Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Videos

  • 741944138.mp4

Downloads

Content

Free, cut version: https://youtu.be/DH5jroBfGIM

Files

Comments

Hayden

Did you watch a version that is slightly sped-up? I tried to sync with my own copy but my version kept falling behind your version.

Elias Deuss

There is also a prequel show to Dune

Freja Corbinne

yeah her copy seems to be about 4.3% faster than mine. (mine is 8,845 seconds from the start to the last frame before the credits, hers is 8,481 s)

Harrycan

I've read all the books, and you have no idea. But this film was much better than the previous one from the 80s. The soundtrack is so overwhelming, so if you have the chance to see it in a movie theatre...do it!!

Freja Corbinne

there's also a 4.5 hour miniseries called "Frank Herbert's Dune" that Sci Fi (now Syfy) ran in 2000. It's really good but I've never seen anyone react to it and almost none of the Dune fans I know, even before this movie came out, had heard of it. They also did a followup miniseries "Frank Herbert's Children of Dune" that covers Dune Messiah and Children of Dune. imo the miniseries is actually the most faithful live action adaptation.

NatesBurgers

as far as I understand, the shields protect from fast moving projectiles/attacks. In training, Josh Brolin says that the slow blade penetrates the shield. The blue is when the shield is actively deflecting an attack and the red is when an attack is moving through the shield

Glen Roberts

Yeah, the guy you called the Emperor is actually Baron Harkonnen, the head of the Harkonnens. The Emperor is not seen in the movie, only the Sardauker, his elite troops.

Glen Roberts

The Atreides and Harkonnens are Great Houses, similar to royal families in our history. They have a long history of feuding with each other. The Emperor is not supposed to take sides and if the Great Houses find out he conspired with the Harkonnens to wipe out the Atreides they would depose him.

Glen Roberts

The sand did not bury Paul and Jessica. Paul used the Fremen sand compactor to create a hole in the sand for their tent so they would be hidden.

Glen Roberts

Great reaction! You understood all you really could get out of the 1st movie. I don't think the book could have been done any better than this. The 1st book of the series is over 1000 pages and very dense reading. It dives much more into the politics and The Spacing Guild and Bene Gessirit and much, much more. Star Wars borrowed a lot from it. The 1st movie covers about 1/2 of the first book. Part 2 covers the rest.

ButtercupsTrueLove

I ran into sync issues with Raine's reaction and my Blu-ray disc. Fortunately, her uncut reaction video scales up nicely in resolution and I was able to watch it on my computer with no issues. I see the sync issues on occasion with some European reaction channels because I think the frame rate is slightly different than the Americas, depending on where they source their copy of the movie. It ISN'T EVERY movie EVERY time.

CheyenneWills

I'm aware of it. I have it on dvd. It's okay, they did try to stick with the source material but the production wasn't quite up to par (who thought up the costumes).

Marty McGee

The books are so much richer with even more characters. But this movie is a fantastic adaptation in my opinion. Similar to LOTR in that vein. I'm sure you will catch a lot during editing, but a few things. You were spot on thinking that this is humans as in from Earth but thousands of years into the future. The Atreides supposedly trace their bloodline back to Ancient Greece, while the Harkonnens supposedly come from Scandinavia. The year in the beginning 10191 is not counted from our present but after a future war between mankind and AI. Mankind won, but afterwards anything resembling an AI machine was forbidden. Thufir Hawat and Piter DeVries (the "bald man" as you called him) are Mentats which are basically human computers. Able to do complex equations and tactical thinking in an instant. These aren't spoilers as the movies don't really go into this. The Baron (the "floating fat man" as the Emperor refers to him in the 1980's version of the film) is the head of House Harkonnen and not the Emperor. The Duke and Jessica were never married because she's not part of a noble house. So he was keeping an option open for a political alliance. So yes, she was his concubine, but they loved each other very much. This movie was absolutely amazing in the theater. If you ever get a chance to see it there, do it! It was an experience. That moment in the tent when Paul uses the Voice, I felt it and had an almost visceral reaction. Can't wait for you to get to Part 2!! A little bit of a different vibe, but still amazing!

Anthony 임종철

I'll never understand people who complained nothing happened. This part of the story they chose to depict is good because they took their time. How shots are established, lines are delivered, the overall pacing. All very deliberate immersive techniques.

Freja Corbinne

oh you might be right, isn't it typically 25 fps in Europe and 24 in the US? 25/24 is about 1.042 so that's pretty close to the difference I measured.

