Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

On a weekend where a near-perfect F1 campaign got its inevitable coronation, nobody was flawless across Mexican Grand Prix.

So who stood alone at the top in the second edition of Edd Straw's new tier list F1 driver rankings? And whose mistakes tanked their placing?

Take a look at his choices, then head to the comments section below this post to submit your questions! And if you're in our Champions tier, don't forget you can have a crack at compiling your own Mexican GP tier list with our handy visual tool! Then share your choices - with a personalised image if you want - in the F1 chat.

Max Verstappen raced with his usual incisive brilliance, showing strong pace and outstanding decision-making at the starts and in keeping Hamilton behind. On top of that, he was also central to Red Bull's recovery after a difficult Friday.

In many circumstances, the lock-up that ruined his last qualifying lap would have denied him a place in this tier, but the mitigating circumstances of traffic's contribution to that save him - even though the one-place grid penalty for Friday nonsense with Liam Lawson is also a small negative that in other circumstances might have bumped him to a lower tier.

Ryo Hirakawa's unique circumstances mean he has to be judged by what would normally be generous standards for the job he did after taking over Esteban Ocon's seat. He was flirting with reaching Q2 before hitting Alex Albon's turbulent air in the middle sector of his final Q1 run, meaning the gap to Bearman was exaggerated. He then drove a combative race, passing both the Williams drivers late on, for a well-deserved point once penalties were applied.

Liam Lawson recovered from setbacks to score points. He started from the pits but despite the red flag timing not helping him, he made steady progress then surged from 15th at the standing restart to take what was ultimately the midfield win after penalties were applied.

For Lewis Hamilton, this was a strong weekend save for his part in the Turn 4 moment where both drivers braked too late to make the corner. Had he avoided that, he would likely swap places with Verstappen. His first pole position since 2023 was also brilliantly-taken.

While Sergio Perez's race was compromised by a five-second penalty for speeding in the pits (by 0.2km/h), the team put that down to a sensor problem. But while Perez was a little disappointed by qualifying thanks to the set-up not being nailed, he raced superbly in the first stint before first losing time to a wheelgun problem then the later penalty.

Ollie Bearman's weekend was dealt a blow when he had to switch to the old ADUO1-spec Ferrari engine during practice. Despite that, he was rapid although a track limits violation meant he didn't maximise qualifying. He drove a decent race until he was rear-ended by Nico Hulkenberg through no fault of his own. In normal circumstances he'd have been ranked in a higher tier than his team-mate, but this ordering reflects the unusual situation Hirakawa was in.

While Kimi Antonelli clinched the world championship, he was under the weather both in terms of health and pace in qualifying and wasn't able to match George Russell. He drove a neat and tidy race, running long and only pitting just before the race was red-flagged, and earned the right to celebrate his title on the podium.

Gabriel Bortoleto was perhaps marginally the quicker Audi driver in terms of peak, but sitting out in FP1 and then problems in both FP2 and FP3 limited him to just three flying laps before qualifying. He then banged in the sixth-fastest Q1 lap, and dealt well with being "a bit blind" on set-up for race stints, with penalties turning 11th-on-the-road into eighth.

Fernando Alonso's weekend is difficult to judge given problems cut short both qualifying and the race, so on balance it's difficult to put him anywhere else other than the middle tier even though his pace looked strong enough to have climbed higher had he had a fair crack at it.

Lando Norris couldn't repeat his Q2 form in Q3 in the tricky-to-drive McLaren and ultimately was once again not as high up the grid as he could have been. He also perhaps could have picked off Leclerc in the final part of the race, meaning that he brought the McLaren home in a good position but not as high as it might have been.

Williams driver Albon inevitably struggled in the limited machinery. Team-mate Carlos Sainz had the better of qualifying, although Albon felt his final lap was one of the best of the season once you allow for traffic costing him all-important turbo speed when starting the lap, and had the edge in the race. However, the late position-loss to Hirakawa ultimately cost him a point.

While Arvid Lindblad had a hand in the clash with Oscar Piastri that led to his retirement thanks to his late move under braking into Turn 1, ultimately stewards held the McLaren driver responsible for the collision that followed. Lindblad showed good pace, especially in Q2, but felt Q3 was a missed opportunity.

Isack Hadjar wasn't happy with his messy qualifying lap, but still turned out a respectable laptime. He recovered well from his first-lap spin after contact with Russell, which stewards held the Mercedes driver responsible for although Hadjar should perhaps have left some precautionary space given they'd been side-by-side through Turn 5 before the clash at Turn 6. He raced decently despite luck not being on his side until he was rewarded with ninth by penalties for other drivers.

