Harry and Y/N are exes (kind of) (Patreon)
Content
SITUATIONSHIPS ARE HARD!! That's kind of what this is about :D someone asked me to do one where they are exes so I did my own spinnnn, kinda sorta! I hope you like it!! IFFF you guys wanted to see more of them, I have a plan for these two that I wouldn't mind seeing through, but only if y'all are interested!
SOMEONE asked for more tutor!harry so that's coming! AND I'm going to rewrite sex!shop worker y/n and inexperienced harry so it's more updated and they can have a proper storyline!
OKAY LOVE YOUUUU!! HOPE YOU LIKE, LMK WHAT YOU THINK
Word count: 2,985
__________________________________________________________
i.
Seeing an ex is weird.
Y/N knows everyone thinks that it’s odd, whether you ended on good terms or bad ones. To be so close to someone emotionally and physically – to whisper proclamations of love into their ears on quiet mornings, take showers together on rainy days, meet each other’s family, be inside of each other. . . and now, you have to spend at least ten minutes contemplating saying hello? It’s weird. Maybe it doesn’t need to be weird – maybe it’s only weird because everyone makes it that way, but it is nonetheless. The happy fluttering butterflies in your stomach are replaced with a fight or flight response.
She and Harry ended things. . .relatively well. Like, when the conversation started Y/N called him a stupid prick, but in the end, they hugged and agreed to not let things disrupt their friend group, and Y/N didn’t call him a stupid prick for a second time.
Some could argue that Y/N took everything too seriously, and that’s why she got her feelings hurt, and her heart tied up in it. Technically, according to Harry, what they had wasn’t a relationship. Sure they slept together, Harry had seen her at her most naked and vulnerable, and knew some of her dirtiest, filthiest kinks – but that was just two buddies helping each other out. Yeah, they spent the night at each other's dorm rooms, they woke up and ate breakfast together, and Harry would kiss her on the temple before leaving — but friends just do that. Y/N knew his mum, spent time shopping with his sister, and hung out with his cousins, while Harry had gone on Y/N’s family vacation with her, met aunts and uncles, and spent time baking with her Nan – but all besties know each other’s families like that. They would go out to eat together, they’d walk through the park on cool autumn days, and show up in matching Halloween costumes that they’d planned while making hot chocolate and baking themed cookies – but two pals go on outings, right?
All close friends become oddly domesticated at some point, Y/N believes that is just the natural progression of companionship. The thing is, that Y/N and Harry became oddly domesticated and he was fucking her several times a week. She was close with most of her friends, there were barely any barriers between what would be considered friendly and what someone would do with their lover – but she wasn’t having sex with them. They weren’t digging their fingers into her hips and begging her to cum. They didn’t pin her down, slap her bum, and degrade her. They didn’t whisper sweet praises in her ear when she squeezed around them, or curl their fingers in her hair and pull when she was too fucked dumb to respond to them, or smear their lips over her mouth and kiss her, letting the word Mine get lost in her mouth.
Harry never had seen any of that how she had seen it. At least, that’s what he told her when she was upset after catching him at a party flirting with another girl, pink-cheeked from liquor, his arm resting above the girl’s head on the door frame. Harry didn’t know why she was upset because Y/N and him were just friends, not together. All the things he’d done were under the guise that they both agreed this was more friends with benefits than anything else which – they had never discussed, actually. Maybe Harry does this with enough people to be confusing her with someone else and the thought alone made her want to smother both him and herself.
She didn’t blame him for all of it either. There had been no discussion about the terms of their relationship or their feelings, Y/N had just assumed they were something more special than they were. She’d never expressed to him how she felt, because she thought he’d already known – honestly, she thought she was making it abundantly clear. Maybe it was her fault though, for expecting a male UNI student to have even the sliver of emotional capacity a trained dog possesses.
They talked it out, they called it off, they hugged in a random frat house bedroom and Y/N left. And that was that – she wept into her pillow, took a bath, toweled Harry off her damp skin, and then sent the application to study abroad that she’d been avoiding. At the time, she hadn’t wanted to leave Harry – anytime she’d thought about it in the past, she’d been consumed with guilt, like she’d be handing off something beautiful in exchange for a cool semester or two in a new place (one that may or may not be beneficial for a resume – do employers even care where you went to school anymore?). It was easy to do it then, with no false promise of a relationship holding her back.
Was it petty of her to not tell Harry she left? Possibly, but it was the only lick she could have gotten on him at the time. He found out from mutual friends, not even from her, and she ignored his messages and calls when he tried to contact her. It felt like she was getting back at him – for hurting her. For stringing her along. For treating her like she was someone important to him, a person he’d want to cradle in his hands and protect from the world. For leaving a Harry-sized crack inside of her, splintered in tiny shards, difficult to mend.
