Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Despite the assurances of many people, the moderator did not see reason and maintained his decision about Chapter 29, so I have now censored the ending scene/discussion about the arranged marriage.

Frankly, it looks way worse now that it's censored than what it actually was, and makes the rest of Tovar's life much less readable without making assumptions about the missing content. As a solution, I hate it, but rewriting seems stupid because this should be a non-issue.

This is the kind of thing that makes me want to take a hiatus, just walk away from the story until the muse re-inspires and I have to write it for myself again. My 6-9 month hiatus from Worldseed was a significantly smaller issue, and were I the same writer now as I was then, that would likely be all I wrote until May at the earliest.

Difference is, this time I have all of you. The support I'm receiving here on Patreon is amazing. Not just monetary, but emotionally and in terms of feedback on the writing itself. With over 800 people now paying to keep reading EoR and almost everyone saying that there was nothing wrong with the chapters in question, I'm not so turned off as to walk away (aside from a few days, which I did, to cool my head.)

I'm still tempted to pull the story from RR and just write to Patreon, now, but I have shout obligations to fulfill. I've stopped taking new shoutout swap requests so that I can step back from RR if I feel like it in the future, but I'm booked through to March, and by then I might be over this. Or, I'll be far enough in the story that stubbing book one is in sight. I could probably call Tovar's life a book and stub just that, at 125k words or so, but I intend on packing all three of the first lives into book one, assuming they don't run away from me (I expect each to be about half as long as Tovar's, probably.)

So, I'm now writing the next life, which you'll see the first chapter of tomorrow, and while my pace hasn't been as great as I would have liked, I'm moving forward. I will note that, while I have given in to the demands of this power-tripping moderator and censored the chapter despite being given no section of the Knowledge Base or TOS that show this isn't allowed, his response time is so bad that the support ticket created for the report still isn't closed. I'm expecting that to take a few more days, but it's possible that now that I'm in his sights, he picks apart the other parts of the story (that I highlighted to show that there wasn't even a "proposal", only a discussion of it, and that it never even happens) and demands further censure.

In that case, fuck him, I'm pulling the story from RR. I'll just keep writing to you here on Patreon. I've read so much worse stuff on RR that the fact that my story is being targeted is absurd to me. But the trickle-down effect of this is problematic. I'm not sure about talking to publishers about it now, and I'm concerned that whatever hater stirred this pot in the first place could follow to Amazon, reporting the story there once it's stubbed, and bring down Amazon's even worse AI-driven support bots on me, which will be impossible to deal with. That could result in my author account being banned, which would completely close off that possibility for my writing--not just EoR, but Worldseed and more, too.

It probably won't happen, but all that over my head is definitely causing me stress. For now I'm just continuing to focus on writing a chapter at a time. As always, thanks for being here and for reading, and I appreciate you.

---

EDIT: Whoops, looks like I made this available to both tiers. Oh well! Thanks for all the support in the comments. I'll leave this up for Party Members, but it was a direct continuation of last week's blog, which was Heroes Only. So, since there's some confusion, I made that one Party Member accessible now as well.

Comments

theoldestdream

My man I am so sorry for everything that happened just know that despite a couple of really stupid people those that are here on Patreon love your story

Potato Lord

I appreciate you. Sorry you have to deal with this headache, I love your writing and that moderator is way out of line. Thanks for being here and sharing your story with me.

Jason Bryant

Such bullshit. Your readers here are with you 100%, do what you think is best for you.

Justus Halbach

Please no hiatus. 🙏 I'm to invested now for someone else's power trip to delay your content production. May said mod stub his toe.

Ravonsword Aceicer

Is it possible to talk to another moderator and have this be cleared up. I will continue to support the book here on patreon and i hope once al the dust settles you wont have to worry about publishing the book

Tom

It’s your story man, do what you want. I don’t see an issue at all with how it was originally posted. Don’t censor yourself and the story you want to create for essentially a Reddit mod.

Parably

It’s extremely frustrating for it to even be an issue. I could give countless examples of full on anime that have extreme success with much more iffy storylines. (I’m talking about you Mushoku Tensei) I did not even know mods could order you to rewrite and censor your story like this. The only thing that would mollify these people if you straight up told the girl he remembered his last life and he was feeling guilty about taking advantage of her and she laughs him off and says she could have been as easily married to an old duke for political reasons.

Kermit The Frog

What's amazing to me is I have read stories with graphic depictions of baby murder and violent euthenasia with a side of sexual assault on RR that didn't accrue the scrutiny of the above chapter. It gobsmacks me at times the lines people draw in fiction and others they are are fine to pole vault over.

Hasse

remove the chapter on RR and tell ppl to go read it here if they are interested

Turncoat

If you can't post on rr, there's plenty of other sites that can maintain a following. S

Nathan Malone

I have read about quite a few authors having censorship problems with RR. You're not the first and definitely not going to be the last. Write what you want too, if someone wants to read it they will, no matter what anyone else says. If more authors start pulling from RR then they would have to change their tune.

