Home
Creators
Search Recent Random
Posts
Search DMs Popular Hash Lookup Tags Random
Importer
Import FAQ
Register Favorites Keys Review DMs Logout
Community
Telegram ThePornDude
Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Questions for Once Upon a Witchlight - Episode 68 - 1/21/26 (Patreon)

Published:
2026-01-21 20:00:13
Imported:
2026-06
Tags:

Content

WE'RE BACK! The first WHIMSDAY since September?? Yahoo! Join us TONIGHT at 7:30 pm ET for the return of Feywild shenaniganry! Leave your comments and questions below!

Files

Comments

Jam

What’s your most selfish favorite moment across all campaigns? Such as a roleplay moment you did, or a story beat you DM’d and felt you did especially well on.

Craft_Eledritch

Coke, Dr Pepper, or Pepsi. You can only chose one

Fulcrum2077

Derek told me to ask here, if the crew of the Rhapsody were to appear in a Fallout ttrpg Mad Max style quest, what type of vehicle would the Rhapsody be (sorry Derek the Winnebago is taken

KnyleBorealis

Y'all have magic wine that breaks fey pacts, I do believe. What pact would you break as players vs as characters? The one promising Torbek to Scabitha, mayhaps? A marriage or three? Whatever Endelyn demands?

Catherine Grzywa

If you could be any type of cheese, what type of cheese would you be?

alazysun

The Krew has such great vibes and chemistry with each other, but if you could pick a character from another campaign to join, who would you pick and why? 😉

kibblez1998

Thoughts on the first episode of A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms?

Cobalt Bluewaters

If your characters were to build a snowman, how would they decorate it?

SorenSilverblade

Besides Witchlight and Prime (and technically Uprooted), what other parties would you like to see perform a stage play?

Zephyr_Tree

If your Once Upon a Witchlight character met your Stardust Rhapsody Anthem character how do you think that interaction would go? Would they get along?

Rebelsaylor

I just wanted to take the time and let you guys know that yo are a fantastic group of people I started watching you all back when I was going through a lot of struggles. I have found comfort in your laughter and your humor and all the jokes you guys shared fast-forward a couple years and I become a single father today beautiful baby girl and seeing her cackle and giggle while watching you guys with me truly brightens my day up, knowing that the group that helped me get through those hard times with their laughter continues to create laughter for someone who made so much to me thank you guys so much for everything. I know it’s not a question. I just wanted to let you guys know y’all are amazing and thank you.

NerdlingMitch

What sort of New Year's resolutions would the Witchlight characters make, and how long do you think they would stick to them?

UnicornTownGoingDown

We all know Derek's unlucky and Mace has the luck of the Irish- but my little statistician heart wants to see if the numbers actually back that up. Whenever you make a d20 roll, will you please tell us what the nat roll is so I can add it to a spreadsheet? Pretty please with a nat 20 on top?

Craft_Eledritch

What is your favorite genre of music as a player and your character

Aidan Churlish-Webb

This doesn’t have to be answered canonically but do you guys out of character even think Madryck Roslof is still alive after all this time? Or has it only been mere minutes in avantris compared to the many moons in the feywild. First time commenter, thanks for the many days worth of laughs! Your many adventures have had me trying to stifle laughing out loud infront of my coworkers whilst I’ve been at work 🤣

Dice Queen Kululu

If your characters wanted to stream a video game, which game would they pick?

HantuKopek

What ever happened to that little piglet Gideon had in a carrier on his back

Misstrickster

You have to star in a classic horror movie with a classic monster which one are you choosing?

Blue Uppercase

What real life show/film do you think your PCs would enjoy if they had a way to watch it (and why)?

leperdpaw L.

No question just wanted to say I missed yall and I'm so looking forward to this

Natalie Gifford

What would each of the WitchLights gangs favorite holiday meal be?

Doom Derpie

If you could no longer play d&d for whatever reason, what system would you switch to? If any

Blue11

Do you think numbers are real or just something humans came up with?

CEOTHEFALCON

What characters from all of your campaigns if you had to choose, would you swap out from the carnival lecroux

Mickey Rose

From each campaign who would be the best cook? I know some are obvious answers but I'd love to know the others :)

Misstrickster

A single phrase/sentence that you think will get someone to watch your favorite show or movie.

