Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Videos

  • 546376960.mp4

Downloads

Content

In this episode I sat down with chemistry educator and pseudoscience debunker Dave Farina of the popular YouTube channel Professor Dave explains. We discuss the threat of disinformation, how to promote truth while reducing radicalization and polarization, wokescold-edgelord dialectics, and the rhetoric of pOwning with facts and logic.

NOTE: The video is having an issue processing, give it a minute

Professor Dave Explains YouTube channel

The Alt-Right Has Its Very Own TV Show On Adult Swim - Joseph Bernstein

Joseph Bernstein and Sam Hyde attempting to assert dominance over one another

FIRST PERSON: The Smartest Man in the World

Files

Comments

Meek

Hamilton, I just saw in a comment you expressed interest in speaking with Prof. Andy Letcher, he is my tutor currently, if you wanted any help making his acquaintance I would be happy to speak to him.

Alejandro C.

Goshh, i'll pass on this. Dave is one of the few youtubers that I just can't stand due to his toxic pedantism and condescending tone of a 12yo nerd telling someone else they got something wrong lol. There are ways of debunking without toxicity or attacking your opponent's character instead of just presenting counterclaims.

Austinn

this comment ain’t it

Alejandro C.

I'm far from the one thinking the same, even after having forgotten him for over a year, some other people pick up at him. https://youtu.be/nc-oCJd9crI If you like "edgy teenage" vibes from your content, you do you. I personally don't like that vibe.

Shtyx 'n' Shtoda

First channel 5... Now proffessor dave?!??!?!? So many of my idols working together!!

Alejandro C.

@Shtyx'n'Shtoda And you sound like Dave's alumni. Learn to argue your points without being toxic and going ad-hominem.

Shtyx 'n' Shtoda

Get off ur high school English high horse mr ad hominem lol. Get an education instead of whining about people who debunk ppl like ur stupid ass.(ad-hominem does not make an argument invalid fool.

Alejandro C.

And the guy doubles down..... proceeds to insult, and spread bs. Let me give you a lesson so you don't make a fool of yourself again: An ad hominem doesn't make a premise false—that would be a fallacy in itself. But, an ad hominem does make the argument invalid because attacking the person instead of addressing their points means you haven't actually provided reasoning for your position and lower your debating to a 6yo's "ur idea is wrong because you're stupid", even if the idea happens to be wrong, the argument itself is invalid—'you're stupid' gives no reason to reject the idea. You've simply avoided engaging with the actual argument and tried to offend a person. In a genuine human cultured discussion, we try to evaluate ideas based on evidence and reasoning, not on the character of who's presenting them . When you resort to ad hominems, you're deflecting the conversation and just trying win the public instead of the truth. You have to explain why the argument is flawed, not why the person is flawed because of their argument. Otherwise you just show yourself as a buffon, and just a regular AH. Like Destiny, or Dave (he could be a normal person as most of his points are ok and he does his research, but that edgy teenage redditor attitude...)

Joshua Landry

IMO it would still be worth listening to this podcast, as Dave's affect is calm/respectful here talking to Hamilton and they essentially examine the exact point you just made in philosophical way - does hostility help? what DOES help when talking about important issues? what should we be doing?

Kaleb

Sarcasm?

Dashiell

I love the diversity of your guests hamilton... It seems like you might be one of the few in this community fighting for actual truth and science. Much appreciated

480billion (edited)

Comment edits

2026-09-06 06:00 Thank you so much Hamilton for featuring Dave. This is so important! I am so sick and tired of the Anti-Science and / or Quackery being blasted to the masses. It is crazy dangerous what is happening. The owner class wants us completely clueless. This must be fought.
2025-10-11 14:18

Hamilton Morris

Yeah, I'd love to interview him. Emailed him a long time ago (probably over 15 years ago) and never heard back.

M

Love professor Dave.

M

Funny you say that. Since you're attacking Dave's character and not what he's presenting. 🤔

M

Woo!!

cam williams

Professor Dave videos are a tough watch nowadays… even when he’s making a legit point, his tone is an unbearable mix of “erm actually…” & crybullying. Loved his flat earth era, but it’s become more grating & abrasive since that arc

Alejandro C.

@M I´m giving my personal opinion on his toxic way of presenting his videos. If i were talking with him or arguing with his points, that would be a fallacy. @Joshua Landry, oh thanks, in that case would probably give it a try sometime in the future. Altho I'll be very sensitive for the first sign of hypocrisy lol.

Meek

I will speak to him this week and see what I can do, I think you posted your email in a chat earlier I can give him that but I’ll reply here and let you know if he is keen.

Mateo

Thank you Hamilton!! Professor Dave and yourself are some my favorite people to listen to the last couple of years

brendan leier

Looking forward to this, mostly because I find him to be condescending and dismissive in his videos - often failing to capture the sense of legitimate criticisms of the process of evidence creation in science itself.

thankfulfor (edited)

Comment edits

2026-09-06 06:00 I am a walking example of a person of whom was appealed to by Professor Dave. I am a 21 year old man from syracuse New York. Professor Dave's tactics gave me the shift in perception required to build intellectual confidence and self reliance. I am not a scientist, but a composer. I waned to encorporate pseudoscience (and elements of the occult/chaos magick/Psychedlic Pseudophilosophy) into my artistic expression *Sarcastically* as a sort of metacritique, but ended up going down borderline delusional rabbit holes. I have a mood disorder, and this tends to happen to me on occasion. but Professor Dave gave me a consistent, grounded set of real intellectual mechanisms that have sort of psychically shielded me since November 2024, where I experienced a psychotic episode where I believed i was being controlled by a demonic entity. I pursued professional help, but during that time I was met with a very real moral dillema, should I incorporate "Infohazards" such as disinformation in my art if I'm easily prey to them? Even if its in an effort to criticize and satirize? Well I decided to go along with it, with Professor Dave giving me a real set of tools to navigate the world of disinformation ethically, and teaching me how to genuinely seek out the truth, so I can then deconstruct cultural lies from the inside. I now understand, after a few months of therapy and a microdose, that that demon was in fact a projection of my perpetual sense of lack of control, on all conceptual scales. Ranging from my sense of place in the universe, all the way down to the inconsistency of my neurochemical patterns. I came to this conclusion after realizing I should apply the same logical breakdowns of character that Professor Dave uses on people like James Tour to MYSELF. Not calling Dave a therapist under any sense of the word, I was just very intellectually moved by his character. I have been a fan of both You (Hamilton) since I was 16 years old, only finding Dave rather recently. this collaboration was truly delightful, as both of you have contributed to that sort of Pyshcological and Intellectual toolbox I've seen myself as constructing since I was 16 years old. Godspeed to the both of you.
2025-10-13 03:49

n8raid

I recognize talk is cheap, but I feel like this conversation really helped crystalize (not in ice) my thoughts on becoming a science communicator of sorts. I watched the debate Dave mentioned and was continually blown away at the underlying story that unraveled of the man Pierre Cory, who I hadn't previously known. We live in such a tangled world, I'd like to participate in the unraveling that you two do such good work on! Thanks for this conversation.

