Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

I share my thoughts on my current situation with this series at the very end of the episode. While I am enjoying my time, I may need to make some tough calls...That being said, I really like many elements of what this series brings the table. It has it's strengths, but it also is not without its faults...Now, let's find the leader of these creatures and make a last-ditch effort to save our Mina!

Files

Comments

Aim Withmoore

I do agree that the story in this show is weak in areas, though I really like how all the dialogue is written in general.💜 I would love to see you react to the other seasons, even if the later seasons ends up being a patreon-only thing.

hypocritex

*cough* Sopranos *cough*

Lee

I’m enjoying these reactions as a chance to revisit the series, but I also wouldn’t mind if you put it on pause and return to it later on maybe as Patreon-only. I think the second season was my favorite, final season was a little shark-jumpy but I still enjoyed. Totally fair to de-prioritize when you have a lot you want to get to. Also, on the comment section: have you considered hiring part-time help for community management? I love that you respond directly so often, but at the same time it seems like a minority of bad comments stick in your brain more than the nice ones (human nature, right?), and I’m afraid it might begin to affect how you approach these shows with bigger fan bases or give you a skewed idea of how the majority are feeling about your reactions. It seems to already come up regularly in relation to IWTV, and I’m sure you’ll get another incoming surge of viewers when the new season comes out. Maybe someone could help out with pre-screening comments for you to react to so you can focus on the positive engagement and keep your head out of the rando muck that washes in? In any case, I hope you know that the majority of us here appreciate what you do and don’t like those kinds of comments either.

Yella

Caliban is the heart of this series for me. I mean, it’s Gothic. Everyone suffers... but his journey and his mindset are something else. And yes, the whole situation with Maude is terrible. I think she felt pity for him and was likely thinking more of her brother—whom she mentioned once—than of him. And Caliban misinterpreted it. Although that was a mistake on his part, too, he did watch as that other guy walked right up to her. And as a "Creature" with absolutely no clue how social interactions work, the question—from his perspective—is "justified": "Why is that guy allowed to approach her, but I’m not?" It’s truly awful how it all played out. Yes, Victor... don't get me wrong, I like *this* Victor, too. I like him infinitely more than the Victor from the books, for instance... But there’s also something a little funny about that scene where he turns his weapons on Caliban. Caliban is completely broken, begging him to let him die, and Victor goes, "Oh, how poetic. Well, in that case, I suppose I can't just shoot him."... Is Vanessa Malcolm’s daughter? No. It’s meant in a metaphorical sense. Mina is lost—she was lost long before this point. And instead of trying to save something that cannot be saved, he focuses on what is actually there—on what he *has*. Namely: Vanessa. As I mentioned in my comments on the previous episode, I’d be really happy if you decided to keep watching. That said, I’d also completely understand if you chose not to continue for cost-benefit reasons. But please do let us know either way. Not that we’d be sitting around waiting endlessly, of course. But if it came down to a choice between more *TVL* / *IwtV* content and *Penny Dreadful*, I’d definitely opt for the *IwtV* / *TVL* content. One other thing... have you seen *Peaky Blinders*? I bet that would be right up your alley, too.

Yella

I think John Logan intended to do much more with the series. However, despite being an award-winning show, it wasn't truly successful. I suspect he had a wealth of narrative material—which he was ultimately forced to cut down drastically. That is why it feels disjointed, and the characters seem underdeveloped in places. I’ve mentioned this somewhere before—though I’m not sure if it was here. But I work extensively with screenplays. During the pre-production phase of a project, I typically receive anywhere from six to ten drafts of a script. The first draft is sophisticated, detailed, and features a solid plot with excellent twists. By the eighth draft, however, you sit there wondering how on earth the audience is supposed to follow it... and the final product ends up feeling both nonsensical and bizarre. Yet, in most cases, the fault lies not with the writer, but with the editorial team—and the sheer number of people exerting influence over the material. The direction then does the rest...

libragrrrl

Hi Penny Dreadful is one of my favorite series and I have been enjoying your reactions on youtube, I appreciate your unique reaction style and joined Patreon to see your finale reaction. I hope you watch the next 2 seasons worth your time in my humble opinion.

Victoria

Please tell me you will continue this show. i have been waiting for ages for any reactor to do Penny Dreadful. Sadly, is niche and not that popular so noone does it. So I would love to see you do it!