Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

00:00:00 - Intro

00:00:28 - Greyhound movie escort group?

00:11:35 - HMS Agincourt as a Battlecruiser?

00:16:48 - Naval requirements that ruined a vessel before the keel was even laid?

00:26:00 - Was any thought given to designing a specific commerce protection battleship?

00:31:36 - Breaking Italian naval codes?

00:39:06 - Naval “histories” that turned out to be false?

00:44:26 - Ki-76 as an anti-submarine aircraft?

00:47:48 - How risky were trips made by various heads of state in WW2?

00:51:53 - Japanese warships still under construction at the end of WW2?

00:53:32 - If the (1930s) King George V class had been designed and built with all forward triple 14" guns, would they have benefitted as 'fast mini Nelsons' or would the design have made them worse in practice?

00:55:58 - How can you gear an economy to support a fleet?

01:01:34 - How can a large country safeguard its maritime interests if it doesn't really need a navy for survival?

01:09:04 - In a real life "Godzilla Minus-One" scenario following the timeline of the movie, how would each of the Axis navies have fared trying to quickly reactivate their fleet to fight the monster (with permission from the Allies)?

01:12:42 - Conversion of HMS Spiteful?

01:17:16 - North Carolina quad 14" turrets?

01:18:39 - How did a ship relight it's boilers if power had been out for a while?

01:21:25 - When a ship went to general quarters/battle stations, were all positions expected to be manned regardless of the threat?

01:25:20 - How much gun powder would an age of sail warship carry in its magazine(s)?

01:29:42 - Cruisers vs submarines in WW2?

01:35:19 - Did Imperial Germany have any significant naval fortifications in the Pacific?

01:37:53 - What are some of the largest automatic anti-aircraft guns used on warships during the period covered by the channel?

01:39:41 - Could HMS Victory hurt USS Iowa?

01:41:32 - Last steel castings for naval use?

01:45:55 - Ahead Standard vs engine max power?

01:51:42 - How big could a 'maximum' submarine have been?

01:55:50 - Gas turbine Iowa's?

01:59:47 - Why did the USN abandon the Lexington class battlecruisers?

02:05:28 - Kido Butai fuel situation after Pearl Harbor?

02:09:42 - Would it have been possible to defend the Channel Islands in 1940 and develop them into a 'Malta of the English Channel' in the run up to D-Day?

02:14:06 - Situational awareness in a naval battle?

02:22:01 - Is the HNoMS Tyr (1887) the most successful flat iron gunboat built?

02:25:23 - With aircraft carriers is it better to have one big hanger space or multiple smaller hanger spaces?

02:31:16 - Would La Argentina have done better against Kormoran than HMAS Sydney?

02:34:03 - HTP in WW2 torpedoes?

02:37:29 - Did the South Dakota's go too far?

02:44:52 - Censored old naval photos?

02:48:56 - Naval slang terms?

02:51:21 - Cruiser comparison?

02:58:21 - What are the longest range confirmed submarine torpedo hits in WW2?

02:59:44 - WW1 and British ships spotting tops aft of the fore funnel?

03:03:04 - ERA for ships?

03:06:59 - Why was the UK running out of sailors in WW2?

03:12:15 - The armor belt of a ship gets hit and withstands the impact, the ship survives the battle. What comes next?

03:16:05 - Would a PT Boat crew abandon ship in a torpedo began to runaway in its tube?

03:20:25 - What is a cartel in the Age of Sail?

03:24:44 - Small calibre guns for WW2, using hindsight?

03:29:19 - Alternate Beiyang Fleet funding?

03:33:03 - Realism of combat and weapons in 'The Expanse'?

Files

The Drydock - Episode 421 (Part 2)