E Lee

Love professor Dave

The-DextroMethOrphan

On the topic of trump fascism and Christo-fascism. I'm looking for a country I can move to with my wife to further my chemistry knowledge. I am desperate to get out of here, somewhere I can be safe and be able to learn, does anyone here have any advice? I don't want to get stuck in debt to a school when I am forced to flee this country, and I'm just a 30 year old white dude. I'm trying to find a country with socialized medicine and low cost of living. Or any country that takes foreign students where I can get healthcare/education without crippling debt.

Eli Gaultney

I empathize with the pain. I lived in Vietnam for many years and while it is cheap, has solid socialized medicine, and is explicitly atheist it's also way more fascist and anti-drug than the US. I've known a lot of expats from all over the world and there's no silver bullet country that will fit all your requirements, unfortunately. The best way to get what you want is to get rich, imho. And the best country to get rich in...the US. Maybe somewhere like Norway or Finland would be worth a look though, if you really can't stomach the US.

Thomas Lappin

At the beginning of the month here in Kansas, our attorney general effectively outlawed sale and possession of delta 8, thcp, all the analogs that aren't strictly delta 9 thc, and a lot of the places that sold those are also taking mushroom gummies, anything that resembles psychedelics etc. (even blue lotus) off the shelves because they just don't know what the police will permit. They did a bunch of raids around the state without a warning and arrested several people. This was really disappointing and got me pissed off so I printed off a bunch of these little cards with the title "Educational Psychedelic Resources," and it's a reading/watch list including Shroomery.org, Erowid, Hamilton's Pharmacopeia, Total Synthesis, Org chem as a 2nd language, psychedelic chemistry, and a few others just hoping it'd reach the right people to generally just get them involved in thinking about drug advocacy, tuning into the dialogue and community, and have them maintain hope. and to a small minority, empower them to explore or even find a passion in chemistry

Thomas Lappin

the majority of people ive given it to have been really excited about it and have ended up at least checking out Pharmacopeia. im wanting to edit it or make a second edition, what do you think should be added that could either be appealing to random ordinary vape store customers, or to academics or even chemistry majors (im in a university town)?

Eli Gaultney

Never heard of this guy before today, but found the pod very interesting. I think I tend to disagree with the *degree* to which he suggests evil intuition on to people like Musk, Bezos, Zuck, Peterson, etc.; I legitimately think they want to make people happy and help the world while also padding their pockets as a reward for that contribution. But I definitely feel like I've got some homework. Either I've missed some stuff (likely) or maybe he's a bit extreme and inflexible with his own views (plausible, based on my own anecdotal experiences with academics). I was particularly surprised by the criticism of Sabine. She's always seemed to be scientifically literate and welcoming of criticism. She clearly (imho) presents opinion as opinion, fact as fact, and I find her evidence compelling...unless she's faked the letters she's shared on air, which would be pretty insane. Excited to watch Dave's criticism of her! Per RFK, I've heard from multiple sources that the people he's firing were the same ones who had the "RESIST" posters up in their offices during Trump's first campaign, and they're intractable and refusing to work with him. This is including direct contacts in the CDC, which I'm told was heavily ideologically captured. I find this completely plausible, at the same time as I can also believe there's some cronyism leading to friends getting appointments. And universities are _clearly_ overwhelmingly subscribing to one political party's ideology. We have the campaign contributions and plenty of surveys to confirm the fact they're not encouraging diversity of thought in their current form. At the end of the day...I find it so difficult to know who to believe on all these issues. And I'm definitely less inclined to trust the person who appears angry instead of calm and rational. I think generally people think less clearly when overwhelmed by emotion. P.S. I will put real money on the line that Trump will step down at the end of his term if someone wants to bet.

Eli Gaultney

yeah he very much has the "well if you don't believe what I'm believe you are wrong" vibe that doesn't seem like it lends itself to great science. or at least, great science communication.

Meek

I have emailed you at hamiltonsresearch@gmail his university email address. He is very keen!

The-DextroMethOrphan

I love this community. It really makes such a large world seem much more accessible since so many people interested in the same things are here together communicating.

Cheminterested

Having been to several universities, I found it to be very inclusive and open to all perspectives. I took a class called Sociology of Race and Racism while at Temple University in 1995. Temple has a large number African American students. The class was open to discussion and while many of the student who had grown up in urban areas had similar views on race and racism, some where white kids from the burbs who did not hold the same views. They got a chance to ask questions and express their views like everyone else and we all engaged in debate over the issues. No one was shut down or told their perspective was wrong. I can honestly say that class changed the way I see the world and has made me a better person. Did you ever think that the reason why people with more education tend to lean left is not because of some sort of indoctrination that takes place at universities, but rather the acquired skill of critical thinking, a better understanding of history, and having been exposed to many people from different walks of life while at university? Maybe it's not universities indoctrinating people into being lefties, but rather education allowing people to see through the bullshit on the right?

Cheminterested

Same. My wife is from the UK and has dual citizenship, so the easiest escape plan for us is the UK. We were Just there on vacation and I can honestly say, it just feel like a better country. It's hard to explain it, but things are just planned better. Even little things just seem more well designed. Hard to explain. Anyway, that would be the easiest option for us. Unfortunately they pay about half or less for my career as they do here in the states. I have a really great job here with a pension and 401k which is almost unheard of these days. I also have a lot of autonomy and work from home. Most days I don't even set an alarm I just wake up when my body tells me to which is often after 8am, and no one is yelling at me or giving me a hard time. As long as I get my work done no one cares and that is something I really value. I will say we have drawn some lines in the sand, and if things progress beyond them, then we will make the sacrifice and go. One of those is if the Trump party, let's call it what it is, starts ignoring election results.

Cheminterested

I wanted to share that i also came to a chemistry based degree by way of my love for drugs. In 2009 I was arrested for heroin possession and pled guilty for a felony charge for the promise of not going to prison. I got on methadone and got into treatment. 2 years later I was considering going back to school or possibly getting a certificate for welding. The reason I chose University and eventually decided to study chemical engineering was because of my love for drugs. Even though my addiction had almost killed me, I was and am still fascinated by the chemistry. Even at the darkest depths of my opiate addiction I would spend hours on Wikipedia going through information about different compounds, their receptor binding activities, and how they are synthesized. I had never been a good student in high-school and math and science were never my strong suits, but something told me I had innate ability to understand this stuff. So I ended up taking a degree in chemical engineering, and I loved it, especially organic chemistry. I also excelled in school in a way that I had never been able to accomplish when I was younger. I finished my bachelor's degree in chemical engineering with an almost perfect GPA. While I was taking organic I I found a website that had information to help students with organic chem, like pdfs with all basic organic reactions types that you learn in Orgo I and II. I reached out to the guy who ran the site and we ended up corresponding back and forth. At some point the conversation turned to drugs and he told me the reason he ended up taking a chemistry degree and eventually teaching organic synthesis was because of his love and fascination with drugs as well. I think many people end up on that path for the same reason. After I graduated, I took a job in process automation, and eventually made my way into pharma manufacturing and today I don't do anything remotely close to chemistry. My job is more akin to IT than chemistry. I miss it so much, but i was 40 when I graduated, with a felony conviction, and as a recovering heroin addict, so I took the job that would pay the most and be the most stable career because I didn't really have a choice. I was lucky anyone would even hire me with my record. If I had the money and luxury to have made different choices, I would definitely have studied organic synthesis or pharmacodynamics. Being in the lab and synthesizing compounds is truly high art.

