Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Videos

  • 767325538.mp4

Downloads

Content

The Expanse season 3 episode 3 "Assured Destruction" reaction

Files

Comments

Shawn Anomaly

Book 2 ends on 3x6! The thing with the SG wavering was due to Ana getting to him. Errinwright was indeed the one that convinced him to strike. When they were ready with the systems all charged up and ready the SG stood down due to the success only being 82% possibility and his prior chat with Ana. That stand down caused the temporary malfunction with #5 so Errinwright used that whole thing to turn around and act like it was all Ana's fault in causing the SG to waver in his decision. Also, not sure if you remembered him but the guy who talked to Cotyar was Admiral Souther. He was the same one from S2 he was the level headed one in the situation room when it came down to fighting Mars. The one that wanted to hold back going straight to war with them. He also had that quick meeting with Chrisjen telling her the truth about Fred Johnson!

Molecularize

Admiral Souther, the original captain on the Agatha King who is helping Cotyar the spy, was in one of the previous seasons. He was the head of the navy who resigned his position rather than follow the secretary general's order to annihilate the Martian moon. Also, with the railgun that failed to fire, they said the malfunction that delayed gun #5 firing was caused by powering up the guns earlier then powering them down. Still agree that the situation is ultimately Erinwright's fault, but his ego would never let him see it that way. He blames Anna's meddling.

Chad K

Not sure if you caught it but the reason Mars was able to launch a missile was because it took so long for railgun 5 to fire. It took long to fire because of the charging up then charging down earlier in the day. That's why Errinwright said it "didn't have to happen". He's basically saying that if the secretary general had just fired the guns earlier when they were ready then the 5th gun wouldn't have had that firing problem. Which is technically true but kind of gaslighting and manipulative

Anthony 임종철

I think the reason you're having a hard time with character behavior and motivation (or deviation from) is just that this show has it's own visual vocabulary when it comes to what's driving people at any given moment. There's nothing particularly complicated at the core but there are lots of new concepts multiplied by shifting perceptions of the events multiplied by each character.

Tom D

You mainly seemed thrown by the back and forth on the UN side. It seems to me like it's just Erinwright wants to pre-emptively strike Mars, in this case their stealth missile platforms. The president guy was talked down by Anna, when the planetary railguns were heated up and ready. Erinwright later turned him around again (this President guy is pathetic...) and they launched, but one of the launches was delayed by a glitch due to the previous stand down and restart. So one of the Martian platforms had time to get a shot off, and Erinwright wanted Anna to feel to weight of her decision to talk him down earlier, resulting in that power cycling glitch. And perhaps spread some his own guilt around. Sorry if none of that is what was confusing, but I didn't feel like that side of things had too many mixed motives in this episode. As for Earth not having proto-molecule, to my mind all the research has been Jules Pierre's and the creepy doctor, either in cahoots with the UN or Mars, but it's all in his hands, except Fred's sample. Hope that's helpful. If not, then I can't really take it back :p

Golladan

The only ones that have a sample was Jules-Pierre's company Protogen, and Fred Johnson. Mars and Earth never managed to get their hands on it. Mars was going to get it last season with the Karakum, but Errinwright had the ship destroyed over Ganymede. The Agatha King is on its way to Io to pick it up.

Shawn Anomaly

Yeah, 3x5 and 3x6 are going to serve as a nice one-two combo to conclude Book 2 and it's going to be one nasty combo for you!

ansik

Don't you think we haven't noticed that you don't mention what you're drinking for the episode anymore!

Parabola

I'm editing my comment because I saw all the other comments already addressed what I posted. I will say though, while on the surface it seems like Earth, Mars, and the Belt, within each are factions that have their own agendas and for Earth the obvious ones are Protogen and then within the government, Errinwright and Nguyen. I don't think it should be too confusing but you mentioned being generally confused but I'm unsure of what specifically to comment on.

ClawedSimian

I think the motivation is powerful people being willing to sacrifice others for self-preservation... Potentially at the cost of many, many others, as long as they're unknown faces. And the President being weak, influenced by whoever he spoke to last, and Errinwright being a real POS... ha. On a different note, Admiral Souther (the black UNN admiral who was relieved of command by Fleet Admriral Nguyen) is one of my favorite characters, his scene last season confronting Avarsarla over drinks was fantastic.

