Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

The Mexican Grand Prix is done - what do you want to know about it and what do you want our opinion on?

Leave your ONE question for Edd, Josh and special guest Diego Mejia in the comments on this post and they'll tackle as many as they can across tonight's episode of The Race F1 Podcast and our Mailbag podcast early in the coming week.

Files

Comments

Jim Al

At the risk of sounding like a hopeless romantic; Isn't this podium the perfect way of celebrating Antonelli's first WDC? Sharing the podium with 2 other drivers being called generational talents is so fitting in my opinion. It genuinely brought a tear to my eye. What a story. For all the well founded criticism around the state of the sport this year, moments like these send goosebumps down my spine...!

Ben Kelly

Edd you always seem to be driving when you report on races, can you give us your top 3 worst places to drive? Also at what point are your colleagues going to pull their finger out and give you a lift for once?

Jake Nelson

Why did Hamilton restart the race 3rd? I thought usually mid-race red flags don’t see the order taken from a lap previous

Sam Bradshaw

Will Ferrari finally sort some form of Papaya rules now?

Will Pearce

Mailbag: Kimi notwithstanding, which 2025 rookie has made the biggest step forward this year? Conversely, who has been the most disappointing?

Sam Hardy

is max now the title favorite going into 2027? It seems like if red bull can keep this momentum going into next season it could be hard to look past him. Especially since he’s only 6 points shy of kimis total since Barcelona.

Adam Brewer

How do you rate Hirakawa's debut this weekend? And any update on the Ocon situation?

Daniel Nevett

Is this possibly the greatest level of talent on a podium ever or is it too soon to make that declaration?

Kukipegs Property Servies

No doubt a special victory for Kimi... my question is how many can he rack up in his career, and can he resist driving for Ferrari at some point in the future?

Roland86

Which PU spec was Lewis using? ADUO1? I think he only had one ADUO2 PU in the pool and it was the PU he had an issue on friday right?

Ben Clarkson

Can the track layout be adjusted to help improve racing? It seems far too easy to defend an overtake

Ed R Gaming

What happened to Russell's pace in the race? At the start he seemed to be so much slower than everyone else, was this something similar to Spa?

carma strikes

It's gonna be on top of everyone's lists today, but did Charles Leclerc cost Lewis Hamilton the win today?

Alex Manley

Is this the end of the previously jovial Ferrari driver pairing?

Daniel Lyons

What happened with Hadgar’s race and how did he end up behind Lawson?

dw053

The headline podcast question, not a mailbag question! Kimi Antonelli becomes the youngest-ever F1 World Champion at just 20 years old, how does his achievement compare with the other young first-time champions of the 21st century — Alonso, Hamilton, Vettel and Verstappen?

Ethan

This may be a mailbag. At what point do we start reconsidering 5 & 10 second penalties. F1 cars naturally space about so much from dirty air that they don't have an impact. Lewis won a race with a 10 second before, Charles here had nearly no impact until the red flag. Should some of these infractions start to warrant grid place drops after the race as that feels like a proper punishment?

PK

Why were all the marshals in the pit lane putting their hands up as a car passed? How much better have F1 got at crowning a world champion? There didn’t always used to be much they seemed to do on the day it was clinched, but now, even if Kimi was not on the podium there’d have been far more fanfare?

Thorarinn Gunnarsson

Mailbag: Hamilton had seven championships in the bank to survive four years of a ground effect slump. If the Ferrari was a championship winnig car he could well be winning the WDC. Does George Russell have the status or the time to survive waiting for another regulatory reset?

Nando Lorris

Why could Charles carry on when his tyre went down to the toirbke?

Thomas Beagley

Did Leclerc cost Ferrari a 1-2 with his first lap antics, and was today proof that Leclerc isn’t cut out to be a world champion? His first lap antics cost Lewis the lead and handed a seemingly assured Ferrari victory to Max.

Chris Wilkins

Hamilton was bold this week, declaring that the sport has “never had anyone like me here in the 70 years” and that he is “built differently.” He backed it up with his first pole in years—and his first for Ferrari. Did Lewis lose the race today, or was he bested by a better driver?

Ben B

With Verstappen arguing that Lawson was 'stupid' to race him as he did given the commercial relationships between their 2 teams, does this add weight to the argument that there is a growing conflict of interest between Red Bull's ownership of 2 teams?

