Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

Mexico has given The Race Members' Club plenty to argue about in Edd Straw's latest driver rankings – starting right at the top.

The big question this time is whether anyone deserved the S tier at all. So Edd explains why he still put Max Verstappen there despite the needless practice clash with Liam Lawson that cost him a grid place. He also says why he prefers to use the full range of tiers every weekend, though Champions are entitled to leave theirs empty in their own version!

The other key strand is the fallout at Ferrari. Edd's quizzed on whether Lewis Hamilton really earned his A tier after losing the lead fighting Charles Leclerc at Turn 4, and whether an E tier for Leclerc was too harsh. He also gets into whether Ferrari should have a clear number one and number two in the first place.

Ryo Hirakawa's unexpected Grand Prix debut also comes under the microscope. Edd explains why the late call-up earned an A tier and where the same drive would rank without those circumstances – and is asked whether George Russell in the D tier and Nico Hulkenberg in the F tier were harsh.

Edd also examines the biggest disparities between his final positions and our Champions members' average, which you can take a look at below:

If you want to have your say, you can do so by signing up to our Champions tier. You can download your own personalised image to share in the comments, our F1 chat, or on social media.

Here's a reminder of Edd's rankings from Mexico:

Edd will be back with his next tier list – and Champions you get your next chance to build your own – from this weekend's Brazilian Grand Prix.

Files

Comments

AdPo

majorly disagree with the framing that lewis's mistake was justified because the alternative was holding back and letting leclerc past. if charles was never making that corner, then lewis could've still braked within track limits without being legally overtaken. saying "lewis either outbreaks himself and goes off track or lets leclerc past" just makes it sound like lewis ran leclerc wide and should've been the one that got penalized

Matteo Morgan

The questioners Lewis takes were very hindsight imo. Good pod Edd, well explained putting Max in S

Esther Basson

I really enjoy this new format of the rankings and agree with the opinion of having one driver in S and one in F - regardless of how the S drive compares to previous ones. Great job, Edd! Also really enjoy your explanations of the rankings, particularly when I don't agree. It's insightful to understand different perspectives.

Xepha

lol sorry to have been a part of the S tier max pile on! I typed my qs while walking around and didn’t read other posts like I sometimes do! Comments about Hulk and Russell make sense. I think I’m just a hulk fan and liking seeing him get across the car, and I figured that having a lot of turbo inertia must have made it harder to be in traffic because he’d be managing boost in any concertina.