Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hey everybody! I'm Jon, and I'm launching a brand-new documentary series: THE HISTORY OF CHARGING THE MOUND. It is about the history of charging the mound. This is the series premiere. Since you're a Secret Base Patreon member, you have special early access to this episode, and you'll also get to see every subsequent episode months before they land on YouTube.

As I explain in this episode, this series is a little different from those you're used to seeing from me. First, it's ongoing and has no definite end point. This subject matter is so rich with strange and funny baseball stories that I could make a hundred episodes if I really wanted to, but ultimately, I think I'll just keep making them until either I get bored or you get bored.

Second, I thought it would be fun to offer y'all a peek under the hood as I produce these episodes. I'm doing something I've never done before: I'm sharing my primary research document. Over here in this post ...

MOUND-CHARGING DATABASE

... you'll find a link to my big Google spreadsheet that lists every single mound-charging incident I've found between 1950 and 2025. It also includes some stray notes I've left as well as links to any video evidence that might be available. Browse it, scrutinize it, steal it, whatever you wanna do. It belongs to everybody.

Anyway, hope you like this series premiere! I'm currently having a great time working on Episode 2, which I'll drop here on December 1st.

Files

Comments

Dr. Katz

Probably the most Jon Bois video topic imaginable

Adam

God is real and his name is Jon Bois

Erik Helmle

Definitely what child custody day needed. Thank you!

Jay

Close enough, we got our spiritual successor to Fighting in the Age of Loneliness!

nicoam

this is incredible and I can't wait to see more.

Jay

1:58 Ladies and gentlemen, he's back!!! (iykyk)

Calvin Schutt

My Monday has been made immeasurably better

Wingcap

Coming back to this episode in a week or two when all the smart baseball people have recommended all the juicy fights Jon is looking for

MoistVonLipwig

God I needed this after Saturday night

Dr. Katz

Really want to see an episode on the great Hunter Strickland vs Bryce Harper saga and the comical fight it produced

Azn

I don't know if it's just correlation, but it's got to be steroid testing right? A least one big part of it anyways

Tater Swift

I hated my fourth grade teacher. Like *really* hated her. But I was in a 4th grade play, as an extra. For whatever reason, I remember her instructions to extras chattering with other extras in the background, say at a café or on a bus. She said that in Hollywood, they instruct extras to mouth the word "rhubarb," because apparently mouthing it silently looks like regular conversation on the big screen. "Rhubarb rhubarb rhubarb. Rhubarb rhubarb? Rhubarb, rhubarb rhubarb." Maybe she was right.

I

Good ol' Bob Hamelin

Jay

On that note: you might wanna check out the database for a really crazy and surprisingly high-grade Bob vs. Bob entry

roljamas

I cannot wait to hear more about the Paul WIlson / Kyle Farnsworth takedown. It's one of the single-greatest form tackles in sports history, and it happened with a pitcher hitting another pitcher with a fastball, then spearing him into the center of the earth. It may have been the happiest I've ever heard Chip Caray.

AsceticLynx

Is any consideration given to the importance of the moment? There are very few entries in October or even late September for obvious reasons, but those could make for an interesting episode even if the actual fights aren't particularly noteworthy For example, this Saturday's incident occurred in game 7 of a world series, which seems rare based on a quick database search. But it would score very low based on the interaction itself (maybe doesn't even qualify as a mound charge since theres not much movement towards the mound?)

Derek Monk

I was able to point and pick out Kyle Farnsworth (2003) from 1000 feet away when the chart first came up. This is going to be an excellent series!

Jay Miller

I would definitely wonder if the institution of plunking a hitter for a slight is just sort of generally on the decline. People do it less and if they do it the whole team is just sort of like oh hes not supposed to do that and clear the benches and the plunked batter doesn't have to take fate into his own hands so much

Secret Base

i think this is a good example of an incident that doesn't meet my arbitrary standards of an honest-to-god mound-charging, but is nonetheless historically significant. this was the only bench-clearing world series incident i can remember. if it erupted into an actual fight it would have been absolutely fascinating, because the game was tightly contested the whole way through -jon

James Z

I remember Phil Garner managed teams took particular fun in mound charging. In particular when facing the white sox

Casey Lin

damn i was hoping for the 2022 mariners/angels fight that ended up sending them to the playoffs to be on here but it makes sense it wouldn't be since winker didn't really run towards the mound after he got plunked...

