Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Mark Hughes is back with the latest edition of his weekly column, The Long Run, which is exclusive to newsletter subscribers and The Race Members' Club.

Is Ferrari scared of improvisation? Does it have an issue with its control hierarchy in the pits? Mark Hughes puts forward a theory for why Ferrari’s struggled with strategy and communication - and suggests a fix...

If you don't receive our newsletters, you can sign up here to receive The Long Run straight to your inbox.

Well, since we last spoke we’ve had another comedy of errors at Ferrari. Not warring team-mates this time, but the latest installation of awful communication between the pitwall and the drivers.

So the conversation getting the most publicity in Brazil was between Lewis Hamilton and his race engineer Carlo Santi. But things were no better in the other car between Charles Leclerc and Bryan Bozzi.

Here’s a few radio samples from Leclerc’s car:
BB: “When you can, diff mid plus 1.”
CL: “If I don’t do something [you have suggested] don’t remind me 10 times please, thank you.”

That’s just a bit of niggle between an engineer looking at the data and seeing potential for improvement and a driver having his own reasons for not wanting to do that but without the time to explain why.

Then, a few laps later, as Hamilton has pitted for slicks and Leclerc is still on inters.

CL: “How is it?”
BB: “It’s ok, just pit lane exit tricky. But then it’s fast. Turn 4 as well.”
CL: “Has the lap time been faster?”
BB: “Yes, he’s faster still.”
CL: “What? Who is faster?”
BB: “Box Charles, box. Will be same flap.”

So, here the confusion seems to be on Leclerc’s part. He’s asking how Hamilton’s switch to slicks looks and Bozzi has answered with the relevant info.

The confusion seems to arise when Bozzi says the word ‘still’. He clearly means ‘yes, he is still faster than when on inters’.

Leclerc takes it to mean ‘driver X is even faster than Hamilton’, so prompting the confused ‘what? Who is faster?’ response.

Bozzi’s reference to the flap is him saying we won’t have time to give you your requested wing flap change on the slicks because everyone’s going to be pitting at the same time and we could lose positions in the pitlane if we take the extra time for the adjust.

CL: “Freaking hell. I’m asking simple questions. It would be nice to have simple answers.”

Here a stressed Leclerc seems to be referring to the fact that he didn’t get an answer to his ‘what, who is faster?’ question. But Bozzi has prioritised giving him the ‘box’ instruction over explaining that there’s been a misunderstanding about his use of the word ‘still’. That’s if Bozzi has even realised where Leclerc’s confusion is coming from.

There’s no time to get into a discussion about this. There are higher priorities. Hence the lack of answers to Leclerc’s questions.

A few laps later, with Leclerc now on slicks and feeling the car to be oversteery.
CL: “Did you do the dry front flap?”
BB: “White 9, position 6.”
CL: “And again. Simple question. Please answer. Did you put the same flap for the dry?”
BB: “Yes, same flap, same flap.”
CL: “I asked for a dry because it’s super-pointy. Do I have overtake?”
BB: “No. Yes you do, correction.”

In Leclerc’s earlier confusion over the word ‘still’, he clearly did not hear or did not retain Bozzi’s clear information that the flap would not be changed at the stop.

After his complaint about the flap he immediately moves on to the question about whether overtake mode is enabled and now it’s a flustered Bozzi’s turn to be confused, giving the wrong answer before correcting himself.

As Bozzi is doing this, Leclerc asks, “Why? I don’t have the beeps.”
BB: “We’ll check on the beeps.”

This is a stressed environment at the best of times, for both parties. Especially so in a tricky wet-dry-wet race where stop timings are potentially crucial.

For the driver, just keeping the car on the road is challenging enough and taking up a lot of bandwidth. He’s trying to fit in requests and understanding in between controlling the car.

For the engineer, with the pressure of being blamed if he messes up their race, he’s doing calculations, making judgements and taking instruction from the strategist in live time in a quickly-changing environment – and on top of that he’s got a frustrated driver ranting at him and he doesn’t have time to fully explain everything to him because there are more immediate calls to be made.

Here’s a theory. 

It’s not a problem of Bozzi or Santi, or before that Xavier Marcos (Leclerc’s previous engineer) or Ricardo Adami (Santi’s predecessor on Hamilton’s car). It just might be a problem of the control hierarchy on the pitwall.

There seems to be almost no room for improvisation. 

Each call has to go through the system, one which is acutely tuned to not be giving one driver an advantage over the other, such is the delicate political situation there.

So much of the engineer’s bandwidth is taken up in having to go through the stipulated procedures, and as they do this, each driver gets continually more frustrated at the slow responses to their questions – which in turn ramps up yet more pressure on the engineer.

It needs a rethink.

Files

Comments

Pamela Rudolph

Clear communication is the foundation for everything.

Eric Bryant

Yes, true. However, I think Mark is saying it’s not enough just to fix the communications alone. If all race strategy decisions are going to be made by a committee, even the clearest of communications between driver and engineer will be stymied by the bureaucracy. That translates to a lack of strategic flexibility and an inability to capitalize on opportunities.

Evan Canny

Can someone correct me if I'm wrong, but the race engineer has to speak English to their driver over team radio? If so, it seems an obvious disadvantage to have two people communicate in a language where they are less proficient than other drivers/engineers (e.g., English first speaking natives; not arguing for British bias, other nations also speak English first) during a high-stress environment. I understand why team radio is spoken in English, and it's very unlikely to ever change. So, should a team like Ferrari not prioritise English-speaking proficiency when choosing a race engineer? While this goes against the Italian-centric culture of the team, for a team/company that is supposed to be data-driven, it seems like an obvious variable (English speaking proficiency) to underestimate.

Jose Vanegas

I was thinking that, I understand Ferrari having to take every decision on track to a congregation of decision makers in Marinello is already an issue. But perhaps there are advantages ok having and engineer that speaks the drivers native tounge to avoid this "lost in translation" misunderstanding, also they could be trained in high reliability speech techniques, very important in lots of jobs I'm surprised this happens in F1 tbh but I guess that's a humanity, wondering if F1 or the FIA has a rule against using other languages, may be difficult to pick up actual cheating in real time

StephenR33

I've thought that many times. Ferrari bad strategies and everything else down to not being native English speakers. In this case Leclerc French speaking and Bozzi Italian trying to communicate in english. Before that Leclerc French and Marcos Spanish speaking English. It does seem to be one of the many unintentional bias' of formula 1 having all the teams based in the UK

Curtis

Such a contrast to Verstappen/Lambiase/RBR. And others ofc too. One thing I continually notice about RBR is that they don’t ever, as far as I can recall, mention a Plan A, B or C, etc. In contrast to the other top teams. Anybody know why not?

Tyler Thompson

Why mention Plan A, B, C, or A+10 etc when your radio seemingly stopped working at summer break?