My "Secret Story" Revealed! (Patreon)
Content
Hello my wonderful patrons! For a few weeks now, I've been working on a bit of a secret project in addition to my usual workload around here, and now that it's finished, I wanted to share it all here with you today! April Fool's in Handcuffs is going to be my entry in Literotica's April Fool's Day Story Contest 2025, and is also going to be my first story published in the Lesbian Sex category. As such, I'm a little nervous about how this one, but I'm happy with this Dakota-centric tale of girl on girl fun, and I hope you all enjoy it as well!
(With the contest beginning in a few days, I will be submitting this to Lit right away, so it won't have the customary week+ of early access here, but it should still have at least a few days exclusivity here!)
-aimingtomisbehave33
------------
As the senior class cheer captain at Regan Hills High School, 18-year-old Dakota Lewis had known that this day was coming for some time. As a known hardass who liked to drive the other girls on the squad hard so they could reach their greatest potential, she knew that April Fool’s Day would likely be some kind of reckoning for her, even if she didn’t exactly know the flavor that that reckoning would come in… but with tradition being what it was, she knew that this was likely to be one hell of a night for her.
She also knew that, with Regan Hills kind of having an unspoken reputation as one of the horniest small towns on Earth that however she was pranked might well be sexual in nature, especially considering the fact that she and the other cheerleaders had all had their share of fun fucking around as the year had gone on, because, hey, when all your friends are hot and horny, why wouldn’t you be having as much fun with them as possible?
Nevertheless, Dakota hadn’t expected her friends to be <i>quite</i> this creative for an April Fool’s Day prank.
Standing at the fifty-yard line at Regan Hills High’s football field, naked save for her shoes and socks and the blindfold that had been slipped over her eyes, Dakota had to admit that they’d successfully surprised her. The cool night air on this lovely April in Southern California evening made her skin prickle with gooseflesh and her nipples go hard, but she stood still, strong and determined and ready to face whatever they intended to put her through. It didn’t mean she completely lacked anxiety over what was to come, as it was easy to fear the unknown when you were naked and blindfolded in the middle of a football field, but for all intents and purposes she thought she did a good job of hiding it by putting on a playfully defiant face.
There were people around her, bustling, their footsteps in the grass obvious. She knew that something was coming, and coming soon, just what that something would be she wouldn’t hazard a guess.
“We’re gonna put these on you now,” a kind, if somewhat sickly-sweet, voice explained as a pair of noise-canceling headphones were slid most of the way over Dakota’s head. “Then you count to thirty… you can take them and the blindfold off then and, like, you’ll know what to do then! Have fun!”
Before Dakota could raise a question, the headphones were completely pushed over her ears, and she was left alone in this world, standing naked and exposed and uncertain of what would come next. It was only that she trusted her friends that she indulged the plan this far, and she meant to see it through.
<i>30… 29… 28…</i>
She could feel more movement around her, more hurried preparation.
<i>27… 26… 25…</i>
Whatever they had planned was certainly elaborate, she had to give them that, as she felt the bustling of more bodies around her.
<i>24… 23… 22…</i>
Dakota felt a body closing in at her left side, some vigorous action that was difficult to determine for how blind and deaf she was to what was going on…
<i>21… 20… 19…</i>
Quickly, she felt the shackle of a pair of handcuffs click around her left wrist, then some resistance as whoever was attached to the other shackle pulled against her with some hesitation of their own.
<i>18… 17… 16…</i>
It was as Dakota felt people running away from them, then experimentally pulled against her own side of the handcuffs to meet the resistance of whoever she was shackled to, that she felt that first hint of trepidation and wondered just what the fuck she had gotten herself into.
And to think, this had all started so promisingly…
***
Just because she was a hardass to the other girls on her squad, that didn’t mean Dakota wasn’t a team player, and it <i>especially</i> didn’t mean she had no respect for traditions, no matter how annoying they made her life. While there weren’t <i>too</i> many traditions that she knew she had to be concerned about, when it came to April Fool’s Day, all bets were off. Regan Hills High clubs had an informal tradition of pulling some fairly impressive pranks on their captains and presidents and the like, and since they always wanted to go bigger than everyone else, the cheerleaders in particular had a reputation to keep up for some fairly epic pranks on their captains from year to year. Though there were plenty ways to get around it with her friends and connections, considering how hard she was on the other girls the rest of the year, Dakota understood that this was one of those times where if she knew what was good for her, she’d take the pranking in stride and let them all have their fun.
But that didn’t mean she was going to do it without at least <i>some</i> dignity.
That was why Dakota snuck into the school at the appointed hour after dark, dressed in her best, most formal blue and white cheerleading uniform, her hair and makeup done up perfectly. It may not have been war paint in the traditional sense, but it was how she chose to face whatever crucible the rest of the girls in the squad had in mind for her, and her way of reminding them that she was one of the hottest bitches in school.
And, Dakota had to admit, she was looking <i>particularly</i> hot today. At a lean 5’8”, she was particularly statuesque among the cheerleaders, her pale skin close to flawless save for a light smattering of freckles across her cheeks that gave her a particularly mischievous look. The formal cheerleading uniform hugged her lean and toned dancer’s body perfectly, the skirt not covering up too much of her shapely legs and full, round ass. While the top and its accompanying long white gloves were not the most flattering in the world, it was tight enough to hug her frame nicely and show off just how nice her C-cup breasts could look. With her shoulder-length, dark brown hair pulled back into a tight, functional ponytail, her clever, angular face was all the more highlighted, which when combined with her delicate features, smug little grin and bold blue eyes gave her an understandable confidence with how fucking good she looked.
So, it was with a spring in her step and a sense of confident ease that she strolled through the empty school, making her way across the darkened athletic fields toward the cheerleading office. Though there was a certain thrill, maybe even fear, for someone as prone to overachieving as her at being at school well after everyone was supposed to be gone, any anxiety about getting caught was far from her mind. After all, the school only had one security officer, and even Officer Brandy had a home to go to at the end of the day.
And even if she was caught, this would hardly be the biggest trouble that Dakota had managed to talk herself out of.
As she reached the cheerleading office just off the football field, Dakota straightened herself out, once again doing a quick scan of the area around her and finding herself seemingly alone, though she knew that was far from the case. Ever since she’d stepped foot on campus, she’d felt eyes on her, watching and waiting and ready to pounce. Though this should have put her on her guard, on this day of all days, Dakota was prepared to let them pounce this once.
Raising her hand, she knocked on the office’s door.
Just as soon as she’d done it, the door swung open about a foot, a cute, cheerful face looking up at her. It was a face that Dakota knew well, her sparkling smile, bright green eyes, bobbing, shoulder-length blonde pigtails… yeah, the ever-energetic 18-year-old Brooke King was one of the more distinct members of Dakota’s cheer squad.
“You’re here! Excellent!” Brooke exclaimed, opening the door a little wider and grabbing Dakota by the wrist.
With surprising strength for her petite frame, Brooke pulled Dakota into the cheerleading office, then quickly closed and locked the door behind her. She wasn’t the only cheerleader in here, either, as the willowy redhead with glasses and a cutely goofy grin, 18-year-old Sasha Pearl, and the busty and charitable Latina, 18-year-old Jade Alvarez, also stood in the office, seemingly waiting and at the ready. These were three of the nicer girls on the cheer squad, so Dakota felt no imminent threat, but their dark clothes gave them a vaguely conspiratorial vibe, which certainly fit the occasion.
“Girls,” Dakota said with a nod.
“Hey,” Jade replied, nodding to Dakota.
“Hi!” Sasha replied brightly.
“So, this would be, like, one of those moments in a movie where I’d totally say, ‘So, I guess you’re wondering why I invited you here…’ but you totally kinda know that, so we can dispense with that step and get down to the April Fool’s of it all, yeah?” Brooke suggested.
“I would like that,” Dakota replied evenly, smiling at the girls with a well-earned confidence. “I know that I’m about to face some variety of humiliation, and I’d like to get it over with sooner rather than later while you all get your laughs in… I haven’t seen them, but I trust the other girls are here as well?”
“Totally,” Brooke replied.
“Yeah,” Sasha replied conspiratorially, strolling over toward Dakota. “We’ve got most of the squad here, and some assorted allies and other friends just to make things <i>particularly</i> interesting. I mean, after they found out what was happening tonight, an audience was inevitable.”
Well, that was fascinating. Dakota had never feared an audience in the past, and she wasn’t planning on backing down this time even if that meant her humiliation being watched.
“But we’re here, right now, to make sure you’re ready for this, and to let you know that if you want to quit, you can. You don’t have to do this just because it’s a long-running tradition, because, let’s face it, there’s a lot of shitty long-running traditions out there and you don’t have to do anything you don’t want just because it’s been done for a long time,” Jade said, her voice, as ever, a natural comfort to Dakota.
Straightening herself out, Dakota replied, “I’ve been preparing myself for this all day. I’m ready for whatever you girls have to throw at me.”
Brooke, Sasha and Jade shot each other conspiratorial looks, then exchanged some rather giddy smiles.
“You’re sure about that?” Sasha asked.
“Positive,” Dakota replied.
“Even if it’s gonna contain a night of sexy shenanigans? Because we, like, want ya to know that it’s gonna be pretty heavy on sexy shenanigans, and we just wanna make sure that everyone’s consenting before we subject ya to anything, because if you do consent and are down for anything like you say you are, it’s got some potential to get totally steamy,” Brooke explained, smiling up at Dakota with the same cheer and enthusiasm she always brought to the field.
Dakota licked her lips at the possibility of sexy shenanigans. She and the rest of the girls on the squad had had a <i>lot</i> of fun together this senior year, and Dakota liked to think that she knew their tastes well, so well in fact that she thought there was nothing they could do to surprise her.
This would turn out to be a bit of a mistake, not that she wouldn’t have a fair bit of fun by the time all of this was over.
Thinking about the possibilities, even if it would mean a certain level of humiliation to be mixed in as well, Dakota said, “I’m ready.”
Jade and Sasha shared delighted looks, while Brooke squealed with joy.
“Alright, girls, let’s strip her, blindfold her and get her outside so we can let the games begin!” Brooke exclaimed.
As the three of them descended upon the brunette cheer captain, Dakota couldn’t help but get the feeling like there was more to this prank than even she had predicted, but by the time she began to wonder what her friends were really up to, they’d already begun to remove her clothing.
***
<i>3… 2… 1…</i>
Alright, enough was enough. Dakota lifted her free hand and grabbed the noise canceling headphones, pulling them off and dropping them to the ground, the blindfold following seconds later. She blinked her eyes, getting readjusted to the limited light of the dark field. Considering her naked state, she half-expected there to be a crowd of people surrounding her, laughing and pointing and taking pictures of her nudity. There, however, weren’t any people surrounding her as far as she could see, even if she could still feel that primal sensation of distant eyes watching her every move, and for all intents and purposes, she seemed to be alone on the football field.
Alone, save for the beautiful blonde girl who stood next to her, her right hand cuffed to Dakota’s left and standing every bit as naked as the cheerleader herself was. The other girl’s count must have been a few seconds off from Dakota’s, because it took her a moment longer before she stripped off her headphones and blindfold, but the moment she did, she looked around with a similar look of blinking confusion and annoyance.
“Motherfucker…” she said, tugging her right hand against the handcuffs, before looking at Dakota with some surprise.
Nonplussed, Dakota replied, “Hey, Eliza… happy April Fool’s Day. They got you too?”
The blonde eyed Dakota with a further wave of annoyance, tugging at her cuffed hand again, before her shoulders dropped with resignation. “Yeah, looks like it.”
As people she could have been handcuffed to on April Fool’s Day went, Dakota knew that she could have done a lot worse than 18-year-old Eliza Dane. While she didn’t know her well, she knew Eliza was the captain of Regan Hills High School’s swim team, and though Dakota had never really attended any swimming related sporting events, she had definitely heard of Eliza’s reputation as a skilled athlete and a beast when it came to any and all forms of competition. Beyond that, Eliza also had a reputation for being as much of a beast academically, consistently scoring near the top of whatever classes she was in.