John Pazniokas

I feel like this is the distant brainchild of the Bob Emergency work. Specifically, that it is the long-awaited descendant of the dearly-departed dropyourgloves.com.

Scarlet Android

Not technically this series, but I need Jon Bois play by play of Jose Ramirez versus Tim Anderson. And Amir Garrett’s reverse mound charging also deserves a shoutout. I can’t wait to watch

AsceticLynx

That makes sense, thanks for the response! Definitely don't wanna scope creep your project one episode in

Alex Prewitt

so does the recent game 7 count or no

Dylan Howard

I know they don't count since they aren't the major leagues, but it feels like it would be wrong to never talk about Izzy Alcantara (2001) and Jose Offerman (2014). Maybe a "best of the rest episode"?

Will Bloodworth

Ventura v. Ryan is, in my mind, the most memorable. Can't wait to see it get covered!

nmi5

Great timing with the drama in game 7, though it didn't become a full on fight.

Nolan McDermott

Mound Charging is Pretty Dead for a couple reasons but I'll list some big ones IMO. 1. Padding - Guys have elbow guards, c-flaps, shin guards, padded batting gloves and what not. Even though pitchers throw harder than ever it hurts less than ever to get hit by a pitch. 2. OBP - Guys like Mark Canha, Tim Locastro and Brandon Guyer have made a living of being hit by pitches, they don't try and get out of the way at all they just stand there and take their base. 3. Cold hard cash - Mound charging gets you suspended, that cost you money. Players these days care about the bottom line.

Nolan McDermott

Nyjer Morgan needs his own episode, him vs the fish

Hannibal Montana

As someone who worked under Ken Schrom when he was a minor league exec, I'm totally down for an episode devoted to him

Zachary Gray

Metric idea: Proximity to the Queensberry Rules, and nominate candidates for the furthest orbit from them (helmets being thrown, flying kicks, Don Zimmer)...

Stefan Preiml

Now I really wish someone would do this kind of charge for hockey fights.

David Ramer

lol glad you already implied ❄️ as a factor in mound charging, but also: leaded gasoline!

FFV

It's minor leagues i know, but the Izzy Alcántara one deserves a shoutout, dude took the catcher out and then went for the pitcher

Brolty

George Bell v Aaron Sele is a favorite of mine mostly cause Bell throws one of the hardest rights I’ve ever seen, Sele dodges it and jukes left, and then bell gets absolutely truck sticked by Mo Vaughn so hard he flips over on the ground.

MathTeacherGuy

I have rarely had such high expectations going into a thing, and also had them so thoroughly met.

Secret Base

i'm writing a future episode about this one right now! it isn't entirely about this incident but it is a key moment -jon

Andrew Humphrey

Leaded gas is probably the biggest culprit here :-)

Alexander Bateman

I'm surprised nobody is mentioning the lower number, lower enforcement, and lower punishment of unwritten rules. Nobody is throwing at guys for pimping home runs anymore. You are not actually able to do takeout slides anymore. This does not mean unwritten rules are dead. I think if you try and bunt your way on to break up a perfecto, I'd be mad if you weren't thrown at. I'm still wondering why Scherzer didn't throw directly at the next Pirates player after Tabata's stunt to break up his perfect game to say "You want a hit by pitch, jackass?" I think punishments by pitchers to enforce the norms of baseball will still happen. There just are not that many norms left to break within the rules of the game, and there's not much willingness by anyone to try and break them.