Gordon Ross

Has Esteban Ocon decided to challenge Fernando Alonso for the crown of F1's premier bridgeburner?

F1DebateTeam

Was this Verstappen’s best drive of the year? His starts (and restarts) supremely impressed me, and he dealt well with the pressure of keeping a red hot Hamilton in a faster car behind. Kept his head cool even with contact with Lewis towards the end.

Nate B

VB sympathy corner?

Oscar Robledo

Charles Leclerc needs reminding that all Ferrari drivers drive for the team first and themselves second. Should Ferrari penalise him and is the team dynamic fundamentally changed?

mrt0mmy

Just one simple question. Did Leclerc ruin Hamilton’s and Ferrari’s weekend with his first lap aggression ?

Dan W

Esteban Ocon. Was dumped by Alline before the end his last season, now dumped by Haas. Has he made himself permanently unemployable in F1 now? An average driver with an attitude problem isn't really an asset to the team or sponsors.

Fredrik Sjögren

Why were there so many poor pitstops in Mexico?

F1DebateTeam

Perhaps Ferrari needs some Horseplay Guidelines?

Alex Michaelides

Super Alesi strikes again! Another Ferrari win thrown away. What can the ‘serious talks’ Hamilton referenced in his post race interview actually change?

Chris Wilkins

Agree, Max seemed perfect today.

Alan North

Does lando Norris have a race craft problem? He seem to be afraid to send one, and far from being the last of the late brakers, he the very first of the brakers!

Chris Foreman

Firstly, Forza Kimi! What a podium to have Hamilton, Verstappen and Antonelli feels right to have the old guard welcome the new pup to their midst. My question: Lance Stroll's parking has caused issues again today. He was instructed to stop the car by the team, and did so, but surely could have parked in a way that meant the marshals could have moved his car far more easily. Instead the VSC was out for longer than necessary while they pushed it back into the track to reposition it. Are there any penalties for parking? Weve seen 'lifetime' bans for crash-gate with Renault. Is there any danger that we could see a 'park-gate' if someone wanted to tactically retire one car for an easy pitstop for the other?

Kombikarlos

What’s going on at Aston Martin? Are they now taking a high-risk, high-reward approach?

Alexander Law

Does Charles have Lewis in his head a bit? He has been quicker on balance but he's made some recent errors that really makes you wonder if he's just driving too aggressively in moments?

Ed g

Does Ferrari need to punish Charles for those first 5 corners it's not the first teammate he's done that to and if they are ever to have a world champion with him in the team he needs to become a team player

George

Has this season changed your opinion on Charles Leclerc?

Rob Fuller

In the cool down room, Lewis and Max have complained about clipping this weekend. It feels like there's less discussion of clipping, yo yo racing, etc now than earlier this year. Has it gone away as a problem or is F1 just finished talking about it?

Simon Emms

He'd have to share the mic. And Edd is the King

Motorsport Mike

Did hamiltons moaning get a bit too much? He complained about Leclerc incident 30 laps after it happened

Nando Lorris

Was it a dodgy toirbke that stopped the Astons?

SimracerSam

Is Fred just gonna sit on his hands until Charles and Lewis smash each other off the road? It seems very silly that they’ve lost four wins or podiums because of overly aggressive driving. It’s like no one’s in charge.

JohnnyO

Should Norris have been able to overtake Leclerc? I felt that any other of the top 6 drivers would have been able to make a move stick. Was Leclerc’s defence top drawer or is it more evidence of Lando’s weak wheel to wheel racing?

Motorsport Mike

Should Hamilton be fined for saying “the stewards have handed Leclerc the win”? Is that criticising the stewards which is not allowed?

Gastón Mazzacane

What do we reckon Haas will do with Ryo Hirakawa moving forwards? If he completes the rest of the season, Haas will need to look elsewhere next year and beyond for someone do step in for FP1 sessions.

James Smith

Potentially Mailbag mini rant - What is going on with the TV direction recently? Having to watch the late on Leclerc v Norris battle in a tiny PIP while the main feed showed the top 3 following each other, not to mention that awful AI gimmick montage on the slow down lap instead of showing the live pictures of Kimi celebrating in the car. Of course entertainment is key, but sometimes showing what’s actually happening is the most entertaining part of it all! Congrats to Kimi though, awesome stuff.

