Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Videos

  • 754219298.mp4

Downloads

Content

This episode we tackle the issue of Ra's.

Files

Comments

michael

Since I'm first i wanna tell everyone coming in hello! Hope your day is well

Jonathan

1:45 Concerning the stealth discussion, I think Batman *wants* him to scream. It freaks out the other dudes. The whole weaponized fear aspect of Batman.

Gyudon

I agree with Alex’s take on Batman completely, less so Dick but still kinda yea, Batman is not driven by individual empathy like Spider-Man, but instead on a greater project of justice, where ends justify the means to specific extents. Rereading No Mans Land and like the first thing he does when he shows up is take over a gangs territory and change nothing about how the gang was running things, instead leaving that neighborhood as a temporary situation until he could reclaim the whole city. If you can entertain the idea for a single moment that a sociopath can feel empathy or at least emulate it with reasoning and a sense of “justice” or fairness you should easily be able to see how Dick is sociopathic sometimes. Also ig I assumed they’ve been reading Absolute Batman but idk now because in those books he makes nobody happy in the moment but is always working towards justice anyways it’s like the main essence of the character that is carried over from og.

Jbomb1900

So for the Batman Morality conversation, Take what many people consider the *Darkest* thing he's done which is plan ways to kill or disable Every Justice Leaguer. Do you think Batman for a second considered NOT having a way to beat up everybody? Like do we think he hesitated on the plan at all or went full steam ahead. I think Alex is right, Batman does feel a sense of right and wrong, But he already knows which way he's gonna swing.

gravey

ive always said " ray-shush"

Dustin Gibbons

Canonically at one time Dr. Crane worked under Hugo Strange and may even stole the fear gas from Hugo Strange. This is because in comics Hugo Strange had fear gas first.

Edward Eagerton

Alex interprets Batman as a small/wiry man, who is impervious to bullets, and behaves sociopathically. That's Wolverine.

Dave P

I don't think Dick Grayson is a sociopath. He's one of the most empathetic characters in the bat family.

Shelby

Clinical therapist here: Both psychopathy and sociopathy are terms associated with Antisocial Personality Disorder (ASPD) though are not actual diagnoses. ASPD is pattern of disregard and/or violation of the rights of others. Individuals diagnosed often display patterns of failure to conform to social norms (more specifically legal norms), deceitfulness, impulsivity, aggression, reckless disregard for themselves and others, irresponsibility, and lack of remorse. Individuals with ASPD often lack empathy and may have an inflated sense of self. ASPD is often connected to criminal activity for personal gain. Something to always tie in with characters like Bruce and Dick (really most super characters) is trauma. Trauma fundamentally alters the brain and the way we seek survival. It’s very common to see one or many of the trauma responses (fight, flight, freeze, fawn). Bruce and Dick show a combo of fight and fawn. Fighting the perceived baddie with a layer of attunement to the emotional state of the situation. The fawn response itself is layered. There is empathy as well as a sense of responsibility for others in it, a need to be helpful. It has ties to shame and guilty as well. I will fully admit I have not read or interact with Batman or Nightwing for a while so I’m working off old memories. Do both showcase traits of ASPD, sure, but you could also argue some narcissistic traits. The lens of trauma needs to be looked through first as it’s the starting place of most personality disorders. Of all the characters talked about Jason is the one I would say is the closest to ASPD. Love the conversation! =)

mike lewis

I love Alex but a major point of Arkhma Knight is Batman struggling with the choice of going after Talia or saving Gotham, to the point Alfred is ready to walk away. Grayson and Batman are definitely not sociopaths They have far too much empathy

Sam Leheny

I recently rewatched Batman Begins - and I appreciated it a lot more than I did as a grouchy teen. But I will say the one gripe with it I had is when Katie Holmes is all "Bruce Wayne is the real mask." right at the end, it didn't feel true. Just in that rendition, it feels very much like Batman is a character Bruce deliberately puts on. And yeah, it has a lot to do with unintentionally funny Batman voice, but there's also just a lot emphasis in that film on Bruce methodically formulating the perfect persona to take on crime. Like Brett keeps saying though, it depends on the which Batman we're talking about.

Lexi Harper

Oh yeah, Nolan Batman very much uses the costume as a persona, and says as much many times particularly in the first movie. He's neither Batman nor really the Bruce Wayne affect he puts on, just sort of an empty shell I think.

Lexi Harper

Very interesting conversation that was somewhat cluttered by usage of terminology that wasn't 100% understood. Both have very good points, unfortunately I largely think this is one of those annoying "depends on the writer" situations. There are times I very much think Batman is essentially on moral auto-pilot, his moral code is aberrant but it's also hard-locked and he cannot break his own rules for any reason. Buuuut there are also times that we see Batman being very sensitive, empathetic, creative, and flexible. I think this is particularly true of ANIMATED Batman specifically. (Dick being a sociopath is fucking bananas though.)

Internet Slime

that skeleton giving bruce a soft left at 24:30

Aaron Van Scyoc

Alex contends, “Batman never does what he wants”. That is the exact opposite of antisocial personality. Though I disagree with that premise to begin with, it doesn’t hold water as evidence of Batman’s alleged “sociopathy”. Not to mention the fact that Batman and most every Justice Leaguer is committed to upholding the social order. The core problem of Batman is that he does not come from an environment where the social order has ever been just or good (unless you imagine pre-Wayne murder times as a “golden age” for Gotham, as some texts do); he can only rely on the morals and ethics inherited from his quasi-aristocratic background. In which case, you are just dealing with one billionaire trying to shape the world to his liking. (And, like, don’t we deal with that enough already?) Alternatively, Batman could be devoted to a sort of cult of good citizenship that we see him promote and participate in until, maybe, the Crisis. I find Batman most compelling when he is undertaking his adventures out of a sense of profound responsibility to others, his community, and the oppressed. This responsibility he takes on often begets more and more sorrow for himself, which is the price he chooses to pay for his love of others. Superman is a god. Batman is a saint.

Vijnananath

I'm usually on Alex's wabelength when he and Brett get into it about stuff, and find that they're often just talking past each other. In this case, though, I think that Alex is defending an indefensible position. Except in Frank Miller stuff, Batman is usually portrayed as being pretty empathetic and sensitive, though his trauma results in extreme behaviors and emotional armor. If he's anything other than severely traumatized, my money is on ASD — which often makes one more prone to severe, long-term trauma responses anyway. I'm not usually one for diagnosing fictional characters whose diagnosis isn't an explicit part of their characterization in the world of the story, but if we're gonna try it with Batman, Dick Grayson, et al, "sociopathy" doesn't seem to fit if for no other reason than the lack of empathy and remorse tied in with ASPD. Sure, they have some of the other associated behaviors, but calling them sociopaths seems like a pretty severe misreading.

Juggalo_V

Please have more discussions like these. I'm infatuated.