Home
Creators
Search Recent Random
Posts
Search DMs Popular Hash Lookup Tags Random
Importer
Import FAQ
Register Favorites Keys Review DMs Logout
Community
Telegram ThePornDude
Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Questions for NOT Once Upon a Witchlight - Episode 65 - 8/6/25 (Patreon)

Published:
2025-08-06 19:00:05
Edited:
2025-08-06 23:58:09
Imported:
2026-06
Tags:

Content

Witchlight is back after a little break for GenCon. Please leave your questions and comments below and we will see you TONIGHT @ 7:30 pm ET!

Files

Comments

tyasia bonds

Whats the closest you’ve ever been to a TPK, aside from the jabberwocky?

TheRandomChild

What is your favourite Australian snack? 😁

Ladadee

if your Witchlight character were packing a school lunch what would it be?

the anonymoose

Who would do better if they swapped campaigns the root crew in once upon a witchlight or the carnival Lacru in uprooted

Clinton Howser

If Carnival Lecroux had to pick a last meal, what would it be?

tasboo_graham

Are you able to share any more details on the Daggerheart collab and how that came to be? Do you have any plans for any other cross brand collaborations with other actual play groups/creator brands like that?

SUN

What kind of dog would the party own?

marshell doonan

Not wanting witchlight to end anytime soon I am wondering what's the next weekly campaign you guys are planning

The_Prisim_Constellation

If your character had a genre/type of music always playing around them what kind would it be?

Katie Simpson

Nikkie: have you read any of Peter S. Beagle's work besides "The Last Unicorn", and if not, would it be creepy for me to ship you some of my recommendations?

Katie Simpson

Would events shaped by Twists of Fate/Dread be considered "fan fiction"?

emmsters245

Now that you’ve written The Crooked Moon, is there anything you wish you’d done differently in Edge of Midnight?

OpalEye 42

They say, "Travel broadens the mind." What are some of the surprising or eye-opening things you may have experienced travelling abroad (or, if you haven't yet travelled abroad, a different state)

RoombaCop

We're you inspired by soul eater for the design of the Crooked Moon?

Erica L.

What do you find to be the biggest differences between streaming campaigns/sessions and at-home campaigns/sessions (both player- and DM-wise)?

GeodeKumo

It's obvious that the Witchlight crew all seem to be big foodies. What would be their favorite "ethnic" foods, or foods just outside of their own culture? Ie Chinese, Mexican, Cajun, Italian, etc.

Fancy Frogmouth

If your characters were on a desert island and had to choose who to eat in what order what would it be?

Fright Knight

Question for each of you; What is something that you feel that you want/need to work on as a player or dm? Something you personally think you yourself could improve upon

AlliCat118

Finally playing catch up over here and hopefully will be back to watching live soon but just wanted to say its so good to see these characters back in full chaos mode! It brings me back to when I first discovered y'all and is like a comfort show to watch. Keep up the good work everyone!

Rambles

With my PCs I always end up putting a bit of myself in the characters even if the chaotic evil sorcerer is vastly different to who I am she will still want to pet the puppy. Have you noticed little bits of yourselves that slip into characters?

TheViallOne, Sam

What is one story element or game mechanic that youd include or exclude for a party of very young first time players? Fey curses? Or hinge like that.

Drift

If you yourself had to make a wish stone, what would your 3 wishes be? No monkey paw business would be involved.

SorenSilverblade

What Stardust races would your Witchlight characters be?

Coyote

Rich, what first compelled you to create a gatorfolk character?

Coyote

Party, what helped you decide on revamping the Faewild characters for Witchlight

Sozzled!!!

Any canpain ideas/ moduales caught your eye lately? Like just anything you’ve seen or thought and and been like “woah that would be cool/ fun to play”

Hamartia

Have you ever had a character's mannerisms slip into your actual personality?

Death2myself

If your characters were made in the cars universe what cars would they be

Misstrickster

Is there a campaign or character that you'd like to redo? Not to do better but just because you miss the character/campaign.

Cobalt Bluewaters

If your characters worked in retail/customer service, who would crash out the quickest, and who would handle it the best?

Slip Dippium

Have you guys played Mage Arena, its a wonderful game i think yall would enjoy

Byrnikins

Which of your PC’s do you think would do the best in OUaWL and who would be the worst?

FreeHugs

We've heard what they're favorite songs are, but what songs would your characters absolutely DESPISE?

BeetleBumDraws

If given the choice, do you think Torbek would want to go back to how he was pre-Witchlight or would he think the strength it gives him is too good to give up?