Alex Schlesinger

April 30th 1994: on a family trip to Montreal my parents take me to my first major league baseball game, Expos vs. Padres. Three things stick in my mind from that game: - Dropping my glove on the field during the pre-game and having a field-side reporter hand it back to me ("never washing this glove! it was on a real (well Astroturf) field!") - Youppi! (I'm still sore he is now the Canadiens mascot) - Derek Bell charging Pedro Martinez. On the last point, 7 year old me was now both hooked on baseball and hooked on the Montreal Expos. In retrospect it was an even weirder fight than it would outwardly seem. Bell charges Pedro not because he himself was hit, but because Pedro first plunked Kevin Lockhart, then threw up and in at Bell (shock from Pedro) and then only after Pedro made him fan on a high fast ball did Bell wait, thinking about it, and charge. This wasn't a spur of the moment thing, Bell took a few moments to consider throwing hands, and then got to business. Also the weird-ass Bip Roberts thing and Mark Davis wandering over to tell Pedro off. Given Pedro's propensity to find himself in such situations, I have to say I have some confidence that one day this will be packaged in for discussion.

Kevin Mulcahy

Tell the story of the only 2020s mound rush

FizerTsakalidas

I need to know what, if anything, let to Pedro dumping Don Zimmer. I was a young Yankees fan when that happened, and it solidified my hatred of the Red Sox.

River

I hope the Red Sox/Yankees fights in the 04 ALCS aren’t too overdone for you to cover! There’s certainly plenty of things to discuss about them

Kiaayo

This is the second most excited I am for a Bois project.

M. C. T.

If only Andres Giménez had the courage to charge the mound, the Jays would've won Game 7. Or not. I dunno.

Ryan Petriello

I might be way off-base (pun not intended), but I feel like men being outwardly angry over minor infractions is less socially acceptable nowadays (which imo is a good thing), and that has probably spilled over into how players conduct themselves. Also players not being coked or roided up probably helps keep tempers down

Mike HBC

I am going to eat up each and every episode. It matters not whether I care about the players or teams; in almost every instance, I will not. I simply can't wait to see some good fights with some good backstories.

sandiegospirit

I think the fighting is from lead paint

Connor Kennard

There would have been something very poetic about Gimenez turning into Tie Domi for a night. Though given the kerfuffle I would call it on the edge of a 0z-2y.

vajdaij

“Who won this fight? Fans like you and me”

Ethan Fisher

I've long considered myself a baseball brawl aficionado so I'm unreasonably excited for this. Any consideration for including (or maybe doing a separate episode on) spring training fights? Mike Piazza/Guillermo Mota was a legitimately good brawl in 2003 (with some history), Hal Morris separated his shoulder after charging Jose Mesa in 1993, Ryan Klesko and Troy Glaus charged the mound in the same game in 2002. In any event I can't wait to see where this series goes

Justin Bacchi

that and varitek/a-rod from earlier that season. was surprised to not see that on the list

Brennan

Bought my first ever Patreon subscription just for this. Incredibly excited. One thing I'd change on the spreadsheet is to replace the video link for the Shane Victorino vs. Ramon Ramirez fight from 2011 with this one: https://youtu.be/CR--8wsV3PY?si=ymiNYhwCTdfU-w41 since it has a much higher fps and the actual call instead of music.

YinnYang

The database section is cool, i like seeing the unfiltered notes on notable things about specific instances + potential fluff. If we have specific info regarding a mound charge what would be the best avenue to send it?

Sid Hirshberg

Lots of people in the comments here have put forward some good and rational reasons for mound charging's decline, but my less rational instinct is to link it to the general corporitization and death of whimsy in our culture. So much has been smoothed over and cleaned up. People are still people, so goofy things still find ways to happen in sports, and there's plenty of ways for fun weird stuff to happen that don't involve punching somebody. But idk, maybe there's something to it.

spoocecow

As others have said, sure, it wasn't the majors, but I truly do think Izzy Alcántara's mound charge is too innovative not to discuss. And also, hey, uhh... I just checked his wikipedia and UHHhhh > He played for Uni-President Lions of Taiwan's Chinese Professional Baseball League in 2005, where he was nicknamed "Al-Qaeda".

spoocecow

My pet theory about the world at large is that the shift away from leaded gasoline has allowed the most evil maniacs among us to cultivate their villainous actions more constructively, so the sort of people that would be serial killers in the 60s are now part of The Heritage Foundation

Paul Steiner

Do you think it's just the declining culture of "unwritten rules"? People would get pegged for violating some weird rule like looking at a home run for too long, being too annoying on the basepaths, doing a takeout slide, what have you. That's going away, and so are mound charges.

