Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

Chapter 252 rewrite?

  • Continue 39
  • Change 15
  • 2025-05-20
  • —2025-05-21
  • 54 votes
{'title': 'Chapter 252 rewrite?', 'choices': [{'text': 'Continue', 'votes': 39}, {'text': 'Change', 'votes': 15}], 'closes_at': datetime.datetime(2025, 5, 21, 21, 23, 8, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2025, 5, 20, 1, 21, 22, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 54}

Content

I got a message about how the current setup feels very forced for 251/252. I’m feeling a bit the same, though it’s partially intentional to get through the rest of the arc a bit quicker. This poll is to figure out how y’all feel about it, and if I should change anything.

1. If I should Continue. This arc will be done in the next 4-5 chapters. Nothing changes.

2. If I should Change stuff, this arc will stretch out a bit longer, but will hopefully feel a bit less forced. I’ll rewrite the end of 251 and completely retcon 252. I’ll stay up a bit later the next week to try and catch buck up to schedule.

I don’t really mind either way. It’s a hundred percent up to you guys.

Comments

Blah64

idk, felt fine to me. This felt likely for a few chapters already.

Sam Stanfield

I honestly just want this arc over with at this point

chris salinas

It's just hard to see a character with no way out facing impossible odds. I'm fine leaving it as is because we know she'll eventually escape/succeed but whether or not she survives by plot armor or if she's given the agency to save herself makes or breaks this arc for me.

Gardor

Haven't read since 249 so i say do whatever you want. Burn it all down and start fresh!

GlassStone

I really like how 251-252 felt because it showed what a presence Mother has become. It reminds me of a fly stuck struggling in a spiders web and really emphasizes the power difference. However something small that I think could really add to the story would be to more clearly showing how injured Shiro is with a sentence or two in 251 or 252. Like Shiro has racked up a concussion, broken ankle, a mutilated shoulder, damaged leg muscles, an uncountable number of scrapes/bruises, and extreme blood loss. A little sentence or two about how muddled her thoughts are and how her body is starting to not respond to her correctly could really go a long way. I really like how they read right now though so I think you should keep going. :)

Mark Robert Mitchell

Well, you could argue that she is only there because of anti plot armor. For example, why split up with the Valkyrie. I suppose it’s all in the presentation and delivery. A longer chapter would explain more about the decision making. A more vivid description of the things the plant cult did in the exclusion zone would create more tension. It’s kinda against genre to have that much description but eh I like it. (One of my favorite books in Jonathan Strange and Mr. Norrell.)

llenay

It felt quite natural to me. The only thing that felt contrived was that Shiro got discovered because she didn't switch her phone off.

lenkite

Yes, most of all - why on earth did she travel to the tree ? That part really, really needs good explanation. She can toggle her shadow perk, get the high ground and plot her route - like she has done dozens of times but *consistently* fails now. Why ? She has walked in utter darkness in the underground, but suddenly has trouble navigating the darkness here. Why ? At several points in the story - she always. keeps clear of borgs - always aware of the threat they represent and keep out of threat range. Yet, now she walks to melee range of a dangerous, untalking sword wielding borg, after identifying them as not a Crusader. Why ? Needs a very good explanation. That was completely unlike her. Apologies, but it seems [Author Plot] demanded that she go to the Tree - severely injured and weaponless and so you made her move there ignoring all her instincts, basic skills and caution. Sorry, but you might as well have made Mother open a [Rift] in front of her and just [Teleported] her there - this would have been far more believable compared to making her [Suddenly Dumb].

Gardor

Kinda feel like she should have just hid in a closet somewhere, maybe im just not understanding the scale of the frequently referenced incoming bombardment.