Of course, one doesn’t get a reputation for being a beast easily, and in the few occasions Dakota had had to talk with her in the past, she knew Eliza fairly direct in speech and rough around the edges personality-wise, which didn’t make her a lot of friends on her team or in class. As a similarly academically inclined hardass, Dakota actually had quite a bit of respect for Eliza, and didn’t mind her <i>nearly</i> as much as everyone else around school seemed to, so while she found it terribly on the nose that the two of them had been paired together for whatever this prank was, she was optimistic that whatever it entailed that Eliza Dane would make a great partner.
And… well, she would have been in denial if she said she hadn’t checked Eliza out either, and it was undeniable that the swim team captain was fucking hot. Lightly tanned all over, the 5’9” blonde had a toned athlete’s body, not too muscular, but with muscles just prominent enough to know she was best not to be fucked with. Her long, shapely legs led to a toned, round ass, a strong back and tight abs. Her pussy was shaved bare, a sight that Dakota didn’t mind in the slightest, and while the rest of her body was tight and compact, her breasts were anything but. Full and high and easily a DD-cup, with prominent, dark nipples that begged for all sorts of attention, Dakota found herself briefly wondering if they were ever a problem with swimming, but knew better than to ask; lord knew she was acquainted with <i>plenty</i> of top-heavy cheerleaders who managed just fine.
Eliza’s face was every bit as striking as the rest of her, her jaw strong and cheekbones high, her eyes a bright green that seemed to constantly be scanning the environment for any challenges and full, prominent lips that were every bit the definition of pouty, briefly making Dakota wish that she’d found Eliza when they were both a little tipsy at a party so that she could make out with the swim captain.
Maybe a bit more than make out if the night treated them well.
Eliza ran a hand through her blonde hair, cut short (but not so short that a few locks nearly fell into her eyes) and shaved on the sides in a way that gave her a distinctly streamlined look. She looked around thoughtfully, before turning her attention back to Dakota, considering.
“So, we gotta run around and demean ourselves until we can get out of these, don’t we?” Eliza suggested.
“I’d say that was the goal,” Dakota said, lifting her cuffed hand and pulling Eliza’s along for the ride. “These… these are <i>real</i> handcuffs. These aren’t your garden variety sex shop love cuffs, no… no quick safety releases here… somebody really wants us to work to get out of these.”
“I’m not afraid of work,” Eliza said, tugging their wrists back down. “Can’t say I’m a fan of demeaning, though.”
“Yeah, well, it’s April Fool’s Day, and we signed on to this for the sake of our traditions and our girls,” Dakota explained, offering the blonde a peaceful smile.
“Maybe we did, but that doesn’t mean I wanna stretch this out any more than we gotta. I’m feeling pretty fucking exposed out here,” Eliza replied, shivering slightly and looking around nervously.
“Well, you’re not alone, at least,” Dakota replied, looking down at the grass before them with some interest. “And it’s not like you don’t look fucking great exposed. Also, I think I might’ve found our first clue on how to get the fuck out of here.”
If Eliza heard Dakota’s compliment, she didn’t let it show, but her sharp eyes did certainly follow where Dakota was pointing, catching sight of the small tape recorder that had been left on the ground in front of them, the words ‘PLAY ME’ conveniently taped to the front of it.
“Something tells me they want us to play the tape,” Dakota quipped, smiling brightly. “Though I wonder if we should- HEY!!!”
Eliza stepped forward, dragging Dakota along for the ride as she bent over and reached for the tape recorder. Dakota was quick and agile enough that she wasn’t taken down, even though it was close for a step there.
“Sorry,” Eliza said, even though her focus on the task at hand didn’t make her sound all that sorry.
“You know, I think we’re supposed to work together on this,” Dakota explained.
“You really think that?” Eliza replied sarcastically, standing back up as she manipulated the tape recorder in her hand.
Dakota had a few choice answers that she thought she could offer Eliza, but held onto her tongue enough to compose a more constructive response.
“No… and you don’t either,” Dakota answered.
“Yeah, exactly,” Eliza said, straightening up and trying to look thoroughly important. “They want to see us fall on our asses, because that’s the joke of this all, and if falling on our asses is an inevitability, I’d rather get over with it quickly. I know you can keep up, and I’ll need you to keep up, because I don’t want to have to be dragging you around with me.”
Dakota felt a flare of anger, and those choice answers she’d thought of a moment before were seeming more choice by the second, but again she fought back that fiery instinct and thought on more constructive responses to the situation.
“Yeah, they want to see us fall on our asses because it’s funny… but have you considered the possibility that we don’t <i>have</i> to fall on our asses?” Dakota proposed.
Eliza paused, her thumb above the play button on the recorder. “I have, but let’s be honest with ourselves: avoiding that is unlikely.”
“So, there might be some ass-falling, but what if we chose to do it on our own terms?” Dakota continued. “I mean, come on, they probably came up with this whole handcuffed idea because they thought we’d be at each other’s throats since, you know, we’re both bad bitches, but what if instead of being at each other’s throats we actually worked together and gave it our best tonight? Instead of fighting, why don’t we show them what two bad bitches can do when they put their heads together, and if we have no choice but to fall on our asses, we fall on our asses <i>gloriously</i>?”
It was far from Dakota’s best motivational speech, a fact that she was well aware of, but it might have been one of the best she’d ever made while naked. It was enough to make Eliza keep pausing, considering her words for more than just a few seconds.
“I don’t like failure… I’m a fucking winner,” Eliza admitted begrudgingly, before cocking half a smile Dakota’s way. “But if I have to fail, failing <i>gloriously</i> does have a better sound to it.”
Now that… <i>that</i> was a smile that Dakota could work with. There was nothing combative (well, nothing combative toward <i>her</i>, anyway) to it, nothing that told her that tonight was going to be misery, no, this was a smile of raw determination and fighting spirit, the kind that they would need to do whatever their friends had set out for them, even if that turned out to be failing gloriously.
Dakota would have also had to be blind not to also find that smile terribly attractive, as Eliza was certifiably <i>hot</i>, and looking at those full lips parting pursing together before curling into a cocky little grin did have Dakota wondering, if only briefly, what it might feel like to sit on Eliza’s face. The way she eyed Dakota in this moment had the cheer captain wondering if Eliza was thinking a similar thought about her, but these notions were pushed aside as she considered the tape recorder in Eliza’s hand, and her competitive side took over.
“Alright, well, if we’re gonna fail gloriously, or win gloriously, whichever happens first, the only way we can do it is by taking that first step,” Dakota said, eyeing the device. “I’m good to play it if you are.”
“I’m good,” Eliza said, chuckling darkly as she looked at the recorder in her hand. “I’m half-expecting to see a puppet on a tricycle roll out here and tell us we gotta start looking for a hacksaw somewhere around here looking at this thing, but… yeah, I’m good…”
With a nod to herself, Eliza pressed the play button on the recorder, holding it up so they could both listen.
After a quick burst of static, a distorted voice came through. “Hello Dakota, hello Eliza…”
Dakota nodded, agreeing. “Yeah, someone’s definitely watched too many Saw movies.”
“Seriously,” Eliza replied.
The voice on the tape confirmed, “Right now, you’re probably thinking that we’ve all seen too many Saw movies, and you’re wondering if that means a night of pain for you… well, I can assure you that tonight you will not feel one bit of pain… well, you won’t feel one bit of pain that at least one of you won’t enjoy, anyway…”
The voice on the tape chuckled.
Eliza was less amused. “Come on, get to the point…”
“In the grand tradition of Regan Hills High School, you two have been chosen to be the recipients of a particularly <i>unique</i> prank on this April Fool’s Day. Stripped bare and exposed to our leering eyes, you will have to complete a gauntlet of tasks if you wish to retrieve your clothes and the key that will free you from your handcuffs. Each task will test your fortitude, your wits, and your school spirit… work together, fight against one another, however you wish to handle this, know that you will be watched, and that your efforts <i>will</i> be enjoyed. So, in order to find your first clue, let’s kick off these games with a little… capture the flag.”
The moment the tape cut out, one of the stadium lights kicked on, illuminating one of the end zones. Though startled by the sudden light, Dakota couldn’t deny she was impressed with their timing (or, at least their ability to listen in from a distance to know when to turn the lights on), as well as their flair for the dramatic.
The school mascot, Petey Puma, standing in the end zone was also a good touch. The off-the-shelf mascot costume looked like a well-worn approximation of a cartoon puma, with a blue and white Regan Hills High jersey pulled over it to further emphasize the spirit of Puma Pride. What Petey was doing standing there, Dakota couldn’t say just yet, but she was willing to wager that it had something to do with their first task.
Narrowing her eyes, Eliza said, “I see the flag.”
“On Petey?” Dakota asked.
Eliza nodded. “Around the waist; they’re wearing a flag football belt. If that’s our clue, it looks like we’re gonna have to run for it. You ready for a sprint, Dakota?”
Dakota thought about this, watching Petey Puma as they began dancing to music that only they could hear, clearly meant to be taunting the pair of naked girls halfway across the field. As she watched Petey dance, a piece fell into place, and she smirked.
She knew those moves. She knew them well.
“I got a better idea. Walk with me,” Dakota suggested, strolling towards Petey.
“What’s the better idea?” Eliza asked, quickly catching up with Dakota before the handcuffs would have forced her to.
“If I said it, it’d ruin the surprise, but walking over there instead of running like a pair of fools is part of it. Just act natural, cool, and collected,” Dakota suggested, tossing her hair back in a playful display of casualness.
Eliza rolled her eyes. “I don’t know about you, but acting natural while naked?”
She waved a hand over her magnificent, naked body for emphasis, before continuing, “Yeah, it’s not exactly the easiest.”
“Doesn’t get much more natural than naked,” Dakota said cheekily.
Eliza rolled her eyes again. “Not what I mean.”
“I know,” Dakota chuckled. “You <i>really</i> gotta spend more time naked.”
“You know, I may not be one of you cheer sluts, but I spend plenty of time naked, thanks,” Eliza said, defensive as she straightened herself up importantly. “Cheerleaders aren’t the only ones around here who know how to get action, you know.”
“Good, because with a body like yours, it’d be a damn shame if you weren’t,” Dakota replied, keeping her tone light, but thoroughly confident.
Eliza slowed in her tracks for a moment, as if taken off guard by Dakota’s words, but quickly caught up with her, mostly because the handcuffs didn’t offer her any other choice. “So, <i>why</i> are we walking again?”
“Patience,” Dakota said, keeping her tone playful yet mysterious as they neared Petey, who continued to dance in place. “All good things to those who wait… HEY, BEV!”
Petey stopped dancing in place, cocking their head to the side before a feminine voice called out from within. “How’d you know it was me?”
Dakota grinned. Truthfully, she wasn’t 100% certain she had the identity of who was in the school mascot costume correct, but with the dancing she saw coming off this Petey she could claim about 85% certainty, and thought it was as good a stab to take as any. She was happy she was right on this one matter, however, because 18-year-old Bev Montoya was the one person who wore the Petey Puma costume most regularly that she’d have wanted to actually talk to. A cute and perky Latina who stood at a rather commanding 5’10”, despite the mascot’s geekier reputation, Bev had always fit in reasonably well with the cheerleaders and didn’t look down on them in the slightest. If there was one girl she would have wanted to negotiate with, it would have been Bev, as she was sharp and could be reasoned with quite easily.
And if she couldn’t… well, Bev also had a reputation of being on the clumsier side, and if they did have to chase her, well, she and Eliza stood an easier chance of being able to overtake her.
“I’d know those moves anywhere,” Dakota said, mostly truthfully, urging Eliza to follow along with her cautiously as they approached the mascot. “So, they got you to sign on to this, too?”
“I didn’t have a lot going on tonight, so, yeah!” Bev said cheerfully, nodding the big Petey Puma head at Dakota. “And, I mean, seeing you two so hot and naked and chained up like that, that’s is gonna be one of those sights burned into my mind for a long time after this, so, I’d say it’s all worth it!”
For emphasis, Bev tipped the mascot head down, then back up as if she were leering at the cheer and swim team captains before offering them a quick wolf whistle. Dakota smirked. She’d always suspected that Bev might have a bit of a freaky side to her, and she enjoyed the confirmation.
