Part 4 of: Harry and Y/N are exes (kind of) (Patreon)
Content
HIIIIII :D DID YOU MISS THESE GUYS?????
I know you did so here they are!! Let me know who you've been missing since kinktober started and I'll write them next!!
JUST SO YOU KNOW I love you guys and I'll always be here for you. The election was rough, but all we can do is try our best to be our best and support each other in the way we need. We'll get through this!
(2.2k+ words)
_______________________________________________________
iv.
Y/N is humiliated.
Shame creeps up from her gut every time she replays the night in her head. Thick and sticky along the sides of her throat, making it difficult to swallow, and hard to ignore. The moment is burned behind her eyelids every time she closes them, settles against the movie theater of memories in her brain for a triple feature of the same showing, is what plays on the white spots of her walls when she stares off for too long and zones out. For the first time since she’d admitted that she had feelings for Harry after getting jealous at a party, only to be rejected – she wants to find a boulder, dig a hole beneath it, and put herself there.
The problem is that Y/N couldn’t be upset with him. There was nobody to blame but herself and a couple of fruity cocktails that seemed to erase all sense of resolve in a matter of a second. She was the one who took it too far – she was the one who leaned forward and kissed him, crawled into his lap, tried to rock against him. . .it was her fault. She was the one at fault and she was so annoyed with herself she could scream into a pillow for hours until her throat was sore and raw.
Another problem was that she didn’t know if she was more upset and embarrassed that she’d gone back on her own word of taking things slow, or if she was more distraught that he rejected her again. And she doesn’t blame him! Not at all – Y/N would have hated herself even more if things had gone further than they did, but that didn’t mean it didn’t still hurt. Like dragging crystals to reopen a tender scrape, only the first layers of skin healed over it. The fact that she was upset about it alone. . .maybe she hadn’t changed as much as she thought she had when she was away.
At first, she plans on avoiding all contact with him. Y/N had always been a big fan of taking some time to lick her wounds, sort out her feelings, and then attempt to formulate a proper response to the situation. Especially when a decision she makes sends her on the self-hate train, in a cart that is moving so wildly with the doors sealed shut that it’s difficult to jump off. That’s a big reason why she’d disappeared after the night of the party – she needed to figure shit out, but it just happened that this was something too big to figure out in a couple of days, like normal. Hell, it was something she hadn’t figured out in a couple of years either.
But then she decided against it. At least, not complete and total silence – clearly that hadn’t worked well the first time for either of them, and it only left her feeling guilty in the end. The murky cloud that oozes over her head at the thought of it is enough for her to type, delete, redraft, delete, redraft again – a message that she could send to him that next morning. One that could convey she needed time to think but not to scare him into believing she was about to flee the country for a second time.
I’m embarrassed about last night and just need a couple of days to like – scold myself and figure shit out, okay? But I’m not ignoring you.
Harry responds quickly despite having drunk the prior night and having no reason to be up as early as he was.
It’s okay!! Take the time that you need.
Thank you sm for letting me know
I’m here when you’re ready. Always xx.
It made her feel a little better; lessened the heavy weight on her chest even just a little bit. This helped her look past the three years of self-doubt and misery regarding their relationship dynamic, and focus on the now. She was drunk. . .she kissed him a little bit because his lips looked soft and she missed it. He stopped it before it could go any further, and while that in itself felt humiliating, it was necessary and she was thankful. She’d spent so much time being embarrassed and feeling like she’d been acting desperate that his words afterward completely slid over her head.
I don’t want to fuck us up again, yeah? Want to do this right. Want to get back into your life properly.
It was sweet. What he wanted to do right, she wasn’t sure – maybe he meant being friends. He just wanted to have a proper relationship without the additional drama of sleeping with one another – she thinks that might have been what he was saying. And she could respect that. She wanted that – no matter what her drunk self did. Being so close unlocked some weird muscle memory that she hadn’t been able to kick, she guesses – at least that’s what she wants to say. At least, that’s what she would tell the others if she ever found the courage to tell them, but is pretty certain she’ll keep this whole debacle to herself.
Harry allows her a week without bothering her for anything and she appreciates it because she knows it must be hard for him. He’s always liked to fix problems as they occur, never one to let shit twist and rattle in his brain before settling into something gloomy in his chest. Before the whole friends-with-benefits thing, their relationship had probably been the healthiest it could have been, because no matter the situation he was keen on talking it out. If he could feel a shift in the mood after he’d done something, he was good at noticing and rectifying it. If she ever did something to upset him, he wouldn’t be passive-aggressive and he wouldn’t ignore it, he’d bring it up respectfully in a way that they could discuss it.
But he gave her a week before her phone pings with a message.
Coffee at lunch tomorrow?
Y/N agreed. That’s why she’s here now, digging her thumbnail into the pad of her index finger as she waits for him. Y/N had already ordered their drinks and a muffin that she would refuse to let him reimburse her for – it was her apology for making things weird again. For making him uncomfortable, probably. For almost ruining their friendship for a second time. The cafe has the heat blasting, something that would normally feel comforting but now it feels stuffy. She wanted to go outside and feel the icy air hitting her face, hoping it would make her feel less smothered by the weight of her actions. She feels so fucking stupid.
