Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Videos

Content

Password: JR2x24

Files

(No title)

Comments

Zenkusen

People give this show a lot of shit because the weirdness surrounding Rudys mental age and all that, but its genuinely one of if not the greatest isekai story in the anime space, and I'm sure it will continue to be for a while. Not many series can mix comedy, romance, adventure, and raw sadness and this show does all of them pretty damn well. Also season 3 is planned to release in April of next year, so theres a chance this show and Bleach cour 4 are going to be airing at the same time, or at least overlap a few episodes depending on when Bleach starts

Some Kinda Abomination

The highlight of this episode was Norns VA. She was fantastic. Can’t wait for season 3 it’s one of my favorite sections of the LN.

Rajeep Brown

There’s a trailer out for season 3 not sure if you have seen it yet, if not love to get your reaction to it.. 👍🏽

Rycen Bonifacio

She reacted to it, she posted her reaction on youtube

ExitStrat

Sylphy was too kind to tear into Rudy for his infidelity, but not too kind as to stop Norn from doing it for her. I love that little bit.

Novice

Overall good season. I didn't really like the ending due to him marrying Roxy especially since he cheated with her on Sylphie who didn't deserve it 😢. Norn's crash out was valid. However, I guess it does make the series interesting. Also nice that Rudeus and Sylphie had a child, I honestly thought she would have a miscarriage based on what man god said. I kind of wish it was a boy since currently it's just Rudy with a bunch of girls. Maybe next season Zoro will visit Rudeus and teach him 3 sword style 💀 ♥️ 🤍 💙

Karatsuki

Opinions are of course always valid and allowed to exist but as much as I do understand Norns actions becaus of her upbringing, even fans outside the story outright oppose the idea of Rudy marrying Roxy when the matter is STRICTLY between Sylphy and them and NOBODY else should have a say in it. Having another persons back in an argument is fine but Making that argument For them is not ok. At the end of the day it was also mainly Roxy who acted here as Rudy was still in a state of shock when it happened. Rudy has feelings for Roxy of course but it was mainly out of consideration for her feelings that he decided to take responsibility wanting to make her happy too.

Karatsuki

To be completely honest Norns crash out was completely out of line. Cheating is one thing, and while she didn't know all the facts as Rudeus took the blame for Roxys actions, she completely ignored Sylphys opinion when this matter should be strictly between Rudy, Roxy and Sylphy and nobody else.

Karatsuki

Eeh... actually in the books SyIphy outright berates Norn and says she went too far

Karatsuki

The world building truly is superb especially with the additional stories

tom leier

Banger series from star t to end. Cant wait for s3 next year.

Novice

I disagree. Yes it should be a matter between Rudeus, Sylphie and Roxy alone in terms of what they want to do amongst themselves, but Norn's crash out was realistic and not at all out of line. Them cheating is serious regardless of who moved first or took the blame. Imagine taking care of your brother's wife during pregnancy just to find out he cheated on her when he returned and on top of that wants to wed the woman he was unfaithful to his wife with after he made his vows to Sylphie. Norn wasn't disregarding Sylphies opinion, but she was surprised at the audacity of Rudeus' sin and then request that she spoke out on what she thought was the obvious thing to say. If they strictly wanted this to be kept between the "adults" they should have never let norn or Aisha in on this conversation. That's just what I think especially since I like Sylphie a lot.

Karatsuki

In The books Sylphy actually starts saying ok but Norn cuts of going on her rant so she actually does kind of disregard Sylphys opinion before she can respond. She also very much reprimands Norn afterwards

Karatsuki

I'm not saying she's wrong to feel that way but she definitely should have listened to the person in question first I do also agree that they should probably have been briefed only atter the matter was concluded

ExitStrat

Perhaps, but she still let her pop-off for a good while. Besides, the Light Novels/Web Novel/Manga/Anime all have thier own subtle differences on many subjects of this story, including this one. In this forum I will only speak in regards of the anime as far as it has developed.

Karatsuki

There are definitely differences but as a baseline the anime is adapted from the light novels and while they have cut a LOT of it to fit these episodes it doesn't mean those things simply didn't happen at all in the anime.

ExitStrat

Sometimes we DO have differences from the anime that have to be excluded in discussion (Like Rudy believing Roxy to be pregnant as a motivation to marry her), because the two take a different path. In any case, light novel or anime, I still think Sylphy took her sweet time stopping Norn because Norn was hitting on the feelings of anger and betrayal that naturally would have bubbled up in her mind upon inititially hearing about her husband's disloyalty. I stand by my opinion.