Dice Queen Kululu

What would your characters card name be if they had Magic the gathering cards for them?

Lord & Lady Deathstrike

Was the Daggerheart collab the "Flint and Steel" that no one would ever guess the real name of? Or is there still something in the works?

CodingZerp

What continent did orpheus grow up on?

CodingZerp

How tall is orpheus?

Crystalline_Roses

andy, how does it feel finally being a knight of chappel roan?

Lunar

Do you think any other campaign party would work in the OUWL(not as is but with rework to fit the theme?)

slaythevampire87

Sorry if this has been asked before, but do y'all have an "after care" activity you do when a campaign gets emotionally heavy?

canned..bread

If your characters were all put in a fight to the death, which of your characters would come out on top?

TheKrakenWithin

What is the funniest way that you've seen someone misspell your name?

Hyikou Fang

After a bad day, what would your characters (any/all) do to make themselves feel better? If eating something is an answer, what kind of comfort foods would they eat?

Roxanne Hennessy

which of your characters would do the best in a Twisted Metal competition?

BeckyFalcon

If your characters were wrestlers, what would their entrance music or finishing move be?

CodingZerp

For Prime arc 1, when sophina involuntary transforms into a hag, did she turn into Mother Mavis?

CodingZerp

Which university did orpheus attend?

CodingZerp

For Prime, what does dr.etouffee's scroll of summon demon actually do?

Dice Queen Kululu

Mikey, when you created Avantris, did you start by creating the full world and worked in toward the countries, towns, etc... or did you start on a town or village and work out?

InvertedRain

For GMing Modules, how do you come up with the theme and the villian's characterization when the module's writing is so bland?

kibblez1998

How do you get into the zone on days where you really dont feel like streaming? We all have shitty days and it must be hard to put a game face on for hundreds of people when you're going through it.

Clone Andy

Mikey, how cool was it sitting front row at the CR panel and seeing you and Andy on the screen?

Brielle Vanderfin

I'm thinking of cosplaying as a character from one of the campaigns. What character are you really dying to see brought to life?

bulbabum

So when yall going to make an appearance on Good Time Society to play commander with Becca Scott? (Mostly a joke but heeey itd be a pretty fun collab)

the anonymoose

Did any of the merch make it past gen con and if so where can we find it

Hennis the Mennis

Did that Ky show that troll lady a good time or did their hand get too tired?

Noah Sidles

Any tips for a struggling dm, on how to write engaging plots and or stories

FrogPetals

Can we get a peek at the gemstone dice for those who weren’t able to attend Gen Con? I need another set to go with the CM ones

mike_from_gentech

If power tools were a thing in Avantris, which brand would the crew have brand loyalty with

Elena Madfisch

Would Crooked Moon be easy enough for a novice DM to pick up and run?

Ice Box

I’m playing the Crooked Moon soon, DM’d by the beloved CandiedKitsune! She showed you guys art of our characters at GenCon, done by the AMAZING Flor. (We’re absolutely blessed to have them!!) Our crew was absolutely floored to learn that you guys saw it lol.

Notedoesart

What we're the best items you got from fans during gencon or what was the best LOA cosplay you saw you can choose which one to answer

leperdpaw L.

Who of all your characters would fair the best in mortal combat

Spazdick

Will the laughing damage t shirt be restocked?

Kyle Hutchings

So what I took away form the GenCon Q&A is, there is a series called "Beneath Dark Wings", and also a limited series called "Prime", and you would like us to watch them. Am I getting that right?

Weird_Wallflower

Derek, can you clarify some confusion about Frost's robes that my friend who just got into OUAW has? Were they his Master's at the psionic order originally then given to Frost as a gift OR were they given to Frost by his Master to show Frost's Master status after completing his training?

Weird_Wallflower

If a FeyCurse allowed Hoostie to speak, how do you think everyone would react? Also, what do you think she would say or be like? (Aka, the sweet little girl Gricko thinks she is or swears like a sailor because of Kremy/Gideon & ineffective earmuffs). Would she have any secrets she would spill that the party thought were safe because only Hoostie saw them?

Hi_CeeeCeee lol

Hii! Welcome back everyone ! What was your favorite moment/memory at Gen Con ?

MxDami

Can you talk about daggerheart? Will you be porting crooked moon to DH?

ladyleshie

For Derek - what's your favorite beer?

Rapt0rHunter

I'm all caught up on Witchlight and currently watching Strahd. Once I finish that campaign which would you recommend I listen to next?

