MONSTERS: A Trashfuture Newsletter (Patreon)
Content
For the past few weeks, I’ve been trying to figure out how to begin the inaugural issue of Monsters.
One version goes as follows: It’s been close to a decade since we’ve been podcasting as Trashfuture. Trump had just been elected to the White House, the UK had voted for Brexit, and there was a change in the air, although none of us knew what that would look or sound like. We had some hints, in the form of weird, and stupid start ups—Juiceros, the mirror that talks to you, a fridge that displays pictures of what you have inside it—that we’d try to make sense of sat around Riley’s kitchen table. We could tell that things were getting stranger and incoherent, especially when governments across the world became more unstable, increasingly reliant on obscure finance sources and the tech industry to prop them up, while elected politicians decided every opportunity to go on TV and radio was the perfect time to talk about gender and ‘wokeness gone too far’ and basically nothing else.
The other version—the one I’m going with—is to recall the year where, for some reason, I kept getting locked inside public toilets.
Don't act like this isn't immediately familiar if you live in Britain.
In 2018, I got stuck in over ten public bathrooms. Most were in train stations—twice in London Bridge, once in Victoria, a few times in Charing Cross and the worst, being trapped in a fancy toilet in Canary Wharf, where I couldn’t open the door because, in the words of the unhelpful, somewhat aloof receptionist outside of my therapist’s office—the “door couldn’t recognise your hand”. Great, thanks.
I still think back to that year frequently, wondering if I had been cursed by a witch (a story for another time), or whether this was the effect of the post-2016 vibe shift. Either way, getting locked in bathrooms did affect my life in mundane and significant ways. I missed appointments, was late for dates and meeting up with friends. At one point, I missed a pretty big job interview, one that could have changed my life. When the company asked why I hadn’t turned up, I could only respond by saying that I was caught between things.
Being stuck in a confined space—one that reeks of stale lager, McDonald’s and urine—for any period of time can be pretty uncomfortable. In many ways, the stagnation that has occurred over the past decade has felt like being stuck inside a broken British toilet, pleading to be let out, only to be yelled at, and in a patronising tone, asked whether you were the one who broke the lock.
This week, my colleague and co-host Nate Bethea writes about his experience of the 2016 election, and reflects on this peculiar decade of economic and cultural stagnation. He asks whether recent election results, not just in the US, but in Europe and Brazil, suggest the emergence of a new vibe shift, one that could guide us out of the malaise.
Meanwhile, some advice from me: check the door of the loo before you use it. And bring a book with you. At the very least, you’ll be able to talk about something when the unenthused maintenance guy shows up.
HK
Hussein@trashfuture.co.uk
It's Been a Long, Long 2016
by Nate Bethea
My photo of Connecticut on November 8, 2016. This is what I mean about how it was almost too nice.
There were warning signs.
On November 8th, 2016, I had a client gig in Connecticut. I voted at a neighbourhood school near my apartment in Crown Heights, Brooklyn, and then took Metro North from Grand Central towards New Haven. It was a genuinely perfect autumn day, the sky completely clear, the foliage stunning. It was almost too nice.
As the train pulled out from Mount Vernon East, I noticed a Hispanic guy with two young kids on the platform waving a hand-painted sign, which read: “TRUMP VICTORY!” I couldn’t help but think that this was an unexpected level of enthusiasm: presumably, this guy had taken his kids out of school on a Tuesday to brandish Trump signs at passing commuters, in famously blue New York State. I just recall thinking, Well, that’s odd.
I worked late that evening and I didn’t get on the train home until after dinnertime. I’d just gotten into the Bronx when the results started posting from Florida. The Democratic vote had massively underperformed expectations, and the news only got worse from there. It was a long night.
That was a decade ago, and in the intervening years that have been times when it’s felt we’ve never really left 2016. I’d been thinking about this for a while, and then after sending an initial draft of this essay to Hussein, the midterm election results came in. Suddenly, it felt like 2016 again, but in reverse. I’ll do my best to explain what I mean.
Obviously, in 2016 the US and UK both experienced pivotal elections, with tremendous and long-lasting impacts, and the votes themselves settling on razor thin margins. Despite both countries being so politically divided, the right and their enablers decided that this was the only true expression of the people’s will, and a lot of people who should have known better decided to play dumb. This manifested itself in every kind of Trump Diner / Brexit Safari piece you could think of, plus exhortations to “get out of your bubble,” and so on.
But perhaps more pervasive than this ever-present vague background hum of scolding was the idea that we couldn’t really make an educated guess about anything. The polls were wrong, the norms didn’t hold, the accepted ground rules and givens were meaningless. Weaponised internet bullshit did in fact make some difference. If you weren’t right-wing you had been wrong and, not only was it your fault, it was something you’d somehow done intentionally.
There was no denying that polls had been wrong, but political commentary post-2016 felt like an aggressive, bad-faith over-interpretation of what had actually gone down. An election goes 48/52 instead of 52/48 and now everyone is running around screaming about the Götterdämmerung, blaming the hated and all-powerful Left, and engaging in a kind of speculative fiction about what things would be like if we could just go back to the times that caused the problems.
I want to make it clear that I am very sympathetic to one particular group for whom this desire for restoration is very poignant and acute: a generation of young people, who rightly felt a sense of having their future stolen, their limited options foreclosed, trapped in a fortress created for no other reason than spite, by older generations who felt they could never fail – they could only be failed.
I hope this doesn’t sound smug. I really do feel for young people who had no say in the matter, and saw their horizons suddenly and violently circumscribed. They have a right to mourn what was lost, and I won’t pretend to know what that was like. I was sixteen when 9/11 happened, and I remember enough of the before to see how starkly it contrasts with the after. But, crucially, America didn’t vote for 9/11 to happen. Not directly, at least.