The bell dings as it clicks against the door, and she looks up to see Harry shuddering from the cold. He has his winter puffer on, navy and huge on him because he’s never been able to handle the cold at all. She’s surprised he doesn’t have a scarf, hat, and gloves too but she remembers that the sudden temperature drop had been predicted for late afternoon but the cold front came much earlier. Once he turned his face to see her, his cheeks rosy and his nose bright red – his hair flopped around from the wind.
And he grins so wide when he sees her.
“S’fucking freezing,” he says when he gets closer, scooting into the booth across from her, “Aish, you already ordered? Thank you, I need to hold something warm or my fingers might freeze off.”
The smile on Y/N’s face isn’t forced – it’s genuine. Even though she knew he wouldn’t treat her differently, there was still that fear that tickled the back of her head. He had every right and reason to be angry with her, for what she did and for how she did it. But he wasn’t, or at least it didn’t seem like he was. He just seemed delighted to be having coffee with her this morning, taking a sip then puckering his lips, cooing a sweet sound, “See you always remember to add the almond milk for me, it makes it sweeter.”
“Someone has to remember your body hates lactose,” she replied, “And you never remember, so. . .”
Harry pouts, big and wet, and his lips still look too fucking soft, “I do too,” he answers, “I just ignore it,” he shrugged, then reached for the knife set out on the table and sliced his muffin in half, “But speaking of things we aren’t going to ignore – we should probably talk about it.”
Her body flushes with more white-hot embarrassment – it tingles through her fingertips and toes, “Yeah,” she agreed, looking back down at her drink – the way some of it swirls around the lid from being overfilled, “I’m so sorry about that, I – I don’t even know what else to say. I’m just really sorry.”
Harry sighed, she could see him shaking his head even though she wasn’t looking at him, but she felt his disappointment more when he nudged her finger knuckle with the rounded end of the plastic knife, clicking his tongue. “What’s there to apologize for, hm?” He inquired, “I told you I didn’t mind it, didn’t I?”
“Well, you never said that –”
Harry huffed, “I think my exact words were ‘I want to so badly it hurts to stop’ – does that ring any bells?” Her face feels warm, flushed from the memory, flushed from wanting to be back in his lap so badly, even with all the shame that’s accompanied by her desperation, “I wanted to, so I didn’t mind it – not at all. But –” I don’t see you the way you want me to, it would be cruel to string you along again, there’s someone else I like and – “I screwed up the last time. Like – horrifically, in the most fuck boy, frat guy way I could have. I want you, I’ve never stopped wanting you, but you deserve more than just a drunk fuck.” He sets the knife down, and stretches his fingers over her knuckles, squeezing gently, “You deserve the world, and I owe it to you for how I treated you before. Even if it was never outwardly shitty, I should’ve been paying more attention and I should’ve been more mindful of both our feelings, not just my own. We never checked in with each other, we never defined the terms of our dynamic, and I was doing very couple-y things while swearing we weren’t together like – the thought of it all makes me so mad at myself.” He sighs again, “I don’t blame you for kissing me – I kissed you back – but we were both drunk, and I knew we’d both be upset the next morning if we let it go any further. It wasn’t for lack of want, though.”
“Do you. . .do you really mean that?” Y/N inquired tentatively, “Like, it just kind of sounds like. . .like you might be suggesting, uh –”
“Courting you?” He supplied, then shrugged, nodding a little, “Yeah, a little bit. But I don’t expect it to happen quickly, and I don’t expect you to accept it either – I’m perfectly content with being in your life in any capacity, even if it’s only every other week for dinner or a coffee. But if there were a chance to do it right – to be with you the way I’ve been dreaming of for the last 3 years, then I want to do it. But I want to work for it. Does that make sense?”
She swallowed hard – it's a bit, to understand. Y/N had left thinking Harry had seen her as nothing more than a fuck buddy who he didn’t feel bad about burping in front of or something. She’d spent three years wondering if he’d ever felt for her the way she had felt for him, convinced her that there was no way because if he had then maybe his response would have been different that night, and accepted that she’d just let her feelings get in the way.
So to hear that for the last three years, he’d wanted to be with her in the way she originally wanted him? It’s just hard to believe.
“I’m usually not this blunt, but I think – I think for us, complete transparency is beneficial. I’m sorry if it made you uncomfortable.”
“It didn’t,” she answers, her voice soft, “No, I want you to be honest with me always.”
Harry’s lips spread into a smile, “It’s settled then,” he handed her half of the muffin, “I’ll be completely honest about my intentions with you, so long as you let me integrate back into your life. Whether it goes anywhere or not, I don’t mind. I just want to be with you, because in the time you were away, I realized that it fucking sucks to be without you.” Y/N takes the muffin from his hands, “Now eat, yeah? And tell me about your day so far, I know your manager was being a huge dick the other week. Has he relaxed at all?”
Y/N’s chest softens, the inside of the muffin still warm in her hands, the chocolate still gooey in the center. This had taken an entirely more healthy communication approach than she had imagined, and she was incredibly grateful. Harry was the same in a lot of ways – the same dimples, green eyes, and brown hair that he was always dragging his fingers through. But he’d changed a lot too – matured, more than she’d imagined. He wasn’t just her best friend who liked to think with his dick more often than not.
She hoped to see more changes like this in the future.