Ryan M

(Possibly Mailbag) in 2023 we seen Leclerc sacrifice his race for Sainz to win in Singapore. But in 2019 and now several times in 2026 we’ve seen he can’t play the team game, is this an issue of his need to be sure the team views him as its best hope? In 2019 he was establishing himself but now Hamilton as big name signing is threatening his dominance within the team and his desperation doesn’t speak to someone who could cope with championship fighting pressure?

Stuart Coulter

Curious as to how Gasly did not get disqualified for running the red light at pit lane exit during a race? (I'm not saying I thought he deserved to get disqualified, but rather, past precedent would suggest he should have been?)

Joe Fitzsimons

Did Verstappen's 1 place grid penalty actually win him the race. He got to start on the clean side of the grid and his first lap arguably won him the race?

Motorsport Mike

Should Russell be miles ahead of the others in the championship? His bad luck has now hampered his championship position

Andrew N

We love that The Race stays neutral in terms of driver support. But on a day like this, do you still find yourself being swept up in the emotion of a championship win like this? Tears swelled up for me, and I’m a Red Bull fan!

Jack Goodall

Putting the starts/restarts aside, would we have seen more of a battle for the lead with DRS today rather than overtake?

Dan W

He's always been unreal at Mexico, definitely one of his best tracks

Motorsport Mike

Do Ferrari need to stricter with Hamilton when he moans in the radio?

Alex Schlesinger

What colour pastel jumper does Lewis opt for to give Leclerc a dressing down?

James Stock

Was Leclerc unreasonable today in his attacks on Hamilton on lap 1 today and given his brazen attitude to gaining the position off track, was he fortunate to get a lenient penalty?

Hurronivich

If you were Fred Vasseur what would you do try and manage Hamilton and Leclerc on track? Clearly it is not easy for him since both drivers are not going to accept lesser status in the team and both will continue to fight it out - however the current approach is very much not working. If next year the top 4 teams are close enough to fight for the title, Ferrari seems destined to boil over as the other 3 teams have a clear better driver.

Ryan M

We seen an overview of Perez pit stop and while there was a problem on a tyre it looked generally slow. Given the failure Bottas suffered today and the litany of reliability issues they’ve had this year is it time to say, yes they achieved something in making it to the grid but that its been something of a failure after that.

Curtis

Was Lawson’s qualifying DSQ driver error for not lifting?

Brian Mortensen

Perhaps a mailbag question, but how would you rate Antonelli's first title in the overall pantheon of first titles? Would you draw any parallels to previous breakthrough champions?

Fritiof

How come Aston is still allowed to start races? It’s not a matter of when they cause a yellow but when. Lance is one DNF shy of the DNF record of Rubens from -97 as mentioned on the broadcast. Just like there’s a 107% percent rule in qualifying there should be some limits to these joker safety car triggers masked in green

Andy Goulding

Yet again Ferrari throw away a potential 1-2 because they can’t control their drivers. How long before they get Horner in to sort out some structure?

Motorsport Mike

Was antonelli faultless all year? with the exception of track limits, he doesn’t seem to have a weakness in him?

MrsKB 🥝🇳🇿

Gawd I really hope so! Very frustrating to watch 😑

Cymro44

Does Leclerc have an issue with team work? I seem to remember him never ceding any room to Sainz and always being in it for himself, regardless of how much his team mate was willing to put Ferrari first. I know drivers are inherently selfish but surely he needs to start showing some maturity in dealing with a team mate from now on. Have Ferrari created their version of a spoiled child who was never told no?

Chris Casabianca

Not sure if this is a mailbag or a special episode, but how do Ferrari keep doing Ferrari things. Easy 1-2 gone due to ego. Crazy.

Motorsport Mike

Lindblad/Piastri collision avoidable as Verstappen/hamilton in first lap of restart avoided collision in similar incident?

dorynickel

Obviously Leclerc's tire situation was his own fault, but how did he manage to keep Norris behind for so long??

Mark Swaine

Are there any positives for Haas today?

Michael Searle

Not a question but can you tell Palmer if you see him that he's using the word Pressurising wrong, he means just Pressuring. It really bugs me 😂

Shrinkinator

In retrospect, does George even deserve to keep his drive at Mercedes? Unless he plans to be a modern-day David Coulthard number 2 at Merc, I just don’t see the point in him staying.