Some guy

I don’t think I understand what the problem is but if you’re happy I’m happy. you are literally giving away free content to read if this was in a literal book in kindle maybe I would get the whole editorial thing but RR is literally free and patron is about buying it literally fresh off the press so to speak not everything is going to be pretty or perfect if you planing to publish this into a book and you have noticed discrepancies that you don’t want or like then it’s a good note for like really far in the further you to fix but the right now is happening Thank you for your work so far

Skeln

i remember reading a grimdark story about a mage that kept elves in his room in a sort of perma chained-tube fed-breeding machine to collect their blood and sexual fluids on RR. no problem whatsoever. but yours is a problem? crazy hypocrisy

Craig

Just leave a (censored by self-righteous user+mod) bit on RR, a link and short description to patreon at the bottom of the chap, and make that one chap free on patreon so readers who don't care can come here and read it 🙂

brennon Petersen

It's quiet crazy how that specific passage is being made a problem especially considering for this first life he is literally no different from any other main character on any other reincarnation story on Royal Road the only difference being the fact that it's expressed at the very beginning that he will have many more lives to come

Girl Moss

I would have never guessed that this would blow out of proportion like that and even have a moderater to go against you? It makes no sense! I feel so sorry for you and I hope you don‘t doubt yourself too much because it was a totally ethical correct and consensual situation. Wish you lots of friends and family who can support you irl and we are here for you and your great story.

Khionu

Was there a post made when the report was received? I remember reading something in A/N on RR, but I'm trying to catch up on this bs so I can make sure I'm seeing the full picture. Sorry you're going through this crap

V M

i have seen other creators that have had this issue on RR, some have chosen to keep the chapters complete, easily accessible and free to post the uncensored versions of the chapters on an other site, the one i have seen is Scribble Hub.

dave hutch

Great now those fucknuts have colonised RR. They already destroyed reddit. Infected Goodreads and now RR. I fucking hate them. I joined RR in 2014.

Disclancer

I feel for you mate, it's such a tunnel visioned reaction to something I felt you handled with tact, especially given it's an issue you can hardly avoid given it's a story about a serial reincarnator. I was just wondering if you intended this blog to be visable to below hero guys? I'm not in the hero tier and can read it. Regardless please don't let this dampen your spirt for writing this series, we're all here behind you.

EsZeus

I hate the RR mods anyway, ngl. I had some issues with them already and they are not helpful at all. Overall, we all know nowadays what the problem with western civilization is... Not needing to name it. We were at a near perfect state 10-15 years or so back then, and then it fell off a cliff. Political, social and all that. The Mods behavior is just normal in current times, sadly.

Sean Hibbitt

You're doing great, Im loving your story! You'll find a solution you're happy with eventually :) Don't be put off of publishing. You'll have to edit things, remove or add sections.. but afterwards you'll reach so many more people to share your story telling with :) P.s, I don't think you tagged this as heros only 😅

Alexander

I think you worry way too much about this. I would literally remove the contested lines and add (Line removed at moderator request – Read on Patreon for the uncensored version) in the middle of the story. Has the benefit of bringing more people to Patreon while also making them pissed at RR. Malicious compliance at its finest.

Bob

Love the story. I do most of my reading on Patreon, but RR is how I find stories. Occasionally Scribblehub. I use to post a review on every story I read on RR, hundreds of posts, then an RR mod came after me. I deleted them all. The whole site has gone downhill. Still one of the few places for me to find decent stories. You could just post a "CENSORED by RR Moderation Team" 'for X reason' post over the old chapter. Then direct them to read it on Patreon.

Rarvyn

I would personally suggest unlocking the full version of the relevant chapter on Patreon so that free readers can view it, mention it in the RR author note, and otherwise move on. The spiciest thing that happened in that chapter was a kiss on the cheek and anyone who reads it will realize the moderators are nuts.

Gojira

You’re not the only author that I’ve seen have to do this for something stupid. Seems like if anything it can cause a short term boost sometimes. Also there’s literally smut on kindle so I think you’ll be fine.

Yshua

The suggestion to link to that chapter free on Patreon is a good one. Don’t worry or stress about follow on effects, this tripping RR mod has no power elsewhere. You handled the scene/concern very well, and frankly the lecture from the Administrator is one I’ve wanted to give to many an RR commenter myself.

Deloach50

Don't worry about publishing it. When you get to that point you can get a with a publisher and they will make sure it has the correct "warning labels" and then the fairies that don't understand life when it isn't magical and anxiety/pain-free can be told to fuck off.

Pete's Place Garage

Most online platforms that allow any kind of written content are hyper-sensitive to negative feedback, because it is too easy to escalate to the server hosting the site with unfounded complaints, and if the website admins appear to not have worked to quell the offending content, they don't even give them a chance to appeal. It is the same disease that has infected SO many Facebook reading groups. The reason why this story gets targeted while so many more egregious stories go unmolested is simply that the mods ONLY react to reported content. It doesn't even really matter why it was reported. If a story isn't reported, it's fine. Stories/chapters that DO get reported are presumed guilty, with no real appeal. I had to re-write my scathing review of Path to Transcendence FOUR times before it would pass muster with the mods. I was so mad at the author for how they were writing their story. It was hard to keep it impersonal. But I digress. The point is, they did not help AT ALL with what exactly I did wrong, and it was up to me to find the specific guidelines and then QUOTE them when the author reported my review AGAIN. It was a very arduous process, and took months to resolve. And that was just for a review.