Chris Beach

I wouldn't be surprised if it gets filtered out of this project. But Canada vs Mexico in the 2013 World Baseball Classic is always worth a watch or rewatch.

Lucas Moore

There was an NES baseball game that I played at my cousin's house in the early-to-mid 90's. There was a certain player, on the Phillies I think, that would charge the mound 100% of the time if you hit him. We did, every time, obviously. I have no idea who this man is, or what got him enough of a reputation to deserve that treatment in a video game, but there's gotta be a good story in there.

LDL

I don't WANT to say therapy helped decrease mound charging, but it's not a wild idea either. There's been a massive increase in sports psychologists and mental health professionals in sports over the last decade or two, like an article from 2018 in USA Today mentioned 27 teams had mental skills professionals, with an MLB.com article from 2021 mentioned ALL teams had someone trained to counsel, or refer counselling, to people in a team. While there's a lot of focus on things like dealing with pressure, visibility and keeping sharp, I don't think it's wrong to say it's also helped with settling on-field feuds. Therapy could've helped several batters think twice & ground themselves before acting on instincts after being HBP'ed. Therapy could've stopped several pitchers losing their cool and blasting a fastball at other players after woeful displays on the mound. Therapy could've made players realize that fighting wasn't the resolution they needed to settle a feud. TL;DR - Therapy works, y'all.

Griffin Cain

this is giving Lenny Dykstra vibes

Ben

I wonder how many of those 19 different fights registering a 5 on the Bois scale could be named by die-hard baseball fans out there? Just show them that chart of those 19 fights and see how many of the combatants could be named. Could be a fun quiz.

Swaggy

Why have mound chargings declined? For the same reasons fights are down in the other sports, even the ones where it’s semi-sanctioned like hockey. - everyone is simply too good to risk their careers. Someone got concussed in the Strickland vs. Harper fight and his career ended. Players are too good and the margins are too tight to risk a roster spot on a hothead. - the penalties are more severe. Thanks to the Malice in the Palace for this. If a Padres vs. Braves event happened in 2025 instead of 1984, there would be a strong chance for a literal fatality or at the very least a crushing police response. - Players at this level have known each other for longer. They’re all super competitive, mind, but they’re also not about to tee off on someone they’ve known since they were 13. - finally, it’s a lot more acceptable to show off than it used to be. Bat flips, yelling off the mound, these are the things that would get you in trouble in your own locker room in the old days, because they knew someone was gonna get hurt. With all of that more acceptable, it’s less acceptable to try to be “intimidating” for the sake of it. Notice, everyone celebrates Nolan Ryan but laughs at Hunter Strickland.

Romano Jr. Tio

Odor vs Bautista honorable mention for being much like a mound charging except with no pitchers? Are there other base-runner fights?

Jake Looney

Mounds charges have gone extinct due to the decline of tree nut allergies in the MLB. As more players are not at risk of anaphylaxis, they are able to safely go for the far tastier Almond Joy charge instead

Josh

I watched the 84 atlanta san diego fight and spotted bob gibson in among the fracas. Nice to see a familiar face in this new series

theMasochistGamer

There definitely are - one SB Weird Rules episode mentions one back in 1950 that was so serious the NYPD was called to break it up (it's the one with Jon as the guest, funny enough).