Sainz may have outqualified Albon, but that battle was swung by his team-mate's slow start to the lap thanks to traffic and he was slower for much of it. That pattern continued in a difficult race, although he wasn't far behind in the end.

Valtteri Bottas acted solely as a towing vehicle in qualifying given his grid penalty, but appeared to lack the edge Perez had. He had a tidy race until the front-left suspension let go.

Russell produced a superb Q3 lap that might have earned pole position with a suitable fuel load. However, his weekend turned on the deployment problem at the start, which was not his fault. Ultimately, though, he should have been more pragmatic when battling with Hadjar given the high tariff of a penalty that condemned him to finishing sixth. With proper power delivery at the start, he could have been a victory contender, which in many ways sums up his season.

Franco Colapinto was a step behind Pierre Gasly during Friday and Saturday, but a great first lap set him on a course to finishing a fine eighth on-the-road. However, his tier is lower than it would have been thanks to him not responding to the single yellow flag on the run out of Turn 3 that led to a 10-second penalty. A minor error - and not as egregious a one as Gasly's - but a very costly one.

Pace was not a problem for Charles Leclerc, who perhaps had a mild edge over Hamilton. However, the negatives started in qualifying, where he likely lost pole position to not nailing the tyre prep on his final run. He then made two errors in the race, the first at Turn 4 with his late-braking attack around the outside, which ultimately created the conditions for Ferrari to lose the race. The second mistake was arguably worse, in his desperation to attack his team-mate locking up at Turn 1 at the restart while trying to cut to the inside and suffering a flatspot he carried to the end of the race.

Like Alonso, Lance Stroll had limited opportunities to show what he could do, but he also had the chance to run throughout Q1, unlike his team-mate, and was still 0.164s slower.

Piastri's underlying pace was better than it looked and he recovered well in the race from a baffling Q2. That struggle has to count against him, as does the collision with Lindblad as while he can justifiably be unhappy with Lindblad's late move under braking and argue it forced him around the outside, it ultimately put him in harm's way given the racing guidelines and cost him a solid result thanks to the penalty.

Gasly had a good run through Friday and Saturday, qualifying decently but then losing ground to a deployment problem at the start. He raced well despite having to take an early pitstop, but getting himself a penalty for not respecting double-waved yellows was a careless error that ruined his weekend and cost a good result.

Hulkenberg's weekend was catastrophically undermined by a single mistake. He was caught out by the Turn 4 concertina at the restart while battling with Lawson and rear-ended Bearman. This was an understandable but avoidable error given the inevitable congestion on a restart lap, and undermined a weekend that otherwise would have put him in the top half.

Files

Comments

George

I feel kimi is a little low, drove well and 3rd was better than the car deserved

Chiv2103

Ferrari appeared to have the fastest car all weekend and Lewis making an error at turn 4 meant he didn't win the race. For such a big error, and I understand it was a decent lap for pole, how is he rated so highly? He made an error under pressure that lost him a race victory

EM

On the leclerc Hamilton situation, why have a driver pairing of Hamilton and leclerc and not have either a Hamilton/leclerc + a clear number 2. It's an inevitability this is going to happen over and over again. I also find Lewis's comments contradictory on one hand arguing for more teamwork but then begging for your teammate to get a harsher penalty and airing everything he said out to the media after the race. I really don't see the argument for having 2 number 1's, McLaren last year nearly lost the drivers championship as a result of this policy also. And as much as constructers gets the prize money nobody outside cares about the constructers let's be honest in comparison to the drivers championship. If Max won it last year nobody at red bull is devastated they didn't win the constructers

Faris

How come only Russel has been having energy problems and Antonelli basically none?

Ed R Gaming

I'm surprised Hulkenburg is ranked lowest, I would of thought one of the Alpine drivers for their errors, based on your ranking then probably Gasly, feels like Hulkenburg got caught out in a situation where he should of done better but was likely a split second, whereas Gasly s mistake was much more serious

Stuart Coulter

I didn't think anybody deserves to be placed in the S tier this weekend - Max's weekend was probably the best of everyone's, but I would still mark him down for the completely unnecessary one place grid drop, even if ultimately it did not harm his eventual race result. Also, whilst Hirakawa's unexpected debut was accomplished, I'm not entirely convinced it puts him in the A tier as it wasn't as if he was thrown in straight into FP3 or qualifying (it's possibly an A minus or B plus at best)

StevieNoises

Glad to see the tiered rankings still provoke some disagreement. Max absolutely was not S tier. The primary chink in his armour is he loses his head. The practice crash was silly and needless and to me, that should have knocked him down more than that. I also wouldn't put Lawson up in S for the same reason. I think Hirakawa or Hamilton had S tier reserved.

