some reason they chose to work for Lumon on a severed floor, and exploring those motives is as interesting as figuring out what the hell is up with the goat people and the random numbers they're sorting into boxes every day.

Sinners, now, Sinners is going to take a rewatch or two before I feel like I've fully absorbed it. But to offer a spoiler-free first impression:

First off, it's 90% 1930s period piece set in the Mississippi Delta and 10% vampire/slasher movie. Sinners lavishes the majority of its attention on its setting and characters in a way that reminds me of the plays of August Wilson. I wrote a paper on Joe Turner's Come and Gone in my final year of college, and I remember a line from my research that described the opening scenes of the play as having the purpose of "Africanizing the audience", by which they meant introducing largely white viewers to the superstitions, spiritual practices, and day-to-day concerns of its Black characters.

I see that same approach in Sinners. Especially in the first 45 minutes (before any vampires are introduced), we're introduced to these characters (and there are rather a lot of them), their histories, and their relationships to one another. Some of it is stated outright from the start, but much of it is implied at first with the details gradually revealed over the course of the film. It really elevates the slasher movie element, because instead of the first death being a bit of a "that was a funny way to die, and they deserved it for doing that dumb thing" because we don't really feel a connection to any of the characters (which, in slasher movies, are usually introduced as barely more than a cliche), the first real death of the movie is a gut punch, the loss of someone I liked and felt like I knew.

Beth often notes that slasher films are a moral genre in that who dies in what order and under what circumstances betrays a lot about who the creator regards (or believes the audience regards) as deserving life or death. In this way, movies like Friday the 13th have a lot in common with fairy tales and even children's morality tales like Charlie and the Chocolate Factory (consider: is Willy Wonka a slasher?). Sinners upholds this to a degree but gives us enough information about its characters that it's also clear how much most of these characters don't deserve what's happening to them - you know, exactly like Blacks in Jim Crow era Mississippi didn't deserve any of the exploitation, lynching, and other racist bullshit they had to contend with.

Race is an inescapable component of Sinners, and it shapes both the lives of its characters and the way it interprets and builds on the slasher movie tradition. I've seen it said that when Black and white people watch Sinners together, they see two different movies, and I don't doubt that that's true. I have some context for the world of Sinners, but it isn't part of my heritage, much less my lived experience, so I can only run my fingers along the edges of empathy. That said, the movie does a really good job of conveying that world even to my white ass - even if only to listen to characters matter-of-factly talk about the unquestionably fucked up shit they've experienced or had friends experience because of the color of their skin.

It puts me in the mind of when, in my early 20s, I worked at a country club in probably the richest suburb of Indianapolis at the time. One of my friends at work was a delightful nerd who loved to quote Star Trek and talk about video games (his nickname was "Snake" because of his love of Metal Gear). He worked in the kitchen, while I worked as a server. He also happened to be Black. One day, we were supposed to be working the same event and he was late in arriving (which was unusual for him). When he got there, he explained he had been pulled over by a cop on some flimsy pretext that boiled down to what I now recognize as the trope of "driving while Black in a white neighborhood". But the way he told that story - not as an infuriating or annoying experience but as an amusing anecdote stuck with me. Maybe he was secretly seething and covering for it with good natured humor, but if so, he had me completely fooled.

I didn't live in that suburb, and it was a universal joke in the donut counties of Indianapolis that the people who lived there were all spoiled, rich snobs. But clearly, my friend experienced a very different rich, white suburb than I did, and the injustice of it frankly pissed me off.

There were several moments in Sinners that reminded me of that experience - my first brush with systemic racism. Even in the absence of vampires, everyone's situation is just so fucking tragic, but they're making lives and finding joy in spite of that. But it doesn't lessen the tragedy or excuse the injustice they face.

I'm really enjoying Severance. It has exactly my sense of humor and love for the surreal. But Sinners is haunting and beautiful on too many levels to discuss in a spoiler-free review. If you haven't done so already, you should watch it.

Comments

No comments found for this post.