Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

In this episode I talk with MAPS phase III trial participant Becca Kacanda about her experience successfully treating PTSD with MDMA psychotherapy. The conversation covers the complexity of psychedelic psychotherapy, the importance of listening to the participants directly, and what it was like to be manipulated by Psymposia-associate Sasha Sisko who attempted to convince her that the therapy she had received was "whack-a-doodle nonsense ‘therapy.'" We also discuss her involvement with different initiates aimed at solving these problems.

Psychedelic Lived Experiences - Virtual Summit - Nov 21st-23rd 2025Psychedelic Lived Experiences is a patient-led initiative advancing lived experience in psychedelic research, treatment, and policy. Use code SPEAKER20 for $20 off when you upgrade from the free pass to the Community or Professional all-access pass.

https://psychedeliclivedexperiences.com/summit

MAPS Clinical Trial Participant Presentation at PS2025:Lived Experience in Psychedelics: Insights Beyond the Breakthroughs

The Watchdogs Need Watchdogs, Too; A Perspective on Psymposia from a former MAPS MDMA clinical trial participant

Psychedelic Art Therapy Network

How a Leftist Activist Group Helped Torpedo a Psychedelic Therapy

Comments

rottogrotto

Worth noting this early interview was conducted shortly after my interactions with Sasha - was too nervous to even talk about it at the time

Sarah

What a great interview! Still listening but I wanted to ask about your experience with taste changing, Becca, if that’s OK? I know someone who has experienced changes in taste and smell linked to a challenging experience and so I’m curious to know what helped?

Hasate

I want to thank you so much Hamilton for this interview. It was great and very eye opening. Thank you again for your dedication!!

Sarah

What an amazing discussion. Becca is so articulate, balanced, and no doubt an excellent art therapist. That second MDMA experience sounds so profound. Personally, I think only a more humanistic open-ended approach would be useful with psychedelics. Sasha Sisko sounds so abusive. And Psymposia sound like such disturbed people. The more I hear of them, from various sources, the more nauseated I become. That argument about super soldiers is just so vile. And so disrespectful to veterans. What sort of mind would come up with that? I used to be interested in understanding the minds of serial killers, but currently I’m curious about the minds of Psymposia members. I do wonder about their funding, too. We know a couple of sources, but I wonder about others. Interesting point about Jules Evans being potentially a more subtle but more threatening concern in the field. Depends on his motivations, I guess. I’m not entirely sure of them, because some recent articles he wrote were very much aligned to Susie Sarlo’s perspective, and yet Jules has a desire to help people who have experienced challenges with psychedelics. He has compassion, and balance in that domain. According to his writings, it seems he has only ever had one LSD experience and one Ayahuascha retreat experience himself, and both were challenging. If he hasn’t had any other experiences of psychedelics then his perspective will no doubt be somewhat skewed. Maybe his future writings will depend on funding sources and affiliations, as well as his own developing views. Hamilton, I hope you post this on your YouTube channel for the masses to hear because as you say, the voices of trial participants need to be heard.

Johan

It’s so crazy that individuals such as Sasha have effectively shut down something so unique and precious. I hope the tide changes again.

rottogrotto

It just gradually got back to normal on its own

T

Thank you for sharing

Sarah

Fingers crossed for the person I know, then.

rayah

i have such a deep respect for becca kacanda, i feel so lucky to have her follow + support my substack!!

Sarah

I liked your point about the inner healing intelligence. It’s so obvious that it’s just part of who we are and this is why positive relational interaction heals people on an emotional level. We have a physical inner healing intelligence too. In the right environment, the body knows how to heal, and so supporting that can be important.

Patrick Farrell

Please do upload the Art Kleps piece you mentioned if you're able to. Unless you have and I'm missing it? Huge appreciation for this chat, thank you.

Josh Galloway

When I got to the bit about the anti-Compass merch, I had to rewind a few times before I remembered that David Nickles and Dr. David E. Nichols are not the same person ahaha

Hamilton Morris

David E. Nichols actually wrote the controversial Compass psilocybin polymorph patent

Vippy

“I thought you guys were gonna prohibit some drugs over here! Why aren’t you prohibiting drugs yet?” -Hamilton Morris

Samantha Firoze Sethna

Psymposia seems so unfathomably bizarre. Are some/all of them licensed therapists?

