Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

…it would seem, because I wasn’t very active on Patreon lately. Sorry for my long absence but I was having a hard time, feeling somehow depressed, listless and useless with no will to even check my Patreon messages. Although I had received some new products in the meantime from Soundpeats and Anker including the Q45, A40 and some sleep earbuds which I haven’t even opened yet, trying out all these made me even more frustrated.

Please apologise the lack of content, in fact I wasn’t sleeping the whole day but was silently “working” in the background and did lots of tests end experiments with my binaural microphones, when I finally noticed that most I did so far seems to be flawed. We had a couple of windy days lately which I made use of trying to capture this natural smooth spectrum as good as possible (you maybe remember my birch recording a while back). The video above already has my new and improved compensation applied, which should result in a pretty natural and smooth spectrum which was manually matched to a reference spectrum I captured simultaneously with a normal omnidirectional microphone. The trick by capturing wind moving leaves is that it’s a more distant and diffuse sound covering a large area and remains smooth and constant even if you move around, while trying to do this with 2 speakers in front of you will result in lots of changes to the spectrum if you move back and forth etc.

You can see the reference spectrum I captured in green and my final binaural spectrum in blue.

You should notice that they align quite nicely from about 2khz upwards, I ignored the area below 2-3khz as I know that HRTFs do not alter the incoming sound below these frequencies much, while lots of peaks and dips are introduced by the concha above that. I was quite excited about my improvements, because my former recordings always appeared way more jaggy when looking at the spectrum. A natural continuous spectrum like the one captured doesn’t contain any peaks thus it should sound smooth and equal to the real spectrum when listened over a headphone or speaker. With familiar sounds like rain, wind etc any errors become way more obvious than with music which was recorded by someone using some microphones, processed by some sound engineer in the studio and mastered by someone else…

The real problem started when I noticed that my final recordings did not quite sound the same like I was hearing in real life regardless which headphone I was using. You can hopefully understand my frustration that’s why I had sleepless nights wasted for further tests as I was sure that my compensation may be flawed. Everything was on halt because I couldn’t offer any videos knowing they do not represent the real sound I am hearing until I discovered that the headphones must be simply flawed and cannot reproduce this smooth spectrum properly. Even my HD600 which I thought I had already equalised for a flat response before just didn’t sound right. With the recorded wind noises, rain etc I started to hear lots of further errors in the perceived sound despite my EQ.

Then I started to correct for these errors again one by one trying to match the sound I was hearing in real life to this I had just captured with my binaural microphones. My first results are quite intriguing. On top of my original EQ for the HD600 I started to add further filters to make the smooth captured spectrum to appear also smooth and more or less the same I was hearing in real life when listening over the headphone. I must confess I am still far from it, but interestingly also “normal” recordings started to sound more lively and exciting to me with this new EQ, and I am currently trying to optimise it and match the response I am hearing over the headphone to that I am hearing in real life. This will of course result in a completely different sound that I would regard as “neutral” for a headphone then I did before. This will also result in a completely new IEM tuning in future. I already spent lots of time to tweak my settings for the Free Pro 2 as well as I want these responses to be matched as good as possible. I had already sent some first results for the Free Pro 2 to my trusty listeners with the same ear canal resonance like me to get some initial feedback but I will need more time to achieve my final goal.

All this finally gave me some meaning of life again and I am quite eager to explore and dig deeper into the mysteries of sound although it can be really frustrating doing the same over and over again ending up with completely different results.

I am so thankful about all your continuous support as my wife again blows everything off I am currently wasting my time on thinking I must have become crazy.

I know I promised to give away the Anker Soundcore Motion Boom+ for last month, and I will catch up on everything soon, so stay tuned!

Files

Gone with the wind…

...the summer I mean, as today autumn started again. Imagine laying at the ground in a forest and looking up into the sky.

Comments

Mister 13

Big respect to you for being able to make a 60€ speaker sounds decent. And congratulations for all you did those last years, you helped me a lot to get a good ear. Keep up the good work. You should work for some big names

Hartyewh

Take it easy Oluv. It's a tricky hobby and business to be in so it will never be smooth sailing, but having faith in your own project and approach regardless of some negative feedback is required. I think this can all grow into something great over time or at least hope so.

Drew M

Keep in mind that microphones have different frequency responses off-axis just like speakers do, that may be part of the problem you're having. I know I tend to forget that fact and get consumed. And don't let things stress you out. You're doing a great job with what you're doing already

oluvsgadgets

They are omni capsules and rather my ear is the sound forming factor. That’s not the problem but rather that no headphone is really tuned properly. I relied too much on existing tunings and postulations and need to start more or less from scratch to achieve a headphone sound which is able to reproduce a natural smooth spectrum the same way you would perceive the same spectrum in real life.

Barton

Would there be a chance you could revisit Anker Q30 EQ at some point with all this new knowledge and experience working with Free Pro 1 & 2 and Uboom? I am still using them for hours every day. Would be great being able to get even more out of them. Cheers!

oluvsgadgets

The Q30 is hopeless, but except some exciting news regarding the Free Pro 2.