Cheminterested

Do it. We desperately need more people who are willing to speak and fight for science. If you haven't read it, I highly recommend, Demom Haunted World" by Carl Sagan. He prophetically the world we are currently living in and we need people to push back against that world.

Cheminterested

There is an audio book version narrated by the man himself. He was one of the best science communicators way before we even had a word for it. One of my personal heroes

Cheminterested

That's an amazing story and a real ringing endorsement of his work

Cheminterested

I disagree. I think he is open to hearing anyone's ideas as long as they have some evidence to support them. That is after all the bar we set for anything in science

Cheminterested

If you like Dave, I highly recommend the book, " Demon Haunted World" by Carl Sagan. One of my personal heroes. The book is beyond prophetic in its predictions of where the world was headed and all misinformation, superstition, and belief in woowoo nonsense we see around us today. https://youtu.be/DWY260b0oew?si=virFcUaXb8iSsGH1 Also there is an audio book version narrated by the man himself. I really can't express how important this book is and what a huge impact it had on me. At a time when I had Just gotten off heroin and was susceptible to being influenced I found this book. Often people who are getting into recovery end up becoming very religious or spiritual. The 12 step programs often push people in this direction and, hey, if it saves your life, great. I was searching for something after I stopped using heroin and was considering things like Sufism. I even went to a mosque to speak to an Imam. In Islam if you can convert a non-believer it's like a guaranteed spot in heaven or some shit, so they ganged up on me and cornered me and basically peer pressured me into taking the Shahada, which is basically the prayer you say to become Muslim. I said it, just to get them to leave me alone, also I didn't really believe in it, so I figured, why not. So technically I think I'm a Muslim now. Haha. Anyway, not long after that I found this book, and it was like the answer to everything I was looking for. It made me realize I didn't need any of that stuff. I fell back in love with nature and science, started studying mushroom identification and taking long walks and enjoying the real world around me again. Not long after that I enrolled in a degree program for chemical engineering. This book opened my eyes to the bullshit and I'm so glad I found it when I did. Another great YouTube channel that breaks down charlatans and fraudsters is Framing Logic where he uses logic to explain the rhetorical methods being used by these people to try and convince you of their argument, and often separate you from your money https://youtu.be/tPAUPY2vhH0?si=EznuFsoLZCyarsNk

Cheminterested

I can understand that. Even in this interview he made a few statements that seemed pretty egotistical. i can also really feel his frustration and can only imagine how mad it must make him to watch the world around us frantically spin it's way into madness fueled by pseudoscience and superstition, while he attempts to be one of the few people who will stand up, speak up, and push back. I feel the level of anger myself and I'm not even a science communicator

Cheminterested

100% agree and we need more people willing to stand up and push back. Most scientists don't want to do this. They want to focus on the science they are trying to study. Its so important. I feel like climate change is such a huge area where science has Just completely failed to counter the bullshit being spread

Cheminterested

Considering how dangerous and serious the bullshit is that is being peddled these days, I think his attitude is pretty on the money.

Alejandro C.

Loudmouthing isn't a scientific approach, its an oratory one, and oratory is a dangerous thing to have among scientific circles as its a political tool designed to pull emotional strings, not scientific logic. If you're proving people what you know is correct and theirs not, you debunk each point and defend yours, it's something constructive from what everyone benefits, and the party thats in the wrong just corrects their course somewhere else. I don't see anything "dangerous and serious" in let's say "hypothetical/alternative history" dudes just day-dreaming scenarios (or some other fringe theoretical stuff born from ignorance or fear, as to deserve the disrespectful approach Dave has towards many in his videos), their ideas might be loony, but the approach allows "actual" historians/archeologists to review their own theories to fend off attacks from weird stuff these randoms find, and maybe one of these would actually matter at some point and force an actual academic to say "wait, wtf". It helps breaking up dogmas stifling scientific inquiry and allows to review things from young perspectives on stuff that somebody X decades ago might have missed or decided to ignore as irrelevant for their understanding at the time. The approach of "this shit is dangerous and deserves being ruthlessly destroyed" is the logic of the Holy Inquisition, not science.

Eli Gaultney

I totally believe that experience, and appreciate you sharing. I think the key point is that was 1995. I graduated in 2013, and also took a sociology class. I fell for everything they taught hook, line, and sinker because my professor was a lot smarter than me. I became a democrat not because I was thinking more critically but because I was well indoctrinated by adults who took advantage of easily swayed children. It took another decade before I saw the flaws in many of their arguments. To be fair, it wasn't all wrong, and I still believe some of what I learned in there today. The point is that even back then it was social suicide in my southern school to publicly espouse conservative views. I think this trend only increased, peaking sometime around 2023. And no, I don't think the reasons staff lean left today is because they're smarter and better educated. American schools used to be overwhelmingly conservative, and what we're seeing is a cultural shift. That theory just doesn't hold up when you look at enough data and scale. Heck, less than 100 years ago in the McCarthy era we had suspected communists being ousted from school. Today it's suspected conservatives who get ousted. To be clear, I'm about as centrist as they come. I hit the bullseye center on every political spectrum test I take. I think both sides have good ideas and the push/pull is good for the country. I also, therefore, feel well-placed to call out the bias I see.

Meek

I definitely cna credit Hamilton and this community for motivating a healthy pursuit of knowledge in me. I think it is likely I wouldn’t have ended up pursuing an academic route in psychedelics if I never found this work!

Cheminterested

I've made several attempts at a degree, so I have been to university probably 5 times in my life. The last, and the one that was actually successful with, I graduated from in 2017. Again, while taking the social science classes, I did not experience anything like indoctrination. In fact one of my professors was an ex Israeli military officer who held some pretty far right views. No one seemed to be trying to oust him. I'm genuinely curious, as a centrists, what about the right wing in this country do you think are good ideas? I'm legitimately not trying to attack you. I just don't often get the chance to speak to someone who is an actual swing voter and ask them what would make them vote for the right in this country.

Cheminterested

Sorry, I'm honestly trying to follow and understand what you're saying. Are you referring to Graham Hancock when tou reference the "alternative history theories"?

Eli Gaultney

Okay, that's awesome, glad you had a more diverse experience. I'm sure there are still pocket of it, at the very least. I was an educator for some time myself and still have many friends employed in universities and they all repeat the sentiment about lack of diversity in opinions in their schools. Most of them quite like it, to be fair. It's comforting being surrounded by people who tell you you're right. I lost a bunch of college friends when I voted Trump in the last election (this after years of voting straight blue down the ticket). They hadn't updated their views one bit as far as I can tell, with that same mindset that "we don't even talk to people who believe the wrong thing" that I find very troubling. I firmly believe civil conversations like ours is how the country heals. I also firmly believe we have more in common than not, and that most of us are actually pitted against the uniparty that dominates politics more than being left vs right. I think the most recent hot-button items the right has gotten it right with are immigration and crime. It's good to take dangerous people off the streets, and it's bad to let people into the country without some vetting. I'm also married to an immigrant; I still think we have lot of work to do making *legal* immigration easier, but I know of nobody who hates illegal immigration more than legal immigrants like my wife and her peers who groveled before the state to do things the right way.