UnicornTownGoingDown

How do I become a manly enjoyer of whiskey? I'm more of an herbal liquor and gin man (I can even do straight absinthe) but can't drink dark liquor without grimacing. I need to be able to assert my dominance via my alcohol choice in case I get yeeted into Mad Men.

Drift

What's your favorite fey creature?

Emrrys

Are you guys still going to mess up the play? The deal with scabitha was that she gets torbek if you don’t mess up Endoline’s play

FreyjdEdge

So excited to see you guys back! I hope you're all feeling better! My husband and I have been arguing because he refuses to be my Quibly and call me things like "My Cozy Enigma". He says real people don't do that. Did you come up with any of those in advance/do y'all have silly pet names for your own partners that you'd share?

Echoeypie

This is the greatest reason I’ve ever seen 😂

Echoeypie

If you got to choose your last meal on earth, what would it be? Like Mythical Kitchen ‘Last Meals’ style.

Sumscrub

I know its not a question but just more or less want to say thank yall for what yall do. it has helped get me through alot of stuff

Sam B

Not a question, but I've been having a bad flare up. So i started watching stardust rhapsody anthem for the first time. I'm loving it! Thanks for the laughs despite my pain

Final Frostasy

Have you considered playing the final fantasy ttrpg?

Lunar

If you were to have an all female PC campaign (like tactical wifi) what setting / set of characters would you create?

ClownySkeleton

just got a huge unicorn tattoo that i think Kremy would be proud of! would any of the gang get a tattoo? if so what of?

Scrit-scratch

New to dnd and was wondering if there are any dark campaigns like curse of strahd?

JacTheNewb

I've started GM'ing on Start Playing. Is there anything against using the Crooked Moon for those games, since they are Pay To Play?

Michael_Mayor

Can we get Betty Midler, Kathy Najimy, and Sarah Jessica Parker, the Sanderson Sisters from Hocus-pocus, to sing "Sing Ye Vermin"?

beccasocks

Where does Nikkie find all of her gorgeous hair accessories? I'm always so jealous!

Skywolf707

Are you excited for the Lorwyn Eclipsed set comming out on friday?

KhaoticKat

Is there anything in particular you're looking forward to this year?

Syddersquidee

I want create a Dungeon Crawler Carl ttrpg game but I’m only familiar with DnD and Daggerheart. Any suggestions in general? Especially since I’ve never GM’d before

Syddersquidee

Did y’all get anything good if you went to the Lorwyn pre-release?

Vasilios Zanakis

Question for Mikey! Have you seen the first episode of A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms yet? I loved how much it adhered to the first novella!

UhOhI'maPufferfish

I already asked Derek, but I've been tracking data for LOA campaigns, what niche campaign would you be interested in seeing stats for?

Blue Husky 2001

If you were given three wishes no bounds what would they be? And why?

kazriel

Was Monster Campaign set in Avantris, and did it impact the setting lore in any way?

Sakisaurous

This is probably just a dumb silly question but would you guys ever collab with other dnd podcast groups?

Jesus Ramirez

Question for mikey. Would is the day in the life of gary goodberry or would andy know since they’re “roommates”?

Jen Sample

For Mikey, do you think you'd ever play Ygor in a one shot like you've played Chuckles in the past?

Disasterkid

Thank y'all for keeping me company during my overnight shifts. Anyways what is y'alls favorite way to start a campaign as a DM?

Bushless Chicken

Question for Mikey. Which Crooked Moon villan made your finger Crooked?

ThrokFellhammer

Love all of you guys you make me laugh so much and rekindled my love for DnD. Question for Andy. How did you come up with the concept for Torbek and the witchlight?

Doom Derpie

Nikkie please give advice for turning a player turned evil into a boss to reclaim their goodness (like Torbek!)

Brittany Gibson

Yall have made me laugh so much I watch yall while I crochet. How do we get the discord and stuff?

Doom Derpie

Who was the first one with the idea of streaming?

Deerney

Have you guys thought about maybe publishing your homebrewed elements from Once upon a Witchlight here? My friends and I are currently playing WBTWL because of you guys, but really enjoy your twists to it. Thanks!

Ronan

Speaking of all of the great Patreon exclusive content, what is the policy on fans making edits or animations using audio/clips from Patreon exclusives?

