Part 3 of: Harry and Y/N are exes (kind of) (Patreon)
Content
HIIII :D SOMEONE asked for these two so I wrote them!! Some angst for a dreary, rainy day! At least it's rainy where I'm at, so it seemed to fit the setting.
YOU HAVE TWO MORE DAYS TO VOTE FOR KINKTOBER!! A lot of the choices are like neck and neck!! and then some of them it is INCREDIBLY CLEAR which one is going to win!! I'm excited!!!!
ALRIGHTTT LOVE YOU!!! STAY NICE AND TOASTY WHILE IT IS COLD!!
(3k+ words)
___________________________________________
iii.
If there were a demon that fed itself from the distress and turmoil of plaguing your thoughts, Y/N thinks Harry would be one.
Because that’s what he does – that’s what he’s always done. She’s certain that he materializes from the shadows in her walls, sits beside her bed, injects every dream with a heaping dose of him, and settles down for his meal. That would explain why he looked so well-kept lately, his hair fluffy and thick, his skin bright and smooth, his cheeks with an ample amount of plush to them, no longer as gaunt as they’d looked in some of the photos she’d seen the last three years.
That’s not all of it either. In the month that she’d reintroduced him to her life, he seemed to gain muscle too – or maybe he’d had the muscle but she finally started noticing it. There’s something about being able to tell how fit someone is through a regular t-shirt that has always made her dizzy when the swell of their pecs practically sucked the fabric against their chest. The Harry she left behind had always been the long, lean, sinewy muscle if he had any at all. This Harry could probably pick her up and throw her around easily if he wanted to – she saw his biceps flex the other day when he was picking up a box for her and. . .well, she never told herself she couldn’t look.
She sees Harry once every other week – they schedule a dinner or something small together. Really, Y/N could see him all of the time if she wanted to since their schedules weren’t all that different and they got off around the same time – but she doesn’t. Y/N had promised herself she wouldn’t be as accessible as she had been to him before and she thinks she was doing pretty good at that. Had this been three years ago, not only would she be seeing him multiple weeks, but she would’ve been fucking him too. And while Y/N wasn’t always in the mood for sex, she typically was in the mood to give a blowie at least 6 out of the 7 days of the week. She would’ve been letting him occupy her time, her mouth, and any other hole he wanted before. Would’ve let him split her open with his fingers, peering down at her, calling her pussy slutty like he used to then letting the head catch between her slit, nudging at her hole. . .
But she doesn’t – she isn’t. Y/N just thinks about it, a lot, but she isn’t stupid enough to speed head-first into that sort of dynamic again.
They focus on rekindling and nurturing their friendship instead.
The first time they saw each other was the weirdest, she thinks. Harry had been the one to reach out first, asking if she was free to try a restaurant with him. She found out later in the night that Harry had actually already tried the restaurant but there were so many things on the menu that he knew she would like, that he needed her to come with him to either confirm or deny it (he’d been right, it was hard to decide between all of them). Y/N doesn't get all fancy how she used to – it’s after work, so she just meets him in what she wore that day. Back then, Harry would have been picking her up and driving her, but she denied the offer.
At first, it was kind of awkward. Harry asked about her day and she inquired about his. The waiter came and took their order, then a thick, heavy silence blanketed them like a sheet of snow. Y/N was playing with her fingers beneath the table, wondering if maybe they were too far gone to come back from it, but Harry huffed out a quiet breath, “Sorry,” he began, with a shake of his head, “But I’m not g’na pretend like I don’t know that your boss dumping all the extra files on you doesn’t piss you off. You’re always getting shit on for being a good worker.”
Y/N’s brows furrowed, “Yeah,” she grumbled, “It was so fucking annoying too because –”
After that it was easy, they fell right back into it. Harry knew exactly what questions to ask her to keep the conversation flowing, and there were no more uncomfortable blankets of silence again. Harry told her about work, about this sweater that he wanted to buy, about a new body wash scent that he tried. Y/N replied that she didn’t know he was some business bigshot, she told him to buy the sweater because it was cute, she asked him about the body wash and knew for a fact they would both love the sweet, warm scent of it. Y/N told him about this ceramics class she wanted to try, this gorgeous lamp that had been sitting in her cart for months, and a little more about her dick of a boss. Harry reminded her she was horrible at the spinning wheel, that she needed the lamp despite having ten other different forms of light in her flat, and offered to key her boss's car.
It was easy because it's always been that easy. From the moment they met, it had always been that easy. And it was much easier to ignore what happened between them when they were together. She’d felt comforted by the fact that Harry wasn’t pushing a physical relationship with her and that he wasn’t flirting how he used to. When he said he would start slow with her, he meant it. When Y/N said she was going to make him grovel a bit, she meant that too.