Good. That’d make the next part of her plan a lot easier.
“So, we’re supposed to chase you down? Tackle you and get that flag so we can find out where we’re supposed to go and what we’re supposed to do next?” Dakota suggested.
“That’s the idea!” Bev exclaimed, kicking a leg in the air playfully as she continued to dance ever so slightly away from Dakota and Eliza. “And I plan on giving the two of you one helluva chase, so, you’re gonna be glad they let you keep your shoes once I get going!”
“If you think you’re gonna outrun us in that costume, you’ve got another thing coming,” Eliza said, determined as she rocked her head from side to side to work out a sore spot. “We can take you down, easy.”
“I’m faster than I look,” Bev teased back, waving her arms tauntingly in a ‘come at me’ gesture. “And I don’t gotta worry about some big boobs bouncing all over the place like you do, Eliza; if you think you’re gonna run with those without feeling it now and tomorrow and some days after that, you’ve got another thing coming!”
Eliza scowled at the mascot’s point, which led Dakota to step in. “You know what, Bev, you’re right. We’d have a pretty hard time chasing you down when we’re all exposed like this, and I’m sure you’re faster than you look in that absurd costume.”
“Hey, it’s not absurd!” Bev interjected, scandalized. “That’s not a good way of showing Puma Pride!”
“You’re probably right, but tonight’s not about Puma Pride, it’s about putting us through our paces while our friends watch us do humiliating things, naked and cuffed as we are. Though before I go any further, I will note, it is our Puma Pride that actually had us come here tonight knowing the sort of thing we’d be in for, but that’s immaterial to the fact that if this comes down to a chase, in the end, even though Eliza and I will be most uncomfortable, we’ll still win. You won’t outrun us in that costume for long, we’ll tackle you, take what we need to take from you and we’ll all be tired and sweaty and ready to move on. Rather than taking <i>that</i> drastic a step, I have a diplomatic proposition for you to consider,” Dakota said, smiling coolly.
Eliza looked at Dakota as if she might have been crazy; they were already only a short distance away from Bev, and could have easily tackled the mascot if they wanted to. Nevertheless, Dakota held firmly, tugging against the handcuffs to prevent Eliza from doing anything that premature.
Bev cocked her head, curious. “I mean, they asked me to help on this because they thought it would be funny, and we do have an audience who’s watching, but, if you wanna try diplomacy, you’ve certainly piqued my interest.”
Dropping her voice to a lower, sultrier tone, Dakota continued, “Well, I can’t see your eyes, but you <i>are</i> looking at us, aren’t you? And you’re enjoying what you see?”
Dakota ran a hand up her own body teasingly, cupping and squeezing one of her bare breasts. Seeing what she was doing, and that Bev’s attention on this seemed quite rapt, Eliza grinned and followed Dakota’s example, turning slightly to better jut her ass to the side for Bev’s benefit, running a hand over it and squeezing her immaculate flesh.
Seeing that Bev hadn’t said a word and still watched the handcuffed girls intently, Eliza added, “Oh yeah, she’s definitely liking what she sees… I mean, I don’t know if she’s into pussy or not, but if she wasn’t before tonight, she <i>definitely</i> is now. How couldn’t she be? We’re fucking <i>hot</i>!”
“I like girls, I like guys,” Bev said a little defensively. “Why should someone be forced to choose? It’s not a big deal or anything, but yeah, I’m liking what I see with the two of you, and if you wanted my attention, you got my attention. What’s your diplomatic proposition?”
Eliza looked at Dakota questioningly, wondering if they were going to jump into some variety of sexual favor for the school’s mascot right here on the field. Dakota, however, already had a plan.
“You give us the flag without a chase, and you’ve got an open invite to the rest of the private parties I hold at my house for the cheer squad. I know you’re cute and fit and have a great fucking body, you’d clean up and be drowning in pussy in no time… more pussy than you could ever imagine. How does <i>that</i> sound?” Dakota proposed.
Bev stroked the bottom of her mascot chin with one of her large gloved hands. “It sounds like a lot of words. You got a timeline on when I can expect to be ‘drowning in pussy’? Because I <i>would</i> like to find a good chance to drown in pussy.”
Dakota thought quickly. “How does something right after Spring Break sound? I’ve been dragging my feet on making a plan and this might be the kick in the ass I need to pull the trigger. Nothing too fancy, but still some good times with some sexy bitches. You want in?”
With a firm, quick nod, Bev answered, “Sold.”
Bev then turned around and jutted her ass out so that the flag attached to her costume was more visible. With little patience, Eliza reached out and snatched the flag off of her.
“I’m holding you to that promise, Dakota, because if you don’t, there’ll be hell to pay, and you don’t wanna see the kind of hell that a mascot can make you pay!” Bev called out playfully as she danced away from the pair of handcuffed girls.
Once Bev was out of range, Eliza asked, “Are you really gonna hold to that?”
“Why wouldn’t I?” Dakota replied. “I’ve been looking to have another party, and Bev’s cute as fuck. Why not invite her?”
Eliza nodded, impressed. “Just… didn’t really expect that out of a cheer slut.”
“Well, I’m just <i>full</i> of surprises,” Dakota replied.
Smirking, Eliza replied, “I’m sure on a good night you’re full of all sorts of things.”
Though Dakota was getting used to Eliza’s bluntness, the suddenness that the swim captain said that with actually took her a bit off guard, forcing a smile to form on Dakota’s lips. It didn’t last very long, but it did make the brunette cheer captain give Eliza another appraising glance, before shaking the thoughts it inspired from her head.
Not yet… they had a lot more to do before she could really think like that.
“Alright,” Eliza said, holding the flag up to the dim light to read. “Looks like we gotta head to the Puma Press offices. You need me to lead?”
“I know the way,” Dakota replied, walking off in the direction of the school’s main campus. “I fuck one of the writers there sometimes.”
Catching up to her, Eliza asked, “You too, huh?”
Dakota wouldn’t have thought this was something the two of them were guaranteed to have in common, but it also wouldn’t have surprised her. After all, with every passing day, it seemed like more and more girls had one guy at school in common… and the thoughts of him were enough to bring out the most delicious of shivers from Dakota’s core.
“Yeah, Ryan really gets around, doesn’t he?” Dakota said, sighing pleasantly.
Eliza chuckled. “Ah, I’ve heard about him… I’m sure he does, but not in my neck of the woods. Nah, my writer’s named Hope, and <i>fuck</i> is she an experience…”
“I don’t think I know her,” Dakota said, racking her brain for the entire list of people from their class before settling on her face. “Wait… Hope Harris? The skinny band girl with glasses?”
“I know, I know, she doesn’t look like much…” Eliza explained, her vague defensiveness tinged with a distinct lust that she couldn’t shake. “Certainly not like the kinds of people usually running in our circles, but she came to interview me for the paper one day and she gave me this look that she was down for some action, and I took her up on it and… I mean, girl’s got some moves. I’ve never been topped like she can top me, and that girl’s fucking <i>amazing</i> when it comes to topping… fuck, gets me all excited thinking about it right now.”
Seeing the beautiful blonde swim captain shiver, her thighs tightening so subtly even in midstride, Dakota could only answer, “Fuck, it gets <i>me</i> excited hearing you talk about it.”
“Oh, <i>really</i>,” Eliza chuckled. “Never would’ve called you for that, I thought you’d be the type to always have to be in charge and on top.”
“Then the public image I’ve been cultivating has certainly been a success,” Dakota replied, smiling slyly. “I like my sexual encounters as varied as anyone else, and sometimes one of the flavors that comes in is wanting to be thrown around and topped and fucked like silly until I can’t walk anymore.”
Nodding, impressed, Eliza said, “Well, you’re just full of surprises, aren’t you? Good to know…”
Again, a hot bolt of energy shot through Dakota’s core as she took in how Eliza was looking at her. Now, as a girl with a high sex drive who’d had more than her own share of fun with the many beautiful girls that Regan Hills High had to offer, Dakota knew that she could be reading plenty more into this than was actually there, especially when in the presence of someone who just radiated a sexual energy like Eliza did.
On the other hand, the exact tone that Eliza had stated her last comment with, when combined with the way she looked at Dakota, was pretty fucking blatant, too.
Rather than just sit on this, Dakota felt compelled to ask, “Are you flirting with me, Eliza?”
She kept her tone light, but her intention clear, as Dakota was normally not one to mince words, and wasn’t planning on doing so this time. Eliza, for her part, only gave a bit of a smirk, cocking her head slightly enough to get a better look at Dakota before responding.
“Yeah. Got a problem with that?” Eliza challenged.
Dakota was only human, and she couldn’t help but take another good, long look at Eliza’s impressive body, tight and toned and yet not so much as to cut down on her impressive assets. Dakota couldn’t argue with the fact that she was curious what it would feel like to have the two of their naked bodies pressed up against one another, rolling around and feeling just how good the other one felt… fuck, and she knew that Eliza would be good for it. Dakota had developed something of a sixth sense for when people would and wouldn’t be good in bed, and she didn’t need to consider the blonde swim captain handcuffed to her for long to know she would be absolutely fucking perfect in bed.
“No,” Dakota admitted, smirking right back at Eliza. “But we’re also naked and handcuffed and on school property; if we want to do anything beyond flirt, we’re probably better off seeing all of this through as quickly as possible, yeah?”
“Yeah,” Eliza acknowledged, picking up the pace a little. “Fuck it, let’s see what April Fool’s holds over at the Puma Press…”
***
It wasn’t so much <i>what</i> April Fool’s held at the Puma Press offices as it was <i>who</i>. As ever, the school’s newspaper offices were small and cramped, filled with mismatched pieces of furniture and computers, with nearly a third of the far side of the room taken over by an ancient dark room that still made the rest of the offices smell faintly of developing chemicals. What was new for the occasion, however, was part of one wall that had been given a green felt backdrop, with a stool and a few decorative pillows set up for accents. With the tripod-mounted lights aimed at the backdrop as they were, it looked like they were set up for a photoshoot.
The goth girl standing next to them with a large camera hanging on a strap around her neck only seemed to confirm that.
“Well, fuck me, if that ain’t a fun sight,” 18-year-old Josie Wong said, offering the two naked girls a wolf whistle. “You two are looking fucking <i>hot</i> tonight.”
Pale and busty, with black makeup that matched every bit of her gothy black clothing, the Chinese-American goth princess was someone who had purposefully separated herself from the cheerleaders on average, but as Dakota and Eliza were both the kinds of girls who liked to know a little bit of everyone around school, they could both at least recognize her.
“You’re the next part of the gauntlet?” Eliza confirmed, before sarcastically adding, “Because if it means getting ogled by you, I’d hardly call that much of a challenge.”
“Oh, me staring at you, commenting, lightly objectifying you if you’re into that sort of thing, that’s just a fringe benefit for me… I’m doing this as a favor for Brooke, because she knows how to ask oh so nicely,” Josie said, sighing pleasantly. “But that’s neither here nor there; if you want to pass this next test and get the next clue to where we’ve hidden your key and clothes, one of you is going to have to give up her pride for a little impromptu photoshoot…”
“If it’s about nudes, I’ve got plenty on my phone; this isn’t that big a deal,” Dakota replied.
“Same,” Eliza answered easily. “I see you’ve got the setup, so if you’re here to make sure we take some artsy, high-quality nudes, that’s something, but if you’re trying to embarrass us, that’s not gonna get the job done.”
Josie pursed her black-painted, pouty lips into a dark little smile. “You know, you <i>really</i> ought to let me finish my speech before you go jumping to any conclusions about what this is gonna be about, because I had a whole fucking speech prepared for what to say when you got here, what tortures your friends had dreamed up for you, and it’s like, now that you think you know exactly what’s going on and are so fucking wrong about it, I feel like I should just keep both of you twisting and wondering, because I know torture <i>way</i> better than all your friends do… but then I look at both of your tits (and you ladies have some nice tits, so, congrats there) and I kinda forget what I’m saying and I remember what I’m here for, so, take some friendly advice: stop jumping to conclusions and let me tell you what the fuck you gotta do for the next clue?”