Hamilton Morris

None of them are. Nese teaches a creative writing class, Brian Pace does “soil science”, David Nickles is a glass blower, not sure what Ross does, Sasha Sisko was an unlicensed “psychedelic integration coach”, another one was an uber driver.

Samantha Firoze Sethna

I feel like it's really unfortunate that participants of such clinical trials can simultaneously find themselves in a position to feel some level of responsible for the very existence of these nascent therapeutic modalities. I absolutely understand how that could be the case, but that seems like it could pile so much else on top of their personal, therapeutic work.

Samantha Firoze Sethna

Becca - you touched on the environment these clinical trials took place in a bit - If you're comfortable sharing, I'm curious if where you went was the space Usona contracted Digital Ambiance to design: https://digitalambiance.com/portfolio/usona-institute/ But most importantly, congratulations on successful therapy treatment. That makes me really happy to hear. ♥️

rottogrotto

Right, and they never even had a licensed therapist on their “team” or whatever - yet presented themselves as credentialed to be experts in psychotherapy.

rottogrotto

Those photos look like the Usona Insititute…so no, it’s not the space. The therapy room was at UWMadison and looked more like a nice living room.

rottogrotto

It absolutely places as insane amount of pressure on patients that is distracting and often harmful

Sarah

A group of experts then. Worth listening to….😝 And do we know what personal experience of psychedelics they have had? Nese had one experience involving a snowflake that I have read about….

William Wallace XXVI

Thanks for releasing this!! I’ve been contacted with an offer to join a psychedelic clinical trial for Chronic Pain at the Hospital I go to, but I’m on the fence about it so hearing first hand what it’s like will be super helpful in making my decision.🙏 Also, the 7oh video is also pretty time sensitive considering how many people are using it, some in high amounts, and many, if not most, buying from companies who don’t release solvent lab results. I don’t even know the full scale/dangers of improper chemistry that causes leftover solvents and I’m someone who’s researched the topic quite a bit. Some questions I have are: how common are solvents in 7oh? But also, how common are they in any chemistry product made for consumption - both in legal & illegal drugs, from Rx pharmaceuticals, to RC’s/supplements & the black market?? And, lastly, if consumed, how dangerous are they? Is there acute risk, or is it mostly chronic & dose based?

Noel

Wonderful conversation! This is an important perspective

Taylor

7ohm seems pretty safe. I don’t think any humans have died directly from it. Respiratory depression is the main fatality risk for opioids which is basically non existent for 7ohm/kratom

Taylor

The methyl man!? Love the vesp guests! Excited about the 7ohm too, I hope he says he picked up the oxone method from your Mike Cunningham episode.

Hamilton Morris

Yes, seems safe compared to other opioids in terms of fatal overdose risk, but risk of dependence is extremely high.

Gabe KS

Listening to Becca’s story, it sounds like one of the most challenging aspects of the clinical trial process was not knowing whether or not she received the active compound. Functional un-blinding critics hate to see it! But doesn’t that make perfect sense? PTSD survivors deal with so much uncertainty as it is… Also, her account of the leg pain reminded me of that wonderful chapter in PiHKAL about the person who had been trapped under a desk during an earthquake (?) I believe, holding all of that trauma in their legs and releasing it during an MDMA encounter with Ann. Beautiful stuff.

David and Teresa Consciousness Medicine (edited)

Comment edits

2026-09-06 06:00 Great reporting and interview. Thank you. What is a 'positive adverse event reporting' (2:08:30)? I'm glad to hear that Psymposia finally seems to be completely discredited after doubling down on their ludicrous and abusive stories and opinions. What a bizarre and unexpected sequence of events.
2025-11-21 03:19

Hamilton Morris

It’s formally reporting whether or not MDMA causes euphoria, hard to frame this as a serious problem, but it should have been recorded.