DJHERO

Do Mikey and Richie ever do a NPC or PC voice too similar to each other or have they practiced enough to not do that being twins

Ashley

Not a question, just a massive thank you. I was too nervous and scared to mention it at Gen Con, but my divorce is finally final!! Thank you guys helping me through the last year and a half by making me smile and laugh when I've needed it the most with your phenomenal campaigns!! Also thank you guys so much during the meet and greet for making me laugh with how nervous I was and being so sweet at Gen Con. So happy you remembered and enjoyed my fanart, when I have more time I'll be sure to send more through fanmail. You guys made my sister-in-laws and my first con a wonderful experience 🩵

Arlo Lee

What would each of your Witchlight character's phones be like? ie. android, iPhone, flip phone, cracked screen, lock screen/background, charms?

OpalEye 42

Just asking for clarification around information from Patreon-only content on the Wiki - is it JUST Saltmarsh that's allowed or can it be anything that is mentioned in any Patreon stream/vod?

PakuPunk

Not a question but I just wanted to say you all have invigorated my love for D&D! I only recently discovered yall in the last month and have been binging so much of your content nonstop at work. From the dimwood to saltmarsh, what an incredible love-filled, passion-driven, project you all have made. Thank you guys 🫶🙏

Remire

Will Dan Dillion be working with Mikey on Prime when it returns in 2038? /j

Clone Andy

Are you guys going to address the fact that everyone is looking sharp? Andy looks bigger everyone looks healthy, and Derek looks the exact same…. Which is kinda comforting, because nobody likes change.

ClownySkeleton

Is there an older campaign you've ever thought of rebooting with a one shot just for funsies?

Jesse Maygra

Give us more icebound Derek is fun to watch dm!

ClownySkeleton

If you had to pick two of your characters that you play to fight eachother who would it be, who would win, and why?

Remire

May I suggest exploring the ghost stream with Forgus as a mini series? I like to think that SoS is partly the reason why he is the way he is

Willow Kitzre

For the 80's rock/synthwave lovers, have you listened to GUNSHIP (Tech Noir), and Maximum Love (Red Lights)?

Travenguard

I've been going through alot of older one-shots on YouTube, and am wondering if games such as Everyone is John or Tactical Waifu may make a comeback?

Remire

Prime is available on their YouTube page!

Clone Andy

Did you guys know that”In the Mood” “ was the name of Lafayette Pool’s tank in WW2? (The guy that inspired the movie Furry)

Fancy Frogmouth

I am not asking you all to show anything off I just wanna make sure you all got the second part that included Richie's gift mainly from me?

Ice Box

Not the crew (obviously lol) but I would definitely recommend Beneath Dark Wings!

emmsters245

How much does Curse of Strahdanya differ from the module? I would love to watch it but am hoping to play Curse of Strahd and don’t want too many spoilers.

Artofjhope

I noticed you guys have a good number of board games on the shelfs behind you; is it decoration, or have you guys played them or plan to play them? Do you have a favorite board game?

CodingZerp

for the wiki, is shroud over saltmarsh session 0 canon?

Croc_Holding

Would you guys ever consider doing Cuttlefish with NPCS? Are there any NPCs you'd specifically want to play?

Hennis the Mennis

Were there cool cosplays of any Avantris characters at gencon?

Hi_CeeeCeee lol

Any plans to visit California for any conventions out here? 🫣💗

belsy

What was your favorite booth outside of your own?

Snip Snip

Derek, whats with your hair. It looks nice

Clone Andy

You guys know that the greatest domestic beer is Miller Highlife right?

jess

I cant believe you like pbr 😂

InvertedRain

Nikkie! I just got a library card, what books do you recommend to up my reading speed? I haven't been able to join in on Nikkie's Nook because i am too slow to finish the books in time

GeodeKumo

Any plans on remastering the audio for earlier episodes of Prime?

MadamCoheed

Did you guys get any gifts or games that you really liked?

RkAngelRami

Rain, snow, or sun? What weather do you like the most?

Symphony

Is there anything you miss about having a smaller audience?

Snip Snip

Least favorite food?

Jacky_alltrades

Can you release the Prime Arc 1 recap please? (Follow up question: WILL you release the recap please?)

Dice Queen Kululu

Which campaign would you want to join as yourselves?

Kaiju_Kyle

I might be running the Crooked Moon adventure for my in person group of three players. I know you guys talk about how well Shroud and WFRP how well the three player party works but I don't know how well it'll run for my table. So in your opinion is it easier to scale up the player's characters or scale down encounters?

