Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Another race, another tier list from Edd! Are you getting used to it yet?

As ever, quiz Edd by commenting on the post and Edd will record a special podcast answering your tier list questions, which will be released later this week.

Now over to Edd...

So strong was Verstappen's pace and incisive his overtaking in the early stages that McLaren team principal Andrea Stella described him as a "material threat" to eventual race winner Lando Norris.

As Verstappen was not responsible for starting on the back row, to surge through the field so cleanly - even if he did require some co-operation from his team-mate Isack Hadjar - to take second was another remarkable Interlagos performance to add to his collection.

And considering the pace drop-off in the car after the first pitstops, which he suggested might be down to damage, it's clear that once he was in second that was as good as it could have got. In that sense, it was a very tough mission accomplished - and it was effectively job done by half-distance.

Norris and Lawson combined tremendous speed with good execution across qualifying and the race, both effectively 'winning' their classes up front and in the midfield respectively.

Norris had a little help from Kimi Antonelli's spin in taking the lead, although that only hastened the exchange, but again showed that in wet conditions he has the technique, feel and finesse to produce Verstappen-like pace.

Lawson was never going to be able to hold onto his early second place, but bossed the midfield and was ultimately classified ahead of Charles Leclerc after his defence drew an error out of the Ferrari driver. He perhaps would have been close to the S-tier if he'd taken what he felt was a chance to qualify even higher.

As for Hadjar, while overall he wasn't as consistently brilliant as Verstappen he was close - and there were spells in the race when he was quickest on track.

This tier is a mixed bag, first of two drivers who had good, clean weekends without achieving anything spectacular.

As you'd expect from Alonso, he dragged good performance from the Aston Martin and was unlucky to pick up nose damage thanks to Ollie Bearman, while Oscar Piastri's Q2 exit was mitigated by "braking anomalies" and the fact that his race pace was better than the result suggests.

As for Hulkenberg, Bearman and Albon, all produced performance levels that would certainly have put them into the A tier, but small errors - penalties for Hulkenberg and Albon that have some mitigations, and Bearman's snap at Turn 3 on lap one that gave him rear damage from Alonso and led to a very slow first pitstop - nudge them down.

This group of five is very much in the middle of the pack. All avoided significant errors, but there were limitations to their weekends.

Bottas qualified well, but a cross-threaded wheelnut denied him the opportunity to show what he could do in the race, with Perez having a decent weekend but not executing qualifying as well as his team-mate.

Lindblad had his moments but overall wasn't at Lawson's level, and missed a points opportunity, while the two Alpine drivers were saddled with a limited car - although Colapinto did show eye-catching pace on softs when the rain came, albeit with fresher tyres than some.

Antonelli looked destined to win the race after the early stages, but the weird handling behaviour of the Mercedes that was not fully explained meant his race quickly turned into disappointment. The spin that cost him the lead is a factor in being in this tier, as is the fact that he didn't appear to deal as well with the understandably baffling car behaviour as he might.

Leclerc cost himself a place with a robust touring-car pass on Lawson that was never going to stick, although you can argue he would never have been ahead had he not done that.

As for Stroll, his race was short-lived and he exited in Q1 without looking like following his team-mate through to the next phase of qualifying.

Mistakes abound in this tier. Camara was cursed with the most difficult of circumstances considering his late call-up for Haas and he showed flashes of impressive pace. However, his two offs in qualifying and untidy moments in the race have to count against him - although the situation saves him from the F tier, with a little help from the fact his soft-tyre pace in the race stacked up very respectably to Bearman.

Russell was unlucky not to get pole position and with a better rub of the green he could have been a victory threat, but his pit-exit spin is responsible for him being so low.

It's a similar story for Hamilton, whose baffling decision to disregard the pit call led to a very slow inlap and the spin, while Sainz is another who showed decent underlying pace but went off twice in qualifying and had a difficult race.

A single mistake, going off at Juncao and lightly hitting the barrier in Q1, ruined Bortoleto's chances.

Although he recovered to the pits, the damage meant he was eliminated and condemned to start down the order. That was unfortunate because he had the pace for a good result, but as Bortoleto himself told me after the race: "I was very quick, but that doesn't matter, at the end of the day, because you are starting from the back."

Files

Comments

Jim Al

I think this weekend for the first time shows the flaws of putting only one driver in the S-tier. Though I'm generally fond of this new system, and get the reasoning behind the decision to do so, I feel like this weekend there was hardly anything (if at all) that both Verstappen or Norris could've done better. So I'd both give them the S-tier (as you allow us to do). Also, a quick other question; You were always kind of keeping track of the "Drivers Ranking World Championship" by awarding the same amount of points for 1st up until 10th with the old method you were using. Is there still a way of "measuring" this championship for the whole of this season, or maybe even from the starting point of the tier rankings?

Robert Chambers

I think you are a little harsh on George - the pit exit spin was practically his only error all weekend. Was there any chance that was due to these unexpected “power surges” these guys get from these engines when he hit the throttle? I thought he deserved extra credit for getting that car turned around and going again in that tight space without taking someone else out or clogging up the pit exit.