Douglas Skene

Such a clear, articulate communicator. I feel like I got quite a good sense of what the whole experience of being in these trials was like. Really sad to keep hearing about Psymposia and Sasha Sisko's trail of nefarious behaviour. It only becomes sicker and more twisted given that they posture themselves as some sort of ethical compass for all things psychedelic, yet constantly display that they are morally bankrupt.

M

Sweet!

araphaelite

Is the name David Nickles a coincidence? Or has this person fashioned themselves after Dr. David E Nichols purposefully to be able to take advantage of the confusion it produces in situations like writing the foreword for PIKHAL?

jake

is there a different david nichols or are we really talking about david E nichols? i would have never thought about him that way.

mia

I've only just started but want to say I appreciate your vulnerability Becca! Thanks for sharing so honestly. 🫂

mia

Hamilton, the sample including 40% of people who have tried MDMA is not close to the general population, which in 2025 still under 10% (though likely underreported). To me this is one of the most valid criticisms that is silly to argue against. I'll noodle on an example or analogy, but I feel like you understand the principle?

araphaelite

There are two people with names that are homonyms, I believe. David Nickles is the psymposia member who is against MAPS. Dr. David E Nichols is the famous medicinal chemist who was good friends / collaborators with Alexander Shulgin.

araphaelite

From how I understand this interview, David Nickles was going to write a foreword for the new edition of PIKHAL and Ann Shulgin's daughter Wendy may not have realized that this wasn't Dr. Nichols, who actually knew Shulgin well.

Hamilton Morris

I should have been more careful in my wording, I meant the PTSD population where substance use disorder is dramatically elevated and may be as high as 50%. MDMA use hasn’t been explicitly surveyed (to the best of my knowledge) among Americans with a PTSD diagnosis but based on trends with other drugs I think it’s reasonable to expect that it is elevated. Along with what Becca said about people who have previous experience with MDMA being more interested in the trials I think it’s likely the case that 40% is not radically different from what would be expected in a post-approval patient population. When you add the fact that there wasn’t a statistically significant difference in therapeutic response between patients who had previous experience with MDMA and those that didn’t I think this simply isn’t a real flaw in the trial design. There are also other arguments for why this may not be a flaw I’ve made in previous podcasts.

mia

This example may fall apart but think of the safety testing of cars. Let's pretend the test dummies are real people who were recruited for the study. A majority of them are white men. They do the tests and the safety data shows the airbags and seatbelts work great in crashes. Great! Then they are deployed in the real world. Women wearing seatbelts are injured in car crashes more than men wearing seatbelts (and this is normalized data, so it's not because women get in more crashes). What's going on, the safety data was great?Well, the average height, weight, and anatomy of the "dummies" was different than the average across all ethnicities and genders. The sample was not representative of the national population where these cars were deployed. The safety is not only a measure of how the technology is deployed, but the "synergy" of the deployed technology and the person it is trying to protect. Therefore, you need to make sure the persons tested on are representative of the persons this technology is actually deployed on. You cannot make inferences across populations with data that is not collected with truly representative samples.

mia

Okay, I understand. I think the main issue is you are trying to make a logical argument, and while your logic makes sense, that's not how the scientific process works. It's simply your hypothesis, and your logic might make it better than most, but it remains a hypothesis until the data is collected. Like you mentioned, if there's not even data collected for MDMA use in PTSD populations, you can't even compare if it is more or less representative. So it's definitely not of the gen pop, and we have a weak logic based hypothesis the PTSD population *might* be closer.

mia

And my last note (for now) - this study wasn't designed to compare the group of previous MDMA user and the first-time users. I would have to look again, but are the sample sizes of each "group" large enough to compare with statistical significance? Or was this verbally conveyed in conversation? Just from memory, I'm hesitant to believe the sample size was large enough for that type of analysis.

rottogrotto

I think there are so many other factors to this question that would be relevant, including- did the person take mdma before or after their traumatic event? How long ago was it? What was the dose? How many times? What was the setting? Recreational or therapeutic? What kind of therapy? This list goes on and on. Having been part of the 40 percent (i took a low dose once, almost 15 years before the trial and about 10 years before the index trauma) it’s hard for me to really link any particular effects this may have had on my trial experience other than the fact that I maybe had a lower level of fear about what it might feel like compared to some psychedelic or mdma naive person.