Justin Terada

You are truly doing God's work Jon. A super weird God, but a God nonetheless. Are you excluding cases where the batter and the catcher get into it, because I can think of two notable instances of that: 1. Juan Marichal vs John Roseboro, August 22, 1965. It's got its own Wikipedia page: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Candlestick. Marichal (hitting) hit Roseboro with his bat. It also delayed Marichal's induction to the hall of fame. 2. Alex Rodriguez vs. Jason Varitek, July 24, 2004. Can we really exclude this iconic photo? https://www.masslive.com/resizer/v2/JYODH3X5QBEBTLUHLEFPWOAI6M.jpg?auth=c0279cf6efaae3f25a0f05eec84159c729d0f9b0ee65858db2fdf7eec2e61c22&width=1280&smart=true&quality=90 And did you consider the Clemens/Piazza broken bat toss in Game 2 of the 2000 World Series? It definitely scores super low on your metrics but was memorable. No matter what though, I will keep my Patreon subscription active as long as this project stays active.

Durgen251

Mound charges died, to me, for one reason; the almighty dollar, baby. It's the same reason that Ray Lewis-esque hits in the NFL died, hockey fights died, and hard fouls and hand checking in the NBA died. As sports grew as a business, those sports needed to cultivate more family friendly, less barbaric images. Their star players also took on celebrity, which has just become more pronounced with social media. So you heavily penalize anything rough and tumble to appeal to advertisers, while in turn having the dual effect of protecting the star players' physical health more, which in turn gives them longer careers where they can continually increase revenue and do the one thing fans love most; create shareholder value. Joke aside, I do think that's it. The leagues can all say it's for player safety, but if fights brought in more money they'd give relievers brass knuckles *tomorrow* and tell them to aim for the new Strauss logo. Violence just stopped being cool to advertisers, which meant it stopped being cool for leagues to do, and they changed the rules to phase it out until the new generation of players across sports didn't think it was cool either.

Missing Texture

IMO it's not a certified mound charge, and I think it's unfortunate. Winker doesn't get to confront the pitcher directly, as he is immediately boxed out by 2 umps and the catcher, so instead has to pivot towards charging Phil Nevin and the entirety of the Angels dugout on his own. It absolutely should get its moment in the sun and I hope Jon gets to talk about, even if it ends up getting sent to the Disqualified Pile.

Missing Texture

In addition to everything else already said, I think there are 3 things worth exploring to see how they account for the reduced number of mound charges. First, maybe the weakest one, but there could be some history to the changes of how umpire crews have handled games that affect where and when they give warnings and ejections (and say, how long has umpires issuing warnings the benches been a thing anyway?), which in turn can change how willing pitchers could be about throwing intentionally at a batter. I understand that some of the rules surrounding ejecting pitchers have changed recently, such as the umpire crew required to convene together to check if they are in agreement to give an ejection to the pitcher rather than the home plate ump giving an immediate hook, so I just wonder if turning the dials on how warnings and ejections are issued trickles back to less cause for pitchers to take actions that end up getting them ejected / incite a batter to charge the mound. Second, I have to imagine that a player understands that doing things that give them the reputation of a hothead and accruing ejections and suspensions will mean getting less money in arbitration and free agency. As fights and charged mounds decline, players that do end up charging the mound or throwing at batters are isolated and considered to be even bigger hotheads now that no one else is doing it. Third, I think as players get a bit more acquainted with the whole sabermetrics thing, they also HAVE to understand how much of a detriment it is for the team to get ejected, and how much WORSE it is to get suspended. The reward/risk of it all must be better understood by now, and I bet managers give more "please don't do a fight" talks to their teams now than they did in the 70s and 80s in a greater effort to just plain win more games.

Kevin Wilson

Was the Mike Piazza/Roger Clemens incident not bench-clearing? That took place during the World Series. I know it's very unique in that it wasn't started by a HBP, and Piazza wasn't at the plate when it happened, and he didn't technically charge the mound. Maybe it doesn't earn enough points, because to my recollection, no punches were thrown, but it still seems weird to me that it wasn't even in the Disqualified section.

dk382

I think society was more violent in general in the 80s and 90s. There's the obvious leaded gasoline theory, but I think there was something more violent ingrained in our culture. It was considered more acceptable to rough someone up for saying or doing something you don't like. Maybe Reagan-era individualism played a role in this thinking. We also got better since then at teaching our children to not react to every slight with aggression. And baseball players are obviously still a product of the cultures they come from, so seeing that surge of mound charges in the 80s and 90s followed by a decline in the 00s and near elimination in the 2020s just makes sense to me. Those trends reflect the broader shifts that have occurred in our culture, I think.