J

Dave has a serious flaw when talking about wealth. There is no such thing as a limited supply of money, dollars. It's infinite. It is not a zero sum game. And this is a very common flaw with those on the left when it comes to economic understanding.

Cheminterested

I agree on the idea that we need to make it easier for people who have something to contribute to get citizenship. I also think there should be some level of vetting to see what that person will contribute once they are here. I dont think everyone needs to be a PhD or programmer, I think most people have something to contribute, but we need to make sure they are not going to be a drain on resources. I also think that some degree of work needs to be done to help people assimilate once they are here. The thing I dont get is that, it's clearly not just dangerous people being locked up. In fact, it seems the majority of them are just people who want to be here to have better opportunities. Just curious how you feel about that. It seems that he is using his ICE squads and national gaurd as more of threat to get people to fall in line. The other thing I never hear people on the right talk about is the enormous inequity in the distribution of wealth in this country. I hear a lot of people complain about poor folks and immigrants getting hand outs, yet no one seems concerned with the billionaire class who get much more in terms of the total number of dollars when you consider back taxes, tax evasion, and subsidies for their corporations. In my eyes, what Trump is doing is the oldest trick in the book for strong men and authoritarian, which is to have people focus on a minority group to blame all their financial problems on, while he and his buddies stuff their pockets. This is the part i dont understand how no one seems to notice or be outraged about. The trump family is literally grifting the US with crypto, sneakers, phones, free planes, real estate deals with Arab countries, I mean the list is endless. Yet, we are lead to believe that immigrants are the problem.

Eli Gaultney

> it's clearly not just dangerous people being locked up I assume you're talking about the ICE arrests, people who overstayed their visas, that kind of stuff? I agree with you that he's using it as a fear tactic to get people to "fall in line", and specifically to self-deport. And it does seem to be working. Lots of people are leaving on their own which I think is net positive. I hate the image of kids in zipties and grandfathers woken up at 2AM in a raid, but I struggle to see how we would correct this issue without tears. I tend to blame the people who caused the problem more than the people who are cleaning it up. > I never hear people on the right talk about [...] the enormous inequity in [...] wealth I think the general feeling on the right is that smarter, higher performing people who provide the most value to the most people should be awarded accordingly. Elon is my favorite example -- I use Starlink and X daily. I know so many people who benefit from his products; it makes sense to me that he gets rewarded with a lot of money versus the bum down the street who just panhandles all day. There are exceptions to this, and we can nitpick examples if you want. At any rate, I'm down to have higher tax rates for billionaires, just like most of the billionaires whose opinions I seem to agree with (including Elon). I could write pages on this topic and the nuance around it...trying my hardest to be concise here though. > the trump family is literally grifting the US with crypto, sneakers [...] yet, we are lead to believe that immigrants are the problem I don't get that vibe on the right actually. Most of them roll their eyes or laugh about the grifty stuff, (which I agree is grifty), but I don't see immigrants being blamed for all our problems. Public spending overseas is a much bigger issue for those on the right I talk to. Billions to Ukraine and Israel. The views you shared at the top about how you feel about immigration reflect the majority of those on the right (and left) that I speak to, actually. Some vetting necessary, but it should be easier for decent folks to get over here and contribute/pay taxes. Bottom line, there are a lot of dumb people on both sides and you can find plenty of examples of bad arguments, and I think if you tend to like one kind of content on social media instead of the other you'll be presented primarily with the worst arguments of the side you don't agree with. My hypothesis is that if you can find the best arguments from both sides you'll find A) the majority of people are quite close in their goals B) one's own views won't fall nearly as neatly into one camp or the other. If you only get exposed to worst the arguments of one side of course you'll think they're all idiots and their views are atrocious. Great convo, appreciate hearing your thoughts. I'll definitely be keeping an ear to the ground around anti-immigrant sentiment to see if I'm underestimating the degree of it on the right!

Cheminterested

Yeah, I'm not saying that people who are talented and smart shouldn't be rewarded, though I think there is a discussion to be had about who is actually talented and who was simply born rich, but what I'm actually concerned with is not just having them pay higher taxes, which the republican, and many wealthy democrats, have rejected over and over (in fact trumps tax cut are very disproportionate in terms of cuts for the wealthy versus the middle class). Im talking about the tax loop holes that allow them to pay almost zero in taxes, as well as back taxes which they simply have not paid. A quick AI query asking how much the top 1% in the US owe in unpaid taxes gives the following, "Estimates vary, but a key report from the US Treasury Department suggests the wealthiest 1% of Americans are responsible for around $163 billion in unpaid taxes each year." That's a lot of money, especially when you consider the way they can manipulate the tax system to pay almost nothing to begin with. The fact is that the top 1% in this country owns about 30% of all the wealth, while the bottom 50% owns 3%. That's a massive inequality. I dont see many billionaires complaining about this, with the exception of many Buffet and Soros. Elon Musk has not said that the top 1% should pay more in taxes. In fact, he has publicly opposed and criticized proposals to increase taxes on billionaires. He has also gutted every regulatory body that would have possibly been a check to his power or scrutinized the government contracts that he has with his many companies. He and people like Thiel, have a singular goal, and that is to aquire more wealth, even though the levels of wealth they already have is unimaginable for more common Americans.

Cheminterested

You dont see immigrants being blamed for peoples problems? This is literally the core message Trump used to win the election. Have you watched any of the election rallies or interviews with the die hard Trump cultists? I agree, people who overstay their visa or came here illegally should not get a free pass, but to say you dont see how this can be corrected without tears is a bit strange since you already mentioned immigration reform to give people an easier path to citizenship. Beyond that, my biggest problem with the way things are being done is the total lack of due process. Habeas Corpus is one of the foundational principles our legal system is built on. They are taking people from their homes, putting them on planes and sending them to a literal concentration camp in a foreign country, or if you're lucky shipping you off to some country from which you never came like an African nation. No court hearing, no ability to argue your case, no due process. They can just see a tattoo, claim you have gang affiliations and ship you off to a prison you will never get out of. If you watch that, and it doesn't chill you to your core, then we dont have the same principles. What makes you think they won't use that same tactic on you one day when they decide you have done something they dont like?

Cheminterested

They took a gay makeup artist from Venezuelan who had left the country because he feared for his life over threats from homophobes, and sent him to a prison, really a concentration camp, in El Salvador, where people are forbidden from any outside contact and never leave. They did this because they said his tattoos were gang affiliations, but in reality they were tattoos about a Catholic holiday celebrated in his home town. The three kings celebration is a catholic called the Epiphany. He had three crowns to symbolize the holiday because he loved dressing up for it when he was a child. They took a gay man, and sent him to a concentration camp with some of the worst criminals in the world. I can't imagine how terrifying that must have been. Luckily, due to public outrage, he was released, but was still sent back to the country he fled because he feared for his life. And that's just the ones we hear about because they have family in the US that can reach out you the media and gain public attention. Again this is the authoritarian play book 101. In times of great financial strain (created by the ultra wealthy to begin with) people will turn toward authoritarian leaders in the hopes they can solve their problems. Instead of identifying the real problem, which is a corrupt political system run by the wealthy for the wealthy, and corporate greed and manipulation, the strong man blames a minority group for everyone's problems. While his followers are focused on that group, he and his wealthy buddies stuff their pockets, while at the same time silencing any opposing voices. Why do you think academics and journalists are always the first to be targeted when an authoritarian takes over a country?