Freja Corbinne

lol I like the costumes! to each their own I guess.

Marty McGee

Also, one thing Denis Villenueve is great at is world-building through visuals. Granted he had a great blueprint from the books, but this looked so great. The sense of scale is also something he's great at. Some purists claim that some things weren't as described in the books. Well of course they weren't. For example, there was a huge complaint about the thopters. The book design was basically flying boxes. The dragonfly design was awesome. So a lot of little stuff like that got changed, but I think for the better. You're also correct that the stillsuits process urine (and feces for that matter). Odd that they didn't include that. So you could spend days in the deep desert. With food of course.

Peter Karstens

This is an incredibly complex universe and has so much depth when you really dig into it. There is long spanning history all fleshed out just like Tolkien did with LOTR that adds incredible context to the current story. Dune takes place in a Sci Fi universe where they have mastered technology and all focus is on advancing the potential of the human body and mind. Different factions have different strategies that they implement to do so and all with their own goals at heart. It's all so good, weird, and meaningful and the deeper you get into the lore the wilder it gets. It's good stuff.

Luke W

There is a lot of depth to the Dune universe, and a timeline that spans tens of thousands of years. This particular point in time is nearly 21000 years in the future for us, but their calendar year is based around the formation of the Spacing Guild that controls all interstellar travel. The years are either BG (before guild) or AG (after guild). Movie starts at the year 10191 AG. (Equivalent to approximately 23350 AD) All humans in this galaxy originated from Earth, but the cultures and physiology of peoples on each world diverged from thousands of years of separation from the rest of humanity. Around ten thousand years before this movie, humanity came out of a dark age brought about by an AI uprising that conquered much of humanity and separated many star systems from one another for over a thousand years. Following that, humanity outlawed all complex computational devices and instead rely on specially trained and bred humans that can think and calculate as quickly as computers. (Mentats) In the earlier periods of space travel, faster than light travel took months or years even at the highest speeds. Space travel all but stopped after the uprising of thinking machines until humanity was able to fight back. The resulting war spanned over 200 years. After the war, humanity was led by a lineage of Emperors, and large and influential families serve the Emperor and compete with eachother for favour. The two largest competing families are the Atredies, and Harkonnen. Their feud has lasted over ten thousand years, since the fall of the machines. With the invention of space folding technology, humanity could quickly jump between star systems, but 1 in 10 ships would be destroyed by unpredictable obstacles between two points in space when they attempted, making it far too risky to use effectively until the formation of the Spacing Guild who used their navigators to revolutionize space travel. The Spacing Guild navigators are technically human, but heavily mutated by exposure to spice. The spice heightens their minds so much they obtain prescience, the ability to predict the near future. This is how they monopolized space travel, and why they need the spice. Also important, are the Bene Gesserit. They are an ancient sisterhood that condition their minds and bodies, giving them nearly superhuman capabilities and posses mental abilities to influence and manipulate others. They seek to "uplift" humanity by guiding the lineage of chosen families and bloodlines through selective breeding and genetic tailoring to create a "supreme being" who will lead the human race. They have a great deal of political influence in the galaxy, on par with the Spacing Guild.

Drew

Book fan with 20 read throughs here. The book makes a lot of use of internal monologue for the POV characters. With the main characters all being politicians, and religious figures, the internal monologue shows how the characters thoughts, spoken word, and actions almost never sync up. Lies within lies, plans within plans. The director made the choice to cut it, which is 70% of the dialogue and exposition. But the performances in the movie perfectly translates what was supposed to be there. Book fans will recognize what every gesture, every change of vocal inflection, every sigh means on screen. I was very happy with how the movie turned out, even with my favorite scene missing (the Dinner scene). My critique leaving the theater was wishing Part One was 4 hours longer

Malfunction

Raine's Sep Schedule and Poll had 2001 on the 12th and the Poll winner (Dune 1) on 19th. Perhaps they have been switched?

