Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Downloads

  • FUBTS_1003.mp3

Missing 1 file, as this post has not yet been imported.

Content

Matt, RJ and Reddi breakdown performances by Cash, Aleš Hrdlička, Henry & Klauss, Jonah Babins & Ben Train as well as Penn and Teller's "Finding a needle in a haystack".

Comments

Thomas Moore

Grumpy stage/illusion designer time..... STAGE magic is a totally different beast to parlour magic, TV magic or frankly any other genre of magic and the problems come when the ill-informed try to jump into or out of stage magic thinking they don't need to modify their material for the medium. Stage magic has to be clear to "read" both conceptually and visually to an audience that is at least 30ft away and many over 100ft away. A well known performer over here just tried to create their first stage magic show and its absolutely bombed precisely because they didn't understand the important presentational and technical beats a stage magic show has to hit and what they created is dull, confusing and totally inappropriate for the medium. A nuanced skilled attempt at lock picking is completely invisible to a stage magic audience, such tiny movements that it might even just look like fake hands - to get something that "reads" as lock picking in a stage environment it HAS to be a bigger, bolder movement that hits a few key beats. To convey danger on stage you HAVE to have oversized blades or large boxes of explosives because the reality (that a few drops of liquid could kill thousands or that a piece of plastic explosive the size of a sugar cube would obliterate a body) would be impossible to see or convey clearly and quickly in a stage environment. Consider the difference between theatre actors and Netflix drama actors - both would convey the exact same narrative concept ("I'm injured and dying") in completely different ways that would look ridiculous if you swapped them over but which are utterly perfect in their respective mediums. Which is a long roundabout way of saying that the remote should have been re-staged specifically to get it into a TV appropriate format for the show with the acting dialled down for camera and the blocking/pacing adapted to suit the medium. It's very common to record TV specific versions of stage performances that the audience in-the-room might not fully appreciate but which correctly conveys the beats and feel of the illusion to the tv viewers that they would feel if they saw the "same" presentation in a theatre. Look at the Copperfield TV specials - they were recorded whilst out on tour but they specifically re-staged the effects, added technical twists (twins for example) and performance tweaks (revolves, extra lighting, reverse camera views) to ensure that what ended up in the camera feels like the authentic live show experience. (I'm sure Jim said something along these lines much better than i could)

Daniel GreenWolf

So, I perform illusions, I love illusions, I've always loved illusions. I've had the honor of working with some amazing illusionists, and I agree with everything Thomas has said. This escape/illusion was just... Pretty awkward to watch. Adding on to Thomas's point- this needed a proper TV director, and some of the skills of a close-up performer and a parlor performer, (and Matt as a hand-director- of course) to make this large illusion work at all on TV. On Henning: I think a proper bio hasn't been done on Doug Henning (although read the Henning Biography "Spellbound: The Wonder-filled Life of Doug Henning", because it's amazing) because there's no happy ending. His obsession with Transcendental Meditation led to him turning his back on Magic, throwing a shit load of money at Veda Land, a TM themed Park, and dying because he followed fake healers instead of medical science. I would watch the shyte out of it, though. On Zany Performers: I would put John Cassidy in the Zany category. He feels like 90s Robin Williams stand up without the swearing and drug addiction (I'm guessing). The audience almost doesn't know if he's going to snap at any moment, and it's brilliantly done. If you can't tell I'm on a 4-hour train ride to Paris with nothing better to do but write this- I'm on a 4-hour train ride to Paris with nothing better to do but write this. -D.G.