Motorsport Mike

Has this been the craziest weekend in recent memory in terms of the variety of things out of the ordinary going on?

Rachel

I’d like to know why tire life seems to have extended far past its usual bounds as of late? RIP to the hard tire.

Max Camposano

Between poor pace, several strange/dangerous mechanical failures, and operational struggles, it seems like Caddy have not built well on their relatively respectable start to life in F1. How would you grade where they are now compared to the start of the season?

Maurice Henry

Can you answer this conundrum? Will Ferrari ever win a world championship with Fred acting like nothing is wrong and Charles seemingly driving for himself and not the team. The lack of co-ordination was baffling and led directly to Max gaining track position. Did Charles just underline his failings?

Motorsport Mike

Could haas/Ocon situation be resolved? If not should they put Doohan in the car or Camara or someone else?

James Melia

Mailbag with the talk of bottas possible losing his seat at cadillac, it got me wondering about there season, i believe its been quite respectable reliability taken into consideration and what changes have been seen trackside in there operations since Graham Lowden was replaced and has there been staff changes behind the scenes

Chris Parrott

Was this a toirbke moment for Ferrari?

Chris Parrott

How was it seeing Bottas in a. Literal sympathy corner?

Motorsport Mike

Last time a driver due to disagreement with the team when Prost described his Ferrari as a truck?

Michael Horner

Was anyone from Aston Martin left to even see the restart, let alone the finish? How could they be so dreadful to only last 5 minutes in the race? Was it Honda again?

Chris Parrott

Compare and contrast Lewis v Max into Turn 1 & Oscar v Arvid. Were the incidents similar and what can the latter pair learn from the former about executing a close battle cleanly.

Dario Dixon

I thought I recalled a lot being made of more consistent stewarding (unless that was Indycar), and now at a race weekend where going off and gaining an advantage has been discussed the stewards immediate action is to go back on what was agreed (5 second penalty for Leclerc). Sure Hamilton also went off but you could see his visible penalty in trying to stay on track (he lost the lead). Maybe rather than mitigating circumstances Leclerc gets 10 seconds and Hamilton gets 5 if they both had blame

Anders Dunkel

With Italy now having it first's WDC since 1953, do you think support in Italy will shift from Ferrari to Antonelli? I feel that Ferrari has gotten a way with a lot simply because they are F1's only "national team". Now that Italians have another option to support, I believe there support will fall away in the coming years.

Timo Ehlers

Was gonna go on the same rant - everything interesting is exiled to the tiniest window while showing a procession on the big screen. It is infuriating.

BOB

What happened to all the yoyo racing and super clipping on the straights? Did the teams learn to manage it better or has fom broadcasting gotten better at hiding telemetry

Nando Lorris

New tyres for the new regs. Pirelli had no race data. Next should be better... hopefully

James Lazar

I’ll repeat my question from only a few weeks ago! Is this another example of Ferrari throwing away a big result? No one is expecting Lewis and Charles to not fight. But 1-2 after the first few corners, surely you hold station or at the very least, don’t battle THAT hard when the likes of Max are so close behind. Lewis said it I believe of Lando a while back, but you don’t pull a move on the outside a 7-time champ like that. It was never going to happen. Imagine Charles trying that with Max…

#37

Anthony Davidson talked about Russell losing time in US Qualifying by going flatout, because that prevented him from harvesting. Along with with every other issue with These algorithmic Engines, will this WDC and every other until 2030 be worthless?

David Saiya

Is Leclerc being so aggressive because he wants to try to demonstrate he is the number 1 driver in the team and possibly down to him not being the number 1 driver in the team

Alex97

One for mailbag - Lewis is trying to lead the prancing horse to water, what more can he do to make it drink? We have the same discussion about Ferrari every year. They seem just too principled and stubborn to become a championship worthy operation. They are so close yet so far!