#37

Russell should be Above Antonelli. He was quicker in Quali and Race, and his Spin in the pitlane should be punished in the Ranking, is more a freak accident than Antonellis Spin and Snaps in T1. Also Leclerc was far more impressive than anyone in the C-Tier, and Piastri as well. Leclerc recovered from a low Grid Position he wasn‘t to blame for, with a car struggling all race. Piastri was considerably slower than Norris in Quali and race, out in Q2 and 30 seconds behind Norris despite the latter losing about 10 seconds of race time after dropping behind Lawson at the start.

Stuart Coulter

Russell should be at least on the same tier as Antonelli in my view - they both made costly errors during the race, but at least George did outqualify Kimi. Otherwise, your rankings are not to dissimilar to mine

Steven James Ward

I'm not sure I understand why Lando isn't sharing the S tier with Max. Supreme pace, no mistakes (that I saw, happy to be corrected) he took pole and all in conditions which should have raised the difficulty multiplier to the top? What could he have done better to earn an S?

Russ Taylor

Quite confused with this race to say the least! Is Gabriel really an F or is he just the lowest ranking? Bottas did well considering he didn’t even start but not his fault. S and A fine but unsure of B, C and D. Russell should be higher.

Steven James Ward

A bit of a behind the curtain question. Do you consider inconsequential mistakes in practice in rankings? It was often said that Michael Schumacher would over step the limit in practice to find the limit, would these have been considered errors and factored into your rankings?

Brian Mortensen

Edd, I thought these were pretty fair rankings all-around. Since one of the themes you've emphasized at points this season has been the difficulty in deciphering driver performance versus algorithm/power-unit advantages, was this one of the easier rankings to complete with how much the weather and challenge of Interlagos put driver abilities in the spotlight?

StevieNoises

Norris should be S tier, what more could he have done? He was superb in qualifying, excellent in the race. Max didn't get the chance to show what he could do in qualifying and while he can't be marked down for that it also can't prevent others from the highest marks when they could. Norris demonstrated extreme skill all weekend.

The Race Members' Club

We'll leave the main thrust of this for Edd to answer, as it is his Q&A! But to pick up on a couple of things – we actually don't have the S tier open to more than one driver for Champions either! I think it's fascinating to see how people make the call when they have to decide. What we did change after the debut in Austin so it can be left blank if you want. Making the S tier more open is something we will discuss. Likewise, having max 5 per tier. The whole point of introducing this now is to have the possibility to assess how it's going and make changes to improve it if we feel it's worthwhile and if there's a popular alternative choice! As for tracking the tiers like a championship, it is doable. Again, I won't speak for Edd, but I am tracking all the choices from Champions! There are few ways of doing it (most common tier; median tier; points system). They all come out near-identical, fortunately! - SMM

AdPo

Would've considered Alonso a marginal S-tier threat behind Norris and Verstappen so I'm surprised to see him down in B tier. What more could he have done to earn a higher spot?

Ahmed Kamala

You said that in some races you might consider more than one driver for S tier. I expected Lando and Max to be both in S this race. From memory, what race this season or last season do you think two drivers were worthy of S tier? PS: Just like Rafael Camara, my last name is read as Ka-mala not Kama-la. It was quite amusing to see that you were corrected for a similar pronunciation this weekend (not that I mind either pronunciation).

Jim Al

Appreciate the swift response Scott. It (surprisingly) is more clear to me now what the idea and intended purposes are, as well as the intention looking forward. Though that clarification might went over my head in earlier Q&A's, Driver Rankings and whatnot, haha. Thinking about going to the Champions Tier once your guys' transition into the new app etc. is completed. Basically next season probably. Anyway, looking forward to the next episode guys. Cheers.

StephenR33

He got jumped by two cars off the start line is one negative. Otherwise not much I can think of

StephenR33

Leclerc had mega warm up issues on the soft that I haven't seen explained yet anywhere. Once it warmed up he actually had really really good pace

Ben Kelly

Think overly critical on Hamilton given he made one mistake on the pit call, otherwise was a strong weekend and showed better pace than his team mate. Antonelli by comparison had more mistakes and he is rated higher

Eric Bryant

One part of me feels like your entire “E” tier list was exceeding harsh, and another part of me knows you had to put some drivers there even when the circumstances and conditions could be used as excuses not to. So, respect to you for making those choices. The part that made it feel harsh is that those who had substantial spin-outs during the weekend were relegated to that tier regardless of performance except for Antonelli. So what prevented Antonelli from suffering the same fate?

Eric Bryant

Including Antonelli’s reconnaissance lap off among the mistakes.

Rob Fuller

Bearman caused both himself and Alonso damage, and potentially cost both point scoring opportunities. Should he be ranked lower as a result?

Camper

Thanks for the rankings Edd! I’m curious whether there is a cap on the number of places within an S tier. Verstappen’s performance was mega but drivers like Norris, Alonso and Lawson suffered from low grip off the line, an out of control Bearman and trying to manage tyre temp and spacing in a wet quali. Would be keen to hear your thoughts.

Tom Arnold

Think I prefer the old 1-20 ranking system, this new one is easy to understand just think the 1-20 works better.

Elian Iorio Farrell

They forgot the adjust his front wing angle in the pitstop so he was on the front wing angle for inters rather then soft tyres. So maybe that created understeer and so less "sliding" to warm up the tyres, thats the only discrepancy I heard reported anywhere .