Hamilton Morris

Yes, if I am saying something negative about someone named David Nickles I am NEVER talking about the chemist with a similar sound name. David Nickles real name is David Maliken. The members of Psymposia chose these fake names to create confusion, Sasha T. Sisko is an amalgamation of Sasha T. Shulgin and Bob Sisko, two widely admired psychedelic pioneers.

araphaelite

wow. seems a bit nefarious

mia

Right! Becca so, in listing all of those uncontrolled variables you're actually reiterating the importance of the sample. So many things can influence your data and it's impossible to control them all. To increase credibility, your number one defense as a researcher is your sample. Sure you need the right study design, but a perfect study design without a good sample is just as bad as a poorly designed study with a perfect sample. With the introduction of the 40% of mdma-exposed individuals, you poke holes in the data and it's interpretability. Were their results different because they were exposed? Idk, new hypothesis. You can't answer that hypothesis with the data from this study because it requires a 2 factorial analysis, meaning 4 groups: drug exposed (placebo and active), drug naive (placebo and active). (From memory but pretty confident I'm recalling correctly...) Of course they wouldn't do that bc 1. That's not the point of this study, 2. They aren't treating participants as 2 different groups/populations, because 3. even if they did it requires more participants for statistical significance. This would be a much more expensive study. I do not disagree with the logic and the hypotheses that are being presented of what may or may not influence results. I don't disagree that MDMA assisted therapy is likely extremely helpful, safe, and effective. I want it to be approved! What I disagree on is whether or not this study meets standards of scientific research, and to me, there are obvious shortcomings. My concern is because I care about this cause and if people can't see these shortcomings, how are we going to address them!? The research is the fixable thing. There will always be prejudice because it's an illegal substance. Psymposia or not, there will always be a group that pushes back. There will always be sensationalized media. There's already so much to fight against, why on earth add to the difficulty by conducting research that is easy for academics to poke holes in?

rottogrotto

I get it. There are endless variables to the backgrounds of individuals entering the study and controlling for them becomes quickly becomes incredibly expensive and difficult. I think many other factors can equally if not more heavily weigh on someone’s ability to be receptive to the treatment then whether or not they’ve taken MDMA before at any point in their lives ( including their current support system, attitude/beliefs about psychedelics, how they are able to spend their time in between dosing sessions, other life responsibilities) so to me the previous mdma experience is just one of many other endless variables and I am not convinced it is of such utmost importance. We’re not measuring the efficacy of MDMA-AT on the general population, we’re measuring the efficacy of MDMA-AT on individuals with PTSD who want to try MDMA-AT. Every single person who entered the trial had PTSD. Their previous MDMA experience did not extinguish their PTSD. I guess I’m sort of confused as to what the implication is regarding prior usage- this study did not detect a pattern in difference in response based on this variable- but sure, it’s an interesting factor to perhaps keep track of going forward.

Sarah

Just to say that the Psychedelic Lived Experiences Summit is really good. The panel discussion today featuring 4 trial participants from UK was so eye opening…. I highly recommend paying the small fee (with Hamilton’s discount) to listen to the recording and access all the other discussions and talks.

Sarah

Mia, I think you might benefit from listening to the panel discussion on UK trial participants and their horrific experiences of having to meet the researcher’s needs for conformity in the Psychedelic Lived Experiences Summit, if you are interested: One participant was forced to continue to listen to music she hated, in a session, which obviously impacted her experience. And given a lack of experience with psilocybin some found the experience too overwhelming. They have suggested that a small pre-trial dose of a drug they were given should have been given to prepare them, if they were drug naive, and felt that not having had a prior exposure led to worse outcomes. But as Becca said, so many variables are at play in humans that can lead to better or worse outcomes. For one participant in a UK trial a nurse changed midway through which was not a variable the researchers cared about but it had a big impact on the participant. In addition two participants were removed from the research studies they took part in because they had a challenging experience or they weren’t getting better quickly enough so the researchers didn’t want their data to be in the data pool. That’s not ‘science’ as I know it! I wonder if Psymposia has been all over these trials like bad breath after a night out, 10 pints and a curry? Having human participants is different to research carried out on mice. Ethics has to be taken into account as well as ‘science’, especially given that the point of the science is ultimately to help suffering people. Does MDMA plus therapy work for PTSD when a lot of other things has failed? That’s the question. And it’s the drug-therapy combination being researched, not just the drug. Noone has previously had the drug-therapy combination. And isn’t a lot of medical research usually carried out on white men? Menstruating women are often excluded from trials in my understanding. So the seatbelt is selective in these trials….

