Hello everyone,
I want to get your feedback on one feature we are considering for EliteMobs 10, which has to do with dungeons.
LONG READ ALERT! HERE'S THE SUMMARY:
TL;DR: Right now dungeons have fixed levels, so once you level past them they become useless. We're considering letting you choose what level to run dungeons at, so you can replay your favorites and still get rewards. This would use lockout timers (like WoW) to prevent endless farming. Vote: (1) keep fixed levels, (2) make all dungeons scalable, or (3) only make instanced dungeons scalable.
One problem I have begun to observe over the years has to do with how EliteMobs fails to do levels in a reasonable way. This is a legacy problem from back in EliteMobs 1, where I wanted to avoid stepping on the feet of other popular mmorpg-like progression plugins, which I was also using.
However, this has ultimately just led to a rather confusing leveling system, where currency is basically exp, but it can be given to other players, it scales in odds ways, etc.
One thing I want to do in EliteMobs 10 is finally sit down and create a proper, satisfying leveling system, based on individual skill progression such as in Runescape. To be clear, I still want EliteMobs to be compatible with other MMORPG-like progression plugins, so it will do this in a way that can be combined with other plugins without breaking anything or interfering, and the bonuses will only be applied when doing EliteMobs content.
There's quite a bit I could say about this experience system, but that's not what this poll is about. This poll is about a problem that has been a headache for a very long time: levels for EliteMobs.
EliteMobs has a lot of low level content, and it has a decent amount of high level content; however, the higher you go, the more you start seeing gaps. Additionally, when we do high effort content, we always hesitate to make it high level. Yggdrasil is a good example: we put so much time and effort into making it, but it is only fit to be run for a short level window, before which it is too hard, and after which it is too easy and gives no rewards.
Obviously the prestige system is a massive help to help fix this, but it is not a perfect solution. If a player really liked doing the story-mode dungeons, they will have to go all the way to the highest level and reset just to have an excuse to do them again with any kind of tangible reward.
So, I came up with an idea. Instead of enforcing levels on content, since we now have instanced content, we could simply allow players to pick the level of the content when they enter the dungeon, or have it adapt to their level, just like how instanced content also allows players to pick a difficulty.
This presents the following challenges:
1) Ordered content, like story-mode dungeons.
These would still be locked behind quests/permissions. You can still enforce an order of completion, or an otherwise permissions-based access system.
2) Finding the most profitable dungeon and just farming that one endlessly
This would be resolved via dungeon lockouts, like in WoW. The idea is that each time a player kills a creature in a dungeon, they get the loot and then get locked out of getting rewards for killing the same boss again for X amount of time. This amount of time would be configurable, and would be anywhere between 24h and 7 days by default, depending on how it feels in testing and planning.
3) Non-instanced content
This is one of the bigger problems. For this to work, all content that can be converted to become instanced would be converted. This is because while it is rather easy to set the level of a boss when the content is instanced, it's not realistic to do for open content - that is to say, content where people with completely different levels might be wandering around.
Two pieces of content we can already tell will not be converted. Primis and Oasis. They will have to keep fixed levels. This is not a huge problem, as they are a great first set of dungeons for new players, and not necessarily meant to be run over and over again as they have massively long quest chains and more of a focus on story and exploration.
4) Reward scaling
This will be rather easy to do fortunately, as most of our rewards already scale by default anyhow. However, it will probably slightly change, as we switch to a proper experience-based system. Right now the most obvious change would be that using gear would be locked behind a level players organically get by killing elites, instead of locked behind purchasing a higher level from the adventurer's guild.
5) Different party levels
The level of content would be decided by the person who creates the instance. Other players joining as a party enter at their own peril.
6) Difficulty
Most if not all instanced content comes with three difficulty levels. This will be something we will try to continue doing. However, we do have to acknowledge that there will be no real difficulty progression as any dungeon can be done at any time in any order. The only dungeon that we will retain as harder will be the binder of worlds, for obvious reasons. This is certainly one area I will look into improving, maybe adding baseline mechanics to bosses at certain thresholds to make them more mechanically challenging.
I will say even now we don't particularly design higher level dungeons to be harder than lower level ones, with the exception of Primis and the Oasis, which are made easier for new players.
The poll:
Alright, after that very long explanation, let's look at the poll options:
1) Keep fixed levels in dungeons - this is what we currently do
2) Make (nearly) all dungeons scale to player level, letting them do any content that isn't locked behind permissions or quests at any time - this would be the most flexible approach
3) Only make already instanced dungeons flexible, and keep the rest fixed level (and probably lower the levels so the gaps aren't as bad and cover levels 0-100)