Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Videos

  • 754349812.mp4

Downloads

Content

cut version: https://youtu.be/PGqFrUfqKK8

Files

Comments

Renato Stojanovic

Yes!!!! Can't wait to watch this reaction later.

c0latrix

That trippy visual effect you mentioned while they were in the tunnel going in for the first time is called a dolly zoom. It's achieved by moving the camera backwards or forwards on a dolly while zooming in the opposite direction. It was originally devised by Irmin Roberts, a camera man working on Alfred Hitchcock's Vertigo, to try and visualize being in a drunken stupor.

Renato Stojanovic

That's so cool. Didn't know that. Thx for the share.

ansik

Abbott and Costello are a comedic duo from ~1930s I think everyone loves who’s on first after seeing it: https://youtu.be/sYOUFGfK4bU This movie is definitely good on a rewatch too, you pick up on so much and seeing it with the new glasses makes all the difference in experience You’re the first reaction channel I’ve started following and seeing you connect the dots and reach the final conclusion is so much fun. That, seeing someone just as happy during my favourite expanse scenes, and taking the edge of obsession got me to understand the appeal of this type of content

CheyenneWills

The novella that the movie is based on is an excellent read. The movie gets the gist of the story (and the screenplay does diverge quite a bit from the novella, the core idea is still there). "The Story of your life" by Ted Chiang was based on 2 scientific ideas, on dealing with how language can mold one's world view, the other is based on Fermat's principle of least time.

Renato Stojanovic

20:18 - when it comes to a "threat" or something unknown to the US or the world...Yes. the government (military) is very quick and efficient in laying groundwork (spared no expense). However, when it comes to infrastructure or civilian/public need, they drag their feet. Amazing isn't it? "Unaccounted" trillions of dollars for the government and scraps for the rest of us.

ClawedSimian

While there are movies that are spoiled by knowing the twist ending, this is one of those that rewards rewatching. Things hang together very well and it's fun seeing everything build toward the end.

Sindre

Loved this reaction. Arrival is one of my all time favorite movies for many different reasons. I remember doing an entire stream regarding this film and the themes of it, but also the book. I think Ian left because he disagreed that it was wrong to bring their daughter to life knowing it would end like that. It might have also been because she didn't tell him from the start, taking away that from him. I'm not saying I agree with him, but it's what I reckon his reasoning was. I think the moment I realized the time twist was when Louise got beamed up. Castello also says "We help humanity". "Louise sees future". And then it sort of clicked with the linguistics throughout the movie. I'd also gently argue that it is worth a rewatch to see how many clues and how well it ties together as a symbolic dramaturgy for its theme. I would also suggest reading the book it was based on by Ted Chiang "The Story of Your Life" and the theme of free will. I'll put down parts of my notes I had for the stream down below for anyone interested. They are a bit fragmented, but can maybe be of interest for some. idk :) Thanks for the reaction!

IAmShirati

Such a good movie! I remember my first watch I realized really early Ian was the father, I thought it was really weird that they added the first part about her child dying and then not doing anything with that for the majority of the movie. And then also how that intro speech sounded like, how they are talking about their child's beginning. And the moment you get the cut back of the first time the kid shows her the painting of "mommy and daddy talking to animals" I immediately got it that these are somehow flashforwards into the future. But it then took me until the very end of her explaining it that this was the alien's gift and that was their purpose there. She was also way to chocked every time she had a what we then believed to be flashbacks, that her confusion kinda got me thinking that way. So yeah no, I don't think you need to worry about having figured that out too early, you probably actually figured it out quite late xD. Regarding Ian and being told about the kid, she does explain to the kid that SHE told him. Right? But that might also just be a simplification for a child's sake. I'm sure at that point the child didn't know that her mother could "see the future". So Ian might've found out from himself actually learning the language. Or like you said, he wasn't ready to see his future so he didn't want to know. And Louise did actually tell him. And yeah I think it's definitely that Ian left her because he couldn't understand how she went through with having a child knowing that it would die. And my take has always been with Ian for this, if you know your child would die I would instead choose not to have one, for it and everyone around them to go through that pain. I think for similar reasons a lot of people these days choose not to have children due to how messed up the world is. But you do make a good point there, taking Louise side. And I guess if you think about it, it's kinda similar to the choice you make when having a pet. You have them, knowing that you will have to deal with them dying. It just feels different when it's a human being, but you probably still would. I think this marks my 3rd or 4th rewatch, it definitely hits the hardest the first time through when you figure out the puzzle for the first time. That "OOOH" feeling. Although I space these out enough, and am forgetful enough that on each rewatch I still have some questions. Like for this, I did completely forget what the aliens did want. But yeah, a really good movie. I did say I think in some aspects it's similar to project hail mary. in very SPECIFIC aspects. But I think the vibe I get from early on in project hail mary with all the scientists and the world coming together to figure out the astrophage and everything. And then of course the language being when they first meet rocky. Although PHM goes through that a lot faster than this, and I like that it dove pretty deep into the linguistics of it. It was very interesting.