James Melia

Mailbag Just wondering when it comes to the race and covering races, when the calendar is released how does the rotation for who goes to races be worked out and is there some races certain staff want to attend over others, also which countries do you find easiest to navigate to and from track and which countries cuisine would be your recommendation to experience

Steve D

Mailbag: who will leave Ferrari first, and who should leave Ferrari first: Fred, Charles, or Lewis? Or would nothing change given the culture there, regardless of who is in the team?

nickthks

I want to say I’m not an Ocon fan. However am I the only one who feels that the Haas behaviour has to be some of the most unprofessional behaviour by an f1 team in recent years? The alpine incident was for a post season test which I can understand, furthermore Haas have been more or less complaining publicly about him and dragging him over the coals and are surprised when he doesn’t like that? Ultimately I get it comes down to performance but if you’re Haas and you build a Haas quality car you can’t expect to have a top team level driver! (Sorry for ranting, just really unimpressed on a job professional level view)

Adam Barton

Was it just me, but despite the moaning, was Lewis Hamilton lucky not to get a penalty for forcing Leclerc off track at T4? How should Ferrari manage radio traffic given Hamilton's comms contributed to or at least didn't help Leclerc's case against his penalty?

Simon Emms

Mailbag: what's the feeling amongst your Italian colleagues? A country with a proud motorsport heritage, but no Ferrari title in 18 years and no driver's title in 73 years. It feels huge from the outside.

Luke Sherman

Feel free to toss this at a mailbag or a tech show or roll it in with other conversations, but what is going on with Aston and the Honda power unit that they had to retire almost immediately?

F1DebateTeam

Many think that Leclerc cost Ferrari a win - but why is Leclerc barred from fighting, and isn’t it clear that both drivers are to blame for going off track? They should be allowed to fight

Anssi Rulamo

If we forget that Leclerc was racing his team-mate, how good was his lap 1 wheel-to-wheel racing? Do you think he was always going to cut turn 4 and take a strategic penalty to get clean air?

Cedi

What is going at Ferrari? They let them race for themself without looking at the team result. Yes they are P2 but today there was a double podium in sight, potentially 1-2 with where they were before fighting. Is this because they (Ferrari) can’t say no to either of the drivers?

MrsKB 🥝🇳🇿

Couldn't stop smiling seeing Kimi sitting by himself on the podium - soaking it all in - with just his car, flag and confetti 💚🤍❤️

Rachel

For sure, it just feels even more exaggerated in the last few races. Hoping it’s better (along with many other things) next year 🤞

Adam Striżyk

MAILBAG question I guess. This is a question I was going to ask: "Should there be a VSC/SC/red flag rules revamp? Hamilton and Ferrari went for new tyres which should have been a good call only to be screwed by the red flag. In cases like this reverting the order to which ever it was in time of deploying th SC would be fair ." In time of writing it the order was changed. So instead it would be great if you guys could explain the rules in cases like this.

Harri Evans

Did Bottas have any damage or car issues before the suspension failure? Or was he struggling on pure pace?

Aaron

When a driver wins a world championship, we see on television what it means to the driver and the team at the track. What does it mean to the engineers, the designers, the technicians, the janitors, the secretaries, and many others back at base?

Adam Striżyk

I second that. Not taking away from Max, brilliant execusion on both start, restart and strategy, but this time Leclerc is the main contributor to Max's win.

sam bedford

Probably more of a mail bag question. With this increasingly lightly to be Ocons last race weekend drive for a while at least. Would his career have played out differently if he had a team built around him like Max at Redbull or Lewis at Mercedes. Personally I don't think he ever quite justified it but I'd be interested to hear your thoughts

Mark A

Probable mailbag question but since his return to Racing Bulls Lawson seems to have stepped up another gear. Is this a result of banishing the Red Bull demons from ‘25? Or did the stint at a bigger team unlock something that was missing from this season?

James Hoyle

In a weekend full of Haas controversy, how long do Bearman and potentially Camara risk being stuck in a small dysfunctional team before they escape the Ferrari ecosystem? (mailbag question?)

JAWSF1

Even For all his speed is leclerc too interested in himself to really help Ferrari move forward? He was like this with sainz several times but seems to have taken on a max 21 mentally when it comes to Lewis with no regard for the team at all

James

After today’s race, is Piastri the driver most in need of getting to the end of the season and hitting reset? While Leclerc has struggled with the new regs, he now seems to have the hang of them. Russell has equally struggled, but unlike Piastri, has reached high peaks during the season. McLaren may have a difficult car to drive, but as Norris is showing, it can be competitive.