Chris Beach

In 1988 I was the age my son is now, and when I look at the shows I was watching then vs what he watches now it's night and day. And it doesn't feel at all like it's, "oh think of the children!" sanitized, it feels more like we've just all moved on.

J. Buck

Money is the reason we don't see mound charging anymore. When every player is a millionaire playing a kids game, they just can't get angry. Life is too good.

Andy Jones

Two folks have mentioned lead-crime already, but I got Claude to plot it up here https://imgur.com/a/VGclM1W Seems like chargings peaked ~10 years earlier than violent crime as a whole. Nothing's conclusive with series this autocorrelated, but that it doesn't line up tilts me against lead as the explanation. Baseball players skewing younger explains some of it but not enough.

Matt

One of my fav Bob stories (as a Brewers fan): Some sportswriter once did a survey on players' least favorite road cities and Bob said Milwaukee because everything these made him think of Jeffrey Dahmer. Like two months later, he got released and had to sign with the Brewers.

Alexander Bateman

I listened to the 1957 White Sox and Yankees brawl, and based on the comments + the radio call it might warrant bumping up to a 5. One of the YouTube comments mentioned seeing it broadcast on TV on WGN Channel 9. I wonder if they, or any others, have video archives that you could view or purchase if you contact them? Would love to see this brawl on tape.

James Speed

Jon I am begging you, if you mention the Amir Garrett charge I NEED you to use the Sam Greene photo of him ready to fight the entire pirates team all at once, it’s the greatest sports photo of all time

Tim L.

oh my lord, kyle 'professor' farnsworth...now there is a name that i haven't thought of in over a decade

Jack Schillawski

Scrolled WAY too far to see this. It was my immediate thought when I saw that he was making this database

Fox Doucette

You've got a fracas, a rhubarb, a donnybrook, but 4 on the Y axis should be properly called a "brouhaha".

Milton Posner

Would highly recommend the Great Nyjer Morgan Charging of 2010. Everything about it is great — the way Morgan flips the bat into another time zone, the way the Marlins' first baseman clotheslines him into next season, the way he's immediately buried in bodies and left to ponder that maybe this wasn't such a great idea. And yet ... somehow it's not the dumbest thing Morgan did on an MLB field that year.

Alex Albrecht

What a hit, reminded me of the Willie Wilson fly-out mound charge! Even at the end I thought they were gonna get into it again, I've never seen an MLB player so heated that they needed to be pulled down from climbing over their own dugout

Matt

Fix my name in the scroll, yo. Mattt

Sam Aronow

I saw two fights break out in a single Canadiens game in January.

Sam Aronow

Lead doesn't make people serial killers. Sociopathy is evergreen and most people are bad at navigating the world as one, so a handful of high-functioning sociopaths have always existed in positions of power.

Durgen251

And Bryce Harper charged Hunter Strickland. Just because it happens doesn't make it the norm anymore. Enforcers as a role are almost extinct in hockey.

Daniel Brandes

It happened in the Nippon Baseball League and not MLB. But! Former MLB player Rod Allen charging Kazuhiko Daimon in a game between the Hiroshima Toyo Carp and Yokohama Taiyo Whales (1991) is one of my all time favourites. Rod charged and he pitcher turned and ran with Rod chasing him around the stadium for like 25 full seconds. I’ve never looked into it, but the way the pitcher just turns and runs for his life makes it seem like no one had ever charged the mound in the history of Japanese baseball.

GordyHowitzer

I think the decline in mound chargings over the past decade plus probably has something to do with the increased financialization of sports and culture at large. Increasingly, we want our players to be brands in and of themselves, and we want our brands to appeal to the widest possible base of consumers to increase profitability - the same thing that has happened to the rest of media, from video games to television to music, a sanding down of all of the rough edges that could interrupt consumption. Personally, however, I'm a huge fan of rough edges. Looking forward to the series.