Drew

Great spoiler free background 🤝 After the Bene Gesserit, I’d add: Humans have developed schools to super-specialize in certain aspects. Bene Gesserit mastering politics, and the human body The Mentats (as seen with Leto’s Spymaster, and the Baron’s strategist) are human computers. Whose minds rival thinking machines. The Ginaz school produces Swordmasters, the peak of martial arts skill. Represented by Duncan, as Leto’s greatest warrior. The Spacing Guild has mastered mathematics, used in celestial navigation. And the Sook School, which produces doctors of the highest trust worthiness

cs3

This movie only covered about half of the book "Dune", i.e. book 1 of the series. The second movie covered the second half. I think the third movie will cover story from one or more of the later books. In 2007, Macmillan Audio made an audiobook adaptation of Dune with a cast of 12 voice actors. It runs 21 hours at 1x speed. There's a 4 minute excerpt from the very start of the book here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lZr_-BLFIX8

Gary Bonaducci

It’s been decades since I’ve read the book; but I remember the ’thopters from the book as described as they look like they do in this movie? With flapping wings? Certainly not like in Lynch’s Dune (1984)?

Gary Bonaducci

I hope that’s simply the case! 🤞Although if she’s going to preempt 2001, at least it was with Dune (2021) and not anything less!

Gary Bonaducci

The movie’s composer is Hans Zimmer. He’s one of the top composers in the film industry; and you’ve heard some of his work before. He was the composer for Interstellar (2014), Blade Runner 2049 (2017), Gladiator (2000), and will be composer again in the sequels Dune 2 (2024) and Dune 3 (2026).

Gary Bonaducci

This movie has a lot of really established and talented actors. One I want to first call out is Oscar Issac, who played Duke Leto Atreides, Paul’s dad. You’re going to see him a LOT in the Star Wars sequel trilogy, minus the facial hair. 🧔🏻 He’s a really talented actor; but unluckily, he also delivers one of the weakest lines in the sequel trilogy during the last movie. It’s not his fault, though. He’s just saying what was written in the script. Oscar Issac is also in Alex Garland’s Ex Machina (2014). It’s a movie about A.I. that you’d probably really enjoy. Another actor you seemed to have missed is Stellan Skarsgård. Underneath all the makeup, he played the big floating guy Baron Harkonnen. He was in Chernobyl, and has a big role in Andor too. I haven’t seen Chernobyl; but by the end of Andor, I think you’ll agree he’s quite talented.

nonleodog

these books are my second favorite series of all time. The lore and history is so deep. They are worth many re-reads. BTW they are kinetic shields: Blue means they stopped a fast moving object, Red means that a slow moving object is penetrating the shield.

Kal

And me who thought the PAL/NTSC framerate difference was a thing of the past, good catch

Chris Gronau

This is the infamous PAL vs. NTSC issue. Movies are made at 24 frames per second. PAL (the main European video standard) uses 50 frames per second. The cheapest way to convert a 24 fps movie to a 50 fps video is to duplicate every frame (which creates 48 frames for every second of material) and play that at 50 fps. This creates a runtime that's ~4% shorter, but the difference is small enough that most people won't notice. NTSC (the main American video standard) uses 60 frames per second. The cheapest way to convert a 24 fps movie to a 60 fps video is to alternate between duplicating and triplicating frames. This gives a nice, even 60 fps video. It also means that the movie speeds up and slows down 24 times each second, but that's generally unnoticeable and at least the movie runtime does not change..... Generally, the only people who notice such things are reaction viewers. If you can find a video playback system that allows you to alter the playback speed, setting the playback speed to 96% gets you pretty close.

Kal

Dude...

Kal

Great write up.

Kal

I love both the books and the movies for different reasons, Villeneuve decided to go with organic storytelling, and hence, had to change several things but the alternative would have been a ton of exposition and that would have been really clunky, we end up with a movies that you feel as much as you see and hear, and even if the books go into unfathomable depth (as others have said, akin to Tolkien) the movie really encapsulates what Herbert was going for imo.

Mister Lou

Great movie and great reaction! I hope i can sync better in part 2

Raine Reacts

other comments have said this but i think its a frame rate issue due to me watching on streaming services rather than a disk, i had issues when adding the subtitles too so that explains it

Sugared Strawberries

Quite talented is a wonderful understatement. :) Stellan Skarsgård is en par with the greatest the acting trade had to offer in the past thirty years. For me he is in the same league as, say, Gary Oldman.

Gary Bonaducci

Yeah, it’s up there at the top for me too. Considering it came out in 1968, it’s easy to see how influential the movie is in many sci-fi movies that followed. Especially with hard sci-fi.

