Alternate Wild Shape (5.5e) (Patreon)
Content
Wild Shape: Templates Edition
Ok as anyone who was following the OneD&D playtest process will recall, the first draft of the Druid class used templates for their Wild Shape feature, instead of making use of beast stat blocks from the Monster Manual, like in 5e. It was a huge disaster, and the intense community backlash resulted in 5.5e wild shape resembling the 5e version in many ways.
I, however, think their hearts were in the right place: the idea was good, the execution was terrible. The biggest problem was that the templates were extraordinarily plain and very weak. There was really very little reason to want to turn into a beast, as most beasts' interesting abilities were absent, and turning into a tiny creature like a Spider for scouting purposes was pushed right back to the late game.
Meanwhile, the 5.5e Wild Shape that we got in the end has its own issues. I've so often seen players want to turn into a beast in combat to have a cool moment, only to be disappointed by how unusable they are beyond the earliest levels of the game. The biggest offenders: the terrible attack bonuses and DCs. Meanwhile, the Circle of the Moon subclass starts off exceptionally strong at level 3, only to become pretty weak by the late levels as their forms fail to scale well.
In this brew, I intend to address the issues of both versions by letting you choose from a small number of stat blocks, and modify them with special bestial traits.
I sincerely believe that this is a better balanced and more flexible form of Wild Shape than any of the official versions, at the expense of being being a bit complicated and requiring a bit of bookkeeping. If you can manage that bookkeeping to a point where it won't slow your game down, I think this is a brew that will really serve you well. One day I hope to develop an app that quickly creates the custom stat blocks for you.
Anyway, enough rambles. I hope you enjoy!
Links:
Online (Homebrewery)
PDF (Google Drive)