“Fine,” Eliza answered.
“We won’t jump to conclusions, promise,” Dakota said, holding her free hand up.
“Good,” Josie said, continuing to openly leer at them. “Alright, fuck the speech. We need one of you to sit on this stool for a photoshoot… of your <i>feet</i>. I’m gonna take some pictures, nice and classy of your sweet, bare feet, and then we’re going to give them to your friends to share around publicly on their socials… with your consent and encouragement, of course, because your friends know you’re all secretly freaky deep down, but obviously won’t force you into doing something that you’d hate doing. And I really hope one of you is up for this; there’s plenty of freaks around school I know who’ll <i>love</i> getting a chance to look at some feet from one of the hotter, more popular girls in school. And, let’s face it, you also know what they’re gonna do once they get those pictures… so, who’s it gonna be?”
Dakota considered the offer. She liked to think that she had very little shame, and had gotten around school enough to not think she had <i>too</i> much to worry about with having some feet pictures circulating around school… but on the other hand, the thought of the kind of people around school who’d want her feet pics having access to them to do whatever they wanted, it did give her some pause. Not enough to make her rule out the possibility entirely, but enough that she knew she had to carefully weigh her options before doing anything.
This was a consideration that Eliza didn’t have to make for even a second.
“Fuck it, I’ll do it,” she said, walking over toward the photo area and taking Dakota along for the ride.
“Interesting…” Josie said, smirking. “I’d have called the cheer slut for this one… but never underestimate a hot jock, I guess.”
“I <i>can</i> do this too,” Dakota suggested.
Stopping just before the photo shoot backdrop, Eliza turned to Dakota and smiled. “Yeah, I know you can, because you’re hot shit and all that, but you don’t have to be hot shit all the time, not when there’s other bitches out there every bit as determined and driven as you who can carry the weight, too. Now, come on, bend over so I can take my shoes off.”
Dakota crouched down alongside Eliza, allowing the swim captain to unlace and take off her shoes, then her socks. This the quality of a person’s feet was one of those things that Dakota was hardly an expert in, since Josie didn’t seem to be unimpressed, it seemed like they were meeting this challenge of the gauntlet well. Now completely naked, Eliza stood with Dakota at her side, taking a seat on the stool and placing her feet on the cushions that had been set out for the shoot.
“So, we doing this, or what?” Eliza asked, confident, shooting a fun little smile at Dakota before glaring at Josie.
“Ooh, love that confidence…” Josie said, getting down on one knee. “I also love how you look from this angle… really great pussy you got there, Eliza… but, yeah, we’re doing this.”
As Josie snapped several pictures, the darkened room brightening with every flash from the camera, Dakota arched her neck to look over Eliza’s body again. While she’d mostly focused on the blonde’s impressive breasts and tight body, from this angle, the way that Eliza sat with her legs slightly spread, she grabbed a look and grinned.
“She’s right, you really do have a great pussy,” Dakota acknowledged, nodding.
“If you think it looks great, you should get a taste of it,” Eliza replied, pleasantly cocky. “I’m fucking delicious.”
Feeling her mouth water slightly, Dakota bit her lip, letting her eyes wander over Eliza again and trying to keep her composure.
“Don’t tempt me,” Dakota replied.
Ready for that response, Eliza quickly fired back, “And why shouldn’t I tempt you? Tempting you is fun…”
Still snapping her pictures, Josie piped up, “At the rate you two are going, I’d say get a room, but I really don’t want you to get a room… I’d watch the fuck out of you two going at it.”
Dakota and Eliza exchanged glances, but said nothing more about the building chemistry. While this had been a night where the two of them were meant to be at each other’s throats, the unique kind of camaraderie that had formed between them was something Dakota found far more exciting. She didn’t know how much longer this night was meant to go, but if she and Eliza could attack every challenge with the same gusto…
“Alright, another couple dozen photos, then we’ll be good to post!” Josie said with a playfully malevolent glee.
“Take as many as you need, not a problem on this end!” Eliza said confidently.
…yeah, Dakota felt like she had every reason to smile.
***
After the impromptu foot fashion show, and posting Eliza’s pictures to social media, Josie had let Eliza put her shoes back on before giving them their next clue, telling them that the next challenge was going to take place in one of the classrooms of the science building, and that they would know it when they got there. That was an intriguing and vaguely ominous prospect in its own right, but Dakota knew she wasn’t in a position to complain about it.
As the two girls left the Puma Press offices and began to walk across quad, Dakota couldn’t help but say, “Fuck… I have no idea how you could do that so easily.”
“It helps to be able to turn your pride off and on,” Eliza admitted, laughing to herself. “Some things, pride is unquestionable on, but other things, I can turn it off and on as I need to. I wear swimsuits all the time as part of the team, and I’ve got a great fucking body, I know people look at me, and I know what they’re gonna think of me when they’re looking like that, and I say, fuck it, let ‘em look. Let ‘em think. I’m still gonna win, so why worry about the other parts so much? Same deal with the feet. They’re out there, exposed enough already, probably already got all the pervs looking at ‘em… so, fuck it, I swallow my pride, and I put those out there, and whatever happens, happens. I won the challenge, didn’t I? And if the pictures are popular enough, who knows, maybe I can work my way through college selling feet pics if the scholarships aren’t enough.”
Dakota laughed with her. “I know I’m not an expert, but from what I saw in there, you could probably make some serious cash.”
Eliza smirked at Dakota, smoothly asking, “You ogling me, Dakota?”
Quickly, Dakota fired back, “Only as much as you’re ogling me.”
“That’s gotta be a lot, then… I should feel flattered,” Eliza replied, chuckling.
“You should… I’m pretty picky,” Dakota said coolly.
Fuck, she wanted to kiss Eliza right now… truthfully, there was a <i>lot</i> Dakota wanted to do with Eliza right now, but kissing was at the top of that list. Eliza had those perfect, pouty lips that she knew would feel amazing against her own, and she could tell that Eliza knew her shit. Dakota had been with enough guys, and girls for that matter, who talked a big game to know when someone actually was as good as they claimed to be, and Eliza definitely fell into that camp. There was something to her swagger, and her confidence, that was utterly genuine and had a way of making Dakota weak in the knees. Looking at Eliza, taking in the toned tightness of her body and the softness of what curves she did have… fuck, she was hoping for this prank to be over soon, mostly so she could find some way to get Eliza between her legs.
Or to get between Eliza’s.
A moment passed between them then, the two of them stopping on the quad, and time seemed to stop for Dakota. Eliza looked into her eyes hungrily, her own breathing catching up in her chest as it seemed like she was challenging Dakota to make the next move.
“So… we’ve still got a lot we gotta do, but I know you’re feeling this, too,” Eliza said.
“Yeah… yeah, that’s pretty fucking obvious,” Dakota replied.
“We have to finish this, you know it, I know it, but I know there’s some pressure building between us that’s getting distracting… I’m not reading that wrong, am I?” Eliza asked.
“No, no you aren’t. I’m there too, I mean…” Dakota waved a hand over her breasts, pointing to how hard her nipples were. “And this isn’t just because there’s a slight breeze.”
“Feeling’s mutual,” Eliza said, darting her eyes to her own breasts, her own nipples already quite prominent. “So, I think we oughta just release some of that pressure, maybe just make out for like a minute or so, get a couple gropes in if we’re feeling really greedy, and then get a move on so we can finish and then <i>really</i> see what happens next. That sound like an idea to you?”
It <i>did</i> sound like an idea to Dakota, though she wasn’t sure if it was necessarily a good one if finishing their April Fool’s tasks sooner was in the cards. She got the idea that once she and Eliza started kissing and groping that things wouldn’t end there, and that this night would last one hell of a lot longer than either of them were expecting. On top of all of that, they <i>were</i> still being watched… and Dakota didn’t get the impression that her and Eliza’s friends would let them dawdle for very long.
This was confirmed when she turned away from the other girl for just a moment, and saw how the quad had changed in just a matter of moments. A corridor of bodies had been formed by their friends, with cheerleaders and swim team girls acting as walls across the quad, cheering and whistling and cat-calling Dakota and Eliza, making it clear that their path to the science classroom was not going to be an easy journey.
“Once more unto the breach,” Dakota muttered under her breath.
“You can say that again,” Eliza replied, marching forward.
There was an electricity in the air as the girls on either side of them whispered and hissed and giggled, and then began to close in behind them.
SMACK!
Dakota barely yelped as a hand impacted with her bare ass.
SMACK!
“Fuck!” Eliza yowled as another girl spanked her. “If you don’t think I’m gonna get you all for this afterward, you’re dreaming!”
SMACK!
SMACK!
SMACK!
SMACK!
More blows rained down on the girls’ asses as cheerleaders and swim team members alike laughed and got their frustrations out on their respective captains. As this was hardly the first time Dakota had been spanked by her friends (though she normally preferred spanking them), she was able to laugh her way through most of this in a way that Eliza seemed to have a much harder time with. For a girl as imposing as Eliza, Dakota did take a certain pleasure in seeing that she wasn’t completely bulletproof.
The spanks were something that Dakota could have dealt with just fine, but the next part was considerably more inconvenient as the next round of girls began throwing handfuls of blue and white powder at the handcuffed pair while shouting “PUMA PRIDE!” over and over. To say this would be the first color run that Dakota had taken part in would be a lie, but she didn’t like it much the first time, and she was clothed then. For the sheer amount her cursing increased by, it didn’t seem like Eliza was much of a fan either, which Dakota was happy to count on the tally of things the two of them had in common.
It only took a few of these girls throwing the colored powders at them for Dakota and Eliza to be an utter fucking mess, coughing and spitting and head to toe blue and white… but in the end, they made it out just fine.
“Fuck…” Eliza cursed after they hit the end of the gauntlet, before putting on a cocky smile. “You know, if that’s the best they’ve got, I think we’re gonna make it out of this alright.”
Looking the statuesque swimmer over, who managed to look gorgeous in spite of having been color-runned to oblivion, Dakota was inclined to agree. “Yeah… I mean, what else could they throw at us?”
“Whatever they’ve got, we can take it,” Eliza said, smirking down at Dakota.
“Fuck yeah,” Dakota replied, smiling back and holding her hand up.
Eliza joined her in a celebratory high five that confused a number of the girls from the gauntlet, their cheers of triumph and delight at the supposed humiliation of their captains turning to quiet in a hurry. The looks of confusion on their faces, as far as Dakota was concerned, were enough to make her night.
***
Though the swim team and cheerleaders had done an admirable job at setting up a variety of challenges across the campus that were meant to be delightful, if not very harmful, humiliations for their captains, they did a fairly poor job of <i>actually</i> humiliating them.
When they bobbed for dildos in a tub in one of the science classrooms, Dakota and Eliza did an admirable job of coordinating in a way where they could clear the tub in a hurry, swiftly finding the dildo with the clue that led them to their next challenge.
When they were given a canvas in the art classroom to paint using only their boobs and some plentiful amounts of blue and white paint, the two girls jumped in with gusto, creating a work of art that, while it wouldn’t win any awards any time soon, certainly was enough to fulfill the criteria their friends had been looking for.
For girls of such standing, they both snuck into the principal’s office without any fear, using the copier to make photocopies of their asses before taping the copies to the school’s trophy case.
Between every one of these challenges came another gauntlet run of spanks and nipple tweaks and more color run powder, reapplying whatever Dakota and Eliza had managed to slough off during the course of their challenges. Though Dakota found herself thinking that the school would have one hell of a mess to clean up the next day, on realizing that wasn’t her problem (assuming she and Eliza didn’t get caught, of course), she reveled in how much of a mess she and Eliza had become as they ran toward the final challenge of the evening.
At the drama club’s little theatre, to get the clue that would finally lead them to their clothes and freedom, they were told that one of the girls would have to record a video of her faking a <i>very</i> loud orgasm. On this, Eliza was happy to take the lead once again, but since she had already done the foot pictures, Dakota happily shot her down and took center stage on this herself. As a girl who knew what she wanted and how to get it, she generally didn’t like having to fake an orgasm… usually she could get out of those situations well before that became a necessity, but even with her usual standards for picking a partner, there were moments where she fucked up and picked someone who didn’t know what the fuck they were doing (usually some muscly jock who looked great on the surface and didn’t have a lot going for him other than that), and if the guy was nice in spite of his lack of skill, she’d gotten pretty good at a nice, dramatic fake orgasm that seemed real enough.