He paid for the meal – he always paid for the meal, and Y/N let him.
Only when normally she would be following Harry back to his flat, taking space on his sofa, spending hours more talking about nothing, and then fucking until she was cock dumb and drooling – they end the night there. Harry drives her home and idles his car in the front, “This was fun,” he told her as she gathered her purse, “I’ll send you the links to all the shite we talked about buying.”
“Thank you,” she would usually lean over, kiss his cheek – off habit she almost does it, but she stilled, thankfully catching herself before it looked too obvious what had happened, “Don’t forget to either! Send them like as soon as you get home.”
And that was that. A small piece of that Harry-shaped crater had been patched; the longing that she’d felt for a friendship that they’d destroyed tickled, just barely. She would be happy to replace all the sad memories with good ones like this. Where it’s just them again, having fun together, talking about stupid shit, and thinking they might be the funniest people in the room.
Y/N wouldn’t lie and say her body doesn’t remember every single thing about him, but she’d become an expert on pretending everything was okay in their time apart from each other. She could pretend, at least to his face, that she didn’t remember all the things he could do to her. How he could undo her stitch by stitch, open her up, expose her unguarded, innermost wants, and desires, before patching them back up and cradling her the rest of the night. Murmuring how good she was, how well she did for him, how she was beautiful, perfect for him, amazing – all those nice, mushy gushy words that made her mind dull into a pleasant buzz and hum.
Harry had been the only person who could knock her into that special space; that sweet spot where she felt like levitating, floating along soft, tufted clouds and existing merely to experience pleasure and dole it out in return. And he’d been the only person she’d trusted to see her that way – that vulnerable and softhearted. He never made her feel weird about it – never even brought it up unless he thought she might need to get there when she was stressed, when UNI seemed too hard when being anything but a greedy hole was too much.
Did she miss it? Sure, but she didn’t let that sway her. She wouldn’t let herself get there again. Wouldn’t allow it, because that’s what got them into this in the first place, and she’d grown since then. Learned that you can’t shit where you eat – that some things are best left in friendships and nothing more, nothing less.
When she’s sober that’s an easy rule to abide by.
When she’s two or three overpriced, fruity cocktails in? Well. . .
Y/N had forgone her carefully curated schedule of seeing him and they had a “friendship date” for two consecutive weeks, once on a Monday, and then the next on a Friday. The Monday date was something small – coffee during a lunch break when Harry could peel away from the office for more than 10 minutes. He gets there first and orders for both of them. He knew by now that her coffee order changed, but she still got a strawberry scone that would undoubtedly be dusting the front of her shirt by the end of the snack. And when it was, he snorted, reaching across the table with a napkin, “Messy thing,” he all but cooed, and Y/N felt her face warm. It was a tone he’d used a lot when they slept together, something he would say a lot when they slept together because Y/N could never give a blowie that wasn’t drooly and all over her chin.
If he’d noticed it, then he doesn’t make any indication that he had. Y/N’s heart stuttered over a beat, but she forced herself to act normal about it. If she thinks about it the rest of the day, and on her way home, and when she’s in the shower, and after that when she’s in bed. . . that’s her business.
The Friday that they see each other, they go out for drinks. Not alone – they’re with friends, sure, but like old times, the group thins out – some go to the dance floor, some go home with potential conquests, some just go home to sleep off what they know is going to be a killer hangover – and Y/N and Harry are the only two left. They’re both decently drunk, and it’s only for that reason that Y/N invited him over to her flat. He hadn’t been to her new flat, and at first, she was determined to keep it that way. To leave this space unmarred by memories of him, how her old one had been covered in them.
But she lived close to the bar they were at, and she wanted to show him the dishware set she’d just bought, and Harry agreed happily. They bump into each other the whole way, bouncing off one another, giggling, and complaining about the oncoming work week even though they still had two days before it. They get to her flat, and she gives him a very brief tour so he can at least find the loo when he needs to piss and afterward, he has the biggest, dopiest smile on his face.
“What?” She inquired, reaching out and digging her index finger into his cheek, “What’s that dumb smile for?”
“Smells like you in here,” he sighed, almost dreamily, “S’good. I missed it.”
Y/N’s body flushed warm and she waved him off, called him stupid, and fled to the kitchen for water and preemptive paracetamol. He doesn’t say stupid shit like that often, but when he does it settled deep in her bones, yanked at something she tried her best to keep smothered in her heart. She wondered if she should kick him out before he could say anything else dumb, but she didn’t. She merely bears the way it made her feel cut open and decided to deal with it later, when he would most likely pass out on her sofa.