Force Assembler

I absolutely loved these films, I think I prefer the first to the second; that harvester rescue sequence showcases everything that is great about this setting. I particularly like when Paul says "I hear your footsteps, Old Man." he's referring to both Gurney and Shai-Hulud as one of several names for sandworms is "the old man of the desert" due to how long they live and the respect they demand. I find it refreshing that in a setting where technology has been mastered to the point where some spacecraft absolutely dwarf some cities, bladework and hand-to-hand combat is still of utmost importance. Ranged weapons were common in the Dune universe until the invention of the Holtzman personal shield (blue is active, red is penetrated) which renders conventional projectile firearms ineffective and so they fell out of usage pretty much everywhere. Laser weapons fared even worse as it was found out the hard way that when a laserbeam intersects with a Holtzman shield either the laser weapon or the shield emitter will detonate in a nuclear reaction; the inability to predict which end will explode cause las-weapons to also fall out of usage. Well, everywhere except Arrakis, where the presence of worms prohibits the use of shields over most of the planet, thus pew pew and pyeeeeeeeewwwww guns got dusted off again. 😁💀 Spice exposure helps some gifted humans the ability to see potential paths into the future, the more gifted they are the less spice is needed and/or the further ahead they can see. After the ornithopter crash near the end it's important to remember that they see *potential* futures even sometimes after the event, like an echo, which is why Paul still sees Jamis guiding him, even after he's killed him: there's some future(s) where he and Jamis become friends and he sees that result. That's also how the navigators of spaceships work and why spice is so critically important; the navigators can see into the near future to predict the safest path through space at impossible speeds thus exceptionally fast interstellar travel is possible and without melange (the spice) the Imperium would fall apart due to the time needed to travel between even the closest star systems.

Gary Bonaducci

He’s very convincing and plays a very complex role in Andor. I’m looking forward to seeing him again in Raine’s reaction videos!

Gary Bonaducci

Are there any plans to watch David Lynch's 1984 version? Frankly, I think it pales in comparison to this. But they did try, and everyone knew Frank Herbert's book is difficult to adapt to the big screen. Plus, the special-effects were much more expensive to create back then. But that version does have its moments, its own visual style, and even an audio sample that was turned into a club hit: https://youtu.be/DWl2VLHTGlU Also, the soundtrack by Toto and Brian Enos is good too. I still occasionally listen to "Take My Hand", the movie's end credits song, every now and then: https://youtu.be/NjJPjAkLXS8

Brad Toune

Raine - well done, I have seen these ones many times and have bought the books and have started reading. I didn't want to spoil the movies though so I've only read so much but man. Denis Villeneuve kicks it out of the park. And when you see how it was made it makes it even more impressive

IAmShirati

Wow, yeah I really enjoyed that. I did give Dune 1 a try when it first released and I got until(spoiler alert, for this movie) the betrayal of the doctor and then just kinda stopped watching. I did feel like what you were saying towards the end that "nothing" happened. But now putting more focus into it, then I can see thatttt well, that's kinda true. BUT they set up these characters and so much world building that I'm excited of what's to come. But because of that it does kinda feel like the pilot episode of a TV-Show :-P Speaking of TV Shows, you did mention similarities to star wars, and there are a lot of similarities to the Foundation as well. It was never confirmed, but the order of the books/movies came out it was Foundation -> Dune -> Star Wars, and they are likely all inspired by each other. Foundation is also a great TV-show, probably my top 10, that's running on Apple TV. Worth to check out in some distant future, as you like these type of movies and shows :-)

CheyenneWills

The prequel series is based on the writings of Frank Herbert's son, Brian Herbert, rather than Frank himself. While Brian used his father's notes, his writing just doesn't hold up to the original. I've read several of Brian's Dune books, and they fall into the same trap that is the current trend: trying to explain everything in the story's universe and leaving nothing to the reader's imagination. All the Star Trek, Star Wars, and Lord of the Rings related prequels, sidequels, and sequels just ruin the experience (at least for me).

TMIMITW

Why u waiting so long to drop the 2nd one lol let us eat

CheyenneWills

There were a lot of things that they had to cut out, but I think they did a decent job with the movie(s). And yes there are a lot of little nods here and there if you know the books well. It was interesting that they had Jessica say the litany of fear instead of Paul during the "test". I liked how they presented "the voice". And as for the dinner scene, there was *a lot* going on there that helped establish a lot of the politics, social and economics of Arrakis, as well as the bit with the water. Instead the movie used the scene with the date palms to drive home the water economy.

Raine Reacts

Ahahaa sorreyyyy I already had others scheduled and I also don’t want to have to wait so long for the 3rd film to come out after I watch the second

weebtrash

So glad to hear you loved the score, and so excited for you to hear Dune Part 2; probably my favorite score of all time.