Cheminterested

I know this is a long messag for a comment section on a podcast video, but you seem like an intelligent person, and it really boggles my mind when I meet intelligent people who seem to be unable to see what is happening directly in front of them with this Trump regime. If you look at authoritarian take overs of other countries throughout history, every single thing he is doing tracks. We are on our way to being Belarus or Hungary in the very near future if people like you dont start to see what is happening. I have no hope for the MAGA cultists, they will never stop supporting him. He said it himself he could shoot someone in broad daylight and they wouldn't care. And now he is on his way to doing just that. But someone like yourself I think is worth talking to, because clearly this is not the way you have been aligned your whole life

Fred P

Yeah, I don't realy vibe with this guy. He has good points but seems too rigid in his approach, which is fine, but didn't really get anything from this interview with him. I know where he stands and his takes but he offers no real wider insight on other topics here. I like how you get different people on the podcast though, all good, but this one was not for me and thats fine. :)

MrRoboto

Absolutely love that you've chosen to interview Dave, glad you've taken the time to talk to this man.. regardless of any of his views.

MrRoboto

Thank you for this. I'm only 22 right now, but I seriously resonate with your story. I've not long been off heroin, still with the occasional relapse.. I'm fairly sure some of the other things you've spoken about are yet to occur, though I won't get into that. I'm not the sharpest tool in the shed, but again.. I really do feel a drive.. want and need to understand and contribute to the world that has taken so much from me.. but inspired me, and shown me so much love, joy, wonder, warmth, and understanding. I wonder where I'll be in 18 years.. or 32- there's not much more I can say than that. Thank you so much, it's so incredibly therapeutic to know that there are people in the world with such a profound amount of similarity.

Cheminterested

Hey, im glad you like it. I hope the best for you. Honestly the thing that really saved my life was methadone. I know a lot of people shit on methadone, but I found it to be really helpful. The one time I tried to relapse and shoot up while I was on it, it totally blocked the high, and I got nothing. I liked the structure. Yeah, having to get up every morning and go to the clinic to get my dose sucked at first, but I met other people there who were really trying to change their lives and I found community. The requirements of individual therapy, group therapy, and daily dosing as well as random drug screenings really gave my life the structure it had not had in a long time. Its important to find a good clinic though. Many are just pushing higher doses, and want to keep you there so they can make money off you. Many also allow dealers to stand outside the dosing exit door and give out samples of dope. I stayed away from the clinics in the city and went to one in the burbs where I grew up. It wasn't close by, but I wojld rather have a long drive than deal with all the shit at the city clinics. The folks at my clinic actually gave a fuck about us. After a few months with clean urine, I earned a take home dose, then two, then three. Eventually I only had to go in once a week to get my meds, and therapy. I stayed on methadone for 5 years. My highest dose was 100mg, and then I started my taper about 3 years in. It took about 2 years to slowly taper down. I was Eventually down to 1ml, which is 10mg, and they can't take you any lower than that, because the machine cant dose below 1ml, so I would add 9ml of water, then dose myself accordingly so I could continue my taper down to 1mg, and eventually jump off. Below 20mg I recommend staying at a given dose for at least 2 months before you go lower to give you body time to adjust. Above 20mg, you can cut down pretty quick. Everyone is different, but I found after 3 years at around 80mg, 20mg was my floor where I had to really start taking the taper slow. Abive that I was dropping 5-10mg each month or so. But they should have a Dr on site you can work with and if it's a good clinic they will be able to guide you. For the anxiety ashwaganda is helpful. I still take 500mg now on occasion to help me sleep. Don't take too much, or for too long, it can have negative impact on your liver. Stay away from Kratom. I spent years taking powder, and tapered off several times, and honestly at lower doses the withdraw is noy bad, but it's just anothet thing to become dependent on and have to get off at some point. Some people find it really helpful, but some chase the euphoria and end up with massive daily doses, or end up on extracts or 7OH and then have a horrible time trying to get off it. The thing that really helped toward the end if my methadone taper was exercise. At such a low dose I was struggling with fatigue and I was in my junior year of my chemical engineering degree taking some of the most difficult courses, so I was really looking for something to help me with the minor withdraw symptoms. I found 30 mins of high intensity interval training on an elliptical really helped to get my natural endorphins up and I would feel better for a while after a workout. But you really need to push yourself to do it, because every fiber of your body is telling you to stay on the couch and sleep. The exercise habit has stayed with me and now I train with weights 5 days a week. I find it really helpful for my mental and physical health. Stay away from the street drugs man. Nothing out there these days is clean. Everything, even the pills that look like they are pharma, are tainted with fentanyl. I volunteer with a harm reduction coalition and we do drug testing with an FTIR machine and then follow up GC/MS confirmatory testing and I can tell you, everything has fentanyl in it. I'm glad I got out before that shit happened. I dont think I would be alive today if I had not. I've lost a lot of friends who relapsed after we went through treatment together. In fact, I dont think anyone i met and was friends with in recovery is still alive today. Be safe. If you're going to use, go get it tested. Find a local organization that does FTIR instant results testing. But I hope you decide to love yourself enough to stay away. I was 31 when I got arrested and started recovery and 33 when I started school. I didn't graduated until I was 40 years old, and that's when I started my career. Its never too late. Reach out to me if you need to talk