mia

Okay I don't understand where the claim there is no difference between these two groups is coming from because there is no analysis of two exposure groups in this study. I heard Rick say this, is that where the claim is coming from? If so, great, that should be published so it can be shown as statistically significant and ease everyone's concern. I don't think that can be done bc the sample size is not large enough for 2 factors.

mia

I don't think it matters either, but that is my hypothesis. When you skew a normal distribution that drastically, you simply have to show the evidence that it does not impact outcomes (which requires a different study design and sample size) otherwise credibility of the data will be called out. It is as simple as that. I agree with the logical thinking of why it probably doesn't matter, but these remain hypotheses.

mia

Thanks Sarah. All I am trying to explain is why researchers were up in arms about this study. I am not saying the standards result in the best care or measure everything that impacts results. I'm simply (failing) to convey there are red flags with this study compared to established standards and that's why researchers are calling it out. I'm not trying to argue this effected the results. But we don't have data required to claim it didn't. I'm not trying to argue meeting research standards means there's no flaws in the data or the treatment or that in meeting them patients get the best care possible. All I'm trying to say is the concerns raised are valid and would be raised for any study! These are not unfair criticisms.

Sarah

Seems a little nefarious, rather irksome and somewhat unhinged…..

Michael Cunningham

It absolutely causes respiratory depression. It’s pretty much like every classical opioiod except a different molecular scaffold. Simply Google “7-hydroxymiteagynine respiratory depression” and there are multiple recent papers detailing this effect. I’ve worked with McCurdy and Kruegel personally and they are credible scientists. The only part that confuses some folks is that mitragynine is a weak mu agonist and 7-oh is potent one and the classical opioid effects are limited by conversion of MG to 7OH (I made plenty of deuterated analogs to probe this metabolic transformation). The plant contains almost no 7OH )and the plant matter slows absorption and distribution) so it appears more safe than classical opioids. However direct ingestion of 7OH is not that different than morphine or oxy. Pure MG is potentially (slightly) safer, but 7OH conversion is facilitated in this scenario. I don’t give a fuck what opioid you use, but do your homework and don’t lie to yourself about it.

rottogrotto

Thank you for highlighting all of this, Sarah. I haven’t had a chance to listen to today’s panels yet because I was at work, but the point you're making is incredibly important. Researchers often fixate on specific methodological features they believe constitute “good science,” while remaining surprisingly unconcerned about other variables that meaningfully shape participants’ experiences. For instance, many participants have described the possibility of receiving a placebo as frightening, and some were genuinely devastated when they realized they had been assigned to the placebo arm. This emotional impact is not trivial—it influences outcomes, and it’s a dynamic that wouldn’t even exist in a real-world therapeutic setting. Yet we continue to treat the double-blind randomized design as the gold standard, assuming it will tell us something meaningful about real-world effectiveness. But does it? Our emphasis on uniformity in clinical trials often comes at the expense of honoring individual needs, essentially requiring participants to tolerate conditions that may be distressing or harmful—conditions that would never be imposed in typical therapeutic practice, where clinicians adjust their approach responsively. Like, what are we actually measuring here? Maybe the issue isn’t only that MAPS’ research may have been flawed, but that our broader, long-standing approaches to evaluating psychotherapy through rigid scientific standards are themselves fundamentally limited.