StevieNoises

Glad to see the tiered lists still provoke disagreement. Max cannot hold top spot. The primary chink in his armour is he loses his head occasionally. Both drivers were rightly punished and there was absolutely no need for it. It wasn't a calculated crash, it was clumsy and caused damage. Lawson also couldn't be top tier for the same reason. S tier should have been reserved for Hamilton or Hirakawa.

Adam B

Hi Edd, I think Ryo did an outstanding job this weekend *given the circumstances*. If Ryo had been an experienced F1 driver and had raced for Haas the whole year, where would this performance rank? D?

Gavin Cameron @ the_loft_workshop

Max had a good weekend but not sure it's worthy of being the top tier ( unless it has to be filled?). Main grumble is with Leclercs position. He qualified about a tenth off pole I think, played the system well at turn 4, and as much as he flat spotted the tyre I give him a lot of credit for holding off Norris.

Matt Tucker

Agree with all of this. I think Max got away with his needless 1 place grid penalty coming at a track where position shuffling into turn 1 is most common. And does Max win the race if Ferraris dont squabble? Probably not, and then it doesn't feel such an S tier weekend.

Simon Emms

That's true enough, but I give him credit for not merely "driving for 9th".

Adam B

Move on Charles at the end impressed me in particular. Could have coasted in 4th but made the overtake look easy

Tyler Thompson

Clearly Kimi wanted to properly celebrate his WC on the podium and make a legendary podium even bigger.

Eric Bryant

Also largely agree that no one deserved S tier this weekend, although if you had to pick one, it would be Hirakawa for me. A point on debut in a midfield car on a tricky track to race on (as evidenced by how many drivers made errors) and compromised preparation because he didn’t know he’d be racing on the weekend. Just shows the caliber of drivers that never get a chance at Formula One is so very high.

Tyler Thompson

Agree, objectively I think it is hard to hold Leclerc any more accountable than Hamilton for the lap 1 turn 1 and turn 4 battles. Sure, he flat spotted the tire heavily, but he also continued to drive it home and kept Norris behind him.

Tyler Thompson

Agree here, sure you know the concertina is going to happen, but that wasn’t the Colopinto at Baku or almost-Norris at Bahrain/Malaysia degree of error. The Alpines suffered with 3 penalties and agree with Edd’s management of Gasly’s being the bigger demerit (plus the not penalized pit lane exit violation), just seemed that would cumulatively put Gasly below Hulk.

#37

Still don‘t like the tierlist much. On another Note, russells Ranking is harsh imo. He outqualified Antonelli, while his race was undone by one of the however many engine problems of his Season and a Racing incident he should not have gotten a penalty for I felt.

Tyler Thompson

Ferrari took advantage of their S-tier desirability and fact that many dream of driving in red at least once in their career. Hamilton has been full of doublespeak all season furious when he isn’t immediately and clearly #1, critical of the team, apologizing within 24 hours only to do the same sequence at the next GP or a couple later. I have massive respect for him and he’s never been my favorite driver, but this season he has become difficult for me to find likable since he apparently has never been in any way responsible for how he chooses to go racing against his teammate.

Tyler Thompson

I’d have to think it would be a solid C, maybe B/B-

Russ Taylor

Edd - An E for Charles is ridiculous. An A for Lewis is ridiculous. Lewis didn’t do much of note other than cock up T 4 in trying to prevent Charles overtaking. Lucky with Safety Car and Red Flag. Charles led for 25 odd laps pulling away from Max and Lewis. He was very unfortunate to be 2nd at the restart on the now very poor right hand side. His 15 lap odd defence against Lando was magnificent. Locking up so badly was on him. You seem to treat all drivers as though they have the same drive and talent. They don’t! Ryo’s best is nowhere near the front runners

Jose Vanegas

Finally a weekend when we overlap a lot Edd! I have to say my biggest issues was Leclerc as his race execution did managed to destroy everything be build up to the race. I'm very impressed with hirakawa adapting so fast to an F1 car compared to the Hypercars he is use to drive is an amazing feat, how come the politics and circumstances for him didn't work up in F1 is still a mystery, that's why I put Stroll at the bottom alongside Hülkenberg as a reminder of that even if this wasn't a disastrous weekend for him.

Mark Hewitt

Does someone need to occupy each rank on each weekend? As the way I see Mexico then nobody is deserving of S tier. Verstappen had a scrappy start to the weekend with a needless incident that got him a grid penalty. That alone should rule him out.

Clive Barker

I don’t feel that there should HAVE to be someone in S or F tier each race, if that is indeed how Edd looks at it. Max in S tier feels a bit high for me. Needless penalty place nobbled him a bit and I think some luck/Ferrari issues helped him win.