Karatsuki

Sylphy definitely is overly soft on Rudy but that is not really the case here, she openly says that Norn is in the wrong for saying what she did and she says to Roxy that she understands the situation and why things happened. There's also the fact that she was already expecting something like this. She certainly does not fully support Rudy going behind her back but saying that she lets Norn talk that way because of her OWN feelings contradicts everything else happening in that same scene

ExitStrat

I beleive it is not in her nature to lash out about her negative feelings. I don't think she would have been able to express her own hurt or anger at that moment, it would have been out of her character. I think she let Norn go as long as she did because Norn was able to vocalize and express those feeling at first. Eventually, Norn started to go too far when she began controlling the situation herself, and perhaps Sylphy saw how painful Roxy leaving was to Rudy, or sensed that he was about to damage his relationship with his little sister. That is when Sylphy stepped in, with her characteristic kindness once again. She didn't have to break character and express her own hurt because Norn did it for her. She took her time to stop her until it went beyond how she felt. To me it just adds up.

ExitStrat

She can be hurt and accepting at the same time, and feelings evolve and change, sometimes rapidly so. She also expressed her own anxiety and shock at first, with acceptance after thinking it over a bit.

Karatsuki

My point is Sylphy was starting to say ok to the whole thing before Norn started going off on him. She for sure was nervous but it is not in her character to be even able to get mad at Rudy at this point. Norns outburst is meant to feel like the people watching self insert but at the end of the day the point was that she has no say in the matter as it is strictly between the people involved. Sylphy waited it out not because those were her feelings being said but because Norn probably needed to let all that out and she was still thinking it over but as she said herself she realized the situation AND made up her mind the moment she heard and saw Roxys feelings about the matter

Karatsuki

Story, definitely. Quality, I'm not so sure.

ExitStrat

Maybe Sylphy starts to answer before Norn starts in the web novel (I don't recall) but I havent seen that in the Light Novel (English translation) or the Anime (both sub and dub). Perhaps when the Manga catches up it will throw in more perspective? I still see my opinion as valid (it is only opinion, as there is no official account of Sylphies thoughts on the matter). My backing points are her prior expressed displeasure of thoughts of him womanizing like Paul and the other Greyrats, and her aggravation and depression when seeing him flirt around with the beast people and closeness with Nanahoshi (when still undercover as Fitz). In the Light Novel Rudy mentions the "troubled look" on her face and its enough of a look for him to become remorseful and beg her forgiveness. For me, the best evidence is still allowing Norn to say her peace, at least up until Sylphy beleives she crosses a line. Being ready to accept another wife into her home is not the same as viewing at as her ideal, I am sure she would have preferred to have Rudy to herself in her own mind, if not at the very least for a little while longer. Otherwise, to have her be a one dimensional docile wet noodle is boring. I can't prove it, I can't say it's cannon, I can't say my opinion invalidates yours... but neither can you.

GhostPhil

After seeing that Fananimation, they really need to up their game with the official animation for those parts in Season 3

GhostPhil

Sylphie looks so incredibly warm and compfy as a mom. It's weird, but in a way in this medival-fantasy setting, living in this mansion of house, having a big family is also kind of compfy. Obviously does it always need to be those harem-like settings in Isekai? Obviously not and in most series, they are just very implimented in a cheap way. Here especially in the last episode they really skipped a lot in the Anime, but I feel like it is kind of "earned", that Rudy also marries Roxy. We had a lot of time to see the emotional connection between the characters and we also saw that in this time/setting/world it is one kind of normality to have multiple partners. I would honestly be fine to just have a normal Slice-of-Life story from now on, that focuses on their day to day life. But SoL isn't that common in a fantasy setting compared to contemporary anyway, so that would make it even more interesting. I can't wait for Season 3 and your reaction to it.

Radiochip

Finally, now we can start the story

Karatsuki

To be completely honest Sylphy IS a wet noodle when it comes to Rudy at this point in the story before she gains more confidence in her position

Karatsuki

Also the analogy you give of the situation is completely without context. Rudy was literally killing himself by not eating or drinking when Roxy saved him, Roxy pushed him down in a situation where he couldn't resist as he was still in a state of shock and Rudys main reason for requesting Roxy to be his wife is because he wants to take responsibility even through all that. Rudy also believes that Roxy is pregnant because of Elinalise. Now imagine Norn doing this towards Lilia, literally telling a pregnant woman to get out of the house and disappear. Now I'm not saying all this makes it ok but it certainly makes Norn crashout way out of line, even Norn herself acknowledges this.

