Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

Hey eveyrone!

In today's episode, I ramble about:

  • 01:07 My sponsorship with proton and whether I should stop it now

  • 10:10 The short sighted approach to rebuilding your entire company around AI instead of people

Let me know what you think!

Comments

Eric Flores

Proton is your client, and your responsibility is essentially to provide the advertising services you agreed to deliver and receive payment for your work. Addressing Proton's internal problems is ultimately their responsibility, not yours. I've always believed in the saying, "Don't bite the hand that feeds you." Personally, I think you may be overreacting to the situation. I wouldn't place too much weight on what others say, whether their opinions are positive or negative. Everyone has their own perspective, and there will always be people who praise something and others who criticize it. The reality is that you cannot please everyone, and no company, product, or service will ever satisfy everybody. What matters is maintaining a professional relationship, fulfilling your obligations, and making your own judgments based on facts and personal experience rather than being influenced by the opinions of others.

kolorafa

I think you should milk them more if it will not affect your integrity with telling full honest truth, unless they already block you from promoting other alternatives or force you to silence. ---- tl;dr: Using AI personally to avoid burnout while making the work higher quality is good. AI can result in good stuff if used right with recent best models. Company forcing devs to use AI will 9 out of 10 times result in enshitification: - devs will just throw prompts and AI and don't give a F - AI will modify stuff that no one look at causing issues all over the places - the support will be replaced with AI in full - resulting in very bad customer support Proton might be your client, but listeners are too (even if they "pay less"). So you should definitely not hide stuff just because someone pay a little for something related (they pay you for ad, not to skip reporting about some news). Overall don't sell yourself short, IMHO the worse thing someone can do is sell themself's for cheap for some shady business. (example, PewDiePie sold his add spot for some shady crypto piramid, it did sound shady, and in the end it turnd out it was a piramid, even if he now produce linux content I'm would be for, I'm constantly discussed with that as god only knows how many people god scammed because of him) --- Personally I would like to hear more about alternative providers or solutions so I as a customer for both Podcast (and Proton) can choice for myself. I would expect Proton to be a "good service" for a little bit more until the AI sinks more, they might recover and all that time they gain using AI put in quality checks and that might result in better product for even cheaper, but only time will tell. For me, I was trying to move from gmail to some (self) hosted email solution, was contemplating with self hosting for full privacy but maintaining it is PITA, so I was thinking of hosted solutions, but now I'm more hesitant to go with Proton. I understand why CEO said to use AI, as it does look good and can achieve some goals for cheap (as I'm using it myself), but that's also exactly why I'm hesitant because I have first hand experience with using AI, it can be scary good, but also scary bad. As even the best intentions can result in bad result.

Alex Aguilar

I appreciate your thoughtfulness and transparency, and I understand why you'd want to discontinue the sponsorship. However, I think that may be an overreaction. Had they ended the sponsorship outright after hearing your comments, that would have sent a very different message. Instead, it sounds like they heard your concerns, responded, and are still willing to remain a sponsor. That suggests that even if they don't fully agree, they still see value in the relationship and are comfortable having you stick around.

Rodrigo V. Perez

Before actually listening to the Proton bit I was gonna say maybe put that on hold, try to not fully terminate it... but knowing their "your video did damage" response, deflecting their own responsibility... better to end it. And no, you're not overreacting, your reaction is understandable and way more professional that what mine would be.

JF002

I'm honestly disappointed by their (lack of) communication: it looks like they are completely radio silent since the last "apology" message from Andy more than a week ago. And if I were you, I would also be disappointed by the response you received from them. You did not do any harm, you just aggregated and contextualized what was already circulating publicly. And the harm was already done on Reddit anyway (according to the constant flow of posts about that drama that I receive in my feed). But still, let's take a step back: a lot of people are outraged because they got a glimpse of what happens in the company. Yes, what is happening (very bad communication from the CEO, "the botched 're-interview' plan",...) is not great at all. But can we honestly say we have such visibility on what goes on internally in other companies? My guess is that we would probably hate most of the companies if we were aware of all the internal drama of many of them. Same for the AI Manifesto: yes, it's ridiculous, short-sighted and probably the result of a PR or management team that doesn't have any idea what they are talking about. But Proton is far from the first company to announce such AI insanity. What I mean is that we may have just discovered that Proton isn't the ideal company we all dreamed of. It's just another company with its good sides (mission, products) and bad sides (atrocious communication, bad management, no Linux client for Drive). Personally, I'm still waiting on a more official response, more actions, and will continue using their services unless their quality decreases or they fail at their mission. About the companies that reorganize themselves around AI, there is another point of view that's worth mentioning : I really doubt there's enough compute resources and power generation available on our planet right now to replace all the brainpower of the whole humain work force. When too many human are replaced by AI, servers will be overloaded, token generation will be too slow to be usable, and prices will increase up to a point when hiring a human will be more affordable... What a time to be alive...

