Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Content

Thanks to Patron Matthew for requesting this David Lynch classic!

You will need your own copy of the movie to follow along.

Files

Previews only

Comments

JAQuinn623

Fred's house was actually David's house IRL. He was inspired by the OJ Simpson trial, in part, for this story. The Mystery Man to me is the embodiment of "the ugly truth", which includes Fred's murder, his inability to satisfy, and towards the end it extends to Dick Laurent's snuff porn exploitations. Other parts of the film seem to me like David's own experiences, mostly bad, with hollywood. I think you got the idea of Fred transforming into Pete to try to escape his fate and fantasize all those things while he was medicated for his migraine before getting zapped in the chair. "Psychogenic fugue" was the key phrase, as well as Fred's spoken line "I like to remember things my own way, not necessarily the way they happened"

JAQuinn623

Good catch on seeing the dog from Pete's perspective that Fred could only imagine

JAQuinn623

What are you to gleam from the road rage incident? Probably what Lynch wanted to do last time that happened to him, but he's too forgiving

JAQuinn623

Alice saying "I have to call myself" is a mixed up version of the scene where Fred first meets the Mystery Man. Even the way Alice approaches Pete in that scene and smiles is exactly the same as the Mystery Man encounter

JAQuinn623

I think the detectives were supposed to be clueless. At least, they came off that way. And after seeing the laughably clueless detectives in The Return, I feel more confident in my assumption. "guy gets more pussy than a toilet seat" makes zero sense, and neither does their closing remark about "no such thing as a bad coincidence". It's a total non-sequitur. You can't make sense of an impossible scenario like that where they still can't believe Pete's prints are there while we know that Fred is back in form.

JAQuinn623

Thanks for your reaction and sorry if this is spammy. You caught some great details and I enjoyed seeing you experience the twists and turns for the first time. In closing, a new detail I found interesting was they made it a point to show Alice having Pete have the gun in his pants, then Fred as well as the Mystery Man also did that. This sort of teamup seems like It's Fred trying to put the pieces back together as a coping mechanism. Everything had to be justified, I mean, look how evil Dick was! Did the Mystery Man condemn him to an endless cycle of hell? If the three identities coalesced into one in the end, then Fred condemned himself. Inland Empire and The Return follow a similar climax structure.

Reel Food

I like to remember things my own way!!! I totally forgot about that line and it ties everything together!

Reel Food

Not spammy at all! I loved reading your comments - they helped me process all the chaos I just witnessed!

Donald Baillie

This film came after Fire Walk With Me. Having been initially disappointed with FWWM I definitely felt like Lost Highway was the Twin Peaks film I had really wanted, for all the reasons you noticed, the doubles, the reality-bending multiple worlds, the morally ambiguous supernatural elements. I'm sure the mystery man could come straight out of the Black Lodge. And certainly FWWM marked a major turn in Lynch's work. Before that all his films had been weird, certainly, but had all mostly had a linear narrative and had, at least superficially, taken place in a single, identifiable world, or diegesis, as film theorists say. From FWWM onwards, nothing he did was like that (except The Straight Story). I think you make sense of this well. One thing I find interesting is that the pale man/mystery man, no matter how creepy he seems, is not presented as positively evil. His menace is directed, after all, first at a man who (seemingly, probably) murdered his wife, and second at a brutal gangster. So does he represent Fred's guilty conscience, or some sort of avenging spirit? And although the film seems like a loop, it might be more of a spiral. Someone once told me that it's not Bill Pullman's voice that says "Dick Laurent is dead" at the beginning, but Robert Loggia (Mr Eddy). Listening back again now, it's hard to be sure, but if that's true it makes things more complicated again. Co-writer Barry Gifford also wrote the novel Wild At Heart, which Lynch adapted as a film while Twin Peaks was also happening, and that was such a rewarding experience that they worked together again to create this original work. And, this was Jack Nance's final film and he sadly died shortly afterwards.

Liam Deeley

Lynch said LH was inspired by O.J. Simpson. It made him wonder how someone could kill their wife and then just pick up and move on and act like everything is normal. Also David Lynch hates tailgating.

Hammer

Were those....special brownies?