Tshern

Everyone has an opinion. That being said we a free site is open to everyone and those enjoying your patreon to mee reflect willingness to purchase your story and enjoy it as is. I had to go back to re read that chapter bc i wasnt aware of anything controversial. Keep writing your story, your doing good work and the patreon count reflects that

Jeff091

In my experience, authors who limit themselves to Patreon disappear into obscurity and lose patrons. The amount of patrons a story has fluctuates, there are always people leaving, and the main way to get more patrons is internet presence. Without these sources of both new and returning patrons, the income dries up. The best example of that is "Soul of the Warrior" the author basically dropped Royal Road and over a year or more lost most readers, then he posted a couple of chapters on Royal Road and regained many patrons, dropped royal road, rinse and repeat. With internet presence i mean everything, whether on Royal Road, SB, SV, ScribbleHub, or just informing people about the story on Reddit. Some pages have problems and might not be worth it (webnovel plagiatism & lack of censorship, fictionpress.com lack of moderations & lack of censorship, AO3 lack of censorship) I am mostly reading elsewhere, and when there is a bad cliffhanger or I really want to read the next chapter or I really like the story, or it is Christmas, I subscribe on Patreon

Orbital Kittens

ScribbleHub is way more lenient on content and moderation. I did not see any issue at all with the arranged marriage. Don't let the butthurt snowflake SJWs get you down!

Atru

I'm new so I never read the cut version of ch 29 until I got here. I'd say to focus on the fact that I was still drawn to your story despite that and there will be more like myself who wouldn't know this story unless it was on royalroad! I'm enjoying the story and hope the challenges in writing it the way you want don't keep you from writing it at all and sharing it to all.

RTS

Hey, what I would do is make that chapter freely available on Patreon for non-subscribers and replace it on RR with a note that says it’s “Too hot for RR, check it out on Patreon and laugh with us at the fact this somehow got reported”.

lamp

Sorry to hear that. I don't really have any idea on how to address the overall problem, but with regards to making the original version available I think making that a "free" chapter on Patreon could be a possible solution. I also think Patreon only will hurt as it will make it harder to find and would likely hurt it in the long run, however scribblehub could be a possible alternative to RR in the future

davetim101

Sorry to hear about all this, seems we continue to live in the state where we can't have nice things in this world. You handled that scene well, I wonder if the moderator in question has a problem with relationships between people being a thing that naturally occurs? Can't cure stupid in that case. If they have any other requests to censor your story, can you make it clear where it occurs and direct users to the exact chapter on Patreon? Have any of your plans for the future been changed because of this?

TheOne320

I really hope you do not change the story because of this. There are actually sick stories out there that are normally sold and nobody complains about it. Fiction should stay fiction.

Simply3thn

Yeah, screw that mod. I have read some OUTRAGEOUS stuff on RR, it's just absurd to me that this is even an issue, as I thought this was super normal and understandable from Tovar's perspective. People are the worst. Thank you for taking the time to write this story, it's one of the ones that I check for chapters every day :)

Amazon Shopper

can't you just talk to the rr staff? there are supposed to be protections against this sort of behaviour. Phillip, this isn't a you problem. this is a public figure gets hate problem, its just that as an author you are more vulnerable-but there are things you can do to help defend yourself like talking to rr staff, and to publishers. i wouldn't be surprised if that user ended up getting banned for harrasment.

The Human

I'd call first life book 1 and stub it when you've finished book 2 (lives 2 and three) - idk if it's still the case or even if I'm misremembering but iirc I was told ~100-125k words is the sweet spot for kindle unlimited

The White Hare

Isn’t arranged marriage still common in indian culture? Some of my indian friends have had happy arranged marriages. Maybe add in a reference to his thoughts on similarities back on earth and pull the cultural insensitivity card…language is also a weapon

meu 32

Obviously I dont know what instructions you were given but if it isnt against them you could add a note to the chapter that is just a brief explanation of the situation. That would clear up most of the confusion.

Phoenix Keene

What an absolute farce. By those standards, Royal Road couldn't host Romeo and Juliet, since a marriage between Paris and Juliet is discussed and R&J consummate their marriage offscreen. Utterly ridiculous. They're coming for you bc you're popular.

Dembed

There has been tons of good advice given. I encountered other troublesome aspects of RR not allowing fan fics to post patreon or other monetary links. I hope you or some others of the community who know things better could escalate this situation and that way things move forward. Worst case, you try other platforms and mainly patreon. Maybe later on try kindle when you feel ready for that step. In the end, stay true to your heart