Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

Hey everyone!

Today, we have:

00:05 KDE explains the AI policy issue

https://pointieststick.com/2026/09/23/kde-and-ai-and-you-and-me/

04:11 Qualcomm talks about Linux support for their ARM chips

https://www.phoronix.com/news/Qualcomm-Talks-Up-X2-Linux

05:57 Ubuntu will update the kernel on a weekly basis

https://canonical.com/blog/accelerating-delivery-of-cve-fixes-with-a-new-kernel-release-strategy

Have a great day!

Files

Comments

Talya

sorry Nick, but I think you have entirely the wrong framing on the KDE issue. the fact that the response fully dismissed members of the KDE community opposing LLM contributions, didn't even bbother to refute their points but just ignored them as "people outside KDE" is no different to saying the opinions of people who aren't code contributors don't matter. KDE proudly calls itself a community project, but this entire thing is exactly the opposite of that. also not only did KDE ban the person who exposed the guy who tried defending the ethics of AI as holding literal 1933 Germany positions (which btw Nate chose to specifically not mention in the post), but they also blocked several people for questioning that decision in other forums. i came out of this whole thing wondering if KDE was still a community project, only to see this post and realise the answer is no. there was no apology, no attempt to make lessons for the future, only a "whoops sorry for causing drama".

Talya

i mean the main people Nate calls "people outside KDE" are the signers of the KDE for People petition. that petition starts with "We are a community of KDE users and contributors", and citing the position of KDE Eco who posted a staunchly anti-AI position. if that's not saying "if you're not a code contributor you're not part of KDE" i don't know what does.

Nick - The Linux Experiment

I didn't see the conversation it was removed before I could access it, but from what I'm getting, basically the debate had nothing do with KDE anymore, and if some people wanted to actually debate the policy, there were drowned out by the flux on "general AI ethic" comments. I do understand why they had to lock that conversation down to restart it between contributors (which doesn't necessarily mean just devs, by the way, could also include anyone writing documentation, doing translations, etc...), and then discussing the thing contributors want to push, with the rest of the community. A 2 step discussion doesn't feel bad to me personally, I don't expect to be involved in every decision for every project I use but don't give time to myself. Then again, I didn't see the entire conversation, so maybe I missed something!

Talya

I said that in a reply to my comment so you may have missed that, but I was talking about the frankly insulting dismissal of the KDE for People petition as being "outside KDE". it very much implies that the views of community members who aren't code contributors don't count. i was even talking to more prominent KDE contributors who overall defended this post but still agreed this framing is dismissive. so to me unless those words are taken back I'll see that as if the position holds: if you're not who Nate would call "a known contributor", your opposition to AI doesn't matter.

Clint Eschberger

Brodie came out and admitted several of his members from his Discord and Mastodon went there to incite arguments. Sure there were some KDE contributors, and that is fair, but it was a lot of outside people who have nothing to do with KDE literally going there to do nothing but incite.

UsernamesAreHard

I think that wanting to ban LLM generated code is a cat a mouse game: today people might catch code that has been written by AI but will it still be possible to catch it once Ai written code becomes better? I'm not sure that focusing on banning LLM generated code specifically is the right way to proceed, it's wasteful effort. Maybe it should be done depending on the context. Is the LLM code well written and helpful to the project? Is the person who submitted the code capable of maintaining it in a proper way? Does the person understand the code they submitted? Does the generated code respect licensed code it copied? Torvalds has the opinion that what matters about code is the quality and responsibility of it, not the means used to write it and I do agree with that way of thinking. Wanting to ban code purely on the premise that it is written by AI is detrimental and dogmatic.

Nick - The Linux Experiment

Yeah, I can see both angles: on the one hand, it does suck that the discussion was shut down and that it looks like some voices are being ignored, on the other hand, if the discussion was brigaded by plenty of people (unfortunately including people whose voices should likely be heard as well), I don't really think they had much of a choice apart from closing it down, and restarting it behind closed doors, to then submit what they have agreed upon to the rest of the community. I guess it depends on what happens next: do they decide on a policy and then fully ignore everyone's opinion, or do they submit what they want to do for approval of the community. If that's the latter, that's fine with me!

Nick - The Linux Experiment

Yeah, it feels like a losing game. I talked yesterday with a senior dev who's a good friend of mine, and he told me that basically, his code (webdev mostly) is not better than what Claude can generate currently. he still develops things himself, but basically when looking at the codebase, he can't tell what Claude makes from what he made after a few weeks have passed, and he's forgotten exactly what he worked on. Still not a fan of that tech, but I don't think projects will be able to fully block it altogether in the future, unfortunately

Talya

but Nate didn't call the comments on the policy brigading. he said that word about a petition, while also calling the person who created it and the people signing it, community members, "people outside KDE". if the literal most polite way of expressing opposition to AI and desire for a total ban is brigading and if community members who aren't code contributors are "people outside KDE", then it means anti-AI positions are to be ignored and that the community doesn't have an input in shaping policy.

Nick - The Linux Experiment

yeah, as I said, I didn't see how the conversation went, so I don't know who Nate is including in the "people outside of KDE" statement :/ I'll wait and see how they handle that going forward, I do hope there will be an open discussion once they land on something, I wouldn't want KDE to start ignoring users and the community.