Well, real enough for a porno, probably.
Taking center stage in the little theatre, a spotlight on her while Brooke stood nearby recording everything on her phone, Dakota steeled herself for what she had to do. Though slightly nervous at first, once she got started, it was easy to lose herself in the part. She was a fucking mess, she’d been run through all sorts of hell tonight, <i>enjoyable</i> hell, to be sure, but hell all the same. She was tired, her ass stung from all the spanks, and she was a fucking mess. Every crevice she had was no doubt filled with blue and white powder, and it’d probably take the better part of a week to shower it all away. Though it had been an exhilarating night, she was looking forward to this being over…
Well, not <i>every</i> part being over. She looked to her side, catching that glint in Eliza’s eyes that sent a distinct thrill through her body. Though she had never had “be handcuffed naked to the swim team captain” on her list of ideas for a good time, Eliza had proven to be great, if often gruff, company, a girl with a similar competitiveness to Dakota’s own, and who had a similar attitude toward whatever challenge they faced. She looked every bit the mess that Dakota herself no doubt was now, but that didn’t stop her from having a cocky look on her face that Dakota couldn’t help but find terribly attractive.
Seeing that certain, exciting energy behind Eliza’s eyes and feeling that twist something inside of her in some pleasurable knots, Dakota looked into the camera on Brooke’s phone and gave the performance of a lifetime. She built up to her fake orgasm slowly, moaning and groaning softly, then louder, her body tensing as she got louder and louder, her body racking with faked pleasure and wild energy until she was crying out and shaking, holding onto Eliza for dear life before she fell over.
Catching her breath, or at least <i>pretending</i> to catch her breath, Dakota then sprung to her feet and looked Brooke in the eye. Somewhere, off in the darkness of the little theatre, a few girls from the cheer squad and swim team clapped for her. If she hadn’t been holding her phone up to record them, Brooke looked like she would’ve done the same, before she finally slid it into her purse.
“Okay, yeah, that… well, that totally qualified as a good fake orgasm…” Brooke said, rifling around in her purse for something.
“And you’ve seen my real ones, so you know how good it is,” Dakota replied.
“Actually, not so sure I’ve seen a real one anymore after what you showed us there, but, hey, do whatever you wanna do, that was fucking hot… whole night was fucking hot, really,” Brooke said, pulling something small from her purse and tossing it their way. “Here, you guys, like, totally earned this.”
Something small and shiny glinted their way, and Eliza caught it quickly, holding the small key in her open hand.
“Fucking finally,” she said, quickly unlocking her side of the cuffs and rubbing her wrist, before handing it to Dakota. “Here.”
“Thanks,” Dakota replied, unlocking her side of the cuffs and dropping them, and the key, to the floor.
It felt good to be free, now… even if she wasn’t quite free of this damned April Fool’s Day yet.
Looking Brooke in the eye, Dakota asked, “And our clothes?”
“Ah, yeah, those,” Brooke giggled, a tinge of mischief to her voice. “Well, about your clothes…”
Dakota was suddenly taken by the image that Brooke and the others might have simply thrown their clothes away, or at least taken them and hidden them away somewhere… it would be a fine punchline to a night like this, after all. Eliza looked like she had similar thoughts, as she took a threatening step toward the petite blonde cheerleader.
“Oh, you better not be fucking us over on this, Brooke,” Eliza said, not raising her fist, but making it clear by her voice that she’d really like to.
Thoroughly unthreatened by her, Brooke giggled. “Oh, ease up, Eliza… you guys did great, and we’re not gonna fuck you over for doing so well… no, I was just, like, drawing it out to get a last little thrill out of the two of you before all the fun was over.”
“It better be over, or you’re the one who’s gonna get one hell of a spanking soon,” Dakota threatened playfully.
“Ooh, promises, promises…” Brooke replied, sighing pleasantly.
“Yeah, and you know I keep my promises,” Dakota shot back, smirking at the perky little blonde.
Brooke smiled up at her cheer captain. “Oh, you <i>totally</i> do… alright, you two’ve been good… made it one heck of an April Fool’s for all of us here. Your clothes are in the cheerleading office. We left the door unlocked for ya since, well, it’d be mean if we didn’t… though you’ll probably want to take a shower first, since I dunno if you two have looked at yourselves in a mirror or other reflective surface lately, because you’re both fucking messes.”
Taking a step forward, Eliza reached down and smacked Brooke on the ass, getting a yelp out of the petite blonde and some chuckles from the others watching in the theatre.
Dakota looked at Eliza, surprised, but the beautiful swim captain simply shrugged. “What? You said you were gonna spank her, I thought it was fair game.”
Brooke rubbed her ass, giggling. “She spanks <i>way</i> harder than you do, Dakota…”
SMACK!
Well, those were words that couldn’t go unanswered, and Dakota didn’t let them as she reached down and smacked Brooke on the ass one more time, the report of it echoing throughout the little theatre. Brooke yelped in a more pronounced way this time, taking a step away from the two formerly-bound girls.
“Okay, okay, I get that was a little too smart-aleck-y, I’m done, we’re done, you’re done… clean up and get your clothes, do whatever you want, have your fun while the rest of us figure out how we’re gonna clean all this mess before tomorrow…” Brooke said, blowing a lock of hair from her eyes.
“You do that… and we’ll do that,” Dakota said, getting another lingering, smug look at Eliza.
Even as messy as they were, she couldn’t help but think that there was a certain Amazonian beauty to the swim team captain, and the way that Eliza eyed her back did something to her deep inside, bringing a heat to her core and between her thighs she found positively yummy.
That wasn’t for now, however… not when a hot shower and a change of clothes was in order, but soon… soon, Dakota would have to figure something out.
Eliza’s mind was clearly in a similar place, though as seemed to be her way, she was more direct about the matter. Once the two girls, now no longer connected at the wrist, stepped outside of the little theatre and began walking toward the quad, Eliza spoke up.
“So, we never got around to that kiss…” she said.
“No, we didn’t… kinda got a little busy there quickly,” Dakota answered.
“Busy and messy, and not the kind of messy that goes really well with kissing,” Eliza admitted, waving a hand over her messy, naked body. “But that doesn’t mean I’ve forgotten about what we talked about, or how good you look naked and not covered in whatever the fuck this powder stuff is… incidentally, we’re not, like, gonna get cancer from this stuff or anything, are we?”
Dakota shrugged, opening the door that led them back outside to the quad again. “Probably not… and I haven’t forgotten either. I need a shower, a long one, and a hot one, and after that, I-“
Eliza cut her off, putting her hand on Dakota’s shoulder as she got a good look outside. The gauntlet had returned, lining their path back to the cheerleading office. All the girls from the theatre, every girl who’d collaborated on this night, were lined up with bags of the colored powders and their eyes looking manic with one last bit of glee.
“What was that you said earlier, ‘once more unto the breach’?” Eliza asked.
“Yeah,” Dakota replied, unconsciously reaching a hand out and finding that she still somehow wished that she and Eliza were still bound together.
Her hand didn’t stay out for long, however… at least not alone. Eliza soon reached out to her and took Dakota’s hand in hers, holding on tight.
“Then… fuck it, let’s make that breach our bitch,” Eliza said.
“Pretty sure that’s not how that’s supposed to go, but you know what? I doubt the Bard could’ve said it better himself. Fuck it,” Dakota replied, gripping Eliza’s hand tightly as the two girls took off toward one final round of color and pain.
***
There was a distinct possibility that Dakota might have had better showers than the one she took that night of April Fool’s Day, but if she had, she couldn’t remember them. Naked and now barefoot, she took the hard spray of hot water with a distinct moan, watching with some relish the colorful trails running off of her body and moaning audibly at the feel of her muscles relaxing and all the tension of the evening leaving her. Somewhere on the other side of the locker room, she could hear Eliza going through a similar ritual, and while she wished she could be there to watch the other girl under the hot water, she also found the privacy welcome in its way.
As much as she wanted to jump Eliza, she also needed this, and if they showered within sight of each other, odds favored that they’d jump each other and never get clean.
So, Dakota spent time washing herself off, scrubbing down with the soap and loofah she kept at school for after particularly intense practices and rubbed the shampoo into her hair, feeling like she had been reborn. While she would no doubt likely be finding streaks of blue and white in unexpected places in the coming days, after the shower, she felt clean… brand new, even, feeling almost as if the night hadn’t occurred.
<i>Almost</i>.
Once the initial layers of the night melted away in the shower, Dakota found herself all too aware of the affect the evening had had on her. It felt like every square inch of her body was still a live wire, every time her hand moved over her breasts or between her legs, even for completely innocent reasons, it felt like she might be set off and explode. Now, she’d been horny before, but usually when she’d gotten <i>this</i> horny in the past, Dakota could find some relief, from her hands, or her vibrator, or one of the many people she had in her contacts list who she could probably make bow down before her with some ease. Tonight, though, she hadn’t been able to find that release, that instant satisfaction, and when in the presence of someone like Eliza, someone that hot and who happened to press a great many of the buttons that turned Dakota on, well… it was easy for her to stay <i>quite</i> charged.
Dakota turned the shower off, and found the locker room to be suddenly silent. Eliza had, clearly, already finished her shower, and Dakota felt a strange stab of urgency at the thought that the statuesque blonde might have already left. She quickly dried herself off with a towel, tying it around her chest to give her some cover, while grabbing another towel to dry her hair as she strolled with some urgency toward the cheerleading office. It wasn’t that she was <i>desperate</i> for Eliza (not that she’d ever admit to it), no, nothing like that… but there was still some unfinished business the two of them had to discuss now that they’d had a chance to clean off.
“Eliza?” Dakota called out, her voice echoing through the girls’ locker room.
There was no response. Alright, so that meant that Eliza had already moved on…
Putting her soap and shampoo back in her locker, Dakota continued to dry her hair, making her way toward the cheerleading office, reasoning that Eliza had likely gone in search of her clothes.
It was a short walk from the locker room to the cheerleading offices, a small series of rooms adorned with cheerleading posters and racks for uniforms, as well as some smaller rooms to relax and change in. The lights were already on when Dakota arrived, and as she entered, she was pleased to find Eliza already in there, standing in the far room of the cheer office, looking at her phone with a towel already wrapped around her own impressive frame.
As Dakota approached, Eliza said, “My feet pics are already pretty popular… word travels fast around here.”
“Yeah, it tends to do that,” Dakota replied, eye-fucking the busty blonde hungrily.
“Probably gonna be a whole lot of stories about what happened here tonight, lots of porny rumors about what the swim and cheer captains got up to. Most’ll probably think they’re just rumors or gossip, but some… those who know how things really work around here, they’ll know they’re true,” Eliza said, setting her phone down on a nearby chair and looking at Dakota.
Dakota normally had a smart remark for any situation, but standing here like this, the two of them looking at each other with the tension of the night having built to a fever pitch… she was suddenly out of words. She tossed the towel that she’d been drying her hair with aside, dark, wet locks of hair falling around her face as she looked to Eliza lustfully.
The blonde swim captain ran a hand through her own short hair thoughtfully, then bit her lip.
“So,” Eliza said, her voice low and full of promise as she looked Dakota up and down.
“Yeah,” Dakota replied.
Without a word, Eliza freed the towel from under her arms, dropping it to the floor and standing in the cheerleading office deliciously nude. With new eyes, no longer clouded by competition, Dakota took in the lithe, muscular beauty standing in front of her, those beautiful, long legs, her full, round breasts with hard nipples begging to be sucked, her hairless pussy… fuck, Dakota could practically smell Eliza’s arousal filling the room, or maybe it was her own.
More than anything else about Eliza, though, it was her lips that captivated Dakota. Those full, moist lips, parted just slightly, looking so fucking <i>ready</i>.
