Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

Hey everyone!

Today, I ramble about:

00:41 How my plans for the channel are moving along (pretty well)

10:31 What is happening in France right now, since the coverage seems pretty unrelated to what is really happening, at least from what I can see from my own experience

Have a great week!

Comments

phoebe headkittens

I've been following the French news, especially as some local socialists have picked it up. I haven't heard your opinions yet and I'm sure there's some divergence. It's okay, i'm not looking for validation. Macron has been horrible, he's blatantly neoliberal, much like Australia's government. So of course the rich profit and the poor's quality of life suffers. Seeing him undermine Melanchon (and I'm very sure I could find something to dislike about him too!), stand by while the far right make a meal out of him. In a country with a rich and sometimes radical history as France, not just the revolution, but the events of May 1968, I appreciate that people are showing their anger at their stolen time, their quality of life. The line "socialism or barbarism" feels more prescient to me now than ever, having lived through the decline in a world run by Reagan, Thatcher and here in Australia, Bob Hawke, an Australian Labor prime minister, unlike the conservatives of the other two. As i type this, you've already confirmed the local socialist view. Teachers have it rough, school is important, it's it's difficult for children, as I was, who don't gel well with traditional education (at no fault of my teachers, they were great for the most part). Obviously, what is to be done is a hard thing to work out, I do not think there's easy answers. But anything that needs to be done needs to be collaboratory, in a spirit of moving forward together.

Nick - The Linux Experiment

macron is likely the worst thing that happened to France in a long while. An entirely disconnected political line of though that refuses to respect any of the principles our very motto states: Liberty, Equality and Fraternity. Liberty is being trampled by cops, curfews, and attacks on the press, Equality is in the bin with taxation being entirely supported by the middle class, and Fraternity is gone, as the government mocks everyone who disagrees. It's insane how far we've fallen, but it's the usual result of decades of pure capitalism without regulation, billionaire-owned media brainwashing, and the usual tactics.

Nick - The Linux Experiment

Haha the stereotype of 'French people can't speak english" is truly well and alive (and not a stereotype at all, in fact) :D

Benjamin Ulrich

Your outlining of the French currenct politicis sounds exactly like what's happening in Germany. Terrible politics made for rich people.

Richard Gunn

It seems obvious to me that for decades the political classes of the Western world have been increasingly captured by corporations and have made laws that enrich big business while giving nothing back to the populations of the countries where they make their profits. I do not believe we have a truly capitalist system where profits trickle down - it's corporatism/cronyism and I do not know how you change that when the people who make the laws are the ones in bed with big business. You cannot get turkeys to vote for Christmas.

CBits Tech

Great podcast today. I love how much you love your new project management tool. Your French Politics segment was interesting. I do not watch news or world events so I have no idea what's going on. I hate all politics, but it's interesting to hear your views (even if you admit they're probably biased). It would be great to hear the views of someone else from the opposite site of the political fence (without rhetoric). I have to say, though, more taxes for a few billionaires won't solve the problem. It won't generate a significant about of tax revenue compared to what is needed. And these super-rich people are economically mobile, they could move themselves and their fortunes (and maybe their businesses) around the world to a more tax-friendly place and France would lose the current level of tax they receive from them. Likewise, if they have companies with shareholders, they need to keep making more profits for their investors, so if they're taxed more then they have to find ways to save tax to make the same post-tax profits, which might lead to price-rises and/or enshitification for French people. I don't have an answer, though, except encouraging growth and income from other countries. Like a household budget, the only real way to be richer is to get income from outside the family. Same with countries, encourage French businesses to expand outside France and bring that foreign money into the country to pay the French workers, which increases French tax revenue.

Nick - The Linux Experiment

It's estimated these taxes would alleviate the tax burden for the rest of the population by about 10 billion, and if these people want to leave, you can also prevent that by taxing them even if they leave, just like the US does :) But yeah, it's not enough. We also need to stop gifting money to companies in the form of tax breaks, and force them to increase wages if they decide to give dividends, so people can buy things, generate VAT, pay more taxes on that income, etc... The big issue is that the taxed base is shrinking as people move below the "non taxable" line, and people who vastly overshoot that line get more and more tax breaks. As people stop consuming, and wealth is concentrated, purchases slow down, taxes slow down, etc... There are also a LOT of savings to be made by reorganizing the government, in France it's currently a massive layer cake of redundant administrations, outdated systems, and fake jobs created for the government's friends and former ministers

Nick - The Linux Experiment

Yeah, and trickle down economics never worked for a single year after it was introduced. The wealth stayed at the top and never reached the bottom anyway