Eli Gaultney

Once again, I'm here for long conversations 😀 I think real change comes from long-form content, including conversations. Don't get me started on how bad shorts are for our political discourse—so many people getting riled up over a 30-second video with basically no context attached. :P I hear you on the tax cuts. I'd like to see those loopholes closed, too. Elon supports taxes up to 40% ([https://x.com/elonmusk/status/1009346561946480641](https://x.com/elonmusk/status/1009346561946480641)), but he also makes a fair point: even taxing every billionaire at 100% wouldn't really put a dent in the budget ([https://x.com/elonmusk/status/1616305844412649472](https://x.com/elonmusk/status/1616305844412649472)). I feel like if one is worried about our country's spending, the real solution has to be cuts at the federal level. Taxes just aren't enough. I do see immigrants blamed for some specific problems, sure, but the way I'm reading you, it sounds like you think that’s the underlying issue most or all of the blame is placed on—and that’s not what I’m hearing from the right. It’s one problem among many. Mostly, though, the non-whacko people on the right (which is the vast majority) think government spending, untrustworthy politicians, healthcare affordability, etc., are bigger problems that don’t have much to do with immigration. I want to reiterate, too, that die-hard Trump cultists are not representative of the majority of people on the right—just like violent Antifa protesters don't represent the majority of the left. Totally fair point about how we could potentially do some in-place immigration reform to avoid having to deport people. But we have to work with the laws that are currently in place first, and those laws make it fair to deport illegal immigrants. I just don't see any way to enforce _current_ law without a fair amount of pain. There are few things worse I could imagine than being ripped from your life and sent back to a hellhole. Interestingly, there's this great news source, Channel 5, that interviews a lot of these immigrants, and they're often like, "Well, it's fair play... I knew there was a risk." That's anecdotal, but a recurring theme. Channel 5 leans left, by the way. I've not seen evidence that people are being sent to a concentration camp. Maybe we have different definitions, though. I'm thinking of somewhere people are murdered by the state. How do you define it? I do think there are civil liberties issues under Trump—100%. I hate to see them, and I've been disappointed on that front, albeit not very surprised. I've also seen spine-chilling civil-liberties issues from the left (e.g., hate-speech laws), so it isn’t a partisan issue to me. If people are trying to take away liberties—whoever they are—it’s a bad thing and we should call it out. You're spot on about the approach: thinking about whether a tactic might be used by a different group than the one you support and end up hurting you. For some reason, our politicians always seem shortsighted about this stuff, like we don’t change control of the country every eight years or so. 🙄 I will say, for the example you shared (the makeup artist), I've heard so much conflicting information that I'm pretty agnostic on it. I've seen compelling evidence the guy was connected to crime, and other stories that make him sound worthy of sainthood. I'd guess the truth is somewhere in the middle. Interestingly, they interviewed him before release and he seemed fine—and he did get out. Overall, I can think of better examples if you want to make Trump look bad, like the Epstein files. Wtf is up with that?? I hear you on greed at the top, and I agree it's a major problem—maybe the root of all our problems. But people on both sides at the top are guilty of it. I get my stock picks from Nancy Pelosi. How many millions have Obama and the Clintons made for 30-minute talks since leaving office? I'd humbly suggest they want to divide us and keep half the population fighting the other half when instead it’s like 90% of us versus the powerful—regardless of political affiliation. Bottom line: most of the things you’re upset about, I agree with—as do most Americans. And while Trump has his unique issues, most of what you point to has copious examples from both left- and right-wing leadership: greed, curtailing of civil liberties, authoritarian actions. Which is why I find myself an independent these days.

RozoFN

If you actually look at the finances the Democratic Party has taken so much more money out of the private sector then the Republican Party lol,

Cheminterested

"Elon supports taxes up to 40%." His position on taxing the ultra wealthy varies, but he is opposed to a wealth tax, and one of the major ways the ultra wealthy manipulate the tax system is by taking loans against their portfolios and assets, which they never have to pay taxes on since loans proceeds are not considered taxable income. Warren proposed a wealth tax that would force them to pay taxes on net worth above 50 million. He opposed that. "he also makes a fair point: even taxing every billionaire at 100% it wouldn't put a dent in deficit. " While it may not close the deficit, it would still be a decent start. A progressive tax bill for the ultra wealthy could generate up to 2% of GDP, and that isn't taking into account a wealth tax on their net worth. Also, you didn't seem to address the back taxes that are unpaid by the 1%. That's number is around 160 billion each year, and that is without any increase in their taxes. "I feel like if one is worried about our country's spending, the real solution has to be cuts at the federal level. Taxes just aren't enough." That's may be true, but military spending far out weighs any other the other departments, yet the cuts that Trump has made have been to other areas while military spending has increased under Trump. I see all the talk about wanting to reduce spending as a red herring. I don't think they give a shit about spending, if they did they would address the military spending. They simply want to gut regulatory bodies so they can get away with things that those bodies would prevent them from doing. Like dumping chemicals in our water and pollution in our air. They want to be able to carry on with business as usual for fossil fuel company and industrial manufacturing without oversight. "I do see immigrants blamed for some specific problems, sure, but the way I'm reading you, it sounds like you think that’s the underlying issue most or all of the blame is placed on—and that’s not what I’m hearing from the right." Its exactly what im hearing from the right. It was the main issue he ran on. While i think Bidens term was too soft on immigration, he tried to introduce a reform bill at the end of his term, am that would have made significant changes and stop the flow over the border, and Trump told his minions on congress to block it because he wanted to be able to run on immigration. It is and was the center piece of his platform. "Mostly, though, the non-whacko people on the right (which is the vast majority) think government spending, untrustworthy politicians, healthcare affordability, etc., are bigger problems that don’t have much to do with immigration." Who are the non-whackos? I see wackos all the way to the top. I rarely meet anyone who is a die hard Trumo supporter who i think is a reasonable individual. "I want to reiterate, too, that die-hard Trump cultists are not representative of the majority of people on the right—just like violent Antifa protesters don't represent the majority of the left." I think the right has been full taken over by Trumpism. There may be a few who dont like him, but are too scared to say so because they are spineless. "I've not seen evidence that people are being sent to a concentration camp." CECOT in El Salvador is a concentration camp with a complete lack of human rights for its inmates. They may not put you to death, but all the need is a designation that you are a gang member, without any judicial review, and they put you in there for life. No one gets out. There is no contact with the outside world, no family visits, no appeals. We made a deal with Bukele to send peope there without any due process as long as the arresting officers decide you are a gang member. Recently it came out that in exchange for that deal, Rubio gave him several leaders of the MS13 gang. Those gang leaders had previously testified against other in their gang, and partnof the deal they made with the US was that they would not be extradited back to that place because it would most certainly mean they would die for cooperating with the government. In order to secure that the agreement with Bukele Rubio renegged on that agreement and sent them back anyway. Do you have any idea the damage something like that does? The ability to make deal with criminals in order to secure testimony from them is one of the major ways in which the US locks dangerous people up and allows them to cast a much larger net in making arrests. Who is going to trust us when we go back on our word simply to secure the ability to send people to a concentration camp in a foreign country? "I do think there are civil liberties issues under Trump—100%. I hate to see them, and I've been disappointed on that front, albeit not very surprised. I've also seen spine-chilling civil-liberties issues from the left (e.g., hate-speech laws)" There hasn't been a proposed hate speech law for a long time in the US. Are you referring to the UK law that recently passed? That's not the US. In fact after Kirk's murder the right, and Trump, we're the ones talking about arresting people for hate speech. "I will say, for the example you shared (the makeup artist), I've heard so much conflicting information that I'm pretty agnostic on it. I've seen compelling evidence the guy was connected to crime, and other stories that make him sound worthy of sainthood. I'd guess the truth is somewhere in the middle. " I think you are confusing two different people. Most of the news coverage was of Kilmar Ábrego García, who there has been some debate about whether he was a gang member or not. He has a wife and child here in the states and is heterosexual. I'm not talking about him. The guy I am talking about is Andry Hernandez Romero. He is a gay man and a makeup artist. There hasn't been no debate about him being a gang member, with the exception of the Trump administration who was trying to justify their extrajudicial deportation of him to one of the most extreme prisons in the world, which I refer to as a concentration camp for the reasons I explain before. https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.cbsnews.com/amp/news/venezuelan-migrants-deportations-el-salvador-prison-60-minutes/ I disagree about better examples of making Trump look bad. I think taking an innocent gay man and labeling as a gang member him without due process of a court hearing, then sending him to a prison where no one expects to ever leave is about as bad as it gets. I would like to see what's in the Epstein files, and yeah, maybe Trump is in there, but we dont know. We however do know that Trump, ICE, DHS are sending innocent people to one of the worst prisons in the world without any due process, so yeah, I think that is worse. " people on both sides at the top are guilty of it. I get my stock picks from Nancy Pelosi. How many millions have Obama and the Clintons made for 30-minute talks since leaving office?" While I'm not a fan of Pelosi and I think she made a lot of money on inside trading, I don't think you can compare giving talks for money, to the type of grifting Trump is doing right now. No president has ever had as many shady scam infomercial bullshit grifts as this guy. The list is endless. . "Bottom line: most of the things you’re upset about, I agree with—as do most Americans. " I don't meet any Trump supporters that are upset about anything he is doing.