Biting her lower lip, Eliza challenged, “So, ready to put your money whe-“
Dakota didn’t let Eliza finish her sentence, closing the distance between the two of them quickly and pushing Eliza against the wall, kissing the busty blonde on the mouth with a fire that would’ve burned the school to the ground if it could have been manifested as real. Those toned curves of Eliza she’d spent the night ogling were now hers to run her hands over, feeling and knowing this girl who’d gotten her so fucking hot and bothered… and those lips… <i>fuck</i> her lips were perfect to Dakota. Though taken off guard by the suddenness of Dakota’s attacks, Eliza quickly began to kiss her back in kind, the two of them kissing with a fiery passion, soft, talented lips against soft, talented lips, their tongues darting in to explore each other’s mouths, first experimentally, then almost as if they meant to do battle with each other.
Dakota knew that Eliza had a distinctly dominant personality, but she meant to show her that two could play that game quite easily.
Eliza broke the kiss, pushing Dakota away just enough for the two girls to catch their breaths, and exchange a smile.
“Okay, that was worth the wait,” Dakota said breathily.
“Why wait?” Eliza said, reaching down and pulling up the back of Dakota’s towel.
Dakota groaned as she felt Eliza’s strong hands dig into her ass, squeezing and massaging one of her favorite parts of herself. Moaning as she was groped so perfectly, she leaned her head against Eliza’s shoulder, rocking her hips just enough to make sure the gorgeous blonde could get the best handful possible.
Kissing Dakota’s neck and continuing to grope her ass, Eliza said, “Fuck… I’ve wanted to grab this ass all night… fuck, it’s so fucking perfect…”
“It sure is,” Dakota said, kissing Eliza’s neck in kind and enjoying the moans it got. “Just like… fuck… I’ve been staring at your breasts all night…”
“I know,” Eliza replied. “They’re fucking great, aren’t they? Not always the best for swimming, but… fuck… they do bring the stares. And I’ve <i>definitely</i> seen you staring.”
“I haven’t been hiding it,” Dakota shot back, kissing Eliza on the lips.
Eliza moaned into Dakota’s lips, squeezing her ass particularly hard. Dakota continued rocking her hips to give Eliza better access, and the blonde certainly took it, squeezing and massaging her cheeks, gripping them and separating them just enough to cause an intense jolt of pleasure to her asshole, one that spread through Dakota’s body and made her shiver. Fuck, if Eliza wanted to get a few fingers up her ass right here, Dakota wouldn’t have objected for even a second.
Eliza, on the other hand, had a <i>much</i> better idea than that.
Whispering into Dakota’s ear, she said, “Suck my fucking tits… you know you wanna…”
This was true, and all Dakota needed to jump in wholeheartedly. She slid her hands up to cup Eliza’s breasts, squeezing them and lifting them closer to her face. While they weren’t the biggest tits she’d ever seen (there were some exceedingly stacked girls on the cheer squad), they looked absolutely tasty. <i>How</i> tasty they were, she didn’t know yet, but there was only one way to be sure.
Leaning in, she enthusiastically kissed the tops of Eliza’s breasts, before teasing first one nipple, then the other, with her tongue. The throaty, sultry sounds that this pulled from deep in Eliza’s core were enough to kindle the fire within her, and she couldn’t help but dive in, sucking on Eliza’s nipple, applying just enough pressure to excite most any girl while flicking it with her tongue. She loved looking up into Eliza’s eyes as she did this, knowing the power she had, controlling the other girl’s pleasure and knowing that she was responsible for her looking so completely and utterly gorgeous.
“Fuck… you’ve… you’ve got some talent there, Dakota…” Eliza groaned, running her fingers through the cheer captain’s hair as she pulled her head closer to her breast. “Harder… come on, suck me harder… fuck, so nice…”
Dakota obliged her, switching breasts to lick and suckle even harder, and while this was certainly fun, the fire burning in Dakota couldn’t be put out so easily.
Wrapping her arms around Eliza, Dakota dragged her across the room, forcing her towards the couch. The thought of falling on top of Eliza and having her way with the lusty blonde certainly had its appeals, but Eliza was not so easily dominated. Bringing her hands up to Dakota’s waist at the last second, she grabbed the brunette cheerleader and spun her around, tossing her onto the couch and then climbing atop her, pinning Dakota down.
“Seems… we’re evenly matched,” Dakota said, her skin flush from lust.
“Seems like it,” Eliza said, rocking her shoulders from side to side.
The sight of Eliza’s breasts hanging above her face, jiggling as she shook them, it did a lot to keep Dakota nice and motivated. She arched her neck, catching one of Eliza’s nipples in her mouth and sucking, hard, running her tongue in quick little circles over her firm nub and driving the blonde wild. She moaned lusciously, grinding against Dakota as she did so.
“Mmm, fuck… oh, you’re good at this… so <i>fucking</i> good at this… holy fuck… mmm, I’m gonna have to stop saying so many mean things about cheerleaders… you keep sucking me… touching me like this, it’s gonna change my mind on a lot of things, fuck… oh, god, you’re so fucking good at this, you’re a good little slut, aren’t you?” Eliza intoned.
The swim captain looked down at Dakota with a mask of such lust that she thought she might cum there and then at the sight of her. That wasn’t going to happen, of course, but Dakota’s efforts were enough to motivate Eliza into pushing things further, as she soon tore at the towel wrapped around the brunette cheerleader until she was every bit as naked as her.
Dakota didn’t need much motivation to suckle at Eliza’s tits with a greater enthusiasm, but now that she’d suddenly been stripped just as bare, it seemed as good a moment as any to show the blonde what she could do with her mouth. Wrapping her arms around Eliza to hold her more closely, she sucked on Eliza’s nipples with a forceful enthusiasm, enough that she worried she might cause Eliza pain at first, but when she only got moans and writhing on top of her in response, she knew that she’d made the right call.
Sliding her hands down Eliza’s back so she could grip her impressive ass, Dakota groped her as she feasted on her tits, enjoying the chance to pleasure this girl she had lusted over for the better portion of the night so thoroughly.
While pleasuring Eliza like this certainly brought Dakota a lot of joy, that didn’t mean she didn’t intend to take her own pleasure either, no… though she was content with feasting upon Eliza’s perfect tits for now, that fire that had been growing inside of Dakota felt ready to burst out at any moment, and that moment felt sooner and sooner with every passing second. Finally, with her mouth full of nipple and her hands full of one of the best asses she’d ever felt, Dakota could take it no more.
Wrapping her arms tightly around Eliza, Dakota wrestled herself on top of the blonde swim captain, who looked rather stunned at their reversal of fortunes.
“Well, I can’t say I don’t like this position,” Eliza purred, leaning up to kiss Dakota. “It does have certain benefits for me…”
To emphasize this, she went back down to squeezing Dakota’s ass, something that made the cheerleader moan pleasurably, but not enough to distract her.
“And me…” Dakota replied, looking down at Eliza with sultry eyes.
“So, what do you have in mind?” Eliza teased, kissing Dakota again. “You want me to suck on your boobs? You gonna fuck me? You-“
Reaching for Eliza’s shoulders, Dakota pinned the swim captain to the couch forcefully. “You’ve been teasing me all night, and looking so fucking hot I didn’t know what I was going to do with myself. It’s my turn, now…”
“Oh, it’s your turn?” Eliza taunted back. “Your turn for what?”
Dakota practically growled, her need was so great, as she climbed over Eliza. In spite of her taunting and vocal defiance, Eliza seemed all too happy to let Dakota crawl over her, especially if it meant getting to see more of her up close.
“I’ve been obsessing over your lips all night, wondering how they’d feel on pretty much every part of my body, if I’m being honest… and I think I’m going to be a greedy bitch and just jump right in and sit on your fucking face,” Dakota explained, straddling Eliza’s face and hovering her pussy only inches over the beautiful blonde’s mouth.
“So, it’s gonna be that simple, huh? You’re just gonna sit on my face?” Eliza teased.
“For starters,” Dakota replied.
“Well, talk’s cheap,” Eliza replied cockily. “I see a pussy hovering above my mouth right now, one that looks, smells, and no doubt tastes absolutely great, and all you’re doing is <i>hovering</i> when you could be smothering me wi-“
Dakota sat down on Eliza’s face with a heavy sigh, rolling her eyes dramatically as she looked down at the blonde girl between her legs. “Do you always talk this much, or- OHHHHHH FUUUUUUUCK!”
True, Dakota didn’t get to finish her question, but when she finally felt those lips she’d been obsessing about closing over her pussy and felt the forceful tongue that came with them exploring her sex, she really didn’t need to finish her question, did she?
Dakota had gotten the vibe from just talking to Eliza earlier that the swim captain was likely good at eating pussy, and as she felt the blonde between her legs really digging in, she was forced to admit that she was wrong.
Eliza’s pussy-eating skills weren’t “good.” They were “fucking phenomenal.” Eliza barely needed any instruction or guidance, quickly exploring Dakota’s body and seeming to know exactly what she needed to do. Dakota’s eyes rolled back into her head as pleasure surged through her body, with Eliza knowing exactly how she needed to be treated, where she needed to go hard, where she needed to go gentle, every little trick she would need to do to bring out the surges of pleasure and raw, physical joy that made Dakota’s toes curl and the world around her seem to evaporate in a haze of meaninglessness as the ecstasy overtook her and rolled over her body in powerful waves. Every nerve in her body seemed to be connected to her clit in this very moment, every sensation threatening to take over her world and make her a screaming, quivering puddle as Eliza brought her close to the edge in a matter of seconds.
It was in her innate skill, however, that Eliza was also able to <i>keep</i> Dakota on edge, bringing her close to it before slowing down and exploring different recesses of her pussy, teasing her with tongue and fingers alike, slipping her middle finger most of the way inside of Dakota before pulling back. Even though Dakota was the one sitting on Eliza’s face, it was Eliza who looked up at Dakota challengingly, almost as if she was daring her, saying, “Is that all you’ve got?”
Dakota had been with some determined, and skilled, partners in the past, but as Eliza silently asked her that, this was perhaps the first time that Dakota found herself wondering if this actually <i>was</i> all she had. She was usually so dominant and forceful when it came to her sexual partners that it felt almost strange to confirm she’d found her match in Eliza. Dakota didn’t often find her match, and certainly not in the strange way they’d come together tonight, and yet here they were… two girls who were evenly matched in aggressiveness and skill, playing out this erotic scenario the only way it truly could unfold.
Dakota was tempted… <i>sorely</i> tempted… to show Eliza everything she had, but when her body was set on betraying her every attempt at exercising willpower, it didn’t feel possible. Even with Eliza’s expert edging, the way she so perfectly ate Dakota’s pussy and kept her on the precipice, there was no preventing what had to happen. Dakota could feel something inside of her building, mixed pleasures swirling and intertwining inside of her, tightening and coiling around one another until it felt like she could hold on no more, before the explosion inevitably came.
“FUCK!” she cried out, bending over and clutching onto the couch for support. “Holy fuck, goddamn it, I’m… fuck… fuck… fuck, you’re making me… AHHHHHHHHH!!!”
Dakota did actually try to form words to best express how she was feeling, but words were pretty difficult to form when that pleasure that had built within her finally snapped, exploding and filling her body with an overpowering ecstasy that made it difficult to hold herself up. Wave after wave of pleasure rolled through her, spreading outward from her pussy until she could feel it in her fingertips and toes, her body spasming and shaking violently as she cried out those formless wails that only the truest of pleasures can bring.
With her hands braced against the couch, and with Eliza wrapping her arms around her, Dakota was able to keep from falling over, if only just. In the brief moments when she could keep her eyes open, she looked down at that beautiful face between her legs, and even with her face buried between Dakota’s thighs and covered with a nice glaze of the cheerleader’s gushing pussy juices, Eliza looked smug as fuck.
Dakota had to grant the swim captain that: she had every reason to be smug about this.
As the last whimpers abated, Dakota collapsed onto the couch. Taking her chance to switch things up, Eliza slid out from under Dakota, smacking her lips loudly while she shifted to getting up on her knees behind the face-down, ass up cheerleader.