Sindre

NOTES: Main theme: Free Will, Love, Linguistics, Time. TIME: Time travel: Non linear time reality (orthography/linguistics). Louis in the future and Louis in the past/present would not be two different sentient beings, but the same but in existing in the entire timeline. Ian Donnelly explains how they write non-linear, which is reflected in the circle (the novella has more details on the linguistics part). This is again reflected in the Non-Zero-Sum-Game. Win-Win. Tied ends. Circular. The first word Louise suggests when daughter ask: Compromise. Which is interesting as that is her first thought: conflict, not positive. This can be mirrored in how human instinct go and why language is important. -> LINGUISTICS: Louise dreams in their language: SAPIR-WHORF Hypothesis = Linguistic Relativity: Determinism: Strong/weak. Strong is determinism where language determins how we percieve life and reality. Weak: Influence (modern with empirical evidence) how we percieve life and reality. It may hint at why the influence is perhaps more prominent in the terms of free will. At least in for the sake of the framwork of this movie. The circular theme also gives a new way of regarding time. It's not a future Louise we see, but a whole embodiement of a life. Criticism has said the time/future of changing Chinese president. When she was surprised about the number, it was not the future Louise...it is the same louise just hoping back and forth between the non-linear time as she goes along. So it's not fixed, but altering differently than cause and action. It's the same as when she understood the language. She skipped back and forth. This is why she is surprised at both time-depictions. What she says to the Chinese President: "In war there are no winners, only widows". (Writer was called by director during production to actually come up with the line, because they had the interpreter on set and Amy Adams had to actually say something. It ended up being non-subtitled anyways in the final cut) FREE WILL: Circular timeline means there is no beginning or end, although it doesn't mean free will is compromised. It would only be compromised if the time is linear, but because it is free flowing, you could alter it and it would continue to be circular. We have to view time differently to understand it. The end is the circular beginning. The message is being in the present. Understanding, value, embrace and appreciate. Ian: "his most important thing in life was meeting her". Reflection of how we gaze at stuff ahead instead of what we have right in front of us. So it's not really a gift to see the future, but the gift of understanding/communication. And ultimately the gift of WHY. Love. When people say, they never. LOVE: Louise's "choice". This was altered from the book. Where the crux leaned towards acceptance of the reality as it occurs and the knowledge the language encompass. Whereas in the movie it was a conscience choice by the writer to make it more about the choice of going through the pain because it felt more emotional. -------------------------------------------------------- Book vs Movie: Ted Chiang researched linguistics for 5 years before writing The Story of your Life. It addresses Free Will. Book: 112 "Looking Glasses" dispatched on earth. Aliens are in orbit, not on earth (screenwriter Eric Heisserer wanted a more urgency for the movie, hence why they are on earth) The linguistics part is quite prominent in the book where the language of the aliens are split into two different languages, spoken and written, and they do not link, thus being two separate forms of language. The written language is adhered to FREE WORD ORDER and a complex multilevel of CENTER-EMBEDDED clauses (creating a phrase in the middle of another phrase). The language is chains of SEMAGRAMS (an IDEOGRAM used to disambiguate interpretation (similar to hieroglyphic determinatives). The book also incorporate physics more than the movie (perhaps a smol weakness in the film) where Gary Donelly (in the book, Jeremy Renners character, Ian Donnelly, in the movie). Where they present the "Fermat's Principle" (Principle of Least Time). Basically establishing that a ray has a point A and B and will always take the fastest path. Louise reasons that in order for it to travel at all it must know where it will end up. Thus connecting it to Free Will, but also how the heptapods write all the ideograms simultanously. Which implies knowledge of where it will end up. It's not CAUSALITY but FINALITY (TELEOLOGY: A definitive end/goal, whereas causality which one action influences the next). In the book the alien leaves earth without explaining why they leave or why they came. In the movie they explain they need human to help them 3000 years from now. Indicating the free will part) Free will is the question the book focuses on. If the future is known it has already been set and free will does not exist. However, Louise poses the question: "What if that knowledge of the future changed a person? What if it evoked a sense of urgency, a sense of obligation to act precisely as she knew she would?"