Nathan Bishop

I feel like Lost Highway is actually pretty straightforward. Lynch saw O.J. Simpson playing golf and smiling after the murders, so Lynch became curious about how people are able to disconnect and create alternate realities in their minds in order to escape their own feelings of guilt. And Fred even says, "I like to remember things my way, not necessarily how they happened." I think we are in Fred's mind from the very beginning of the movie. I think many of the scenes are accurate memories of what happened, many scenes are complete figments of Fred's imagination (especially when he changed his identity to Pete), and many scenes are combinations of the two, where real events are altered so that Fred can remember them in the way that he wants to remember them. And despite Fred's best efforts, many parts of his psyche keep attempting to make him accept the horrible reality of what he has done. So from the start, Fred is in his jail cell, and we get to experience his thoughts. He's thinking about recent memories with his wife, and probably trying to alter those memories. I think a lot of what we see between Fred and Renee are real memories, but we see many added elements - such as the video tapes and the Mystery Man. These added elements are Fred's guilty conscience trying to make him accept the horrible truth of what he did. And I think Fred does accept the truth for a little while, which makes him snap back to reality, and he remembers being arrested, interrogated, sentenced and imprisoned. But then Fred eventually comes up with a stronger method of disconnecting from himself and his guilt by concocting a more elaborate fantasy world where he's a completely different person (Pete). I think the "Mystery Man" is Fred's Dark Passenger, which is a combination of Fred's murderous desires and his guilt. And the Mystery Man came into existence when Fred first learned about Renee's shady past involving Dick Laurent and Andy, which caused Fred to start having thoughts about murdering all of them. That's when he "invited" the Mystery Man into his home. And if Fred's perspective is to be believed, Renee was still sleeping with Dick Laurent and possibly Andy, but that could just be Fred's paranoia and insecurity altering the memories and making it seem like she was being unfaithful to him, which in his mind would justify the murders. And throughout the movie, the Mystery Man keeps showing up, trying to remind Fred of the truth - especially in that scene where he's holding the camera up to Fred. And someone like Fred obviously hates cameras and video tapes, since they plainly show things for how they really are. And I feel like Fred may have found out about Renee's past by coming across one of her pornographic video tapes, which further explains his aversion to video tapes. And we get many glimpses of reality in Fred's made-up world, especially about why he felt the need to kill Renee. To me, it boils down to Renee having a sketchy past where she made pornography with Dick Laurent, Andy and others. And when Fred found out, he became insanely jealous and also maybe felt inadequate. And what really drove Fred over the edge was when he wasn't able to perform sexually (likely due to the feelings of jealousy and inadequacy) and Renee patted him on the back saying "it's okay", which Fred likely found to be very condescending and disrespectful. And it's right after that unpleasant experience that Fred describes a dream to Renee where she was in his home, but she wasn't herself, which is Fred's way of saying that he doesn't know who Renee is anymore after learning about her past. And we see Fred's POV in the dream where he was about to kill this "doppelganger" of Renee, and that point is demonstrated further when the the face of the Mystery Man (Fred's murderous side) shows up over Renee's face. Fred is just a very insecure and jealous man, and he couldn't handle feeling inadequate and disrespected. Men usually have a strong need to be respected for their abilities, which is also why I think Fred chose a mechanic as his new identity in his fantasy world, since mechanics are known for fixing problems. And that's why Fred's fantasy world also involves Alice (Renee) needing Pete's (Fred's) help to escape this "underground pornography" life. And naturally in Fred's fantasy, Renee was forced into that lifestyle and wanted to escape it, as opposed to the alternative where she chose that lifestyle and enjoyed it. Fred would obviously rather believe the former. And since this is all in Fred's head, we see aspects of Fred in many of the characters - such as how Mr. Eddy being possessive of Alice reflects how Fred was possessive of Renee. And Pete's co-worker (played by Jack Nance) really wanted to keep the jazz music on the radio, because he has Fred's love of jazz. Of course, Pete / Fred is trying to live in this dream world and avoid anything that will remind him of reality, so that's why he wanted to turn off that jazz music. But many things cause Fred's fantasy world to collapse, such as when Pete's parents disappear after Pete talks to Mr. Eddy and the Mystery Man on the phone. And his fantasy world was really shattered when he kept desperately telling Alice / Renee that he wanted her, only for her to respond with, "You'll never have me." To me that's when Fred started to accept that Renee was dead, especially after Fred's Dark Passenger told him to stop this nonsense about "Alice" and "Pete". Then I think we just got a flashback of the night that Fred and his Dark Passenger killed Dick Laurent, because killers like to mentally relive their kills. And Fred reporting Dick's death to himself through the intercom is just showing us Fred's ability to disconnect and compartmentalize, where it was the Dark-Passenger-possessed Fred reporting Dick's death to "normal" Fred. And I'm thinking that Fred regrets not killing Andy too, which is why Andy dies in a horrible way in Fred's fantasy. And I think that Alice being so cold and cruel near the end of the movie is due to Fred's subconscious trying to blame Renee for everything that has gone wrong. I'm sure that's also why we hear "Song to the Siren" many times in this movie, because Fred sees Renee as the "Siren" who lured him to his demise with her song. Along with the Mystery Man, I think the police officers in Fred's fantasy also serve the purpose of making Fred see the truth - such as when the police officers recognized "Mr. Eddy" and called him by his real name of Laurent. And the officers also visited the scene of Andy's death and they saw the real picture of Dick Laurent, Andy and Renee (without Alice). At the end of the movie, Fred is still living in his mind, even after accepting many truths and becoming himself again. But in his mind he was still running away from his guilt and avoiding responsibility and accountability for what he had done. So the movie ends with him fantasizing about evading the police, but in reality he was already strapped in the electric chair, and we see him receive the justice he deserved.