“You taste good… <i>really</i> good,” Eliza said, running her hands over Dakota’s ample ass, squeezing and groping her shamelessly. “I’ve been with some girls who… yeah, horror stories, but your pussy, mmm… I could eat that for a while and keep coming back for seconds…”
“Yeah, well… god…” Dakota moaned, still trying to put even partial sentences together. “You’re, fuck, you’re so fucking good at that.”
“I should be… god knows I get enough practice,” Eliza said, gripping Dakota’s ass cheeks and pulling them apart. “Ah, fuck… seeing a sight like this, almost makes me wish I was a guy… if I had a cock, I could wreck your holes and make you beg for more.”
“I think… you’ve proven yourself capable… of doing that without the need for a cock,” Dakota replied.
“Fair,” Eliza said, running her fingers down between Dakota’s thighs. “But guys make them look like so much fun… ah well, I can always make do.”
The way she slid two fingers into Dakota’s dripping cunt, the brunette cheer captain thought that Eliza was more than making do. In point of fact, she knew what she was doing with her fingers every bit as much as she did her mouth, pumping them in and out of Dakota’s tight, clutching cunt with a perfectly slow speed, enough to keep Dakota interested without overwhelming her after such a devastating orgasm. With effort, Dakota pushed herself up onto her elbows, looking back at the blonde kneeling behind her, feeling those pumps and slight twists of Eliza’s fingers, looking into her eyes as she watched Dakota with that perfect smug superiority of hers, knowing how fucking good she was, thinking she had to be the fucking best.
With that tight body, tits like hers, and those perfect lips curled into such a perfectly slutty smile, Dakota could well understand <i>why</i> Eliza thought she was the best of the best… but that didn’t mean she couldn’t show Eliza that she was every bit her match.
Growling slightly, Dakota got on her hands and knees, then quickly whirled on Eliza, pushing the busty blonde until she fell away against the couch.
“The fuck?” Eliza laughed.
“You’ve had your fun,” Dakota growled again, dropping to her knees on the floor and forcing Eliza’s legs apart. “It’s my fucking turn.”
“Oh, it’s your fucking turn, huh?” Eliza replied, challenging. “You think you can do better than I did to you? Because it looked like I did a pretty fucking great number on your sweet pussy…”
Dakota could have noted that, in spite of Eliza’s big talk, she put up no resistance whatsoever to Dakota spreading her legs, and sliding her ass more toward the edge of the couch. In fact, Eliza was even leaning against the back of the couch, reaching up to cup her own breasts, flicking and squeezing her nipples as she watched Dakota between her legs. Dakota, for her part, was trying not to lose it with her face mere inches away from Eliza’s dripping cunt. It was flattering in a way to see how excited she’d become through their fooling around, and with her prominent lips just begging for attention… well, in this moment, Dakota couldn’t recall ever having seen a more perfect pussy. She leaned in, slightly, just enough to get a whiff of Eliza’s warm, musky scent, inhaling it and feeling that warmth travel through her body as an overwhelming lust took over her mind and soul.
“Yeah, it’s my fucking turn,” Dakota hissed, leaning in to kiss Eliza’s inner thighs. “You might think you’re hot shit, but let me tell you… you’re not the only one in this room who’s got a lot of experience eating pussy.”
Eliza moaned, softly, never taking her eyes off of Dakota as she ran her fingers through the cheerleader’s hair. “I’m sure… a mouth like yours, what you did with my boobs, I can see how you’d think you were that good, but-“
Dakota wasn’t going to give Eliza the status of smuggest bitch in the room right now, no… no, she had her in a position where she could truly show off, and she was going to show off. The brunette cheerleader cut Eliza off by closing her mouth over her pussy, running her tongue quickly over every inch she could manage before thrusting inside the busty blonde above her. It was, admittedly, not exactly the most effective move, but getting her tongue almost all the way inside of Eliza had the double benefit of making the gorgeous blonde cry out in ecstasy while also shutting down whatever remained of her smug speech. Instead, she seemed content to keep her fingers in Dakota’s hair, holding the cheerleader close.
“Oh god… oh fuck… that’s… yeah, okay, maybe you are… close… close to being as good as you think you are… I can’t say for sure yet, but… ah… god, keep doing whatever it is you’re doing, it feels sooooo good,” Eliza chuckled, dropping her head back and rocking her hips against Dakota’s mouth.
This wasn’t something Dakota needed a lot of encouragement to do, as Eliza’s pussy was positively delicious. A little sweet, a little musky, and perfectly tangy in that utterly feminine way that drove her wild whenever she was with a girl. Fucking Eliza like this wasn’t just something she wanted to do, no… it was her <i>fucking</i> pleasure to do it, and she wanted to make it clear how much of a pleasure it was every bit as much as she wanted to show off for the woman above her.
Pulling her tongue from Eliza’s suddenly <i>quite</i> juicy cunt and without ever breaking eye contact, Dakota brought her tongue over Eliza’s clit and began running it in a firm L-shape, over and over and over again, making Eliza moan lusciously, her pussy practically flooding with juices as she went down on her. The way Eliza gripped her hair was almost painful, but so far in only a pleasurable way… a way that Dakota could certainly take if it meant getting to do more of this. She licked with a greater passion, slipping a finger inside of the blonde and fucking it in and out of her.
“GodDAMN, that’s good!” Eliza groaned, laughing and dropping her head back again as she pushed her pussy up against Dakota’s face. “Okay… okay… I think… mmm… yeah, okay, yeah, you’re as good as you think you are… holy fuck… definitely as good as… mmm… fuck, I might have to take back every mean thing I’ve ever said about the cheerleaders, and there’s been a lot of them… fuck… god… you’re gonna keep me… ohfuck… I dunno what you’re keeping me, but that’s so fucking good, I don’t fucking care!”
Eliza took her hands from Dakota’s hair, reaching up to squeeze and flick her nipples in time with Dakota’s own oral efforts, looking like she would positively lose it at any moment.
It took a lot for Dakota not to be perfectly smug in this moment, stopping and giving a nice little speech to Eliza to boast about how fucking good she was, all it took was a look upward for her to push aside thoughts of anything but sex. Looking up at Eliza like this, all she could see was a being of raw sex, her body tensed with need and building release, her large breasts rising and falling with every hitching breath, her eyes glazed over as she looked down at Dakota with a growing desperation. Dakota had had a varied and intense sex life over the course of senior year, and she knew she would continue to have one well past tonight, but in the moment it sure felt like she couldn’t possibly have seen a sexier sight than Eliza on edge like this.
Of course, she knew if she kept at it, she’d see something much, <i>much</i> sexier, and that was why she didn’t slow down. No, Dakota kept going, faster and harder, licking and sucking Eliza’s clit while pumping her finger in and out of her hot, clutching cunt, watching as Eliza only got more and more wound up, grunting and groaning and squeezing her nipples and rocking her hips against Dakota’s face with such intensity you’d have thought she was bouncing up and down on a cock. Eliza was losing herself to her pleasure, and Dakota was getting lost in Eliza’s pleasure in kind, only spurred on by the sudden surge of the swim captain’s juices.
Her dirty talk certainly didn’t hurt, either.
Eyes rolling back into her head, Eliza groaned, “Jesus Christ, fucking hell, you’re… god… you’re so fucking good at that… know my pussy better already than… mmm… fuck, god, I might have to keep you, might have to ask you to do this for me all the time, holy shit, please, keep going… ohgod, keep going, keep fucking me like that, keep fucking me… lick me… suck me… fuck me… keep fucking me, Dakota, like that, like that, you’re gonna make me cum… make me cum… <i>please</i> make me cum, I’m so close, so <i>fucking</i> close, and I’ve been good to you… and you’ve been good to me, fuck, we had such a night and I’m gonna cum, gonna cum if you keep doing that to me, yesyesyes, like that, harder, harder, fuck me harder you cheer bitch, fuck me, like that, fuck my slutty hole, ohfuck, keep, keep, keep… AHHHHHHHHHHH FUUUUUUUUUUUUUCK!!!”
Now, Dakota had always thought she was an impressive squirter when she really lost herself to a proper orgasm, but as Eliza broke down and came, she realized that this girl could positively put her to shame. A glorious rush of juices splashed against Dakota’s face, and she lapped it up eagerly, not minding the mess and reveling in the power she held in this moment. Eliza moaned and cursed and shook as if she’d been struck by lightning, her filthy mouth lost to shapeless sounds of guttural pleasure that coursed through her body. There was no dignity, no control here, just a raw release of built-up passions that neither of them could stop even if they wanted to.
And certainly, neither of them wanted to.
Dakota continued licking and sucking and fingering Eliza through her orgasm, unmindful of her cries of overwhelming pleasure. They were music to her ears, of course, but they could hardly make Dakota let up with her efforts, not when things felt so fucking delightful.
Finally, the tension left Eliza’s body and she collapsed into the couch, panting and looking down at Dakota with a drowsy, lust-filled gaze.
“Not bad… for a cheer slut… <i>holy</i> fuck… holy fuck, you know how to fuck…” Eliza laughed, massaging her tits as she stayed lost in the moment.
“I’m not the only one,” Dakota said, climbing up onto the couch and straddling Eliza’s hips. “You’ve… holy fuck, you’ve got some serious talent there yourself.”
“Thanks,” Eliza replied, pulling Dakota in for a long, luscious kiss.
Dakota had no problem with this, at all, eagerly making out with the stacked blonde beneath her, holding tight to her and taking more than a small amount of glee for the little jolts of pleasure that came out when their nipples rubbed against each other. It was an exciting little thrill, jolts of electricity passing through them and making the two girls shudder and shake as they continued to make out.
“Well, I don’t know about you, but this is easily one of my best April Fool’s Days ever…” Dakota said between kisses, chuckling softly.
Eliza laughed with her. “Yeah, <i>this</i> right here… this is the kind of prank I could do with more of in my life.”
“Agreed,” Dakota replied, leaning in to kiss Eliza’s neck.
Eliza growled appreciatively, leaning in to kiss Dakota’s neck in kind and reaching down to squeeze her ass again.
“Ah, fuck… fuck, that feels so good…” Dakota murmured.
“Yeah?” Eliza groaned back softly, squeezing Dakota’s ass some more. “Mmm… never would’ve taken you for an ass slut, not on sight anyway, but when you’ve got an ass this nice, I don’t see why you wouldn’t be…”
“You took the words right out of my mouth,” Dakota replied, kissing Eliza’s neck some more. “I’ve got a great ass, and ignoring it would be a damn shame… just like ignoring yours would be…”
Dakota reached down, slipping a hand behind Eliza to squeeze her luscious ass. Though the positioning was difficult considering the fact that Eliza was still sitting down on the couch, Dakota’s intent was clear enough, and Eliza’s smile registered enough interest to prove that it hadn’t been a bad move on Dakota’s part.
Purring softly, Eliza replied. “You wanna fuck my ass, Dakota? Because I’d let you fuck my ass… I bet you’d really know how to make the best of a girl’s ass…”
“You’d be right,” Dakota said, straightening herself up in Eliza’s lap, reaching down to squeeze her nipples. “And I think I’d like to do that, too… but that’s not how I want to fuck you now.”
“It isn’t?” Eliza asked with a raised eyebrow, pulling Dakota in so she could suckle at one of the cheerleader’s nipples.
Dakota moaned, softly, closing her eyes in the face of the pleasure that Eliza was giving her. It was clear that the other girl was playing with her… but Dakota was not one to be easily distracted when she was horny.
“No,” Dakota growled, reaching a hand down between them and fingering Eliza’s clit.
Eliza’s eyes went wide with the sudden contact, and she had to bite her lip to keep the moan at bay, but when her mind fully caught up with her body, she easily rocked back against Dakota’s hand, further encouraging the brunette cheerleader to finger her.
“Good move… good <i>fucking</i> move,” Eliza admitted. “But in this position… not that hard… for me to do this…”
Eliza reached down between the two of them as well with her own hand between Dakota’s legs, fingering her with every bit as much enthusiasm as Dakota touched her. Dakota was less restrained, feeling no need to hide her moan as she threw her head back, grinding on Eliza’s hand while fingering the other girl all that much harder.