Sindre

PS: As a small sidenote. As someone who has lost two of those closest to me at a early age, despite all the hardships and things that has caused my entire adult life...I would do it all over again to be with them even if I knew it would end the way it did. <3 Be generous with your time to those you love <3

Augustin Laufer

I recommend you look into the "CETI" program. It's been going on since 2020 and it's trying to understand the language of sperm whales. They learned that sperm whales use very complicated series of cliks to "speak" between each others. There are different languages and different accents according to which part of the planet you're listening to ! We already found a sort of word structure and things that would be close to letters, it's really fascining and it's actually the most advanced program dedicating to communicate with another specie !

Russ

I do love this movie. Great actors. Love Jeremy Renner. The idea of this movie is great too. Another great space movie... Gravity

Renato Stojanovic

Great reaction! Finally finished it. And no, I dont you've seen this before. I figured it out around the same time u did in the movie when i saw this movie a few years ago. That's the point when all the pieces start to fall into place and your mind gets blown.

Stuart Compton

The "fog" as they first approach the Shell is completely natural. They are in the highlands in Montana, USA. You had me smiling the entire movie. So fun seeing how you take it all in. Sorry, I have watched so many movies, all of the future dreams I figured out after about the second time she saw the vision of the daughter, first time I was saying the same thing about did she have a daughter before and figured out who dad was as soon as she said mom and dad talk to the animals. I may have went back and forth a couple of times in the first few visions as to was this before we met her or was it future, but somehow I realized early on it was future but not sure if it was visions or time jump information if I'm honest.

Manny Romero

Well you can win, by not caring what people think. And you figured it out at about the same pace as a whole lot of other folks. Nice shout🍻.

Kal

I absolutely loved your reaction. When I saw it first, I think the first alarm bell that I noticed that made me think "all might not be as it seems" was the absence of a wedding ring during the movie but very prominently showed at the beginning, then the zero sum game also tripped me, but the full realization came at the same point you did, I'm guessing it's the AHA! moment, but it's done very elegantly. As for them being separated, I'd guess she only told him when Hannah was a child, while she knew before they even got together, she basically stole his choice away by not telling him, making him love a daughter that he was doomed to lose and inflicting that loss on him when she could have been upfront about it. I don't think many couples could recover from that sense of betrayal or broken trust. But there's not really a right answer to that, especially considering her notion of time, to her, there is no choice, everything is pre-determined. Really fascinating premise.

Kelton Rochelle

US MIC will probably stand up a FOB like that in a couple hours from nothing on a tuesday tbh. Thats just a couple airlifts to drop some boxes in a field.

JazzKane

You hadn’t seen the movie before you just remembered yourself watching it in the future

Renato Stojanovic

That is true. Doesnt take much militarily speaking. Honestly, it just struck a chord with me personally when she mentioned ingenuity of the military op getting things up in a hurry that I kind of took it a step further by dotting all the i's and crossing all the t's.