Ed W

Agree it's hard to see a deserving S tier driver this week, with a few excellent performances marred by small but notable errors. Does Max get the nod by reserving his best for the race and essentially negating his earlier mistakes? For me Lawson, Hamilton and Verstappen are mostly equal across the weekend, and I can't argue with Hirakawa given the circumstances. Maybe he should get the top spot, since he didn't make the slightly silly mistakes the others did.

Melmut Harko (Ret.)

With you on this. If you listen to Lawson's team radio before the Verstappen incident you can see he was a completely innocent part just trying to get a lap on, while Versatppen was on an outlap and acting like the bully we've come to know and loathe. Can't have an S Tier when you've caused this kind of unnecessary drama. (Still don't like this format!!!)

Brian Mortensen

Echoing the other comments, I do wonder if this is a good example of a race where perhaps an S tier isn't merited for anyone. I ultimately rated Verstappen with an S also, but would be curious to hear your reaction, Edd. Also - Liam Lawson's overall body of work continues to be impressive. It seems like it should be a no-brainer for "RaBu" to bring him back for 2027. What's the holdup?

wal

I agree with Bearman in B, because his mistake in qualifying cost him 3 positions on the grid. That definitely made his job in the grand prix harder. However, I do think that his race on Sunday was much better than just decent. He had a good start, a very good first stint. He overtook Bortoleto on lap 19 and put pressure on Hulkenberg until Nico stopped. Had a very long first stint at a really good pace to build a big tyre delta, but unfortunately for him, he stopped 3 laps before the red flag. He was running in P11 and ahead of Lawson and Bortoleto behind the Alpines when Hulkenberg took him out. He would have had a good shot at finishing in P7 in the 8th fastest car without Nico's mistake. I don't think there is anything else he could have done. Hirakawa was a positive surprise, but I also found his qualifying performance very hard to read. His run plan was very different compared to Bearman. Hirakawa used 3 different sets of softs. Bearman was fueled up for multiple push laps at the start and was out on track when the red flag happened. His second lap was done on what was his 8th lap on that set.

Paul Southgate

If I go top to bottom, left to right down the tiers does that give me the old ranking or is the order in each tier random? Max shouldn’t be in the S tier due to his clash with Lawson in FP. That was completely unnecessary. He also didn’t maximise things in qualifying. Hamilton should be lower due to throwing away the lead (and the win) fighting Leclerc.

Rucus

Do the FIA need to investigate the Cadillac crashes? - Bottas has had some weird incidents which are car related. What is the threshold before a car is considered unsafe?

Xepha

I’m a bit surprised that Max’s error didn’t disqualify him from s-tier given a lot of prior form here. Are there quotas for the tiers, or was his race drive that good? A bit surprised by Russell being D tier. Thought he did pretty well before making his race defining mistake-that-wasn’t. I’d still count that a bit against him, but as you said on the podcast it seemed like a RI but for the silly guideline wording. Also a bit surprised by hulkenberg, but I guess here again I’m giving him more credit for pace on a weekend where Audis turbo penalty may have been particularly relevant to the car’s drivability (speculation).

Xepha

Also I’m excited about the new format. Been really busy so this is the first I’m seeing it.

Chris M

I'm not really sure why Hamilton is graded A, when he ultimately didnt win because of an unforced error. Sure, the team game would have Leclerc hold back from attacking Hamilton, but that move was never on, it was never going to stick, Lewis should have known this and kept his car on the track. Ultimately, running himself out of road is what cost him. Had it been Max, or anyone else behind him and he made the same mistake, the conversation would have been more about Lewis's mistake costing him, rather than placing the blame on the attacing driver behind. It is a race after all.

Vin Narayan

I've seen too many reddit takes and need a dose of calm Edd Straw logical reasoning. Is Hamilton not the reason Hamilton lost the win, and wouldn't that cost him more than A tier for not fulfilling his mission? He had position and chose to defend the inside, which is fine. He could have done an Oscar vs Max Miami T1..25? And baited him into missing the corner on the outside at no risk to himself. Instead he chose to follow Charles's late braking on cold Lap 1, and that cost him P2 and a swap back from Charles. LeClerc deserves a lower tier for his multiple errors, but Hamilton doesn't deserve A in my opinion. Help me see the way

Faris

There is no way Hamilton deserves the S tier as he was partially to blame for going wide on lap 1. Lost an easy win there

Faris

I agree completely. People (and Lewis) blaming Charles the whole time, meanwhile Lewis went wide himself and lost the lead. He had a good weekend, but that was a huge mistake.