“What’s to say… this wasn’t my idea all along…” Dakota replied, leaning back into Eliza and fucking her all that much more enthusiastically. “That I didn’t want you, face to face like this… wanting to look you in the eye while we fucked each other… this way, neither of our mouths are… ohgod… neither of our mouths are occupied, and we can look at each other, touch each other, fuck each other, kiss-“
Eliza emphasized this latter point, moaning and pulling Dakota in for a long, deep kiss, before breaking that exact same kiss and fingering the cheerleader all the harder.
“You’ve sold me on the position… you don’t have to keep selling me on the position… this feels good, <i>we</i> feel good, and we’re fucking… and it feels fucking good… you don’t have to sell me on shit, just keep touching me like that and… fuck…” Eliza replied, fingering Dakota’s clit even more enthusiastically.
Dakota didn’t <i>need</i> to know she’d won anything in this moment, but as it was, it didn’t hurt her ego in the slightest to have forced Eliza into a position of admitting she was right, and since that deserved some reward in its own right, well, that meant she had no problem giving Eliza the best fingering she’d ever received. Dakota liked to think she was <i>quite</i> experienced when it came to her fingering game, and the way Eliza responded to her so perfectly, it felt good to have that confirmation.
She would be the first to admit, however, that she wasn’t exactly assessing the situation with the clearest head. Eliza’s fingers were magic on her clit, knowing exactly how to touch her, with just the right pressure, just the right speed… fuck, if she’d thought Eliza’s mouth was magical earlier, her fingers might have been even better, hard as that was to believe. Dakota felt the pressure building in her again through their mutual efforts, rolling waves of pleasure spreading throughout her body, occasionally punctuated by individual jolts that threatened to make everything spill over.
“Fuck…” Dakota replied, leaning into Eliza so she wouldn’t have to support herself.
“Yeah… yeah, I get it… holy fuck, you’re so fucking hot…” Eliza moaned into Dakota’s ear.
“Feels so good…” Dakota replied.
“Which part?” Eliza laughed. “’cause from where I’m sitting, it feels like everything and… ah, fuck… whatever you’re doing down there, don’t stop… fuck, I haven’t been fingered this good in a long time.”
“Same… I think… everything’s kind of blurry now, kind of hard to compare anything… kind of hard to know anything right now,” Dakota admitted, fucking against Eliza with a greater fervor and laughing. “Fuck… there’s… mmm… we did just have a whole April Fool’s night before this, right?”
“Might’ve been tonight,” Eliza replied with her own laugh. “Might’ve been a week ago, I dunno… how long have we been fucking?”
“Not long enough,” Dakota replied, moaning. “God, I’m so wet…”
“Me too… so fucking wet, so hot… god, keep going…” Eliza moaned, rocking her hips with a greater desperation against Dakota’s hands.
“Gonna cum for me again?” Dakota asked, staring into Eliza’s eyes.
Biting her lip, Eliza nodded. “Yeah… fuck, yeah, I’m gonna cum again…”
Dakota stayed where she was, trying to brace herself so she could keep looking Eliza in the eyes. “Me too… me too… just, let’s keep going, just a little longer, I think we can…”
“I’m trying… it’s not easy,” Eliza replied.
“I know… it isn’t…” Dakota said, kissing her lover. “But if we just-“
“I know,” Eliza interrupted. “You’re… oh, fuck… fuckfuckfuck… keep going, keep going, right there…”
“Almost…” Dakota whimpered, her fingers a blur over Eliza’s clit. “Come on… come on…”
The two girls looked into each other’s eyes, almost daring the other to finish before them. Though they were still thoroughly lost in each other, nothing could change the fact that Dakota and Eliza were also incredibly competitive girls, and once it became clear that there was a finish line to be crossed and that one of them was going to break the other first, a sort of silent (well, silent save for the moans and wet fingering sounds) contest was agreed upon. With both of them calling on their stores of skill and self-restraint, they fingered each other swiftly, staring at each other and smiling as their bodies tensed and their hands ran slickly with each other’s juices.
And in the end, this was a contest that truly had no losers. Dakota and Eliza made each other cum in such quick succession that it was almost impossible to say who truly broke first, and by this point, neither of them was in a place to really care about much of anything except letting their orgasms roll through them. The two girls, unafraid of getting truly loud, cried out in pure ecstasy as the pleasure overtook them. While Eliza let loose with a deeply guttural sound that threatened to shake the windows, Dakota couldn’t help that she was a screamer, throwing her head back and letting loose with a wail of raw animalistic pleasure.
Their bodies writhed together in a spasmodic, violent dance that had them clinging to each other even as they fingered each other through the last remnants of their climaxes, and when they finally went limp against each other, they took a moment to truly take in what had occurred. Out of breath and weak from what they had brought out in each other, the two girls collapsed into each other, exchanging soft, wet kisses as they came back to their senses.
Dakota’s senses returned slowly, the world around her a little slow and bleary from what Eliza had done to her. She looked down at the beautiful blonde beneath her, expecting a look of recognition, understanding even, that they had earned a decent break for perhaps some cuddling and making out.
What she got instead was a certain smug smile from the lusty Eliza, those full, moist lips curled up in a look that felt positively devilish. It was a look that felt at once overwhelming and intensely erotic, as Dakota knew that what would happen next was something where she would <i>not</i> be the one taking the lead.
Sure enough, Eliza soon wrapped her arms around Dakota and threw her onto her back on the couch, before standing over her. The two girls spent a moment looking at each other with animal appraisal, saying nothing while their eyes said everything. Dakota looked up at the goddess standing over her, the swim team captain positively glowing in the aftermath of her orgasm, a slight sheen of sweat formed on her toned, curvaceous body. The way Eliza looked at her, Dakota knew she had to look pretty damn good too… and honestly, she knew she did. Dakota had always had a great “just-been-fucked” look, and even though she knew that she had to be a bit of a mess, flushed from exertion and glistening with their mutual juices, she knew her lean frame, juicy pussy and pert breasts had to look fucking great to the girl standing over her.
“Decisions, decisions…” Eliza said, running a hand down the side of her body. “Fuck, all the things I could do to you…”
“I’d think about doing them all to you, but you threw me around, which means you want to take me, and since I really don’t mind being taken now… fuck it, do your worst,” Dakota chuckled.
Eliza licked her lips, looking over Dakota’s body predatorially. “I’m tempted… sorely, <i>sorely</i> fucking tempted, but I won’t be that selfish. Well, not <i>just</i> that selfish.”
Before Dakota could come up with an adequately cocky response, Eliza had climbed on top of her, straddling Dakota’s face before falling onto the dark-haired cheerleader and burying her own face between her legs. With a pussy just inches above her mouth, Dakota happily wrapped her arms around Eliza’s ass and pulled the blonde’s pussy onto her mouth, while Eliza dove in just as quickly and began to eat Dakota out once more.
In seconds, it was a messy, frantic 69, and the two of them wouldn’t have had it any other way. There was little patience or exploration needed anymore, as these two girls had become quite accustomed to what got each other off by this point. Now it was just a position for the two of them to go wild on each other, and go wild they did. Their bodies, at once soft and toned, sheened with sweat and slick with their mutual juices quite easily smeared from their passionate encounter, conformed to each other perfectly, the two girls unable to get enough of each other as they feasted and groped and held each other close. Eliza enjoyed her position on top quite a bit, holding Dakota in place while she ate the cheer captain’s cunt as if her life depended on it, while Dakota was fine exactly where she was. This position gave her all the access she needed to get Eliza going and <i>keep</i> her going, licking and sucking her clit with relish while squeezing the swim captain’s amazing ass cheeks, spreading them in a way that showed off her tight little asshole and made the blonde moan lusciously against her.
It was difficult to say how many times they came in this position, especially once it became difficult to count for all the pleasure coursing through their veins, but they held on like this for a while, licking and sucking and fingering and cumming, taking brief moments to catch their breaths when they had to, before continuing on and starting the process over again.
After a while like this, Eliza finally collapsed on top of Dakota, laughing and trembling from her most recent cum.
“Okay… okay… that’s my limit, for now, I think…” Eliza groaned, twitching and shaking some more as Dakota touched her. “Holy… holy fuck… this is… wow…”
Though she was quite tired herself, Dakota wouldn’t admit it. “Don’t tell me… don’t tell me you’re done.”
“Hardly,” Eliza laughed, kissing Dakota’s inner thigh. “It’s just… I need… a moment, to rest my tongue…”
“A likely story,” Dakota said in mock defiance, before a better idea struck her. “But if it’s just your tongue that needs resting… bend over the arm of the couch over there… I’ve got some ideas, that need to be done…”
“Do you, now?” Eliza chuckled weakly, before crawling over to the other side of the couch and bending over the arm.
Forcing herself up onto her knees, Dakota crawled behind Eliza, admiring the blonde’s ass again, before reaching out and squeezing both cheeks. Eliza groaned lowly, rocking her hips gently against Dakota’s gropes, letting the cheer captain spread her cheeks and show off her hole. It was an exposed position, and one that Eliza didn’t allow herself into easily, but for Dakota she was willing to make all sorts of exceptions.
“Still in the mood to let me fuck your ass?” Dakota asked, slipping two fingers between Eliza’s legs and into her pussy.
Eliza moaned, dropping her head forward as she pushed back against Dakota. “Fuck… like this, you can do whatever you want…”
Looking over her shoulder at Dakota, Eliza could only smile. It was a weak smile, one that spoke of the intensity of their evening in a way that Dakota could relate to all too easily, but tired as they both were, the two girls also understood that this was far from over.
Pumping her fingers in and out of Eliza’s cunt, Dakota couldn’t help but let her mind wander over the events of the evening, and quickly began to grin, perhaps a little manically. Eliza didn’t necessarily look concerned over Dakota’s smile, but it certainly caught her attention.
“What’s… fuck… that for?” Eliza asked between moans.
“Well, it’s just that some thoughts came to mind… a couple, really, but they’re hard to shake, and I find that I am forced to smile,” Dakota replied cheerily.
“Yeah?” Eliza replied, pressing back against Dakota’s hand.
“Yeah,” Dakota replied, pulling her fingers from Eliza’s pussy.
The busty blonde whimpered, rocking her hips needily. “Well, are you gonna tell me what’s on your mind, or not?”
“I was getting there,” Dakota explained, sliding her now thoroughly juiced-up fingers between Eliza’s ass cheeks.
This stopped any complaints that Eliza might’ve had instantly as she relaxed, moaning when Dakota began to tease her fingers against Eliza’s asshole.
“Okay… okay… that’s, mmm… that’s fine…” Eliza whimpered, reaching back with both hands to part her ass cheeks for Dakota.
“Good,” Dakota replied, grinning at the naked perfection before her as Eliza presented her ass. “My first thought was that if our friends put their heads together and pulled off a night like this for us, the cheerleaders and the swim team really ought to party together sometime soon.”
“Agreed,” Eliza groaned, pushing back against Dakota’s fingers. “I didn’t think they had it in them, but those girls really came up with one hell of a night… the sorts of things we could get up to with a little alcohol, a little weed, and <i>very</i> little clothing… we could get up to the best trouble.”
“Exactly,” Dakota replied, pushing harder.
Even as experienced as she was, even with Dakota’s fingers as lubed-up as they were, Eliza still let out a cry of pleasure and pain as Dakota’s fingers slid into her tight, gripping asshole. The cheerleader was merciless, pushing as far into Eliza as she could before pumping them in and out of her, fucking her asshole with a pleasant roughness. She looked so good bent over like this, her large breasts pillowing against the arm of the couch as she whimpered and groaned and fucked back against Dakota’s fingers in her ass, sliding both hands between her legs to finger her clit while her ass was getting fucked.
It was as glorious a sight as Dakota had ever seen, one made all the better by the fact that she knew it wouldn’t be long before she’d be in the same position, with Eliza’s fingers buried in her ass as she was fucked mercilessly.
“And… ohgod… your second thought?” Eliza asked, looking back at Dakota and smiling.
Smirking, Dakota replied. “April Fool’s Day… it’s not so bad after all.”
To punctuate her point, she smacked Eliza’s ass with her free hand, causing a pleased scream to escape the blonde’s lips.
It would be far from the last scream to fill the cheerleading office that April Fool’s night, but it might’ve been the loudest.