J. Buck

Jon, you got me again. I can't wait for each and every episode to release.

Chris Creguer

Rod Allen also (allegedly) put his broadcast partner in a chokehold, leading to both being fired.

Orthos_Logos

Take a look at Peter Berger, "On the Obsolescence of the Concept of Honor," European Journal of Sociology 11.2 (1970): 339-347. And Tocqueville, Democracy in America, Vol. II, Pt. 3, ch. 18, "Of Honor in the United States and in Democratic Communities."

Lancelot Link

Many have mentioned the leaded gasoline theory which does make sense to me but I think there's multiple factors at play that have caused the art of the mound charge to die out. One thing that I think is worth considering is that as sabermetrics have gained more and more acceptance and a walk (or in this case a HBP) is considered just as good as a hit are pitchers less willing to hit players in retaliation? Are players that have been hit less willing to charge the mound because in some respects the pitcher has done them a favor by raising the OBP? The other thing that came to mind is that the "unwritten rules" that loomed large over past MLB generations are now seen as hopelessly out of touch. The MLB even ran a series of ads a few years ago mocking the unwritten rules. Are players self conscious that if they charge they mound they might seem like they're still abiding by the archaic rules? I also think you might like to know if and when you get around to covering the Hunter Strickland v Bryce Harper incident that Hunter Strickland is used as an example in Merriam-Webster's definition of "dingus". https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/dingus

Matt Beaty

Bob Sebra v. Tracy Jones 1990 needs an episode. Two bad and angry teams with a lot of legends (Randy Johnson appearance!). A Bob versus the Mariners. Just a ludicrous, never-ending fight that bounces all over the field. Who knows what exactly led to the fight, but I’d bet it’s a good story.

Heiko

When I play MLB 06 The Show (I still play it, and have never played a more modern baseball game), I set the difficulty to the lowest setting (and tweak the sliders in my favor too) so that I can essentially never lose. Something about sports video games, I just never learned to stomach losing. In any case, it’s still baseball. Sometimes they hit a home run off me. Unfailingly, every time that happens, I bean the shit out of the next batter. How dare they?? So I get it, Mr Smiley.

JudoJoker

I have a 3 contributions: 1) https://youtu.be/TPqobZxTT6A?si=VtX9TT_-pQZOFvL2 I'm sure Pedro Martinez will be featured at some point, I feel like this Celebrity Family Feud clip must be included for context. It may be the honestly best answer moment in the history of Family Feud. 2) I hope the Bryce Harper v Hunter Strickland fight is featured, as I'm a Nats fan and it's hilarious how premeditated this fight was. 3) The Amir Garrett fight must be included, because it's hilarious how premeditated this fight was

KCSunshine

I have some excellent photos of both Don Drysdale/Johnny Logan and Larry Doby/Art Ditmar brawls from June 13, 1957! I posted them on bsky, where the quality is terrible, but I can also upload higher quality versions. These pics are incredible in person. https://bsky.app/profile/cwexler.bsky.social (edited for date accuracy)

Mylo Grams

Initially I thought, maybe its because as a society we've become less hot headed and reactionary. or at least ya know, maybe its not as appealing to the average viewer. But no! Look at streamers, theres popular videos of top crashouts, hell poofesure has a whole YouTube channel dedicated to crashing out and, while its not taking his anger out on somebody else, his entire brand is based on breaking things out of anger. So its not due to anger not being entertaining for the masses anymore. Im actually interested to see what the repercussions are in terms of suspensions- its just a theory, but I feel like fights in the 90s after charging the mound, it led to players just playing the next night like nothing happened. Now theres repercussions to a greater extent. At least those are my hypotheses maybe ill do a Lil research for Jon to see the suspensions associated with each fight

Tyler W.

The 2003 Cubs are near and dear to me, and I am so so so so excited for the Kyle Farnsworth breakdown. Watching that happen live is a literal core memory, alongside many more that magical summer. A lot of people make Michael Barrett's punch of AJ Pierzynski into this iconic moment, but the 2006 Cubs sucked and AJ actually seems kinda cool. But Kyle Farnsworth's tackling form and the beatdown that ensued? Iconic.