CBits Tech

Maybe it's our own political biases (which is understandable and acceptable) but I don't think taxing busineses more encourages business to invest in that country. They could invest elsewhere, which hurts long term growth. Again, I'm not well-informed. Oh, and let's not use the US as a good example 🙂 Re the French Government layer-cake, it's not just France. It's the same here in England. I think the problem has been (since the 70s, when I became aware of fiscal matters), politicians are in it for the ego and the own benefit. I'm sure that many have altruistic reasons, but as I once heard on YouTube, someone's views are influenced by who pays the bills (or helps get you to power, in this case). I don't think there will ever be an answer for that. Getting things done properly needs money, but you can't get the money to get things done properly from taxes, so you need to get things done cheaply, which means cuts and poor services. That's economics 🙂

Richard Gunn

For too long big business has been having it both ways - they can outsource their labour to the cheapest economies in the world, sell their products into the richest countries and keep their profits in the lowest taxed economies. Globalisation benefits big business more than it benefits the people - this needs to change. We have a problem with spiraling public sector costs in the UK - no party on the left want to reform/cut public services - instead they borrow more. The UK national debt is out of control.

CBits Tech

Maximising profits is the company's obligation to the shareholders. That's how business works. It keeps the employees employed, and those of us in the position of having managed funds in pensions, insurances, and other collective investments benefit from those profits by growth on those funds.

Steve C

Thanks for shedding some light on current French disturbances. Surprisingly, it doesn't sound that different in some ways from the situation in the US. The main difference is that we're more passive about it, and probably more poorly informed. I don't think much of it is about policy. It's more about feeling, and who hates whom. We also don't want to pay taxes for government services. Teachers are not well-paid, and have to beg for or pay for their own basic classroom supplies. Parents are control freaks, and demand that their precious geniuses are properly launched into elite universities. Government is the puppet of large corporations. So I think many of the problems are universal. The protests may be out of control and misguided, but some feathers badly need to be ruffled.

Hamish Dehmer

The protests aren't misguided or out of control. The system only speaks in force, it showed that when they killed protesting kids and street medics. It showed it when they started encited class violence against them.

Nick - The Linux Experiment

It's not taxing them more, it's taxing them normally, without the tax breaks. As we've seen in every country that gave tax breaks to companies, they pocket it AND still invest outside, where it's cheaper :) on the "taxes can't pay enough to do good services": they did so for 50 years, up until the 70s when trickle down economics were mistakenly introduced. Before that, taxes paid for good services, because taxes were more fair: the richer you were, the higher the share you paid, that was the case in virtually every country in the world. The only reason taxes can't pay for good services is because taxes are now only paid by a fraction of the population, and uses to subsidize companies instead of paying for these services :)

Nick - The Linux Experiment

THis isn't true in all countries either :) In France there is no legal obligation to maximize profits at all. Employees being employed at the cost of not being paid enough to even go to their jobs and house themselves isn't a system that needs to be preserved, IMO.

Nick - The Linux Experiment

Yeah, the protests aren't out of control, it's the usual 1 out of 20 000 person taking advantage of the mass protest to break things. They're also not misguided at all, they're fully right to protest :)

Steve C

I wasn't sure they were misguided. I was trying (poorly) to say that _even_ if they are imperfect, they may be needed.

Ian Betteridge

Really good podcast, Nick and I enjoyed getting a French perspective on what’s going on there at the moment

AArexx AAron Ruscetta

Thanks for speaking out about the media fraud surrounding reporting on the massive protests in France and for sharing your view of the political conflicts. A lot of what you are saying also came to me from a favorite U.S. political law analyst (now an expat living in Ireland). < https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wjQU77bKP08 > Unfortunately very similar to the dire situations and propagandist mecia in the U.S.

CBits Tech

I see. Sounds pretty messed up then. It makes the UK seem like we've got it figured out. We don't, but by comparison we seem better. It has been an interesting diversion from the usual programming, and good to hear the perspective of an individual within the situation, thanks.

Nick - The Linux Experiment

Yeah, we generally do the same crap as what the US does, 5 or 10 years after, without ever learning about the failures of other countries. I do like the "We can do it here in France, our own way" mentality we have here, but it's also applied to the idiotic decisions, unfortunately.

Eric Flores

I just watched a podcast featuring a French woman who openly blamed the Muslim Brotherhood for virtually all the problems France is facing today. I was surprised by how strongly and confidently she presented her views. That's quite a sweeping claim about such a complex situation! Interestingly, an investigative reporter have also raised concerns about the alleged infiltration and influence of groups associated with the Muslim Brotherhood in France and other European countries. The podcast also claimed that government financial assistance had been discontinued, prompting some affected groups to take to the streets in protest. So, here's my question: Are these claims supported by the facts, or is there another, perhaps hidden, agenda behind the narrative? What is really happening in France and across Europe?