Karatsuki

Rather than feeling anger, when they talk about it later in the story Sylphy says she feared that Rudy would leave her for somebody else rather than Sylphy herself taking action and that she could never hate Rudy like that. She's also the one who says to Roxy that they should support Rudy with their all going forward. She might feel anxiety and uncertainty and she might pout at times but she has never truly felt anger at Rudy to the point of saying anything close to what Norn did.

ExitStrat

This is not the forum to discuss future events. If it were, I could present other supporting arguments, so no fair skipping ahead. Anyway, I would argue her ACTIONS (not emotions) are that of a wet noodle so far, and that she has YET to gain the confidence to voice her own feelings on such matters herself (Norn as proxy, because she wasn't far off. Anger can be another manifestation of pain). We can discuss that more after season 3 drops.

Karatsuki

Aside from Sylphy gaining confidence all of these conversations between her and Rudy have already been cut from anime as they happen between Sylphy accepting Roxy into the household and Rudy visiting Pauls grave after his child is born Almost a whole chapter got cut when they skipped that month Circling back to the original comment to close this off I do agree that Sylphy was partly not "kind" enough to stop Norn at the start but my opinion is that it had NOTHING to do with Sylphys feelings being in line with Norns as they are completely different personalities

Novice

Honestly with the context, to me it just makes the crash out invalid in terms of directing it towards Rudy versus Roxy. Imagine the gender roles were reversed. Roxy is married and just lost her parents and is mentally and physically drained. Rudy loves Roxy and then takes advantage of Roxy's inability to resist to then have sex with her. If I was Roxy's brother and heard this context that a man literally just 🍇 my sister, my crash out would be even worse towards Rudy even if Roxy's husband is ok with sharing Roxy with a 🍇 ist. If it was a case that Lilia went on Paul in a state where he couldn't resist and happened to get pregnant, that is lilias fault and thus responsibility to take care of her child that she forced Paul to have. In such case, it's perfectly fine to want to kick her out for that, it's pretty much 🍇. Right?

Karatsuki

Again it's not black and white like you make it to be It is true that Rudy couldn't give consent and that is never ok, BUT they BOTH obviously love each other and if that was the only way of saving him from starving himself to death then that needs to be taken into account too Sylphy also expresses genuine gratitude towards Roxy for saving Rudy The morality of this situation is entirely GREY no one side is completely right or wrong

Karatsuki

I genuinely recommend reading the last few chapters of volume 13 of the light novel, from the fight with the Hydra to Rudy visiting his fathers grave after his child is born to fully understand each characters emotions The anime not only skips Rudys suffering after Pauls death but also some important conversations between everyone going home and Sylphy giving birth

Aaron Wright

I don't like how frictionless it is. Two women who barely know each other need to have more friction and character moments together, not just slotting in like that.

Aaron Wright

yes, Sylphie is written badly in the books too, Kara. I love MT, but there's nowhere near enough friction between the girls, and Sylphie is too much of a pushover. Its glaring because everywhere else the characters are written so carefully, but there needed to be a lot more clashes and friction in rudy's personal live especially of Roxy and Sylphie arguing and disagreeing. Its all a bit too smooth for me.

Karatsuki

Sylphy is 100% a pushover now and her writing is a bit flat at points But why would there be a NEED to have conflict between them You can absolutely still write a good story without that kind of conflict Sure spicing things up will instantly make a story more interesting but it's not neccessary to make a good story

No Swear

i cant wait to april 2026 and season 3

Mahuloq

So good. Honestly sylphy grew up at the Greyrats house. So having two moms, or wives was like... normal for her to see. She spent all the time over at his place. And for years afterwards when he was sent away.

SilverCrow

Can't wait for season 3. People shouldn't be too eager about Eris joining the harem. It's too weird and too soon. Sure at this rate she will most likely join it (with some rocky or brute drama) but those things should be built up with a story. Not just suddenly pop up within episode 1-5 and be like → Eris: "Rudy im back and I'm here to take you by force" -_-

FROST

"I think I did my best." You lost focus on the pivotal moment of the Hydra fight and Paul had to intervene to save you. He waited years before attempting to save Zenith which led to her disabilities being this severe. Let me marry first so then I can have the excuse of having a child on the way so I won't have to go to the labyrinth to save my OWN mother. All that power wasted on a selfish wimp. "I think I did my best" what a joke..