Kendra.saurus

A question for everyone, Are there any characters that you think deserve more character art?(Also, welcome back I hope you guys had an amazing break 🩵)

TiaRex

What is everyones favorite songs from the midnight? I already asked derek but I'd like to know everone else's too!

Illiterate Ducko

Going off of the start of the stream, what archetypes does everyone prefer in magic??? I’ve always assumed y’all played and finally got confirmation☺️

Smalls

Hello! Not sure if this has been asked before but what is everyone's current favorite commander in mtg? Thank you for the stream and all of the amazing work you do!

Anna Killingbeck

Just became a patron while watching the stream, absolutely love y'all! I just want to know how many Bits would I have to donate to convince Nikkie, Andy, and Mace to return to Demonologist!? I just watched the VOD and I love it so much lol! God bless and much love <3

Soutarou Dreemurr

Out of curiosity, where do y'all get your backdrops for the GMs from? I really love the one for Stardust and I really want to get my own for my online sessions.

pomegranate_poser

Could a party take on 100 apes if they were all lined up single file in an alley? How does this change the survivability of the question?

Amazon_Jayde

SPOILERS FOR PRIME!! Richie, could you tell us a little bit about Rodek's lover that we learnt about during the campaign that you never got to expand upon? What does she look like? What's her name?

Call me jazzy

If you had to make a pc based off of two characters from movies, tv shows, comics or books in general, what two people would you choose and what species and class would you make them.

TheDragonWhisper

what is chuckels most prized possession that he has

GeodeKumo

Hey yall! It's great to see y'all back! Just wanted to say that I've FINALLY been able to start catching up on PRIME because of some sweet new earbuds I got for Christmas, and I'm soooo excited!

ButtchugTheClown

Do you think we can get another one-shot that includes ygor constantly messing with bitsy?

barracudah

Has any of the gang watched The Pitt? Thoughts?

Ace Hudson

I'm about an episode away from finishing arc 3 of beneath dark wings and I wanted to say the connection map I'm making for the horror trilogy is starting to look insane!! always in awe of you guys' storytelling and so glad to see you all back 🎉🎉🎉 happy whimsday!!

Zorbrian

Gonna pump some iron to tonight’s campaign. What’s yall’s favorite exercises? (It’s pull day for me)

Anna Killingbeck

How do you find independent musicians to collaborate with? I've been playing cello for almost 13 years now, also a singer through church and musicals and such, and I just love the compositions you've produced, and being a musician I can really respect the time, effort, and passion put into these projects! God bless and much love <3

Jacky_alltrades

Have you found a singer for Phillip yet?

Reader_of_Runes

If you were sucked into Avantris and had to choose one of your characters to replace and experience their adventure yourself which would you choose?

Rhi

Welcome back y’all!! Nikkie! What was your fav book from the last year?? I’m super excited to start the book nook this year :D

Looneylounna

If you or character has a mmusical shows curse place on, what be favorite music style and less favorite?

ButtchugTheClown

Can we get a guest DM and you 6 play your most unhinged characters and it just be utter chaos

UnicornTownGoingDown

Whiskey journey update: Thank you Richie and Andy for the advice! Made a Manhattan on the rocks (substituting amaretto for vermouth cuz I don't got that) and it's DELICIOUS!! And Derek, thanks for the recommendation. I'll grab some Monkey's Shoulder whenever I go to the liquor store next. :)

Keelay42

How many subs for a full Shooch animation of the play?

ladyleshie

Did you guys prepare for how insane this would be? Or are y'all just off the cuff? (I think everyone is impressed either way?)

Trivialsublime

Would yall be willing to post the play script up for download?

JollyDripps5777

First off, how am I supposed to keep a straight face, talking to the vice president of my job while hearing the play in my ears... I recently started playing DnD thanks to you all, I was wondering what your MOST FAVORITE Vicious Mockery insult that you have ever heard was/is?

ThrokFellhammer

Nikkie I have to ask...was this some kind of revenge plot for something these guys did?

LostMindSorcery

im new to wanting to play D&D (you guys inspired me so thank you so much), what would your advice be?

samanita

Singing is really fucking hard. How do you practice and take care of your voice?

ButtchugTheClown

Let's get nikkie's booknook with Derek reading as the Duke

Tsuki

What outfit would you like to have the most from any of the Avantris characters?