Sarah

“Researchers often fixate on specific methodological features they believe constitute "good science," while remaining surprisingly unconcerned about other variables that meaningfully shape participants' experiences.” EXACTLY Becca! Mia, you are concerned with one variable and yet so many variables affect us humans on an emotional level. We are not mice in a laboratory. Receiving a placebo, only coming into contact with a therapist you will spend hours with a few days before the trial starts and feeling very vulnerable as a result because you are neurodivergent, a nurse changing between the first and second sessions and this creating a gender imbalance in the room, seeing another research participant in the hallway and not being able to talk to them, hating the music but being forced to endure it for consistency purposes, being removed from the trial because your data isn’t suitable yet not having been told in advance that this could be a possibility and feeling confused and abandoned, not feeling enough integration support is available afterwards and feeling lost, feeling that the process is ‘extractive and invasive’… these are all important variables that have an emotional impact, but somehow they aren’t important to researchers who want to critique a study focused on people’s mental health? (I don’t see Pymposia as ‘researchers’, but perhaps other academics in relevant fields like to hyperfocus on one drug-related variable in a drug-therapy intervention and ignore so many others? Why weren’t the researchers concerned if participants had previously had therapy or not?) The MAPS trial was, in my understanding, attempting to test whether MDMA could enhance a therapeutic intervention that could be of benefit to people with PTSD. People who hadn’t yet found a way of addressing their PTSD satisfactorily. It was never just about the drug. It’s frightening to me, actually, that pharmaceutical companies want to have drugs legalised without therapy for mental health conditions. In this interview at 2:06:54 onwards, Rick notes that Esketamine was approved without therapy in US. And yet if ketamine is combined with therapy this leads to better results, longer durability AND less ketamine is needed overall. But Johnson & Johnson just want to sell Esketamine of course….so the more people need to keep using it, the merrier for them. https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=j--3eXrn0ps&pp=ygULcmljayBkb2JsaW7SBwkJHgGjtWo3m0M%3D I think Robin Carhart-Harris is in the initial stages of a study to compare the impact of drug alone v drug & therapy. I wonder if people having taken the drug previously will be a concern? https://www.facebook.com/share/v/1BtMihThD9/?mibextid=wwXIfr

Sarah

Becca, I imagine you’d be interested to hear the professionals in the third panel from yesterday’s summit, arguing against the continued use of the double-blind randomised design now that we already have this type of data, for the reasons mentioned. One of the women in the second panel said that after taking part in two trials for depression she wouldn’t want to experience any more. Yet she has used the same substance that was offered in the first trial on a retreat and found that to be a very valuable experience in which the connection with the other participants was very much part of her positive outcomes.

Drew LaBarre

Beautiful uplifting and informative interview!

William Wallace XXVI

Guys… I’m asking about RESIDUAL SOLVENTS commonly found in 7oh products due to bad chemistry. Please read my reply in this thread - where I clarify my questions about 7oh/RC’s. My 1st comment was obviously TLDR, my bad.

Michael Cunningham

That’s great! All the Takayama work should be required reading- but the papers I cited are a very worthwhile update connecting this critical work to current use patterns. I wouldn’t say conversion is minimal, just rate limited.

Hamilton Morris

What you are suggesting would make more sense, but that's not what happened. A new edition of PiHKAL was being edited by Jon Hanna and he inexplicably developed such intense admiration for Psymposia that he donated money to Psymposia when they were attacking me for my Wonderland talk and asked David Nickles to write an introduction to a new edition of PiHKAL. This was not a product of confusion between the two David Nickles with similar names, it was done knowingly. This is why I suggested that it almost seemed like people in a cult, it makes no sense.

William Wallace XXVI

Cool I’ll check those studies out too then, thanks! Love reading reputable studies on actual harms/risks of drugs. As a chemist, do you have any insight on how residual solvents in 7oh tablets could be harmful? Such as high methanol or Acetone levels? The 7oh industry seems overrun with amateur chemists making “bad batches” aside from a handful of companies.

Thomas Cook

Becca, your comments on “inner healing intelligence” were insightful. Nesé, Lily Kay and Brian Pace are Marxists who believe inner work is a pointless substitute for changing “systems of oppression” which are by definition, external. Lily Kay is broadly skeptical of 1:1 trauma psychotherapy in general and her unhinged dissertation was on that. To draw on individual, inner strength to overcome trauma is a threat to the Frankfurt school ideology, which in the 1950s argued that psychoanalysis will become a tool of authoritarians… does that sound familiar?