Walter Bishop

I dont remember when i figured out the ending, but i think it was close to that, when you figured it out, or maybe a bit sooner and i remember i felt strange after watching it. Almost like i was about to get that gift and see the future, it hard to explain :-D I watched it twice, few years apart and i got that feeling at the end both times and even now, but not that strong like, when i watched it for the first or second time by myself. Its was just a "glimpse" of that feeling, something like you forgot something, but its really close and you just cant reach it in your mind

Russ

O Oblivion is a great sci fi mystery

Buchanan

You HAVE to watch Contact. The movie based on Carl Sagans Novel of the same name.

Stuart Compton

I like your reply here. I would submit that the rational to her having a child with an end of life date known is that she was able to figure out the "Gift" because she had the visions. If she changed that future, does it change the past? This question is not answered or discussed in the movie so it is obviously too complex to be explained. Just as Abbott was killed and it would seem logical that the Heptapods would have known that was the path that gets the resolve. Just a thought.

Heck

If you're interested in another alien movie I would recommend one of my all time favorites Annihilation. IIRC it came out the same year as Arrival too! Not space but is also an Earth bound, very science heavy movie. Also has a stellar Women led cast!

Tom D

Arrival, Dune(s), Blade Runner 2049, Sicario... all in just over 10 years. Denis Villeneuve is the greatest currently working director for my tastes. Enemy and Prisoners, earlier, were good too. I still rewatch this from time to time, despite knowing the end. I just think it's beautifully made, and revealed. I'm a bit of a sap - I get really moved by really well done things; happy to admit I'll often tear up just from something being really beautifully done, whether or not it's a traditionally emotional moment.

Erich

Good job figuring it out, Raine! And don’t worry, as others have said this movie is totally rewatchable, in fact it rewards a re-watching. A beautiful, heartbreaking film, anchored by a remarkable performance by Amy Adams.

Marty McGee

Great movie! It's one of the best movies I've seen that I don't think I could watch twice.

Marty McGee

Love this movie! Denis Villenueve has become one of my favorite directors in recent years. Don't worry about catching the twist too early. I caught it right around where you did. I wasn't sure until she said, "who is this child I'm seeing?" I think the whole thing with Ian leaving her wasn't so much about her decision to bring Hannah into the world. It was probably more about not telling him about the disease beforehand. I'm not mad at her though. That's such a personal thing I can't judge. I also can't judge him for leaving because of it. I still tear up (I'm a softie at heart) at all those little memory/future moments. The music kills me every time.

Sonny Liu

Consider watching The Wandering Earth II

Kal

I always liked the analogy that time is like a book, you can skip forward or read back but the book remains the same, we only perceive the story as something moving forward linearly but the whole story had always been on the desk. So for Louise, there is not really an agency, she doesn't see different possible versions of a future, she sees what has and always will happen, her brain has been changed to no longer perceive time as an arrow, Ian probably couldn't understand that and resented her for robbing him of his choice, but Louise is just as much a victim as he is, she also doesn't have a choice, but the fact that she can see life as an entirety means that she can see the gift for what it is, better to have loved and lost than never have loved at all. I don't necessarily blame Louise, but I really feel for Ian, what a horrible thing to have every moment of love with your child tainted by the knowledge that she will die from a wasting disease at a young age. Must have been unbearable.

Raine Reacts

damnnnnn i feel like mum and dad talk to animals was one of the earliest points you could get it

Raine Reacts

yessss its on my list, ill find a space for it

Raine Reacts

oh interesting, i thought you meant SETI but i googled it and yeah CETI, never heard of this before

Augustin Laufer

It’s actually called CETI because of SETI 😅

Raine Reacts

yeah i was thinking the same, it seems like the future is set and she cant change it she just has to live knowing what will come but i think if anything that makes you cherish what time yoy do have together.

