Image with strong 2.5D element (Patreon)

1st image is the setting i used in my Shokuhou Misaki work, 2nd is generated using a model with much stronger 2.5D element, the shading and shadows is much more detailed and pronounced making the illusion of 3D much stronger. Just want to show you guys the difference.

Both are good, the erotic power of both images is really high, but a strong 2.5D effect makes the image anime element weak, Still anime but i prefer image that closer to 2D than 2.5D

I generate images because i like anime, and erotic anime art like ero dojins, ero CGs, visual novels manga, anime all very 2D . i will always prioritise strong anime elements in all my images.

What you guys think? Should i make more work with strong 2.5D ?