Everything was normal at first. Maybe too normal. . .too close to their old normal. They were practically sitting on top of each other, watching a movie that neither of them was paying attention to in favor of showing each other videos on the other’s phone. It was an overstimulating nightmare for a sober Y/N, but a drunk one thrived off too many stimuli.
It’s when Harry is adamantly speaking about the proper way to chiffonade spinach that Y/N realizes how close they are. She was close enough to see the sparse eyebrow hairs Harry hadn’t had the chance to pluck yet, the dusting of a drunk flush high on his cheeks, the flecks of light that glitter off her fairy lights and onto his eyes. She’s close enough to fixate on his mouth, how it was stained a pink punch color from the drinks, how they were wet from his tongue running over them, how they still looked as soft as they used to feel.
Eventually, Harry realizes how close they are too. The impassioned cutting technique conversation slows to a stop, his gaze darting across her face – she can see the way his eyes were glossy and swimming but now they’re focused, stuck on her. His brows crinkled in confusion and she just. . .thinks he’s cute. She always has – her cute best friend, who she wanted to throat over and over again. Eat him up, curl him in a tiny ball, and chew on him. Everyone felt that for their friends at some point or another right? Cuteness aggression that somehow spun sexual and somehow was sinking its teeth into her.
It’s probably her that leans forward first, she could admit that. His lips are as soft as they used to feel, maybe even softer, and after a questioning hum in his throat, he responds in kind. Y/N remembered all of the things that he used to like – suckling his bottom lip into her mouth, nibbling on it until it was sore and red, threading her fingers in the hair at his nape, and pulling close to the root. He moaned a reedy sound into her mouth, parting his lips for her, letting her control the kiss, the speed of it, how she flicked her tongue into his mouth and licked the inside of him. Behind his teeth, the roof, against his tongue, underneath it. She wanted to memorize it again, taste him, even if it was stupid – even if she would hate herself for it in the morning.
Y/N pushes forward, coaxing Harry back. Even with three years in between, it feels like second nature to throw her leg over his lap, seating herself on his thighs. They were thicker now than even then, strong, she could feel the muscle move beneath them to adjust to her weight. She still has a hand at his nape, and he meets her hips, squeezing her hard, his fingernails pinching into her flesh. Y/N wants to melt into him, wants it to be like before, and wants to stop thinking and just feel him for a little while. It’d been so long since anyone had fucked her right and she never wanted to admit it, but he could, she knew it. And she was different now, right? Her feelings for him weren’t like they were before – she had plenty of casual sex when she was abroad, she could do it without getting clingy, or needy, or thinking they were in a relationship. She could show him, how well she learned.
It’s only when Y/N scoots down, grinding against the stiffening bulge in his trousers, that Harry pulls away.
“Baby,” the pet name makes her heart twist, “Baby, we have to – we have to stop.”
She whined in her throat, “What?” Their mouths are still so close together that their lips graze, “Why? Why not?”
“We’re drunk,” his face is drawn tight like he’s in pain – Y/N wondered if it was because he didn’t want to stop or because he didn’t want to do it, to begin with. Maybe he’d just been pitying her when he kissed back. Maybe she was just making a fool of herself all over again, “I – hey, stop, I know that face. That face you’re making,” she’d tipped her head down but he slid his hands from her hips to her cheeks, making her turn back to him, “I want to. God, baby, I want to so badly it hurts to stop but we’re drunk,” he takes a slow, deep breath, shaking his head, “And I don’t want to. . .I don’t want to fuck us up again, yeah? Want to do this right. Want to get back into your life properly.”
Embarrassingly enough, her eyes bead with tears because he was right and he was a good enough person to stop them even when it felt good. She feels stupid, the rejection squeezes hard in her brain, as she scrambles out of his lap, “I’m sorry,” she frowned, “I’m sorry, I don’t know why I – why I did that.” Wasn’t she the one preaching about how they needed to take it slow? How they couldn’t just jump into being besties again? And here she was kissing him, grinding against him, ready to throw that line of thought out of the window. It was stupid, pathetic – she was annoyed with herself and annoyed that she couldn’t be annoyed at him.
“Because it feels right,” he turned to face her, resting his hand on the cushion beside her, interlacing their pinkies, “Because we’re drunk and it’s. . .it’s easier, like this, but we. . .we can’t. I want to, but we shouldn’t.”
She swallowed thickly, “If we were sober, would you have stopped me?” She can’t stop herself from asking.
Harry nodded, his gaze soft on her.
“I want to do this right,” he repeated.