Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Files

Comments

Robin Berglund

A brief explanation by google~ The proposition that a deity cannot simultaneously be omnipotent (all-powerful), omnipresent (everywhere), and moral (or all-good) is a central debate in philosophy of religion, often referred to as the Problem of Evil or the Epicurean Paradox. The argument contends that if God has the power to prevent suffering (omnipotent), is aware of it (omniscient), is everywhere to stop it (omnipresent), and is perfectly good (moral), then the existence of evil and suffering constitutes a logical contradiction.

Lyn

Hi Manamyte, thank you as always for the reactions, it is very enjoyable and I appreciate a lot of the animes you watch, including The Saga of Tanya. You comment about God made me think of an idea that I saw in another anime "Orb: On the Movements of the Earth" which is one of the best written anime I got to see and a big part of it is related to religion, to paraphrase it: "No matter what we do or think, god will remain silent, he does not act to change our life because we are the master of our life, this allows us to think freely and not be dependent of an omnipotent thing." My sentence does not do justice to how it is beautifuly done in the anime Orb but I think it is an interessing concept. Anyway, have fun!

Darkrai_69

Ah yes, the age old dilemma "If God exist, why bad thing?". The answer is actually quite simple. God allows humans free will, and if God were to interfere by restricting that free will, that would be immoral. The reason Lucifer was sent to hell was over this exact topic, he proposed that they could allow more people into heaven by not allowing bad people to do bad things.

Manamyte

Lucifer seems like a good guy and he should not have been sent to hell 😒

Hhound42

6:58 The author of Tanya and the author of Overlord are friends so as a nod we get an Easter egg of an Overlord poster on the subway wall. 26:50 The badge they awarded her is the highest medal they have, like our Congressional Medal Of Honor (usually awarded posthumously) and with her kills she is consider a war ace. Far from staying in the background she's now being recognized by the higher ups in the military. 28:25 Remember Tanya is really a 30+ year old man being dressed up as a cute little girl, the emotional inner turmoil must be soul breaking.

Azer S

Ok, now define free will

Azer S

« Dude being a litteral cocky sociopath » Manamyte: « exactly ! He think just like me ! » That’s not reassuring

Manamyte

Being an atheist doesn't make him a sociopath 💁‍♀️

Azer S

Being an atheist no. But man is an avid follower or Chicago school and the virtue of selfishness of Rand, where every action should be thought as a loss/gain and where success is the one metric to determine the value of man. (Granted they skipped it a bit in the anime) He’s a sociopath. Or at minima someone who’d wish to be one. It’s not that he doesn’t believe in God. It’s that he doesn’t believe in anything but his own success

Manamyte

Okay yeah nothing of that sort is mentioned in the anime. 😅 I must have agreed with him for the atheist part

Azer S

It’s reassuring, I got scared for a minute 😁

Manamyte

Hahhaa understandable 😂😂

Azer S

Also being an atheist is one thing. But playing the atheist in front of God (or at least someone able to stop time/take control of human) wasn’t really smart That also show the character is a bit lying to himself. If he was really calculating and cold, he would have played to regretful new believer (which would have worked. Based on what the author said, God/X would have saved him if he actually played his game). Instead the protagonist stick to his gun, mock him and start a fight he clearly can’t win, while going full against authority. So exactly what he blamed the 2 soldiers for in ep 1. He’s more emotional that he pretend to be

Darkrai_69

That's a debate for smarter people than me.