Haruki Imanishi

Mailbag question Edd. With how chaotic the Ferrari pair have been in terms of their conduct, why do you think there has been such a change in how they have been in the past, even a year ago? They used to use team orders all the time, to an annoying extent, but now they’re afraid to do anything about Hamilton and Leclerc. What do you think changed?

Sue Moorcroft

If we had this exact race under next year’s regulations, would there be more overtaking opportunities at the ends of the straights? Or am I being optimistic?

Chuck Aoki

If you had to be George Russell or Lewis Hamilton going into next season, who would you rather be?

David Flett

Leclerc seemed to go into this race wanting to prove he’s the top driver at Ferrari rather than getting a result for Ferrari. In the end he cost the team a likely 1-2. By how much has he damaged his standing within the scuderia?

Simon Emms

There have been some really action-packed races that have felt dull because of the desire to not move away from the leaders. Is this George Lucas's doing?

Khalil Berry

Was it just me or it was overtaking really difficult today? What contributed to this?

Matthew McMahon

How close are we to Hamilton losing trust in Ferrari?

Daniel O-D (edited)

Comment edits

2026-11-03 04:00 Ferrari seem unwilling to reign in LeClerc’s being too aggressive with Hamilton, or to ask him to move over when Hamilton is faster or on a different strategy. Is it possible that it’s a contractual thing with LeClerc that he doesn’t have to move over for a team mate or follow strict team orders - ie hold a 1-2 position if you head out of the first corner that way. It seems genuinely baffling otherwise.
2026-11-01 23:41 Mailbag: Ferrari seem unwilling to reign in LeClerc’s being too aggressive with Hamilton, or to ask him to move over when Hamilton is faster or on a different strategy. Is it possible that it’s a contractual thing with LeClerc that he doesn’t have to move over for a team mate or follow strict team orders - ie hold a 1-2 position if you head out of the first corner that way. It seems genuinely baffling otherwise.

Mailbag: Ferrari seem unwilling to reign in LeClerc’s being too aggressive with Hamilton, or to ask him to move over when Hamilton is faster or on a different strategy. Is it possible that it’s a contractual thing with LeClerc that he doesn’t have to move over for a team mate or follow strict team orders - ie hold a 1-2 position if you head out of the first corner that way. It seems genuinely baffling otherwise.

Chiv2103

Is the criticism by British TV (although expected given who's invoked) unfair on Charles. He's a racing driver trying to win a race at the end of the day and the championship was gone months ago. Yes Lewis lost a place to max but he'd have lost that anyway having gone wide

Katie Bober

maybe more of a technical question than directly related to the GP, but I'm here in CDMX so I feel like it counts. When the Ferrari powered cars pass (Ferrari, Haas, Cadillac) you could see visible exhaust coming out of the back of the car, and it's not visible to the eye on any of the other cars. What is the reason for this? Since they're all Ferrari powered, is it related to the engine/PU?

Matt Tucker

If Lewis had cut the same corner as Charles, and therefore he keeps ahead of Max, to give a first lap order of 1.Charles 2.Lewis 3.Max, what penalties would have been given?

Maytham Abdul

After Bottas’s crash this is the second time Cadillac has had a suspension failure like this. At what point might and what mechanisms can the FIA use to intervene on safety grounds, especially given that such a failure is most likely to happen in a high-load and high risk situation?

BOB

Is it fair to say that Leclerc lacks the racing IQ and bigger picture mentality to ever be a world champion despite his undeniable raw pace? People make excuses that he never had the car, and yet even in the early parts of 2022 we saw the same high risk driving biting him despite having a quick car and a healthy championship lead...imola 2022...

Robert Chambers

Was George’s deployment issues at the start due to something he did wrong or just another random gremlin amongst the many that have plagued him all year?

AdPo

Is it fair to blame Leclerc for losing Ferrari the race? I'm not defending him, he was fairly penalized and cost the team a 1-2 finish, but Hamilton didn't lose the race because Leclerc cut a corner, he lost it because he himself ran wide and left the door open for Verstappen.

Rj Patterson

What happened to Aston Martin? Was it the Honda engine causing the DNFs in the race and issues in qualifying?

Ollie MacKenzie

Mailbag: How easy or difficult is it to tell whether someone is going to be a future world champion from karting/junior formula.