Hamilton Morris

Could you email me the Ross dissertation? I was looking for it (as well as Brian's) but couldn't find it on ProQuest

rottogrotto

Thanks Thomas, Would be curious to read this too, if you have it can you email it to b.kacanda@gmail.com or tell me where I can find it? I’m only vaguely familiar with their affiliation/promotion of these ideas. I found it to be ironic that they’ve so vehemently attacked the concept of IHI because the flipside would be a more directive approach, where the therapist takes the position of authority to tell the patient what they need to do or think. Given their intense skepticism toward authority, hierarchy, and power, this contradiction feels like yet another entry in a long list of maddeningly blatant ironies. I also think that individuals who have survived society’s worst social ills (rape, abuse, violence, war) who have recovered might be in the best position to help find solutions to these and other problems since they have some intimate insight into them, and usually have quite an expanded capacity for compassion for others and are often self-mobilized to be in service to others. Their recovery is so worthwhile. Maybe instead of attacking and invalidating PTSD survivors they could have shown interest in learning from them? But no, they chose to try to convince them and the public that they’ve been indoctrinated into a cult, stripping their autonomy and voice yet again.

Thomas Cook

Hi Hamilton, I’m a psychiatrist and I see Lily Kay Ross as essentially using Critical marxist/third wave feminist theory to undermine mental health treatment. https://www.psymposia.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/12/TheSurvivorImperative-LKR.pdf We should quickly save this, as a PDF. At the end of her beginning abstract she says any discussion of “survivorship” (i.e. psychological recovery) functionally “erases the social reality of sexual trauma….” In other words, therapists themselves *enable* abusers in the act of trying to fully heal people or help them grow. And abusers think “they’ll grow from the trauma so i might as well assault another person…” This is batshit crazy stuff. Almost reminiscent of Peter Boghossian’s spoof papers on “rape culture” in Portland dog parks.

Thomas Cook

Hi Becca, It’s just how totalitarians think. They interpret everything (even trauma therapy) as an expression of power, as if therapists are the unwitting puppets of abusers, and of “systems of power”. They “problematize” everything, i.e. call everything a micro-aggression. Lily Kay Ross’s paper essentially says trauma therapy is a micro-aggression against victims, by changing *them* while ignoring social justice. That’s her paper in a nutshell. Also: I admire your resiliency through art therapy. I’m writing a related blog on Brian Wilson of the Beach Boys. He was severely abused by his father and deaf in one ear from being hit by a 2x4 as a toddler. He was such a sweet man and, though psychotic, he would say his music gave him the feeling that he created everything, i.e., he was like a god creating the whole world… and this creativity helped him rise above the evils perpetrated by his father: as if the world and everything in it (with its evils) were all part of his creation.

m/z

Good interview, enjoyed hearing patient perspective on maps clinical trials.

M

Oo can't wait for the clandestine interviews !! Methyl man 😂 it sounds like a antihero moniker and it's perfect

K

Is there a comprehensive list of "MAPS trained" psychotherapists? There are so many new ketamine clinics popping up and it's hard to tell who's legit & who has no business doing it. I personally know an anesthesiologist who has jumped on the ketamine treatment bandwagon, and they have zero therapy training. Would a therapist actually trained for MDMA therapy also be adept at ketamine assisted therapy? Cause MDMA therapy is still officially illegal, correct? Great interview, thank you.

rottogrotto

Just Found a screenshot from Nese from a year ago about about the IHI. Nese says : “ In the Grofian MAPS model “letting the IHI rip” involves expulsions of trauma imprints after ego defenses have softened like a dilating cervix, w/therapists in the role of midwife & often using touch. The analogy to would healing is how the therapy model has gone with so little scrutiny for so long.” ———————- I truly have no fucking idea what she’s talking about, and I think you’d be hard pressed to find trial participants who resonate with this.