For breaking her heart.
So, yeah, maybe it wasn’t the same thing as seeing an ex, but it sure felt like it. Y/N had been away for three years now – she ended up practically completing her degree at the partner university in Japan before deciding to come back home. She kept in contact with most of her friends, messaging, and video calling as long as the time difference allowed it. And of course, she came home for breaks, and though she mostly spent those with her family, she still made an effort to visit with her mates that she’d left behind. Did she duck, dodge, and avoid Harry at all costs? Of course, she did, but that was her business, at the end of the day.
It’d been three years since they spoke to each other, let alone saw one another, yet here he was. Ambling up to the table at the bar she and her friends visited as a ‘welcome back home/congrats on graduating/congrats on securing a job at Niall’s same place of work so he can annoy her’ kind of celebration. It’s not that she wasn’t expecting her friends to invite him – she knew they would. Nobody had any clue what had gone on between them and Y/N hadn’t been around for things to necessarily be awkward. Plus, she didn’t want them to feel like they needed to pick sides or anything (and she didn’t want her feelings to be hurt if they chose his side over hers) so she kept it to herself. And considering she’d never received a message demanding an explanation from any of her nosy friends, then she imagined Harry had kept it to himself as well.
She just hadn’t been expecting Harry to come. Why would he want to, when things ended the way they did?
“Oi,” Niall’s brows dipped as Harry stopped at the table, his thighs bumping against the oak, “You’re late, we’re already a couple of drinks in so you’ll need to double fist to catch up.”
Harry smiled and it was the same, dimpled grin. He hadn’t changed much, but Y/N has always believed that men – for whatever reason – go through about three different sets of puberty before reaching their final form. Harry looks more mature and more chiseled in places where he used to be a bit softer. His hair is still in unruly curls but he has it trimmed neatly, and instead of the loose-fitted tees and bottoms he used to wear, he’s dressed like he’d just gotten off work. A button-up slightly wrinkled from the day around his lower torso, the first two unbuttoned and his tie loosened. His trousers were still looking crisp, his shirt tucked into them, beneath the sleek black belt.
It felt weird to see him like this, but she bites her tongue. She’s determined not to make it weird or awkward because as soon as she does that, it’s like an admission of guilt. And Y/N didn’t do anything wrong – she just pursued higher education elsewhere. That’s all.
“Sorry, I was finishing a report and got out late,” his eyes scanned the table before settling on her, and there’s something in them. . .something that dances behind a gaze that she doesn’t know how to read anymore, “Welcome back,” he said gently, though his smile had softened into something more pained, “We missed you.”
We or you?
Y/N only meets his smile, “I missed you all too.”
The night isn’t ruined, but she certainly doesn’t live it up how she should. She drinks slowly, catches up with everyone, and avoids making eye contact with Harry. Y/N leans into Ulma, who sits to her left and soaks in the warmth that radiates from her body – she’s always cold, shivering when everyone else isn't, so they were all used to it by now. Harry used to carry around his jacket, always saying it was in case he got caught a chill, but she’d always known he brought it for her. She was always the one who ended up wearing it by the end of the night anyway.
There’s no jacket this time, just Ulma teasing her and wrapping an arm around her body, sliding her palm up and down Y/N’s bicep to heat her up. She can feel eyes on her but she closes her own, revels in the contact, and ignores her bladder for as long as she can in favor of staying like this. She is three cocktails in though and eventually, the need to piss outweighs the desire to stay cozy, so she’s nudging Niall out of the booth so she can have a wee.
Y/N takes her time peeing – the bathrooms here are typically (and impressively) clean for a bar, and they don’t smell rancid or have any odd, sticky stains around the marbled floor. She washes her hands and stares at herself in the mirror, sighing gently, wondering if Harry thought she looked any different. Did she? Y/N really doesn’t think so. . .she’d gotten her hair cut a while ago, but it’d grown out since. Maybe she learned how to color coordinate outfits a little better while she was abroad, and she’d expanded her once picky taste for food. . .but she was the same person, wasn’t she? The same person Harry wanted nothing to do with romantically.
Whatever.
She isn’t expecting to see Harry outside of the bathroom, but at the same time, she is. Y/N knew the night would not go without a hitch – Harry was never one to let things go, and she did leave the country and go MIA. It wasn’t a matter of whether Harry would bring it up, just when. She just thought he might let her settle some before he did.
“Jesus Christ,” Y/N startled when she opened the door and he was standing right there, looming, “You know, people are gonna think you’re a creep if you hover outside the bathroom like this.”
“Sorry,” he replied, not sounding even a little apologetic, “I just wanted to talk to you without everyone around.”