Raine Reacts

thanks for sharing, this was very insightful and got me wanting to read the book. the bit you said at the end resonated with me a lot. while i havent lost people at an early age (only grandparents) this movie really made me think about the relationships i have. for example, i know my cats are not going to be there forever and that makes me cherish the moments i do get with them. my family, my partner i just sort of accept they are going to be around forever and take them for granted and it really made me think like i need to cherish the moments i have with them because them being around forever is not guarenteed.

Raine Reacts

oh for sure worth a rewatch, what i meant is this is one where the experience you get the first time can never be repeated.

IAmShirati

Oh yeah, I like Stuart's take here, obviously they knew Abbott was going to die, and if they could've changed it they probably would. Yeah you guys are probably right

CheyenneWills

The novella, which the movie is based on, is written almost like a letter to the daughter and packs an even greater punch to the gut than the movie. I don't want to say any more to avoid spoilers for the novella, but it would be fun to discuss it.

Sindre

Thanks for taking the time to read my comments and for the reply. I can absolutely recommend the book, especially after having seen the film. If I may also recommend another book, or rather short story, it would be "The Machine Stops". It's a Sci-fi written by E.M. Forster in 1909. The theme is a dystopian future where humans have become reliant on technology and addresses concepts as the internet, video calls, and AI and lots of other things that are quite prominent today. And it's 1909! It's very short but worth dedicating attention to. I think it's really generous to be aware of our limited time, both for ourselves and those around us. I think it's good to cherish moments without it being all encompassing. Appreciate the small and "trivial" things in life with those you love, being aware that you do is what's vital for feeling them at heart. <3

CheyenneWills

This movie introduced me to Denis Villeneuve and the composer Jòhann Jòhannson. While watching the movie, i did a quick lookup on the composer because I really thought it was Vangelis at first. This was while Blade Runner 2049 was early in the production, and after seeing Arrival, many of my personal fears about the Blade Runner sequel were removed. It's too bad that Jòhannson was dropped from BR2049 (I suspect in part might have been due to health).

CYBRLFT

Another MUST WATCH series is For All Mankind. Fantastic.

Danny

A lot of fun game theory in this movie. Aliens set up a game between different nations to help us overcome our tendency to act purely out of self-interest and instead cooperate/communicate with each other to achieve a better outcome. I guess the Nash Equilibrium here is each nation deciding if they can't crack the language and receive the "weapon" then the best bet is to start a human vs alien war? Not sure, there's a lot to think about with this one. If you're still looking for good space movies, CONTACT (1997) is one of my favorites. Also on the topic of game theory, A BEAUTIFUL MIND (2001) is a 10/10 movie about John Nash, nobel prize winner & originator of the Nash Equilibrium

Nick

Haven’t seen this since becoming a parent. Hits a LOT harder now.

CheyenneWills

If you've read the novella, it hits even harder.

Daniel Kane

Her husband left her because, from his perspective, she chose to have a child that would die tragically young instead of, say, terminating that pregnancy and having another child who didn't have the unspecified very rare disease. The cause of death in the novella is a preventable accident, making the protagonist's unwillingness (or inability) to alter the future much easier to blame her for.

Mr. Fresh

I actually saw this movie in theaters back then, and I remember being a bit disappointed. I found it underwhelming, the whole attack felt like a forced action element, and I really didn't like the ending. My problem is that I tend to overthink things. The more you think about them, the more logical inconsistencies you find. But watching it again, I actually enjoyed it much more. Knowing the story, I could appreciate all the little clues and clever details, and even the ending was surprisingly well done. Still, I think you just have to accept certain things without questioning them too much. Otherwise, the logic starts falling apart. Overall, definitely worth watching, but not one of my favorite sci-fi movies.

Zack Olson

As a parent this movie absolutely wrecks me every time I watch it.

Joleff Cordongo

I wrote a whole thing about "don't listen to the trolls" in regard to your "can't win" comment, but I read it back and it was pretty blatant white knighting. So instead I'll just say keep posting and I'll keep watching. I'm seriously enjoying rewatching my favorite shows and movies with the benefit of your perspective.

AK

Pun intended?