phoebe headkittens

I think walking shows integrity on your part, you get to be discriminating in who you associate with, and as you say, you have a competitor lined up. That said, though I walked from Proton myself, I don't have strong opinions about whether you should. I don't like the reported behaviour by the CEO, I don't much care for their apparent strategy, and it feels a bit like a cover up effort to discredit the source, and acting dismissive towards your coverage as well is just kind of scummy. I get it, they're trying to manage a PR problem, but taking it out on partners isn't the way. I don't like muddied waters, I trust your judgement. I won't be put off by Proton partner spots.

ifearghal

Thank you for asking for our input. You have been covering open source/linux/tech news as far as I have known you. The video that led me to monetarily support you was a video in which you stated your principles. You have been pushing forward a measured approach and haven't been over reactionary as far as i have seen. In terms of how you see your income, you have discussed this before, but if you are compromising your moral alignment for some cash, you have to live with that, not anyone here. Them being upset with you for covering the news is gross. If a company or sponsor wants to hold their partnership with you over your head, to me that tells you everything you need to know. I left proton as a customer and its a pain in the ass, but to me, it's about what I know about where I put my money. For some, this doesn't bother them. When i have a choice about where I can put my money, i make that choice. Hearing what proton said to you after your video make s me believe that I made the right choice by leaving.

enistello

Proton's reaction seems to have been "it was partly your fault we got bad publicity". I think that ignores the fact that the bad publicity was a result of the CEO and CTO's publicised actions. To take that through to a logical conclusion, Proton would like only positive publicity. If you are happy with that, stay with them. If you are not happy with that arrangement, look elsewhere for sponsorship.

Clint Eschberger

From my perspective, I can no longer recommend Proton in good faith due to what happened. That said, this is your livelihood. If you can replace it and not hurt that, sure, I would like to see it gone. However, if it is going to cause you issues, then you do what you need to do towards that end. I am not going to judge you on that. That said, the way they handled your video on it would not make me feel good about the situation.

Rafał

On Proton – a lot depends on exact wording of what you said and what they said and I can't afford the time to re-read/re-listen to all of it, so here's my overall impression: I think you might've rushed the initial news item. You said that you got in touch with them about it, so clearly it would've been better to have their response. But you gave them a few hours to respond, which is not enough, and it sounds like the reason for that was that the video was due to be published soon. There's always the next episode, right? As for the situation on their side – if the CEO outright insulted people, that's very bad and should be rectified. But the state of matters in the industry is that AI works and doing everything manually is no longer competitive. Engineers have to recognize that, as uncomfortable as it feels. I say that as a software developer myself.

Dellin Drifts

I can see strong reasons to end the Proton partnership and to stay, which is to say that as a patreon I support either decision. I don't like how they responded to you or their implicit expectation that you'll only cover them favorably. Your response sounds spot on. As for AI, completely agree with your takes, people aren't thinking far enough ahead about what all this use really means for the bigger picture. It's unsustainable in so many ways!

Steve C

I'd take their money, even if it's a little tainted. I think the vast majority of tech companies are tainted, or will become tainted, at this point. But I still wish YouTube creators would switch to a TV model, where they show ad spots provided by the sponsors, instead of doing personal endorsements.

FOSSCharlie

At least Proton staff felt comfortable enough to talk about it, albeit anonymously. There are many companies where staff are terrified of being blacklisted for even thinking something negative about their company. Keep the sponsorship and move on.

UsernamesAreHard

The response you got from Proton is disappointing honestly. Instead of clarifying the situation, they decided to blame you for talking about this fiasco and giving your opinion about it. I do agree that messaging your contact only a few hours before your video was too short, but the answer you got back from Proton kind of confirms the current lousy management situation over at Proton, where management is right and people concerned about AI need to shut it, obey management and serve the Ai. Proton must be in hot water financially currently. They wanted to grow too fast and compete with Google products head on, despite having only a fraction of Google's workforce. They're going all in on Ai, probably as a last resort to salvage the messy situation of releasing unfinished products every other month. Ai is not going to fix their unfinished products and putting Ai on a pedestal, before their engineers, no matter the cost, won't do them any favour long term. Proton really hurt their reputation those last few weeks in the privacy and security community and failed to address, clarify and rectify this whole mess. While I understand that you're at least a little bit dependant on their sponsorship, I think that dropping them as a sponsor is the right choice whenever you can, it will probably avoid some backlash by some of your viewers too if you drop them.