KhaoticKat

Nikkie how much time did you spend coming up with this play?

ChaosGaySupreme

Can Derek read as Yugioh? The whole time he did that laugh i wanted him to say "you activated my trap card"

Spazdick

Is there any relationship or inspiration with Jamity from BDW and Torbek?

Birdyoftheinkwell

Which character of yours do you like the design most of and why???

StarlightCryptid

What is your favorite thing to collaborate on together? The story, the jokes or the character creation?

InvertedRain

When is the next Cuttlefish?

GeodeKumo

In a similar vein to you guys trading places with one of your characters, how would the characters you'd be okay with switching places with react to your other characters' stories?

MissMurberTime

Do you think if the dice had rolled differently that Kremy would have opened a little sit down restaurant and make the best money ever for his dishes? With his husband, of course.

Jess_Gore

What is the favorite food of every character on stream tonight?

Kendra.saurus

Nikkie, where did you get your glasses chain? I'm in full bird brain mode and I'm obsessed

StarlightCryptid

Actually what advice would you give to someone trying to build their own system/campaign?

Kimberly Lawrence

Can I just say Mikey I always thought you are a cutie. Your personality makes you attractive. Congratulations on the 4 years.

Drunkenhobo9d

What about 100 gorillas in stardust space combat?

Joules

inspired by the ability to go back and change your choose your own adventure selection like in many games or especially the books created for DnD, if there was a point in any campaign you wish you could go back and change your characters decisions, who would you choose and what moment was it?

Joules

If there was any videogame weapon you could reach through the screen and pull out and make real, what would it be?

UnicornTownGoingDown

Nikkie, I was going to ask how you write such amazing horror, but idk if I can ask this with my whole chest after that.

Anna Killingbeck

Thank you for answering my question about musical collaboration, I greatly appreciate the information! And yes, we need that stage play I'm telling you!

Kydashing

Which class/subclass or species do each of you find difficult to play or to work with?

Anna Killingbeck

What do your neighbors think?? 🤣🤣🤣🤣

ladyleshie

might've posted too late but, if you could choose- ride falkor (neverending story) OR be best friends with the worm and ludo from the labyrinth?

SinkofDragonSoup

Soooo nikkie coalecroux fic when?? (Kidding :) )

Birdyoftheinkwell

How are you guys mentally? How are you all getting on?

Blue Husky 2001

If real life body swap happened how would you handle it?

ThrokFellhammer

With the Hag now wanting to keep the crew together to perform, how do you think this will impact the deal you made with her for her sisters and debt clearing?

TheSoooperTaco

First time question, favorite taco bell menu item?

SinkofDragonSoup

Do you guys have the current fey curses doc somewhere?

Trivialsublime

If you could mix two of your campaigns together for genre which would you mix and why?

delightfulfoxxing

What's one piece of merch that hasn't been made yet or will never be made that YOU want to have in the store?

TiaRex

not a question but you guys have helped me through some of ths worst times of my life, staying up past midnight is worth it to watch my favorite streamers! you guys are awesome!

-

Since yall introduced me to the amazing art that is Cow Tools - Have you seen that cows do in fact use tools, and that the last quote in the article about it was “Perhaps the real absurdity lies not in imagining a tool-using cow, but in assuming such a thing could never exist."

Cobalt Bluewaters

If your characters were to have their abilities (classes) magically swapped, whose abilities do you think they would have the easiest time dealing with and whose would they struggle with?

cat_chase_dog

(as much as you're comfortable sharing) what'd you get up to over your break?

DrCoolJ

Did “moneys before honeys” lead to the demise of the middle class?

T

Any tips for someone new to D&D but wanting to DM? *cough cough* me lol

abigail mancini

I found your channel through Facebook reels and I just finished episode 67 after binge watching for two weeks haha. So happy to catch the live tonight! My question would be-from when Kremy and Gideon were alone outside Odun’s house-when did Kremy begin to consider Torbek a true friend? Such a great heartfelt moment. Here for the story, the laughs, and the loveable moments.

Kendra.saurus

Are there any characters you think deserve more art? Or are completely underrated?

Birdyoftheinkwell

You can tell the group is hungry. They are getting so into talking about this food. y’all are so wholesome. Sometime…

T

Give me homemade cathead biscuits and sausage gravy any day and I'll feel better whether I'm sick or not 😂😂