Also, some of the before-times nostalgia is a desire to live without something that can in fact be defeated, and has been defeated: credulousness and imaginary grievances metastasizing via social media and, for lack of a better word, total bullshit proliferating unchallenged. It’s not as simple as “fake news sites mean reactionaries always win,” but to my eyes 2016 was the first real proof that spurious internet bullshit at scale could have serious impacts on electoral politics, especially in winner-takes-all systems.
I’m hostile to the “decrying echo chambers” argument, or the “it’s the Left’s fault for complaining too much” argument, because I do remember quite clearly all the things that were supposedly to blame for Trump winning.
It was Bret Stephens who claimed it was Democrats being in thrall to what he called “boutique sexualities.” America had actually gotten too queer and needed to be gay-bashed by the indefatigably heterosexual Donald Trump. Moonlight was getting too much praise. I dunno—pick your grievance or absurd claim. I saw someone comment on a story in NYT Magazine (an article by a gay Black man about how America’s last taboo in cinema was showing Black male nudity), published two weeks before Election Day, in which they said , “You’ve just convinced me to vote for Donald Trump.” Maybe it’s hyperbole, but, looking back, there was something telling in the comment, foreshadowing what ‘political debate’ would look like for the foreseeable future: Guys whose entire politics could be summarised as: “I’ve decided to embrace fascism because a Black guy wrote something gay.”
And then, of course, Trump won. All those shitty people—Richard Spencer and the frog Nazis! Sebastian Gorka! Jet-ski dealers and people in Alabama holding signs that read Thank You Lord Jesus For President Trump!—were the legitimate, forgotten Americans, supposedly ignored by a cadre of elites who simply refused to acknowledge the everyday struggles of working people, whose volkisch and heartfelt complaints just so happened to all be about immigrants, seeing Black people literally anywhere, trans people playing sports, and basically nothing else. I can’t imagine that any of you need me to explain the illogic of this.
After over a decade of repeating the same culture war ‘debates’—each year becoming dumber and more absurd, and driven by an endless supply chain of grifters armed with 4K camera rigs, podcast mics and overhead lighting—a sea change may be occurring. The shoe may be on the other foot, because in the US, and in Hungary, and in Serbia, we can point to examples of people just getting sick of this weird bullshit. I'm thrilled that the US voted the way it did in these midterms. I'm dismayed at the apparently bipartisan electoral consent for transphobia that also happened. I hope this is the end of Long 2016. But it’s worth thinking about what 2016 was, and why we've struggled to escape from its shadow.
For me, the lessons of 2016 weren’t that the right always wins, or that fascism is inevitable, or that we’re powerless to stop whatever is coming. Rather, it’s that in spite of the technocratic, rational politics subscribed to by wonks, data analysts and pollsters, the absolute worst and dumbest thing can in fact happen. And when it does happen, a lot of influential and powerful people suddenly find it really easy to make peace with the new reality.
In some cases, they’ll even work out how to benefit from it as they declare that the world simply cannot be another way, or that whatever degradation and decay that occurs must be the fault of the marginalised. The script is almost always the same: “We need a total economic apocalypse in Britain to put the left in its place. We need Trump to punish America to remind people that daily school shootings are completely fine and normal. And if you don’t like it, it’s your fault for buying boutique sexualities on Vinted. Look what you made us do.”
Like most people in 2016, I naively did not think it possible that Trump would win, at least not that first time. In the ten years that have passed since then, I’ve gotten married, started podcasting, moved to two different countries, gotten my heart crushed by electoralism (2019), become a parent, libbed out shamelessly because of electoralism (2020; 2026), and it seems to me that the wariness that resulted from that shock has never left. The distress I felt that night when the result was announced—when I knew the world would change for the absolute worse, in ways I couldn’t yet envision—still lingers.
In those moments, I remind myself of that family standing on the Metro-North platform, each of us confident that we knew where we were heading, with none of us having the slightest clue. I wouldn’t have believed Trump would win. I wouldn’t have believed his inauguration speech would have been about “American Carnage.” I wouldn’t have believed any of this.
I’d like to hope that that family came around and realized that Trumpism is a dead end. But, if not, I can at least take stock in the fact that they get to be the ones waking up to a very, very unpleasant November morning, and I’m going to respond with an amount of grace commensurate with what was offered to the losing side back then. And believe me, that much I remember.
[Okay, there was another warning sign, but it’s harder to explain. In August 2016, the same day Hillary passed out from the heat during a campaign stop, I was in lower Manhattan with my partner. We were waiting on the subway and happened to see a young woman about my age, covered in cupping therapy marks, playing Pokémon Go on the incredibly packed subway platform. I turned to my partner and, without really giving it any thought, said, “You know, I think Trump’s gonna win.”]
Edited by Hussein Kesvani.
A few closing notes:
Friend of the show Nathan Akehurst is having a book launch event in London on 24th November! You might recall Nathan's appearance to talk about the Central Mediterranean, and his book ALONG THE WATCHTOWER will debut this month. Get tickets here!
November: I'm currently recovering from surgery, and I'm enjoying Borges’ Ficciones. ‘Tlön, Uqbar, Orbis Tertius’ predicts LARP. That's all I'm going to say.
Riley: I've been enjoying Developer's 2012 klubnacht mix where it was recorded from the booth rather than directly off the desk. Listen to it here.
Nate: I revisited a recipe from 2011 published on a now-defunct website called the Japanese Food Report. It remains the best from-scratch Japanese curry recipe I've ever found, and thankfully someone saved the page on the Internet Archive.