Jason Tubnor

I agree with your stance on Proton. I have issues with the company but won't view you as a sell out if you keep them. Thanks for the tip on Internxt. Their S3 offering is competitive against Backblaze and Bunny but European based (Bunny is as well but a little more expensive). Competition is good and non-US based alternatives, even better.

Ryan Thiessen

Local models are already quite good. I’m running strata, which enables me to run frontier models on a midrange gpu and local ram — and it pairs extremely well with Linux. I’ve honestly had a lot of fun getting it to make custom plasmoids and small utilities, personal mods for games I play, that sort of thing. Does it make sense for the companies making these models or the ones firing and stopping hiring? You make some good points but I can’t control what they do — and so it doesn’t feel to me like it subtracts from the enjoyment and utility I get from my local models.

Dewir3

I don't think you're overreacting about Proton. Whether you want to stop advertising for them is up to you, but I think you have good reasons to if you do. The one doing damage to them is not you or your videos, it is their CEO, both in his business decisions and his public and internal statements. His public behaviour has raised some red flags before and already made me skeptical of Proton before all of this, and his leaked communication and response to your coverage is showing a further downward trend in my opinion. They are in dire need of a change in leadership and I fully understand not wanting to have business relationship with them at the moment. From their reaction I would also not be surprised if they would end their sponsorship themselves if you continue to shed light on their wrongdoings.

Jechtt

Nick, does this mean you would cancel your Proton subscription as well? You’ve mentioned using their services, do you have services in mind that you would move to? I’d be interested in you covering alternatives. I’ve been a subscriber to Proton Unlimited for five years, and I never considered that I might unsubscribe from their product. So now I’m fully entrenched in their ecosystem, and I have no idea what’s out there for recommended and comparable alternatives.

David

I agree with your sentiment on Proton's management issues, 100%. It sounds like Andy Yen doesn't have the respect of his employees, and probably with good reason. If you could know for sure that other companies aren't behaving the same internally, then I'd be likely to advise against renewing any contract with Proton. However, we don't know that to be true of other companies. If I had to bet on it, I'd put my money on Proton not being alone here. It's likely a lot of other companies are operating in the same way, only it hasn't been publicized yet. If you were to bail on Proton, you might be jumping to another company with similar problems you don't know about. If I were in your shoes, I would not intentionally dump Proton just yet, but unless your agreement with Proton precludes it, I would also be open to other competitors (like Internxt, which I hadn't heard of before this podcast episode—thanks for that tip!). As a developer who uses Claude Code to help with development, I find it to be great at troubleshooting issues and at writing code that generally works. Its code is quite often not efficient or all that well-written, but it's rarely completely broken (I couldn't say the same thing a year ago). I still find it making mistakes almost constantly though, so humans reviewing the code, in my opinion, is critically important. This does concern me with security and privacy-aimed products like Proton.

assaf rutenberg

I am thrilled that you are considering dropping Proton as a sponsor. They have had a disconnect between their public stance and what they actually do for years. I used them for many years but dropped them when they continued to support Russia after Russia invaded Ukraine. They claimed the reason was net neutrality, but net neutrality is not the same as neutrality in the face of an obvious evil.

Nick - The Linux Experiment

Well, I made my own opinion on this, which is: this sucks, it washandled badly, and the CEO looks like a pretty bad boss, which is generally enough for me to want to walk away :) I don't base this on anyone else's opinion but I'm willing to hear other arguments, which is why I asked about it here :)

Eric Flores

Is the CEO also the owner of the company, or does the company operate under a board of directors? This is an important distinction because a board of directors generally has the authority to remove a CEO, particularly when the company experiences sustained poor financial performance or fails to meet its strategic objectives. Even if the CEO founded the company, that does not necessarily guarantee job security when a board of directors has oversight and decision-making authority. Nick, you have something good going here. Keep working hard to maintain it, improve it, and build upon what you have already accomplished. Success takes time, dedication, and perseverance. Stay focused on your vision, continue delivering quality content, and don't let temporary setbacks discourage you. You've built something worthwhile, and as you continue to develop it, more listeners will come. Keep moving forward!

Andrew

I agree with the statements saying to end the relationship. Their behavior even in their response to you in and of itself isn’t great. Maybe there will come a time where they realign and become a good option again (good as in terms of not just the product but their direction) but until then I say best to respectfully wash your hands of them.

Talya

one thing i'll say about local models is we have to remember who they come from and how they're trained. once this bubble pops and these companies can't even pay for the electricity to keep making new proprietary models, they're definitely not gonna make new locally-installable models for the public to use, there's no way it's gonna be worth it. and then what? will people keep running a four-year-old model because it's the latest one that got released? all this means imo is that once these companies go under we still have a few years of juice left in the AI bubble-of-hype, but at some point this too will run out.