Sarah

Interesting. I thought I might not like him and I currently think (47 minutes in) that he’s actually great. In what way is he too rigid?

Eli Gaultney

So yeah, I just don't think we're going to agree about the budget stuff. Totally respect your views though, and appreciate you sharing them. Also we'll have to agree to disagree that immigration was the main issue Trump ran on. Fair enough if that's what resonated with you the most. Also, I agree to disagree about CECOT being a concentration camp. I think you can have human rights abuses short of being a concentration camp though, and CECOT doesn't seem like any bastion of civil liberty. I feel for anyone innocent there. I'm sorry you have only met whackos from the right, but all I can say is that I know many people who identify as Republicans and overall they're mostly moderate and agreeable. Same is true for my Democrat acquaintances. I see way more in common than I see different, and I constantly am discussing politics with folks. I was a conference this weekend and saw the same themes again. Saying the right is taken over by Trumpism? Eh, I can see that. I mean, he's their candidate. It's like saying "the left was overtaken by Obamaism" in 2004. I voted for Obama then, and for sure we were all in his camp at that time. I'm curious what else you'd expect? I don't mind lying to criminals, no. That's one area where I'm strongly aligned with the majority right opinion. If they're bad people I'm okay with killing them, and so lying doesn't bother me. In terms of civil-liberties issues from the Left, the classic example is cancel culture. silencing speech for opinions you don't like. There are plenty of documented examples now of the left-controlled government pushing social media companies to close accounts that disagreed with their narrative. This was extra-judicial curtailment of people's first amendment rights. Yeah, I was definitely confusing two people, thanks for the correction! It certainly was a fuck-up. But also it got corrected, as far as I can see. Bottom line here I think it makes Trump look bad, and if you think that's the example to lean on, fair enough! I adamantly believe that the money we see these people getting paid for their half-hour speaking appearances are 100% grift, and no worse/better than any other grift I see from Trump. Once again though, I can respect if you think those are fair prices for the speeches given. > I don't meet any Trump supporters that are upset about anything he is doing I was more talking about the general concerns you have: respect of civil liberties, budget issues, immigration, etc. I see it time and time again, people just want to be able to afford a good life for their family, have freedom, good health, etc. They're happy to have legal immigration, and so on. When it comes to Trump specifically, sure, most people on the right get a one-sided accounting from their social media and news sources. I would offer the counterpoint that when Biden was president (and I voted for him) I was hard-pressed to find any basic Democrat who were upset about anything Biden did. Most people live in bubbles. It takes a concerted effort to break out of one's own filter bubble. You have to understand how the algorithm works and "like" content that you disagree with, which almost nobody seems capable of. For example, I've liked all your comments on this thread even though I don't tacitly agree with them. I've had a lot of practice with this, and I do think it's helped me get a more nuanced view of things. But I'm also still an idiot and don't know shit, don't get me wrong 🤣

jacob

never thought id see the buzzfeed sam hyde exposé as a source on here that’s so funny

soap.

thank you for writing this out, very inspiring.

nova-x13

That’s ridiculous! Where the hell did you learn about economics to get that nonsense? Money isn’t infinite, it’s expandable but not limitless. If it were, inflation would destroy value overnight. The Fed manages supply because scarcity gives dollars their value. Calling it infinite isn’t factual economics, it just ends up coming across as intentional ignorance.

nova-x13

Eli, this isn’t some abstract disagreement about personalities or “tone.” It’s the textbook psychology of fascism you’re describing, and excusing. The idea that billionaires like Musk, Bezos, and Zuck “want to help the world” while “padding their pockets” is exactly how every authoritarian cult justifies its leaders. They always start as self-styled saviors promising progress, order, and innovation. Then they consolidate control, gut institutions, destroy labor, and weaponize media. That’s not altruism, it’s corporate fascism with a friendly face. You say you’re turned off by anger? But don't you see that’s how fascism wins. The public equates passion with instability, and calm deception with reason. They count on people like you to value civility over truth. The ones smiling as they dismantle democracy will always sound “rational.” The ones warning you about it will sound “angry.” Would you like to guess which side history remembers as right? Sabine isn’t above criticism just because she speaks softly or wears the costume of intellectual neutrality. She’s part of the new academic laundering of reactionary thought, where pseudo-skepticism and false balance let the far-right narrative infiltrate science and media under the banner of “open discussion.” And your “contacts in the CDC” story? That’s the same fascist propaganda line used to justify purges of civil servants, painting professionals as “ideologically captured” so the regime can replace them with loyalists. It’s exactly how Hitler consolidated control of Germany’s bureaucracy in the 1930s. Step one: discredit experts. Step two: replace them with zealots. Step three: call it reform. What you’re witnessing isn’t political polarization, it’s a coordinated fascist takeover dressed up as populism. And your instinct to trust whoever “sounds calm” instead of whoever’s telling the truth is how democracies die without a single shot fired. By the way, I'll take that bet with you any day of the week!  There's no way in hell Trump will step down willingly regardless of whoever wins the next election, assuming we even have another "fair" election in the first place.

nova-x13

Don't really see how someone who's in agreement with what he's saying and trying to do would have such a negative opinion of Dave. I'm sure he's extremely annoying to the people he's either debunking or their fans or simply someone who believes something he's debunking. But other than those two reasons how could he actually get on your nerves so bad?

nova-x13

Eli, you're confusing the facts. Dave only has that attitude when he’s debunking frauds and liars, not when he’s teaching. Watch his actual science content and you’ll see he’s calm, structured, and focused on evidence. The frustration only comes out when he’s dealing with people who distort reality for clicks or profit. He's an excellent science communicator and he has millions of satisfied students to show for it. That’s not arrogance, that’s integrity.

nova-x13

Oh give me a freaking break! You're confusing confidence with condescension. Dave isn't toxic, he's just allergic to bullshit. That means a lot of charlatans and pseudo-intellectuals start feeling attacked the moment he opens his mouth. His job isn't to babysit fragile egos, it's to dismantle nonsense and show exactly why it fails. If you want nice debunking, go watch someone politely nod while lies spread unchecked. Science communication isn't customer service, it's war against ignorance. Dave's tone only sounds harsh to people who care more about feelings than facts.