00:00:00 - Intro 00:00:28 - Greyhound movie escort group? 00:11:35 - HMS Agincourt as a Battlecruiser? 00:16:48 - Naval requirements that ruined a vessel before the keel was even laid? 00:26:00 - Was any thought given to designing a specific commerce protection battleship? 00:31:36 - Breaking Italian naval codes? 00:39:06 - Naval “histories” that turned out to be false? 00:44:26 - Ki-76 as an anti-submarine aircraft? 00:47:48 - How risky were trips made by various heads of state in WW2? 00:51:53 - Japanese warships still under construction at the end of WW2? 00:53:32 - If the (1930s) King George V class had been designed and built with all forward triple 14" guns, would they have benefitted as 'fast mini Nelsons' or would the design have made them worse in practice? 00:55:58 - How can you gear an economy to support a fleet? 01:01:34 - How can a large country safeguard its maritime interests if it doesn't really need a navy for survival? 01:09:04 - In a real life "Godzilla Minus-One" scenario following the timeline of the movie, how would each of the Axis navies have fared trying to quickly reactivate their fleet to fight the monster (with permission from the Allies)? 01:12:42 - Conversion of HMS Spiteful? 01:17:16 - North Carolina quad 14" turrets? 01:18:39 - How did a ship relight it's boilers if power had been out for a while? 01:21:25 - When a ship went to general quarters/battle stations, were all positions expected to be manned regardless of the threat? 01:25:20 - How much gun powder would an age of sail warship carry in its magazine(s)? 01:29:42 - Cruisers vs submarines in WW2? 01:35:19 - Did Imperial Germany have any significant naval fortifications in the Pacific? 01:37:53 - What are some of the largest automatic anti-aircraft guns used on warships during the period covered by the channel? 01:39:41 - Could HMS Victory hurt USS Iowa? 01:41:32 - Last steel castings for naval use? 01:45:55 - Ahead Standard vs engine max power? 01:51:42 - How big could a 'maximum' submarine have been? 01:55:50 - Gas turbine Iowa's? 01:59:47 - Why did the USN abandon the Lexington class battlecruisers? 02:05:28 - Kido Butai fuel situation after Pearl Harbor? 02:09:42 - Would it have been possible to defend the Channel Islands in 1940 and develop them into a 'Malta of the English Channel' in the run up to D-Day? 02:14:06 - Situational awareness in a naval battle? 02:22:01 - Is the HNoMS Tyr (1887) the most successful flat iron gunboat built? 02:25:23 - With aircraft carriers is it better to have one big hanger space or multiple smaller hanger spaces? 02:31:16 - Would La Argentina have done better against Kormoran than HMAS Sydney? 02:34:03 - HTP in WW2 torpedoes? 02:37:29 - Did the South Dakota's go too far? 02:44:52 - Censored old naval photos? 02:48:56 - Naval slang terms? 02:51:21 - Cruiser comparison? 02:58:21 - What are the longest range confirmed submarine torpedo hits in WW2? 02:59:44 - WW1 and British ships spotting tops aft of the fore funnel? 03:03:04 - ERA for ships? 03:06:59 - Why was the UK running out of sailors in WW2? 03:12:15 - The armor belt of a ship gets hit and withstands the impact, the ship survives the battle. What comes next? 03:16:05 - Would a PT Boat crew abandon ship in a torpedo began to runaway in its tube? 03:20:25 - What is a cartel in the Age of Sail? 03:24:44 - Small calibre guns for WW2, using hindsight? 03:29:19 - Alternate Beiyang Fleet funding? 03:33:03 - Realism of combat and weapons in 'The Expanse'?

Comments

Rob Smith

In your answer to the question about a gas turbine electric power-plant for an Iowa you get the units wrong - the GE 5-frame delivers between 20 and 50 MEGA watts depending on the exact model, those in the first generation GTELs delivered about 4500hp. Given each of the four shafts of an Iowa is driven by about 55000hp, thus one would need about 12 of the units used in the first generation GTEL for each shaft. The final generation of the GTEL had a newer gas turbine rated at about 8500hp, thus we drop to 6.5 gas turbines per shaft - it is of course very difficult to get half a gas turbine, so it would have to be 7... A single gas turbine in a package with its generator is about 35ft x 12ft x12ft, with the whole assembly weighing about 150 tonnes.

Felix B

The Swiss Gasturbine loco of 1941! Had 2200Hp nominal. Sulzer had nothing to do with it, its Brown Boveri & SLM. There was a Powerplant Gasturbine "Neuchatel" with 4MW in 1938

Steven Palmer

There is another part of the Engine Order Telegraph where you put in the requested RPMS. For example the command, "Engine(s) ahead 2/3, indicate 60 rpms for 12 knots." For harbor maneuvering 999 RPMS meant a set RPM for each area of the telegraph. For example 1/3=25 rpms, 2/3=50 rpms, full=75 rpms.

Ted M Jones

The other personnel problem the UK had was that they had a large number of people involved in the domestic anti-aircraft effort. And by the end of 1944 they were desperate for infantry.