Hamilton Morris

Many ketamine providers have no therapy training, it’s not required and the field has many anesthesiologists who think therapy is entirely unnecessary.

gossamer

This was a wonderful and really fascinating conversation. Thank you so much for sharing, Becca! You have such an important perspective and it deserves to be heard more. Really happy to hear about all the amazing things you’re up to now and hope that life has been treating you kindly.

K

Seems very irresponsible to not properly process a patient's ketamine experience and just send them back out into the world. The whole thing is crazy, but not surprising. Even the most basic therapists/social workers require training & state licensing.

M

Unbelievable

M

☠️

rottogrotto

K I would suggest really doing your research on the place you are inquiring with, what their backgrounds/expertise is, how they dose , how they determine who is eligible, visit the clinic before dosing, ask around. I’ve heard positive things about a local ketamine infusion clinic in my town from the MAPS therapists I know and this was a place that doesn’t provide in house therapy. But If I were going this route personally I would probably also try to find a therapist familiar with ketamine or join an integration group because I think good therapeutic support can only help the process .

K

I'm skeptical of anyone who labels themselves a "Marxist" (or anything, for that matter). Gimme a break. The psychology & motives of all these players is fascinating. So dark.

Edwina Tollstoy

Wow….I heard some stuff about it but had no idea. So Sasha isn’t taking things out of context, he is lying. Patting someone going through heavy shit on the shoulder is not anything like cuddling with someone on the floor in a fetal position. Are they on the DEA payroll? Sasha sounds like a real douchebag or a fundamentalist control freak (same thing). What he said about your therapy makes me so mad. How could someone as fascist and control freakish as this guy Sasha be involved with psychedelics at all. It honestly sounds like he was harassing you. Has Sasha assaulted people who disagreed with him, sounds like he could and would.

Edwina Tollstoy

It sounds crazy but the stuff Sasha/Symposium is doing sounds like classic counter-op style psych-ops.

Thomas Cook

Grof may be eccentric, but the idea really isn’t IMO. After a painful labor comes a baby— many artists and writers have likened the composition process to labor and delivery. socrates called himself a midwife. And to overcome trauma we “make” meaning of it, and comparing that to childbirth is a little weird but not unhinged IMO. i think what Nese is doing is trying for guilt by association. “he mentioned the cervix therefore…” It has all the suspiciousness and moral hysteria of a struggle session in which Chinese students had to prove against guilt-by-association (an impossible task) that they didn’t oppose Mao Zedong

rottogrotto

Yes good point… maybe the metaphor isn’t as weird as it sounds . Stan is so wrapped up in this birth process stuff in a way I really don’t resonate with . I find the phrase “expulsions of trauma imprints .. often using touch “ to sound weirdly violent and not at all an accurate representation of what the therapy is like . It almost makes it sounds like patients are convulsing and therapists are touching them trying to physically remove the trauma. I don’t think digging into the weirdest Stan grof quotes is a fair way to represent the maps model .

JetPackInca

There are people in this world that devote their energy, unconsciously, to hate. It doesn't matter if you can prove that everything they say is wrong. You will never be able to get through to them, even if their propaganda genuinely harms other humans. They are misguided, mentally ill and NEED attention. In the 7-hydroxymitragynine and kratom world, we are suffering from this on a daily basis. There is a woman who takes videos of herself yelling at homeless addicts on the street. Threatening to call the police and acting like a delusional, very sick, child. She goes on to post these video on different platforms with the title, "drug addicts shooting up dangerous synthetic 7OH in a school zone. Notice the synthetic 7OH packaging all over the ground." There was never any 7-hydroxymitragynine packaging, anywhere. It was never even mentiind. Street addicts aren't using 7oh. It's too weak for their tolerance. They were all strung out on fentanyl. It doesn't matter what you say to her or how many studies you send her. She is genuinely furious about 7oh and kratom and makes up blatant lies in order to get a ban. This is what we deal with when it comes to chemical compounds and it's a damn tragedy. I think the only cure is a massive dose of LSD. Fill up a mist bottle and just spray her many times. I call it Gorilla Psychedelic Warfare

Siwanand Das

Is Dave nickles still a mod on Nexus? Anyone know his username?