Elena Madfisch

What is your favorite book that isn't by Tolkien or Martin?

Hi_CeeeCeee lol

Any favorite song you have on repeat? 😁❤️

Echoeypie

How did yall get started playing DnD? Had yall played it a lot prior to starting to play together?

RkAngelRami

Which states in the lower 48 have you been to in your life? And what was the best/worst one?

Prodeucer freaky INC.

You guys scared me so bad talking about the bad gencon because I didn't realize you were talking about LAST year until the end. Can you please talk more about gencon (25) and how it was for you and what your favorite things to see and do were, because as a first con it was freakin awesome for me.

Ice Box

Soon, myself and some friends are playing the Crooked Moon, DM’d by the lovely CandiedKitsune! (She showed y’all art of our characters done by the amazing Flordellums which is crazy lol). Any roleplay advice for new/nervous players?

RkAngelRami

Have any of you heard of the Abhorsen series by Garth Nix?

Spazdick

For Nikki, have you listen to The Magnus Archives?

jess

DRAMIONE MENTIONED!!!!

Christopher Hewett

Is there a character that you guys always wanted to create but but didn't in a campaign

Kelsey_goblincore

Nikki have you read any of ann rices sisters books ? I have silver wolf and read the book so many times over the years I've had to tape the book back together its my fav

Tartan Bampot

Are you guys open to ever return to spelljammer for a a longer term game?

Echoeypie

Also, how did Derek get started with the sound effects? Did he just figure out by accident that he’s good at it and continue?

jess

Oh please play E33 😭

Haywire

Which of each of your characters was the most challenging to write?

BuddhaDaBoss

Have you guy considered doing a World of Darkness type campaign or something similar? Also love you guys!

Jesse Maygra

Im sure this has been asked before are you guys ever going to release a stardust ruleset

Valerie Reeves

Niki have you listened/read any of the Dungeon crawler Carl books? It’s such a fun series if you haven’t read them yet!

RkAngelRami

If you could pilot a mech or exoskeleton from any movie or anime, which one would you want?

Michael Jaeger

I got the Signed Deluxe Hardcover Book will you be doing those on stream?

MaggieMay95

Since Andy and Mace are going to punch each other! If each one of you had an entrance song what would it be?

MadamCoheed

What is your favorite movie that is arguably just TERRIBLE? Like absolute guilty pleasure. Mine is Master of Disguise

Noah Sidles

For the Warhammer’ers of the group what faction is your favorite in 40K,AoS, or whichever you play

Free

Maybe a silly question but after seeing all the effort put into the crooked moon, is there any way to experience the story without playing the campaign? I’m probably never gonna play it with my party but after I’d still love to experience it. Glad you made it back from a successful gen con!

InvertedRain

Mikey, what DO you remember from Shroud over Saltmarsh?

RkAngelRami

If you had to be roommates with any of your characters, from any campaign, who would be your best/worst choice?

XxSyexX

Not my question but Paper_Milk_ had a great question I had to ask, what are you guys' favorite Lunchables?

Cobalt Bluewaters

A similar questioned was asked to Derek during Detroit: Become Human, but now that everyone is here, what do you think Avantris themed, Pacific Rim Jaegers would look like?

Potatoboi

Will you guys do a warhammer mini painting stream in the future? If so which set will you do?

Avery

Would you guys do a livestream playing bg3 again?

Noah Sidles

Do you guys have weird and unusual punishments for getting off track, my dm used to read smut out loud when we got off track

Avery

They have mods for playing as bugbear or goblin

slaythevampire87

My question kind of got buried and I hate to repost and take space away from other questions, but do you guys have an "after care" routine after emotionally heavy sessions in a campaign?

JackTheMurph

Have you guys seen the movie "Sinners" yet?

Sam Storm

Seeing that you know Hamilton, I'm curious do you guys know of EPIC The musical?

samanita

Mikey look up 1997 toyota tacoma water pump gasket

Prince F-8

what species would the anthem version of forgus flamecider be?

JustALilDot

Can we get a voodoo man musical number for Kremmy?

Ray_of_sunshine

Will there be a day where you guys play jackbox games? Specifically quiplash?

sylvyy

If a company came up to you guys and proposed that they wanted to make an entire anime-esque series out of Once Upon A whichlight or possibly another one of your campaigns would you guys take it even if it meant a lot of money Or possibly that they call the shots on how the story is written but the ending is still the same?