Steamboat

Subtitling the 1st and 4th Super Smash Bros games Rhubarb and Donnybrook, respectively

Anthony Dolce

Oh man I absolutely need an episode on the Nyjer Morgan-Chris Volstad fight just to watch Gaby Sanchez's stiff arm

Clayton Hurdle

Nope, I saw the half second appearance of Bob Hamelin and that’s the only one I want to see.

anon

I'm fascinated by the fact that the increase of pitchers breaking their pitching hands punching things lines up with the decline of mound charging.

Terrier44

make this series forever please

Matt Gilson

I'm sure you guys are already on this one, but maybe my favorite mound-charging of all time is the one where hunter strickland hits bryce harper because he was mad at him for admiring a home run i think literally YEARS prior and he had just held that grudge forever. my favorite thing about it though is that not only does buster posey not even make a cursory attempt to get in front of harper as he immediately decides to charge the mound, but he actually takes a step backwards and watches him go. posey's a veteran catcher and a team captain and would know the unspoken code that you always stand up for your guy in that spot, and yet in that moment his body language so clearly says "well hunter, play stupid games, win stupid prizes."

Yggdrasil325

Weirdly this video more than any other before it makes me want to see you do a video about hockey. The logic of hockey fights is nearly identical to that of mound charges.

Boreal Tempest

I have a soft spot for any former Expos player and seeing Andres Gallaraga mentioned not five minutes in put a huge smile on my face. I remember watching grainy footage over and over of that one he hit about 8000 miles in 1997 with the Marlins. Same kind of wow factor as Wily Mo Peña, but a much better hitter. e: not the "Cocaine popular" callback

Sean Broderick

Is Juan Marichal the only guy to chase a pitcher down with a baseball bat?

Merkwerdichliebe

Is Jon Bois the hardest working journalist in the game right now?

Matt

in the video, you can see Robin Yount picking up Junior and pulling him away from the brawl, which I always thought was very cool.

Matt

I'd guess that the rise of travel ball has taken a lot of the piss out of players today. Most american prospects have now essentially been training to achieve prospect status since they were about 8 years old, so there's just less room for throwing at batters and fighting.

Matt

when he ran my brewers, it was a real 'take no shit but we're still gonna lose 88 games' kinda vibe.

John Jacob

Cocaine. And steroids. But mostly cocaine.

Dwayne Zackamore

Clint Hurdle has Pirates pitchers throwing at Reds batters at a truly aggressive clip for a decade and no one really knows why; one day a hero emerged and finally said enough...Amir Garrett I'M LIKE THAT

Wagons

another piece of evidence to prove lead made us more violent (also coke and steroids help)

smalls

does cocaine make you.... good at baseball?

Gregory P Gonzales

It does fit into the curve of rising and falling violent crime that coincides with lead.

Michael Adams

Ahh yes, another indirect documentary about the effects off leaded gasoline

Omar M

Where the hell can I find solstice by tensei? I tried YouTube but nothing

Emma K

Mound chargings may be dead but thankfully baseball fights are not, there's still multiple bench-clearing incidents every year. José Ramirez vs Tim Anderson happened at second base instead of a mound charging, but I hope it gets at least a mention at some point.

I hope you have a good day!!

15:50 accidental cut, a truly surprising ‘79. I don’t know if y’all can fix this after patreon upload, but I eagerly await these 20 seconds of context summarizing 29 years of baseball in the youtube upload.

josh

JORGE SOLER!!

Simon DelMonte

Why are we celebrating this? It's pointless violence.

joyboy700

If this video counts as a celebration for you, then I'm not sure I want to sit in with a session with your therapist.

Caleb Patterson

Will arod-varitek be on here? Not really a mound charge but as close as you can get

CPJMLT LTD

Hey Jon, do you edit these videos as well? I think they are very well edited but don't see that (imo pretty important) credit at the end or in the video's description. Thx!

Michael Webb

The flowchart is wrong- you said no, but followed the yes option