Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Well... uh.... shit....(proudly straightens tinfoil hat)

Files

Comments

Paris Hardy

YESSSS!!! This is the episode I’ve been waiting for since you announced AOT. *** You’re so damn sharp. Reiner escaping Annie in season 1 tipped me off to him being Armor as well. I would eventually have my suspicions confirmed in spoiler fan artwork of Reiner, Bertholdt, Ymir, Eren, & Annie below their titans in 2014 or 15. I started reading the manga every month after that point.

lindelofstan

Bertholdt said Reiner "used to be more of a warrior", and then this episode Reiner says "as a warrior, I'll fulfil my duty to the bitter end". Also worth chewing a bit on the "we were just kids" line IMO

Mostly Harmless

Yeah, this is the big one a lot of people wait for, and it definitely delivers. I love that even for the people who've already guessed the reveal, the way the reveal is delivered is its own sort of twist. I really think what it comes down to for people who do or don't guess it is that scene where he breaks out of Annie's hand either being bullshit in a suspicious way or more bullshit in a TV way. I assumed the latter, because the show had done a somewhat similar thing way earlier on with Eren somehow getting to Armin before he was swallowed, despite the apparent timing of the scene. I think when you don't suspect foul play there, that all the other evidence toward the suspicious nature of Reiner and Bertholdt (mostly Reiner lol) really just comes across as the same way the show makes most things some level of mysterious. Needless to say, though, that as someone who wasn't suspicious of Reiner at all, and found him to be my favorite out of all the cadets introduced back in 3/4, the reveal was one of the most shocking things I had seen out of a show, with both the contents and the delivery. I was legitimately pacing around my room. I went to shave to just have something to do to calm down, especially since I didn't have any friends who had seen the show. I even knew coming into the episode there was gonna be something big and something Reiner related cause of the title and Bertholdt's mention of him having used to be a Warrior, and the fact this episode is tied with like 7 others for the highest rated AoT episode. Besides that, though, I also wanna give props to the atmosphere of the episode. Calm before the storm is nothing new, but I think I might find this to be the most effective use of the concept in anything. It's such a quiet opening, it's slow in a way the show usually isn't. One by one, we help up more people onto the wall, we're still reeling from the titan reveal of Ymir (Hell, even the Annie reveal wasn't even 10 episodes ago). The weather is cloudy, the wind is howling, and Reiner and Bertholdt are saying things that don't exactly make sense. Then, after the flashback and the reveal, the weather clears, and the music builds in an episode mostly devoid or ambient into one of my favorite tracks of the whole show. Absolutely killer stuff.

Nightshade

"I'm the Armored Titan, and Bertold is the Colossal" HE SAID THE THING!!!! *and everyone in the crowd stood up and clapped

Dachtone

Take the tinfoil hat off darling, the theories are coming true!

LuxLoser

Crazy that he was right about Reiner for totally wrong reasons. Annie never wounded him, the steam was just Annie's blood steaming off of Reiner (as Titan blood does for anyone, with Levi and Hange already shown having the blood steam off of them in prior episodes). But from that misunderstanding came him locking in on Reiner