Gary Bonaducci

Right? It’s probably a good way to get a sponsor for the channel. 🥂😄

Gary Bonaducci

In case anyone was wondering, “Nguyen” can be acceptably pronounced like “Win”. How do I know? I have a Vietnamese co-worker who tried to teach me how to properly pronounce her last name. After a while she said, “Just say ’WIN’ already!!!! 🙄” 😆

Raine Reacts

I didn’t think people cared ahaha so I stopped doing it

Gary Bonaducci

Whenever I watch a movie or tv show, I pay attention to see if the production team is sending additional clues or information through symbolism and juxtapositions. Water and the various forms it can take (as rain, frozen as ice, in a fish tank, in a swimming pool, etc.) is commonly used for this purpose. But I can’t figure out how this show handles symbolism using water, and what it always means. Take this shot, for example. It was obviously intentionally set up by the camera operator and the props department. It wasn’t randomly set up just to look interesting, right? But what does it mean, if anything? 🤔

Dave Willow

I know it’s likely just personal preference, but the only character (antagonist or protagonist) that I don’t like in this series is Naomi (and this is my 3rd viewing). I think her choices are generally poorly considered and I just don’t like the scenes she’s in.

hend0wski

Thak God i complained about how long this would take on YouTube cuz im so glad patreon is moving so much more quickly. This has become a core part of my Monday work day.

Raine Reacts

im gladdddd, the patreon edits are soooo much easier!

hend0wski

Bruh you pulled a CRAZY plot snipe in this reaction. I will not elaborate for fear of spoilers but I literally gasped dude

hend0wski

Nothing big but still fun lol

Varun Laks

So at this point, neither the Earth or Mars governments have the Protomolecule. The Roci crew just thought they did. But remember we know a bit more than them. We know that Errinwright was working with Mao, but then at the beginning of S2, when Mao realized Avasarala knew they were working together, he cut off Earth from the project and chose to work with Mars. Then Mars was the one who got the "Sales Demo" on Ganymede and ultimately went to pick it up when Holden and company were there. But before Mars could actually pick it up, Errinwright turned the tables, killed the Martian Defense Minister and blew up the ship going to pick up the Hybrid. Mao also hasn't given Errinwright access to the Hybrids at this point, because he still has family in prison. Holden and Naomi assumed that both factions had a sample, because they haven't been privy to the political back and forth that's been happening in the other storyline like the audience have. To them, Earth had a sample because it was known that Mao's ships were made on Earth and Mars has a sample because Mars was at Ganymede and getting a sample (which they wouldnt have known was their only sample). As Naomi said, she gave the Protomolecule to Fred so that the Inner Government's wouldn't have something over the Belt yet again. But in actuality right now, only the Belt has a sample (outside of Jules Pierre Mao).

Malfunction

Regarding the scene in your photo, my initial impression was that we were looking through prison bars. I did some research using your photo and found this detailed explanation: The out-of-focus IV bags dominating the foreground create a literal barrier between the viewer and Mao and Mei. It emphasizes that that Mei is not treated as a human, but as a sterile laboratory specimen or commodity in a clinical, corporate-backed experiment. Also Jules-Pierre Mao poses as a benevolent visitor, but he is the architect of the children suffering. Framing him behind and through the medical equipment visually tethers him directly to the medical abuse and systemic horror happening in the room, highlighting his hypocrisy as he tries to justify the experiments to himself and Mei. I would not have thought of any of that!

Gary Bonaducci

Interesting. I didn’t interpret it that way either. I was thinking about how the liquid is contained; and similarly, Mei is contained in the facility too. But that interpretation doesn’t seem to apply to Mao, unless if the show was foreshadowing that these experiments are going to end up containing him too. But the explanation you found is closer to the events in the following episode. Thanks for finding and sharing this! 👍

Spatterjay

We don't know that the railgun would have worked flawlessly if it had been fired earlier.

LibGamer

The arcs in this series have stakes that feel earned. The conflict between Naomi and the crew, Bobbi’s anger and mistrust, etc. One thing that I like about the series is that it gives us a chance to really get to know Aversarala’s character. In the books she doesn’t show up until book 3. For casting reasons, the show spreads out her story out across the seasons which gives us a chance to invest in her and that makes her appearance on the roci (she’ll always be the roci to me) so much more impactful.