Joshua Primiano

I’d like to know your thoughts on the Piastri/Lindblad collision. When I saw it while Piastri did look like he came from a decent ways back he was alongside going into turn 2 and Lindblad kept moving over like he didn’t exist. In my opinion it was a racing incident but I’d like to know your thoughts.

JJ Cooper

With Esteban Ocon's benching...as much as I admire his drive and determination is it fair to say that he has proven to be his own worst enemy? This is now multiple teams where they seemed to have tired of having to deal with him.

Ferrari Fan Club

Ferrari have two mega drivers in their team. I don’t think they need to make any changes in that department. But why can’t Ferrari tell their drivers how to race each other? It seems like every team at the front like Mercedes and McLaren have a say in how their drivers race. Why can’t Ferrari demand the same? Ferrari has always been bigger than their drivers until now for some reason.

Dan W

I think it's clear that if the top two are within about 2 seconds of each other then they'll always get the main screen focus. Presumably that's some sort of policy for the TV director

Dan W

Considering Papaya rules only means "don't crash into your teammate" and nothing more, I would hope they've had an equivalent to that for a while

Amoros Rokaj

Lewis has always been a clean driver. That hurt him against Max and now Charles. Is it time for him to change his approach and get more aggressive?

Tyler Thompson

Ocon wasn’t there and there was enough drama and celebration to keep them out of the spotlight once the race got underway?

Tyler Thompson

100% disagree with your take. I like Ocon off the track, but clearly Komatsu has the record of much better behavior on track days and was extremely professional (cannot say anything of detail given legal implications) when asked about it during Saturday’s Sky coverage.

dontaylor500

On the Apple TV broadcast the announcer went on and on and on today about cars following closely behind another were in such danger of overheating.

dontaylor500

Overheating.. continued I saw Hamilton weaving a bit 'to keep temps down', but not a great deal. I didn't hear of any drivers complaining about overheating, or that cars retired with heat damage. You were there. Was it just an often-repeated talking point for the announcers to fill air time?

F1DebateTeam

I disagree, I think you can say Leclerc was overly aggressive against his teammate, but track position is important and if Hamilton keeps it on track at T4 this entire sequence is quickly forgotten. Irrelevant of the penalty, going off track allowed Verstappen through and realistically he has only himself to blame for that. This was a battle of egos and they both lost

F1DebateTeam

This would probably also be gamed. If you can cut T1, know you’ll get a 10 place grid drop at the next race - why not just do that at a place like Mexico, take the engine penalty at the next race, guarantee a win for yourself in the process as there is no detriment to the race in which the infraction occurred. The current system is as good as it’ll get I think

Andrés Bastanchuri

Mailbag. Can we a section on yellow flag penalties they have confused me greatly this season. George Austria, arvid and franco in zandvoort now franco in Mexico which seems ludicrous to me. Am I being blinded my 'arg' bias they seemed wrong to me all the decisions.

Ethan

My argument was for current race. Like George completely ruined Hadjar race and his penalty didn't really harm Russel's race. Why not make it a grid drop in place of seconds.

Ethan

Turn a 5 second penalty for causing a collision to be upgraded to three place grid drop or even 5 places to your final race position.

Patrick Shumar

With red flags so much more frequent in recent years, should F1 consider a rule similar to what NASCAR or Indycar have where tire changes and most work on the cars is not allowed under red.

Jude Ellison

Leading with the obligatory "not an onsite reporter," but I wouldn't be surprised if the combo of high altitude and paddock crud slowed folks down.

Vin Narayan

Should Hamilton be more upset with himself once he reflects back tomorrow? LeClerc braked late from the outside with no risk to his teammate, while Hamilton also didn't make the corner and could have taken them both out. He could have held off the red mist, kept Max behind, and made it easy for the team to give him back the position.

Tim Green

Mailbag. Ed love’s an alternate universe, so if Hamilton stayed at Mercedes, who do you think would be world champion this year? And where would Kimi be now?

Rob Mee

Great way to have a podium to celebrate Kimi! 3 great champions, congrats to Antonelli, well deserved year.