Eli Gaultney

hmm, which AI did you use for this? It's okay though, I'm not surprised nor do I blame you. Your arguments are fine (albeit computer-assisted), but the key thing is there are counter-examples. Just because something is in the authoritarian playbook doesn't mean it's necessarily authoritarian. I'm not sure what you think rich people _should_ do, but they're just humans. Some good, some bad. Mostly I see good with Elon, for example. You're not going to convince me that he's a net negative when I can see his positive impacts all around me with my own eyes. It brings to mind Rockefeller. By many accounts a terrible person...hurt a lot of people. But some of his lasting legacy (eg. libraries) are outstanding public goods. I think it's easy to paint people two-dimensionally, but reality isn't so simple. If you want to see authoritarianism around every corner, good. The world needs people who are intensely worried about that, although personally I'm more worried about control and authoritarianism coming from the modern left than the right today. Watchdogs from both angles are good. You cover the right and I'll cover the left :) I think there's a stronger argument that anger gets weaponized by both sides and is used to increase polarization, but fair enough if you think pacifism and/or calm rationalism are the real paths to fascism. Do you have a specific example of Sabine spewing bad science? I'm no deep expert on her material. I just haven't seen that myself yet. I'd love a hint/suggestion where to look. My "contacts in the CDC" story is an actual story from people I know, not just something I read in the newspaper. And these are people who are quite liberal themselves. One of them is (was?) a trans-activist. Always fun when people tell you that your primary sources are propaganda 😀 Which platform do you want to make the bet on? I guess we could use polymarket or something. I'm not sure if there's a proper escrow system site where we can make a direct bet against each other, but at the least we can throw the money on current markets and see who wins. I would say I'm 90% certain he'll step down peaceably, but hey, I'm wrong all the time and it would be happy to congratulate you in that circumstance.

cam williams

Are you saying you’re incapable of agreeing with someone, but thinking their tone, and/or approach, is a put-off or an abrasive listen?

nova-x13

Eli, you didn't engage with a single argument or point I made. Instead you decided to sidestep all of it hiding behind vibes and anecdotes. Then you waved it away as “AI!” Why? Might it be because the sentences are complete and the history is correct? And possibly because you're not capable of matching it, not to mention come up with one single counter to anything I said. That's not a rebuttal Eli. That's you admitting you can't engage with the material. So, for your benefit and others, here's a little review: “Just because it's in the authoritarian playbook doesn’t mean it's authoritarian.” Seriously Eli?! That's a dodge, and one of the stupidest things I've heard. Authoritarianism is literally identified by recurring tactics used together over time which is precisely what we're witnessing with this admin. First, build a cult of personality. Then discredit the press and the civil service. Destroy trust while simultaneously cutting funding in science and education in general. Gut government labor. Capture the communication channels. No, I'm sorry sweetie, but you don't get to isolate one tactic and then declare it harmless in a vacuum. That's not how the real world works, and I named the pattern. You decided to simply pretend the pattern doesn't even exist by chopping it into pieces. Eli, that's a pathetic low effort, illogical evasion! “Rich people are just humans. Some good, some bad.” Wow! Eli....congratulations, on finally  discovering morality in fortune cookie form! You must be so proud! So, all kidding aside the issue isn't whether a billionaire seems mostly good.. The issue is structural power and who's wielding it and why. When one person can buy the media space, rewrite the rules, and punish critics in real time, that's literally the opposite of being neutral. That's the media capture, in case you're getting lost. You keep substituting personality for structure because structure is where your argument is lacking and that's me being generous. “Mostly I see good with Elon.” Okay.....so you see what his PR wants you to see and no doubt block out anything else that shatters that notion that happens to get past the fire wall. EV adoption and rockets don't erase union busting, stochastic amplification of propaganda, and the platforming of extremists. Not to mention being a space Nazi. Philanthropy or cool tech isn't a moral laundering machine, Eli, not to mention Musk has no major philanthropic ambitions. So, as a thought experiment, and stay with me here, but say what If I where to burn your house down and then buy you a blanket as compensation, would you then consider me a humanitarian? Just a thought. “Rockefeller built libraries.” Yes....he did, and Standard Oil crushed competition and workers both figuratively and literally to create the wealth he later sprinkled on public goods. The philanthropy was real, but the harm was far larger. Citing the library like it cancels the monopoly is historical amnesia Eli, and it's not very intellectually honest of you. “I’m more worried about authoritarianism from the modern left.”😏Sure you are sweetie!😂 Based on what, exactly?! Book bans aren't coming from the left. Purges of civil servants for political loyalty aren't coming from the left. Threats to jail opponents aren't coming from the left and I could just keep going for quite a while like that and you know it! Threats to deploy the Military in peaceful US city streets to terrorize citizens isn't coming from the left. You don't just get to assert a fucking vibe and try calling it even. If you actually have evidence, then I expect you to present it. If not, you're just repeating some slogan you heard from people whose job is to keep you confused. And it sounds like they're doing one hell of a good job! “Do you have a specific example of Sabine spewing bad science.” Yes, but the point was never that she’s out there publishing fake equations. It’s about narrative laundering, and how the performance of neutrality gets weaponized to sneak reactionary talking points into respectable spaces under the guise of “just asking questions.” That’s how capture works in educated circles. You ask for a lab report so you can pretend the larger media ecosystem isn’t part of the experiment. It's....very convenient. “My contacts in the CDC say X.” How many times do I have to say an anecdote isn't data! And I could care less if your cousin’s roommate once sent an email. Fascists always try to delegitimize public servants as “ideologically captured” so they can replace them with loyalists. Which is precisely what's been happening since Trump was sworn in. You just recited the script and called it a personal story. Nice! As for the bet, you can't possibly be serious right now?! That was a throw away line, FFS! I’m not about to try to take time out of my day to put money in some escrow account to bet a stranger I got into a pathetic excuse for a debate with online. And the fact I'd win is irrelevant. So, here's the reality of the situation we're in, ready? You're not debating me sweetie! You're just dodging me. You offered cliches, anecdotes, and a museum pass to Rockefeller’s library while pretending the monopoly didn't exist. I'm sorry, Eli, but that just isn't an actual argument.  Try again.

Fred P

I mean being rigid is not necesarilly a negative in some contexts. I meant rigid as in I would have liked to hear about something else than what he already says in videos. Like I dunno, maybe im just spoiled at how amicable an soft-approach (with a purpose, I do think that is more effective imo though) is. He says you gotta do something, I guess.fact is Most people that debate flat earth, ancient egypt, alt history (ive been in the communities of past 2, R. carlsson etc) no matter how fucking obvious their grift becomes it somehow never registers to the audience and they keep on keeping on. They prey on the lonely and people at their weakest, be it mourning, depression or otherwise. People missing a community, finally feel like they belong. The discord is full of people to talk to about these alternative histories or topics. It's not some evil systemic practice it's just the kind of people that can be attracted and no amount of facts and logic will pry their last cling them away from that sphere if they got nothing else left.. Some people after years realize they were in some psychosis like state and get out (me) new people come in with no context and the cycle repeats. and so it goes, fighting against the ocean punching down waves. Fun? maybe. But I don't wanna watch a guy doing it as he says he is making a difference in a wave pool sponsored by people that hate waves