Barton

Thanks, I will, but I also need something over ear with ANC to survive. :)

Douwe de Vries

I agree what Drew is saying there. I think you are doing a really great job by what you offered us on this journey and are over delivering in that aspect too I think. You want to really go for the best and that is someone really striving for high quality tunings as that keeps evolving. That is what is keeping me interested. Some things in life do come first and sometimes we have things to deal with and that's okay. So thank you for being a part of this :)

Mika

I agree: I absolutely love my Free Pro 2s but over-ears have a lot of nice properties of their own and I'm super glad I can switch between the two, when I need to.

oluvsgadgets

I couldn’t name a single over ear which I could recommend without reservation. Everyone is about Harman right now which IMO is a totally flawed target. But after my recent experiments I can postulate that even the HD600 which is always regarded as neutral is not neutral. In reality the HD800S is way more neutral in regard to overall tonality, which I had to “learn” first, although it has its flaws due to heavy peaks and some hole in the mids it can reproduce my recordings with my new adjusted compensation more correctly. I am currently readjusting my tuning for the Free Pro 2 and it got the character of the HD800S just better and smoother.

yossibm

Oluv, don't despair! the problem is that the general population only care about bass (having as much as possible), and mainstream reviewers such as crinacle and resolve reflects that. but there are still people that care about faithful sound reproduction and they are members of your patreon. BTW, have your head about the new airpods pro, using "True depth" camera to scan your ears and make correction? that could be very interesting if it's not total bullshit.

oluvsgadgets

If done well it could definitely be a game changer, already Super X-Fi had something similar and there are open source apps on the net like mesh to HRTF which basically could correct the response towards one’s ear perfectly but I didn’t have the best results with this so far, although Apple may have something good here. Also the new Bose IEM has some ear canal calibration which at least could deal with the ear canal resonance, I would also like to get one for a test, but I need to set my priorities somehow

yossibm

to me, when I equalize an headphone the most benefit comes from flattening the bass, and reducing upper treble gain (above 10k, somehow manufactures almost always missing that part of the tuning. probably they cannot hear it). and obviously also removing the most noticeable peaks and dips. but I don't try to get a really correct sound because after removing all the obvious flaws I am getting into the territory of the quality of the recording itself. maybe if I were to listen only to perfectly mastered recordings it would be worth it, but since almost all recording have different flaws, it is impossible. (i guess that is a topic which should be fixed in software in the future -to automatically correct bad mastering). so to me a priority would be to get a neutral sound, without obvious flaws, and then choose headphone according to other qualities. for example if I could get good sound out of airpods pro that would be great because other features such as transparency/anc makes it worth-while. also if HD800S could have good sound maybe it would be worth to buy because everyone praises their spaciness and sound stage.

Barton

I wasn't expecting miracles, just that you might be able to squeeze a bit more out of them thanks to all the experience. You have proven countless times that you are a wizard and you can achieve the unachievable. :)

David Zecua

I had recently picked up an Earfun Uboom L and overall, I'm quite impressed, however, I had also gotten a Sony XB33, but it had intermodulation past 60%, I'm not sure if that's normal? As it's even more intermodulation than the XB30 in my experience.

MMMM

Olaf, you are doing an amazing job, seriously! I really love the Uboom L, and it's thanks to your tuning! I have the latest firmware. I have two of them and they differ in sound, but that's ok, it's a 60 dollar speaker, I don't expect it to have consistency in every aspect of sound. The more expensive stuff have better quality control, they check the resonance of the speaker, and if not within spec it gets recycled or something. So you should take that into account next time. I hope this helps. If we talk about the microphones, and headphones, again there's so much variables that one just can't find the perfect solution, it's me saying this a second time to you, because I want you to feel better. We aren't perfect, so it's not possible to make something perfect as well, but we can try to deliver the best of our possibilities. We are here to support you, we can do that also by monthly donations, or words of encouragement. Don't neglect your other good things in life, like family for example. I'm sure you are doing your best in every regard. Keep it up man. I myself when I had lots of free time, I would EQ my headphones to the limits. I know how it's like. I liked pink noise, but as you probably know, the sound we perceive is constantly changing as it adapts, so in the end some deep bass thing comes out of it, so it's important to let the ears rest too, and be rested. Even when I was ill, I couldn't manage to make things decent. Anyways, I hope you don't feel bad, depressed, or something along those lines my friend.

RODOLFO ALEXIS HUERTA SANCHEZ

you are the best oluv!!! Be proud of yourself, thanks to you, many people are happy to have a loudspeaker that is unsurpassed in all aspects. Life is about this: if you stumble and fall you will get up stronger, you will walk stronger and you will want to get ahead. Greetings from Peru.

Cristian Guiducci

Ciao olufs forza e coraggio! Spero che qualcuno ti faccia parte di un bel progetto di tuning, ma non sottovalutare mai il tuo lavoro, ho diversi amici che ascoltano ottima musica grazie ai tuoi video. Ti seguo dai tempi di klavinet junkie!