Pierre Geromboux

Maybe this is a naive question coming from a motorcycle racing background but is the lack of perceived danger mean that F1 drivers never back off in the interest of self-preservation as you might see in Moto GP block pass? They all seem to keep the boot in and then either act surprised or winge and moan when the other car either crashes into them or runs them off the road. The stewards are then forced to adjudicate in scenarios with no clear cut right or wrongs.

StephenR33

Was what Leclerc tried the same thing Hamilton Tried T1 Monza? Hamilton complained about getting run off the track. Now Hamilton did the same.

Adam Hussein

This might be a newbie question but in the post race press conference Lewis talked about a ‘clip at the end of the straight where you can’t go past a certain speed’ and that being a hindrance to passing. What exactly is he talking about? Is this an issue with this reg set? Can it be fixed?

Adam Hussein

If you took over Ferrari tomorrow what conversation would you have with Charles and Lewis and what changes would you make, if any, to how they race each other?

Benjamin

With all the criticism of these regulations that don’t allow drivers to push the car to the limit, how will we look back at Kimi’s title? Also, are too many people becoming a prisoner of the moment crowning Kimi a generational talent? I’m not convinced when he did poorly last year in a car that required more of the drivers.

Benjamin

I think the well-founded criticism on the current regulations is what prevented me and I assume a few others from feeling any emotion seeing Kimi win the title. I think the drivers probably feel the same way since they all said that you can’t push the car to the limit and that anyone can drive these cars because it’s easy when you don’t have to push. I like Kimi (way more than Lando) but I was more impressed with Lando’s title last year.

Benjamin

Definitely especially with his history of bad starts this season. He nailed both of them and didn’t make any mistakes. Thought it would be a worse issue here with the long straight.

Benjamin

Drivers don’t have to push as hard in these cars so it’s easy not to make mistakes.

Jim Al

Even though I had the pleasure of feeling so (unsurprisingly you might say) joyful after the race, I fully understand your sentiment as well Benjamin. I think I was just really pleasantly surprised by the podium finishers, with Kimi being one as well which sweetens the narrative just that bit more in my opinion. But obviously I'm never going to get behind this way of racing due to the engine regs. It took a lot away from us fans yes. After all the celebrations I was especially displeased with Stefano coming on the post-race show, again giving him a unfounded reason to gas up this formula and stuff. Seriously couldn't listen to that PR talk again. But anyway, I'm rambling. I'm sorry you lacked at least the little bit of joy I experienced after the race. Let's hope for some (small) steps forward next year.

Gavin Cameron @ the_loft_workshop

Mailbag question. Are Hamilton's radio messages and post race media briefings not worse for the team than what actually happened on track?

Mark Martin

How did Verstappen get away with the grid box infringement? It looked similar to Hamilton’s error in Silverstone but no penalty this time

Ollie West

George Russell has been given an absolute pasting by Kimi Antonelli. We seem to always point to the microslides and low grip nature of these modern cars now some downforce has been removed. But could it be possible that georges biggest issue could be understanding the engine deployment of these regs ? We have seen on a few occasions that Kimi and George have been evenly matched in the corners but George loses out on straights (Silverstone for example) Could George’s big issue be getting the turbo spawled up and has Kimi got a secret trick we don’t yet give him credit for ?

Jim McNellis

Mailbag question. Given the unexpected nature by which Lewis left Mercedes, is there a >0% chance he moves back this winter? It’s been on my mind all season, and events make it seem less ridiculous with each passing race. Or could he move elsewhere?

Josh

Maybe a little late but relevant for Tuesday…. Can they not just install gravel traps at turns 4/5/6 on the inside?

Helmut Gaishauser

Weren’t the apexes in the first two corners not monitored this year? Already during qualifying but also in the race I saw a couple of drivers cutting the corners with all four wheels beyond the white line? Or did they make the lines so much wider? It appeared that they had two shades of white

Scott Harris

Mailbag Question ✉️ Will Max win the title next year if the challenging teams don’t have a natural hierarchy? McLaren and Mercedes both have a clear number one currently, Ferrari don’t and we can see the problems that causes…

Dave Smith

Mailbag question now I've finally caught up: How do you rate the two Audi drivers' performances this year? Some talk before Mexico that this could be a good weekend, but Bortoleto picking up scraps due to others penalties isn't what they would have had in mind. Hard to judge with a brand manufacturer and engine coming in, but could another driver have got more from what looks like a fairly decent package this year?