Y/N blinked at him, “Yeah, okay,” she wiped her wet hands on her top, “About what?” If she feigned ignorance, maybe he would let it go. It was wishful thinking, she knew that, especially when he didn’t seem all too amused with her tilted head and furrowed brow.
“You know what,” he stepped a little closer – she didn’t think it was to be intimidating; it coordinated with the loud cheers coming from one of the tables, making it a little harder to hear, “I – can we go outside?”
Against her better judgment, she does follow him out there. The air was cold tonight, biting on her bare arms but she felt determined not to show any signs of weakness. When she started seeing Harry as some form of animalistic predator rather than her friend, she was unsure, but she was worried he’d sink his teeth into her if he saw any soft spots. If he realizes that Y/N was the same person who left – the same person who cried and called him a prick then hugged him thirty minutes later and wished him well. If he realized that there was still a gape in her heart where he used to fit before he pissed it all away.
“Are you gonna tell me why?” Harry cut right to the point, slicing through the quiet air – they were standing near a fire escape, a small alleyway that Y/N would never step foot in alone at night. She’d always been scared of alleys like this – maybe that’s why he stands so close.
“Why what?”
Harry huffed a breath, frustrated with her game, “Why you left without saying anything?” He offered, “Why you didn’t answer my messages? My calls? For three years?” He continued, getting a little more worked up, though he does well not to get too loud, “Why you just. . .just disappeared one night?”
Y/N stared at him, eyes dancing across his face. She hated how much she wanted to feel his cheeks beneath her palms again – how desperately she’d still like to nuzzle into his neck how she used to, and hide from his gaze, pretend that things were different. How she wished that they were still close to how they were, even if it didn’t mean having sex. How she hated looking at Harry, not knowing what’s going on in his life, if he’s seeing someone, if he’s happy at his job, if he’s happy in his life. He could be engaged, for all she knew – or even married. Three years is a long time, and she knew. . .god, she knew he wasn’t waiting for her. He didn’t even want her to begin with.
She swallowed thickly, the last thought making her whole body cringe, her insides turning.
“I needed space,” she replied, “You rejected me and I just – needed to be away from you. Then too much time had passed and you had stopped reaching out so I. . .y’know.”
“You needed space, so you left the country?” Harry’s face warped into one of distress, “You could have just told me –”
“No, dummy, I was already wanting to study abroad,” she shook her head, and she had nothing to lose, really – she could be honest. Physically, maybe Y/N hadn’t changed a lot, but emotionally she had stepped her game up. She decided not to hold her feelings back much anymore; to be clear and honest when she’s expressing herself, because how else are people supposed to know how she feels? If she isn’t clear with them, then she ends up in situations like she had three years before. Sad and alone, shutting him out because that was easier. “It was just easier to leave after all of that.”
Harry is chewing through his bottom lip, a habit he hasn’t kicked. It’s almost funny, how Harry hadn’t changed in this aspect at least – how he lets things simmer and burn until it explodes. How he needs to talk about it right then but doesn’t think about what he’s going to say before he says it. Has all these plans to give someone a piece of his mind, but it all falters on his tongue, withers in his throat, and he’s helpless to the awkward gaps of silence as he searches for what to say, and how to say it.
His face is flushed from the alcohol, and his lips are swollen from his teeth. There’s a yearning in her chest but she smothers it.
“I missed you,” he finally settled on – she could tell it wasn’t what he wanted to say, but she guessed it would do for now, “I know things ended. . .ended so weird but I – you were my best friend. I missed you so much.”
Guilt does ring through her chest, at that. Gnawing around the edges of her heart, burning through it, searing through old scars and reopening them. She feels weird. . .weird and unsettled, and sad. If she didn’t check herself, then her eyes would bead up with big, watery tears. Harry had said it so many times, the night they decided to stop sleeping together. That she was his best friend this, best friend that – how he didn’t want to ruin it with a relationship. How he wanted to stay close friends, to which Y/N had replied that close friends don’t fuck (“Then maybe we shouldn’t sleep together,” is how he countered).
She chose to believe Harry wasn’t being vindictive back then – he might have really thought this was what had been best for the two of them. He couldn’t have known how big her heart had grown for him.
“Will you come with me?” Harry asked, stepping closer, taking her by the hand and squeezing it tightly, “Come home with me, I – I just want to catch up, yeah? I want to hear about your trip, and I want to eat takeout and be. . .be with you for a while. I missed you so much, I’m like. . .I don’t know if I’m convinced you’re real and not some elaborate hallucination.”
Should she say no? Probably.
Would she though?
“Y-yeah, we can,” she nodded, “We need to tell the others though.”